The Nun's Story

  • Thread starter Thread starter a_priori
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’ve only seen it in color. 🤷

It’s funny how my mom and I see that movie in two different ways.

My mom (who’s bit independant, like Sr. Luke in the movie, but also sentimentally attached to things.): “They tell you what to do, when to eat, when to speak, what you can read. You can’t even go to the mall, talk to friends or read any book you want to!”.

Me: “Right mom, you wouldn’t be nun.” 😃
Well, if everybody were a nun we’d run out of Catholics right quick.

My mother said she always hated it when she heard “So-and-so has a vocation” meaning a call to the priesthood of religious life.

She always insisted she had a vocation as well. I’m sure there were moments when she thought poverty, chastity and obedience would be a snap compared to marriage and riding herd on seven kids 🙂
 
I was in the convent. What you saw in the Nun’s Story was the way convents were run. Do you have any idea of what actually living in one like that does to one’s soul and mind? Unless you have actually lived there yourslef, you really have no idea. I am beginning to think that Vat 2 has validity in that regard. PPius 12 was beginning to make some changes in the religious rules, but died before much had happened. There were too many instances where the superior/prior was nuts/wicked. And what happened to the poor souls under their guidance? Hmmm.
 
I was in the convent. What you saw in the Nun’s Story was the way convents were run. Do you have any idea of what actually living in one like that does to one’s soul and mind? Unless you have actually lived there yourslef, you really have no idea. I am beginning to think that Vat 2 has validity in that regard. PPius 12 was beginning to make some changes in the religious rules, but died before much had happened. There were too many instances where the superior/prior was nuts/wicked. And what happened to the poor souls under their guidance? Hmmm.
Code:
I can attest to that…:o…although I am probably a bit younger…
 
Very sad story. In real life the woman on whom Sr Luke was based ended up falling very low after leaving the convent. Eventually she comitted suicide.
You might be referring to the singing nun Jeanine Deckers who left the convent before taking her final vows she disagreed on many of the Church’s teachings especially abortion and contraception sadly she became a spokesperson for planned parenthood and supported gay rights EEK she committed suicide in 1985.
 
Soeur Luc had her vocation tested seriously before she ever left for the African mission. She was a very talented and intelligent nurse, and in obedience, was asked to fail an examination to give a less talented sister the opportunity to go to the missions. She didn’t do so, passing the examination with the highest mark in the class. The movie goes on to highlight her continued disobedience to the Rule (particularly the rule of grand silence,) but the death of her father at the hands of the Nazis in occupied Belgium brought things to a head, so to speak. Subsequently, a downed American (or English) pilot showed up in the order’s hospital as a patient, as well as a postulant who had ties to the Resistance, and her grief and outraged patriotism at the Nazi occupation of her homeland tilted the fine balance that her effort to live out her vow in the direction of leaving the convent. The film and the book allude to her helping the Resistance for the balance of the war, hiding and tending to wounded.

The links provided are interesting, but clearly, Sister Luke did NOT belong in the convent! Holy Rules are supposed to be a support of the path to sanctity, not an impediment. For her, they were in direct conflict with her basic personality, one of independent thought and action. The fact that she entered the convent anyways was more of a reflection of society when young women were viewed as somewhat marginalized if they were not married or consecrated religious. She should have remained single, in the world, doing what she did best–being a nurse–and bringing glory to His name that way.

I first saw the film when I was in about the seventh grade, when the Sisters at my school were talking quite a bit about vocations. One Sister emphasized to us that all three states in life are ways to glorify God and live out sanctity. She issued this caveat—“If you do not listen and follow where Our Lord is leading you, you can be holy, but you will never be as happy as you would have been if you had followed His call to where you are supposed to live out your life.”

Miss Hepburn was absolutely brilliant in the movie. It is one of my all-time favorites of classical film.
 
A later superior even said the former superior meant well, but what she advised was wrong.
 
The Nun’s Story was on KQED Saturday night and I watched it again. It is a favorite movie of mine. Audrey Hepburn was never more luminous.

