W
weller2
Guest
Stigmatisation and commercialisation of abortion services in Poland: turning sin into gold
Chełstowska, Agata
Reproductive Health Matters , Volume 19 , Issue 37 , 98 - 106
Chełstowska, Agata
Reproductive Health Matters , Volume 19 , Issue 37 , 98 - 106
Abstract
This paper is about the economic consequences of the stigmatisation and illegality of abortion and its almost complete removal from public health services in Poland since the late 1980s. Once abortion left the public sphere, it entered the grey zone of private arrangements, in which a woman’s private worries became someone else’s private gain, and her sin turned into gold. The most important consequence was social inequality, as the right to health, life, information and safety became commodities on the free market. Women with money, who are more likely to have political influence, find this bearable, while working class women lack the political capital to protest. In the private sector, there are no government controls on price, quality of care or accountability, and almost no prosecutions. With an estimated 150,000 abortions per year, a rough estimate of US$ 95 million is being generated annually for doctors, unregistered and tax-free. Thus, the combined forces of right-wing ideology and neoliberal economic reforms have created reproductive and social injustice. To address this, stigmatisation of abortion must be countered. But a change in the political climate, a less restrictive interpretation of the law, or even a new law would not resolve the problem. Given reductions in public health care spending, abortion would remain excluded from state coverage unless neoliberal health care reforms could be reversed.
Meanwhile, in the private sector, a vast new, profitable market in health care emerged, without any government control on price, quality of care or accountability. If the cost of a surgical abortion is on average 2,000 PLN, and an estimated 150,000 procedures are carried out annually, that would make about 300 million PLN of annual income (approximately 95 million USD or 75 million EUR) – unregistered and tax-free.23 These numbers are of course very raw estimates. Neither the real number of procedures, nor the exact cost is known – another result of the private sector being outside government control. Doctors providing abortions privately therefore have little interest in legalising abortion.
Doctors who perform illegal procedures are not discouraged by the law, even though in Poland the sentence for procuring an abortion is up to three years in prison for the provider, not the patient (or up to eight years if it was against the woman’s will).
Every year the police report a few cases of unlawful pregnancy termination carried out against the woman’s will: 4 cases in 2003, 5 in 2004, 4 in 2005, and 2 in 2006.23
The government report on the number of cases detected of illegal abortions (with a woman’s consent) was, in 2006 for example, only 47 cases,30 however, or 0.03% of the estimated total illegal abortions.
Full paper hereThe reluctance of the state authorities to prosecute, even when advertisements for illegal abortion services can be found in the newspapers, raises this question: is it possible that the purpose of the law is not to reduce the number of abortions, but to serve a purely political role, as a symbolic achievement of the Church and right-wing parties?