The Moment of Lift by Melinda Gates

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dave27360
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

Dave27360

Guest
Has anyone read the book, if so what are your thoughts? I checked out the book from the local library and it is an interesting read though I don’t agree with some of Melinda’s suggestions mentioned. There are two things mentioned which go against church teachings 1. Family Planning via the use of artificial contraceptions. 2. Women should be ordained as Catholic priests. Other items mentioned don’t conflict with church teachings.
 
I think Ms Gates intends the book as a memoir, not as an instrument of doctrinal teaching.

We are free to read books that have things in them which are sinful, and most memoirs do talk about some of the person’s sins as well as triumphs.
 
Although she brings up her catholic identity, Melinda Gates’ feminist views are not new. She sees empowering women as a means to promote contraception and population control. She espouses women priests.

Why would any catholic want to read her book?
 
Last edited:
Why would any catholic want to read her book?
To try to understand her opinion on how to empower women. Not to read it as Catholic doctrine of take advice that is counter to Church teachings.
 
Why would I want to read a book, just because she is Melinda Gates. I could read the same from many feminist writers. She is no exception.

She may be worse than many feminist writers because she sees empowering women as a means to control population. That is her real agenda.
 
Last edited:
There are many people in this world, we are free to read their books or think they have valuable thoughts in spite of their sins.

I am frequently pressured on these forums to look beyond the moral failings of one well known politician and to accept all that he says as edifying. One would think these folks would grant the same open arms to embrace to Mrs Gates.
 
Melinda has been going around the world promoting contraception, family planning and population control for two decades. Their foundation is one of most highly funded with was worth 53 billion in 2010.

Her influence on poor people may appear to be noble but that is not her intent. She has this Utopian view that she can eradicate the poor by giving them contraception.
 
Not going to enter a list of the things that other people have done or said where I am encouraged to look past that for the good.

As far as I know, this book is not required reading, and if you do not want to read it, do not read it. At the same time, do not fault those who do read it.
 
But you likely don’t accept all he says as edifying. If you are like I am, you accept very little of what he says is edifying. So others may tell you to, but you don’t. Good for you. But then why should I accept Melinda Gates book with open arms?
 
Simply drawing a parallel.

The Gates book is not required reading 🙂
 
Has anyone read the book, if so what are your thoughts? I checked out the book from the local library and it is an interesting read though I don’t agree with some of Melinda’s suggestions mentioned. There are two things mentioned which go against church teachings 1. Family Planning via the use of artificial contraceptions. 2. Women should be ordained as Catholic priests.
Does she say she has always had these positions?
 
Last edited:
Yes, indeed. Three cheers! Wonder who that politician might be? Since when are we not permitted to read a book by a writer we may disagree with on certain issues?
 
Last edited:
Melinda Gates is a hard-working, intelligent person who was a valedictorian, super-achiever, and early woman in tech. She became very influential when she caught the attention of Bill at Microsoft and married the richest person in the world.

Like anybody else, her views have become fairly cemented with older age. She still identifies as a Catholic so obviously there are aspects of the faith that are attractive to her, but she also enthusiastically endorses programs that are gravely contrary to the dignity of human beings. She has been doing it for a long time so the chances of a change of heart are increasingly dim. Like many people, she is utilitarian.

There is nothing wrong with reading books by people that dont express Catholic views. I do it all the time, although I don’t think Melinda is very interesting or brilliant, at least in the creative sense. You kind of already know what she is going to say. She’s big on mainstream figures like Oprah.
 
Last edited:
Like abortion. She is very distressed that Trump has pulled money away from these overseas agencies who do family planning and abortion.
 
It seems obvious to me that the best way for a woman to become empowered is to marry a billionaire!

In our city, we have several woman who did this (actually, one married a multi-millionaire, not a billionaire), and “empowered” is an understatement of their current very nice situation!

People sure pay attention to you if you have a lot money.
 
She did not specify a specific date. She does mention using contraception to delay having children and to space out the age between having children with her husband Bill. She also mentions that her view on contraception has been influenced by the women she has spoken to during her trips who want contraception but don’t have the access.
 
She did not specify a specific date. She does mention using contraception to delay having children and to space out the age between having children with her husband Bill. She also mentions that her view on contraception has been influenced by the women she has spoken to during her trips who want contraception but don’t have the access.
As I understand, Bill is an atheist. So contraception, (as a religious matter) isn’t going to be on his radar.

However,

His wife as I understand, is Catholic. If so, then her “views” on contraception, should be from the Church, not from just everyone she comes in contact with. Just sayin. 🙂
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top