It disturbs me that people want to fault Mary Louise Habets for leaving the convent. I prefer to remember that she had spent seventeen years in the convent and did not leave until her father was killed in World War II. This created a crisis of faith in a God who would permit such a horror as the War to happen.

If, after nursing in an insane asylum, developing tuberculosis in the Belgian Congo (not the little paradise on earth portrayed in the movie), and the experiencing the terror of genocide, Habets was not entitled to question both her faith and vocation, who is?

How many of us are also unable to come to terms with a God who permits bad things to happen to good people? I think most of us come to that conflict sooner or later and decide it will not be resolved in this world.

That’s why it’s called “faith”.
 
Soeur Luc had her vocation tested seriously before she ever left for the African mission. She was a very talented and intelligent nurse, and in obedience, was asked to fail an examination to give a less talented sister the opportunity to go to the missions. She didn’t do so, passing the examination with the highest mark in the class. The movie goes on to highlight her continued disobedience to the Rule (particularly the rule of grand silence,) but the death of her father at the hands of the Nazis in occupied Belgium brought things to a head, so to speak.

The links provided are interesting, but clearly, Sister Luke did NOT belong in the convent! Holy Rules are supposed to be a support of the path to sanctity, not an impediment. For her, they were in direct conflict with her basic personality, one of independent thought and action. The fact that she entered the convent anyways was more of a reflection of society when young women were viewed as somewhat marginalized if they were not married or consecrated religious. She should have remained single, in the world, doing what she did best–being a nurse–and bringing glory to His name that way.

From Cavanlass—I watched this movie after I had left the convent. It is the truest nun/convent story that I’ve ever seen.

I disagree that Sr Luc was disobedient, and that her spirit was too independent, no matter what the movie said it was proving. I see her as one who tried with all her heart to conform, for all those many years. What I see is that the superior who ordered her to fail the exam (after all the money the order put into Sr Luc’s education, and the time involoved)–She has demonstrated her own poor judgement and inability to govern those under her.

I also see the constant happenings where other nuns are given the positions they had so hoped for, while Sr Luc is constantly put into a depressing and bleak job instead of being sent back to Africa, where she blossomed under an understanding and loving superior.

I really don’t know what else to say, other than you’d have to have been there in order to see the situation from the inside, and THEN make your judgement. Some of these convents had rules to break the soul, and some of these superiors --hard as it may be to believe, were nothing but broken and nasty women in their own right, who used their position to belittle and sometimes destroy the young women who entered their orders. That is not holiness.
 
The Nun’s Story was on KQED Saturday night and I watched it again. It is a favorite movie of mine. Audrey Hepburn was never more luminous.

It disturbs me that people want to fault Mary Louise Habets for leaving the convent. I prefer to remember that she had spent seventeen years in the convent and did not leave until her father was killed in World War II. This created a crisis of faith in a God who would permit such a horror as the War to happen.

If, after nursing in an insane asylum, developing tuberculosis in the Belgian Congo (not the little paradise on earth portrayed in the movie), and the experiencing the terror of genocide, Habets was not entitled to question both her faith and vocation, who is?

How many of us are also unable to come to terms with a God who permits bad things to happen to good people? I think most of us come to that conflict sooner or later and decide it will not be resolved in this world.

That’s why it’s called “faith”.
So refreshing to read your post, pmitchell. I completely agree with you. I had written my post before reading yours, so thank you for your words. And as for Mary Louise, I don’t know how she lasted THAT long!

Has anyone read the book written by the real nun whom the movie Come to the Stable was made from? Regina Laudis Abbey in Bethlehem, Connecticut. This is the order that Dolores Hart entered. The foundress was a medical doctor, and in her book, she stated that very, very many of the nuns in the convent who actually came in for a medical problem, suffered more from the mental than physical. This does not mean they were not sane, only that the rules and regulations, and the absoluteness of perfect conforming to these rules, caused serious problems of their own. It has taken me awhile to absorb this, as I have always been, all my life a complete supporter of the rules of the church. They could do no wrong. Sadly, now I also see that they can. Do wrong.
 
So refreshing to read your post, pmitchell. I completely agree with you. I had written my post before reading yours, so thank you for your words. And as for Mary Louise, I don’t know how she lasted THAT long!

