The Death Penalty in Georgia

  • Thread starter Thread starter wjhii
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
W

wjhii

Guest
The Death Penalty in Georgia

William John Hagan
Houston Home Journal

This week I was assigned the unpleasant duty of reporting on the murder of 16-month-old Christian Edward Martinez. For those of you that didn’t read my article in Tuesday’s newspaper, I’ll briefly bring you up to speed.(Original report at: news.mywebpal.com/partners/963/public/news653608.html ) Christian was murdered last August, and authorities believe the killer was Gregory Class.

The details of this case are sickening, so if you have a weak stomach I suggest you turn a few pages and read the more comforting words of your daily horoscope. For those who want your blood to boil, you are invited to read on.

According to Houston Circuit District Attorney Kelly Burke, Gregory Class was babysitting young Christian when he beat and smothered the boy to death. He then reportedly called 911 and said the child had choked. During their investigation, authorities discovered two previous cases of abuse that had occurred. In the months leading up to the murder Class had allegedly broken Christian’s arm and then, a short time later, he followed up this brutality by kneeing the child in the testicles, according to the DA’s office. Incredibly, it wasn’t until Burke was handed this case that the prior allegations became part of the public record. Once the litany of actions Class is accused of were learned, it became clear that only one punishment fit the crime: Death.
In Georgia, however, a prosecutor cannot bring a death penalty case without special circumstances. If you murder a person during a rape or robbery you can be sure that you are going to the death house. Yet, if you walk onto a playground and shoot a child in the head, not only will you not face death but, in Georgia, you won’t even get life without parole.

Why is this so? Simple. Georgia legislators have never had the common sense to pass the proper legislation that would make the murder of a child a “special circumstance.” The reasoning becomes even more dim-witted when one realizes that the very people behind this policy are supporters of the death penalty. Death penalty proponents in the Georgia legislature have supported a statute that will only allow life without parole in a death penalty case at the discretion of the jury.

So, simply put, if a district attorney cannot bring a death penalty case to begin with, then a convicted child murderer is guaranteed a future parole hearing. The warped logic behind this policy is that many legislators fear that district attorneys will use the death penalty as a bargaining chip to get pleas rather then pursue the ultimate penalty. The unfortunate reality is that Georgia ends up releasing murderers back into society because of this loophole of special circumstances and poor legislation.

Burke did not just pursue this one death penalty charge: He set out to change the law. As a direct result of Christian’s murder, Burke approached several legislators and proposed new legislation that would make the murder of anyone under 16 or over 65 an automatic death penalty circumstance.

Sen. Bill Hamrick will be introducing this legislation during the next session and we can wait and watch while our legislature works to quickly correct this affront. The only question now is, where can Georgia find a few more politicians with the fortitude of Kelly Burke?

Letters to the editor can be e-mailed to: hhj@evansnewspapers.com
Please include your name and location

William John Hagan can be visited on the Internet at:
williamjohnhagan.blogspot.com
 
Seems like a false dilemma to me.

The third option is to change to law to make any first degree murder charge open to life without parole if the prosecutor chooses to file charges that way.

Like many Americans who have seen one too many Dirty Harry movies, my gut reaction is also to want to pump this monstrous baby killer full of lead. But there is this pesky still small voice that keeps reminding me that even this guy is treasured and loved by God. That He desires for this killer to repent and be forgiven. Add in that the cost of imprisoning a man for life is less than the legal costs of a capital conviction and I ask why give in to the temptations of Rambo justice?
 
There is no justification for capital punishment in this case, or any case in the USA. There is no reason why proper laws cannot be passed and proper prisons/mental hospitals/rehabilitation units created that provide the necessary protection for the community, as defined in the Cathechism. The fact that some pro-death legislators have messed up their legislation is neither here nor there.

Mike
 
40.png
MikeWM:
There is no justification for capital punishment in this case, or any case in the USA. There is no reason why proper laws cannot be passed and proper prisons/mental hospitals/rehabilitation units created that provide the necessary protection for the community, as defined in the Cathechism. The fact that some pro-death legislators have messed up their legislation is neither here nor there.

Mike
sorry to disagree, but “cruel and unusual” punishment as established with the FRAMER’S INTENT in 1781, did very well include death by hanging and firing squad and some other means.

hopefully, with a STRICT CONSTRUCTIONIST supreme court judge, he will recognize this, and help overturn the ban on executing juveniles [which in 1781 was NOT cruel], and help continue a state’s right to execute as it sees fit.

you cant have it both ways, cant have strict constructionist judges and then advocate for the elimination of the death penalty WITHOUT constitutional amendment.

look at the case of the maryland snipers. Gov Ehrlich stayed the death penalty in Maryland. then the snipers were caught. the FEDERAL GOVERMENT assumed jurisdiction, and transfered the snipers to a state where execution was LEGAL so Virginia could seek the death penalty. then they went ahead with the federal case to ensure that the death penalty would be attatched. Ehrlich went crazy.

ok, so ban the death penalty in ALL states. remember that a FEDERAL RESERVATION is not part of a state. hence, a prisoner may be executed by the federal government at a federal prison in a state where no death penalty exists.
 
40.png
BioCatholic:
sorry to disagree, but “cruel and unusual” punishment as established with the FRAMER’S INTENT in 1781, did very well include death by hanging and firing squad and some other means.
Err, yes. Capital punishment is legal in the United States, I didn’t say that.

I was speaking as a Catholic. The Catholic position is clear, as I already said, in the Cathechism.

Mike
 
The death penalty is wrong under all circumstances. When I was a child, the man across the street murdered his wife after my mom and I dropped their daughter off from ballet class. It was a painful, confusing time but my parents taught us that we can never take the place of God and that we needed to follow the Commandments.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top