V
VivaCristoRey27
Guest
Exactly. Collective guilt, not mass personal guilt. The distinction is lost among some people. I do believe that the Jews (that is, carnal Jews) are collectively guilty of the death of Christ. Just as the Jews were elected as a collective, they abandoned God as a collective. They turned their back on God and so God turned His back on them. God abandoned their Temple and allowed to be demolished and never rebuilt. The Jews have suffered much in the past 2000 years since they rejected the True Faith and this is because they have abandoned God. If they would turn to God, things would be different. We believe that this will happen en masse when Henoch and Elias come again to preach to the Jews before the Second Coming of Christ.The Jews do bear guilt of rejecting Jesus. What St. Basil means is they suffer the consequences as I have already explained. However, the catechism is clarifying that although this is true, the Jewish people themselves are not guilty and should not be treated as guilty of the actual sin of rejecting Jesus. It is a similar principle to Original Sin. All humanity bears the consequences of the guilt of Adam and Eve for rejecting God yet no human being is actually guilty. It is as simple as that.
However, personal guilt is more important. When an individual rejects Christ and blasphemes Him (as the Talmud does), they bear with them the guilt of the greatest sin of unbelief. Even more of a fall this is for the Jew, who was born into what used to be the “Chosen People”. But all of us reject Christ after a fashion when we commit a mortal sin and how much greater a fall is it for us as Catholics, who have the True Faith, who have the Sacraments, who are Baptized and are sons of God, when we reject Christ through mortal sin?
Thus both statements that the Jews are collectively guilty for the death of Christ and that it is we ourselves who bear responsibility for the death of Christ are true statements. The former has been de-emphasized to the point of being almost rejected after the horror of the Shoah (popularly misnamed “The Holocaust” – a “holocaust” is a burnt offering to God, the Jews who died in the Shoah were not an offering to God, the Catholics who suffered martyrdom were). It is true that the various pogroms, including the Shoah, were horrible things and should never have happened. However, even though that might make it less prudent to speak out against the Jews, it doesn’t change the truth regarding them. So it is fine that the Church does not speak like St. John Chrysostom anymore but neither should we go so far as to imply that the Jews are saved for being good Jews (something like “Dual-Covenant Theology”, which is anti-Christian heresy). It’s wrong to massacre Jews, but that doesn’t change their relationship with God.