The Fool On the Hill

  • Thread starter Thread starter zgraf
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Z

zgraf

Guest
But the fool on the hill
Sees the sun going down
And the eyes in his head
See the world spinning around
Click to expand...
These are the lyrics from the song “The Fool on the Hill” by the Beatles. It’s an old song, from the 1960s.

I recall back in high school one student suggested it was probably intended as a mockery of the life of Christ. The image is that of the crucified one up on the hill, suggesting that no one is listening to him, and that he is a fool. Perhaps it’s even begging the question “what did he die for?”

I never really liked the song after hearing that analysis. But perhaps there is a different interpretation. Bear with me a minute…

In the gospels, Jesus tells us “those who wish to be my disciples must deny themselves and take up their cross daily” (Luke 9:23).

But another way of looking at “taking up one’s cross” is “to allow oneself to be taken up by the cross”. And Christ did just that. In Phillipians, Paul tells us Christ “emptied himself” and humbly submitted himself to death.

So perhaps we could visualize Jesus looking down from the cross. He sees the men and women from high up upon the tree. He sees their comings and goings and “the world spinning around” beneath him. He still longs to help and heal them. But he is barred from doing so, with his arms spread wide and nailed up against the beams of the wood.

Helpless. Totally powerless.

He sees the sun going down. And yes, he has allowed himself to become a simple “fool” for the sake of the gospel. For love. And for God.

At this point, perhaps it would help to reflect – how about us? When we feel totally powerless, with no control over what happens. At home, at work, in our families. In sickness, death, and at other times.

Can we allow ourselves to be “taken up by the cross” as Christ did? Can we allow ourselves to become like the “fool on the hill”?
But the fool on the hill
Sees the sun going down
And the eyes in his head
See the world spinning around
Click to expand...
 
Perhaps:

“Paul McCartney wrote this. It’s about a man who is considered a fool by others, but whose foolish demeanor is actually an indication of wisdom. An event which prompted this song happened when Paul was walking his dog Martha, on Primrose Hill one morning. As he watched the sun rise, he noticed that Martha was missing. Paul turned around to look for his dog, and there a man stood, who appeared on the hill without making a sound. The gentleman was dressed respectably, in a belted raincoat. Paul knew this man had not been there seconds earlier as he had looked in that direction for Martha. Paul and the stranger exchanged a greeting, and this man then spoke of what a beautiful view it was from the top of this hill that overlooked London. Within a few seconds, Paul looked around again, and the man was gone. He had vanished as he had appeared. A friend of McCartney’s, Alistair Taylor, was present with Paul during this strange incident, and wrote of this event in his book, Yesterday.”

lyricinterpretations.com/beatles/the-fool-on-the-hill
 
I will need to lookup the lyrics to the rest of the song, as I am not a Beatles fan; but when hearing this song before, I never heard any mockery of our LORD in it.

The “fool” is a standard archetype in the European countries, as someone who accidentally or deliberately presents to others as someone silly or stupid but in reality equal or wiser than everybody else. A North American version of this trope would be the title character in Mark Twain’s “Pudd’nhead Wilson.”

The fool in the song seems to be this type of person. While watching the sunset, he knows – “his head” – that it is really the world turning.

There is nothing in this piece of lyric to suggest that he is suffering or dying. I’d say no, it is not a mockery of our LORD.

ICXC NIKA.
 
Michael_Mayo said:
Perhaps:

“Paul McCartney wrote this. It’s about a man who is considered a fool by others, but whose foolish demeanor is actually an indication of wisdom. An event which prompted this song happened when Paul was walking his dog Martha, on Primrose Hill one morning. As he watched the sun rise, he noticed that Martha was missing. Paul turned around to look for his dog, and there a man stood, who appeared on the hill without making a sound. The gentleman was dressed respectably, in a belted raincoat. Paul knew this man had not been there seconds earlier as he had looked in that direction for Martha. Paul and the stranger exchanged a greeting, and this man then spoke of what a beautiful view it was from the top of this hill that overlooked London. Within a few seconds, Paul looked around again, and the man was gone. He had vanished as he had appeared. A friend of McCartney’s, Alistair Taylor, was present with Paul during this strange incident, and wrote of this event in his book, Yesterday.”

lyricinterpretations.com/beatles/the-fool-on-the-hill
Click to expand...
This is the account I’ve always heard and read, too.

I suppose you could also take fool in the Dosoyevskyan sense, which could fit both your interpretation and Paul’s explanation.🤷
 
“The plans of the heart
belong to Man, but THE
REPLY of the TONGUE
is from the Lord” Prov. 16:1

We know the history of the
writing of the song, but perhaps
it actually God who allowed
these words to be penned!
 
I remember performing a jazz choir version of this song and I can’t recall all the lyrics, but I agree with other posters that the “fool” is portrayed in the song as actually having more wisdom than the world he’s in.
 
I never cared for the song much (seemed sad to me) but I never got the impression it was about Jesus. While the OP posted a snippet, it starts out - “Day after day, alone on a hill” - so if we were saying based on the snippet that because the fool is on the hill and Jesus was crucified on a hill, well then the opening line makes no sense.

The OPs experience reminded me of one of my own. I have a cousin who is a non-denomination kind-of-a-guy. He told me that 'Strawberry Fields" was all about how when drug-users shoot up, they leave a ‘strawberry field’ on their arms. :rolleyes:

Yes, the Beatles were no angels, but there’s no need to find references where there aren’t any.
 
Dandelion_Wine said:
I never cared for the song much (seemed sad to me) but I never got the impression it was about Jesus. While the OP posted a snippet, it starts out - “Day after day, alone on a hill” - so if we were saying based on the snippet that because the fool is on the hill and Jesus was crucified on a hill, well then the opening line makes no sense.

The OPs experience reminded me of one of my own. I have a cousin who is a non-denomination kind-of-a-guy. He told me that 'Strawberry Fields" was all about how when drug-users shoot up, they leave a ‘strawberry field’ on their arms. :rolleyes:

Yes, the Beatles were no angels, but there’s no need to find references where there aren’t any.
Click to expand...
The Yellow Submarine was allegedly a kind of pill, and “Imagine” was a paean to atheism and communism.

I don’t get how a Christian can be a Beatles fan; but TFOTH isn’t a rip on our LORD unless it’s very hidden.

ICXC NIKA
 
GEddie said:
The Yellow Submarine was allegedly a kind of pill, and “Imagine” was a paean to atheism and communism
Click to expand...
I’ve never heard that one either. Everything I’ve read, it was nothing more than a catchy silly kids tune. McCartney has said that he figured someone would read drugs into it somehow but it wasn’t meant anything more than a kids tune.

Again, the Beatles did enough allusions to drugs without a need to find allusions where there are none.

I can’t stand Imagine. I used to like it when I was younger because it was a piano tune and I played the piano and loved the Beatles. But now I turn it off when it comes on the radio.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top