Sunday 3/20/05 reading Matt 28:38

  • Thread starter Thread starter cccnative
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

cccnative

Guest
On Sunday I was taken aback when I heard that in the version of the missal Jesus was crucified surrounded by 2 **revolutionaries **not **thieves **as I am used to hearing. I need to know. Is revolutionaries the correct translation or thieves. I can’t imagine that the word for both is the same.
 
My misselette says revolutionaries as well.

Does anyone know, did the term ‘revolutionary’ have a different meaning than it does now? Perhaps it meant something closer to thief then?
 
The New American Bible translates it to “revolutionaries”, out of about 20 Bibles I have access to, all other versions are either robbers, thieves, criminals, or bandits.

According to the Nestle-Aland Greek New Testament, the word is λῃστής, which is defined in the Theological Dictionary of the New Testament as follows:

When Jesus was crucified, and was thus punished as a political rebel against Rome, two others condemned as λῃσταί suffered with Him (Mt. 27:38 ff. and par.). The title on the cross marked Him as one of them, and indeed as one who aimed at the crown, as more or less all Zealot leaders had done from the time of the first Judas (→ 258, Mt. 27:37 and par.). His crucifixion as a λῃστής was at the request of His own people (Mt. 27:21 ff.), which decided against His Messiahism and in favour of that of the Zealots, and which thus elected war against Rome and its own crucifixion33 instead of the peace which the Messiah of God brings (cf. Lk. 19:42 with 19:38 and 2:14; → Χριστός). How far this decision affected the judgment of Judaism on Him is nowhere more clearly seen than when Celsus calls Jesus a λῃστής and thus seeks to dismiss Him as a false Messiah.34%between% par. parallel.

33 During the siege Titus set around Jerusalem a ring of crosses on which untold numbers met a painful end.

34 Orig.Cels., III, 59 (I, 253, 24 ff., ed. Koetschau).

%between%Theological dictionary of the New Testament. 1964-c1976. Vols. 5-9 edited by Gerhard Friedrich. Vol. 10 compiled by Ronald Pitkin. (G. Kittel, G. W. Bromiley & G. Friedrich, Ed.) (electronic ed.) (Vol. 4, Page 262). Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans.
 
First of all I cant find Matt28:38. its 27:38

I noticed this as well. I am used to hearing that Barabbas was both a revolutionary and that he commited murder. It is possible to be both at the same time.

As for the two guys Im used to criminals/thieves.
But now that I think about it that had to be some big heist if they were there for robbery and not something more. People like Barabbas should have been there before a few thieves, which makes me question if there was more to the story than just a couple of pick pockets. The death penalty should be given for serious matters not for theft.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top