Has anyone read the book written by the real nun whom the movie Come to the Stable was made from? Regina Laudis Abbey in Bethlehem, Connecticut. This is the order that Dolores Hart entered. The foundress was a medical doctor, and in her book, she stated that very, very many of the nuns in the convent who actually came in for a medical problem, suffered more from the mental than physical. This does not mean they were not sane, only that the rules and regulations, and the absoluteness of perfect conforming to these rules, caused serious problems of their own. It has taken me awhile to absorb this, as I have always been, all my life a complete supporter of the rules of the church. They could do no wrong. Sadly, now I also see that they can. Do wrong.
Code:
This is true…they do wrong…my own story dictates this…😊
 
Code:
This is true…they do wrong…my own story dictates this…😊
Shoshana, don’t you think that it is a “good” thing that happenings like ours should be made known? Maybe not the whole story , but enough to let people “understand” better the problems the individual/church had to live through and what they truly faced? And the fact that just because someone has left the convent does not mean they were lacking in any way, nor that they had “lost their vocation”? That they were no longer doing the will of God? So terribly sad.
 
Shoshana, don’t you think that it is a “good” thing that happenings like ours should be made known? Maybe not the whole story , but enough to let people “understand” better the problems the individual/church had to live through and what they truly faced? And the fact that just because someone has left the convent does not mean they were lacking in any way, nor that they had “lost their vocation”? That they were no longer doing the will of God? So terribly sad.
Sometimes those discerning a vocation and a particular order are just a bad match. The seeker may indeed have a very strong vocation, but is entering at the wrong order for them. That’s something that is supposed to be worked out during the time of discernment. I realize Holy Orders are a different matter than the religious life, but I have a dear friend who was a so-so diocesan priest. He discerned this years after ordination, made a decision, and now has become a stellar Jesuit. Why? That is more in line with his own particular gift of teaching and direction, rather than pastoral administration.

Even assignments in an order are sometimes a very bad match: In the film, for example, Sister Luke’s gift was tropical medicine (which means epidemiology and infection control.) She was instead assigned variously to a psychiatric hospital, and once in the Congo, to an operating room. Per my sister (a nurse who has been in practice for forty years,) these assignments are very, very different!

And I for one never believed that one who leaves the religious life is necessarily not doing the Will of God. Sometimes it just doesn’t work out: Nobody’s fault, not the order, nor the individual. They are truly supposed to be elsewhere.
 
I was in the convent. What you saw in the Nun’s Story was the way convents were run. Do you have any idea of what actually living in one like that does to one’s soul and mind? Unless you have actually lived there yourslef, you really have no idea. I am beginning to think that Vat 2 has validity in that regard. PPius 12 was beginning to make some changes in the religious rules, but died before much had happened. There were too many instances where the superior/prior was nuts/wicked. And what happened to the poor souls under their guidance? Hmmm.
For those who attended parochial school, we got a taste of nuts/wicked too. :whackadoo:

On the more serious side, I could never comprehend that the nuns I had were restricted from returning home to visit their parents. The deal they were given was if you must return to take care of them, and then got better but later died, the nun couldn’t return for the funeral. Really? Turned me off.
 
Sometimes those discerning a vocation and a particular order are just a bad match. The seeker may indeed have a very strong vocation, but is entering at the wrong order for them. That’s something that is supposed to be worked out during the time of discernment. I realize Holy Orders are a different matter than the religious life, but I have a dear friend who was a so-so diocesan priest. He discerned this years after ordination, made a decision, and now has become a stellar Jesuit. Why? That is more in line with his own particular gift of teaching and direction, rather than pastoral administration.

Even assignments in an order are sometimes a very bad match: In the film, for example, Sister Luke’s gift was tropical medicine (which means epidemiology and infection control.) She was instead assigned variously to a psychiatric hospital, and once in the Congo, to an operating room. Per my sister (a nurse who has been in practice for forty years,) these assignments are very, very different!

And I for one never believed that one who leaves the religious life is necessarily not doing the Will of God. Sometimes it just doesn’t work out: Nobody’s fault, not the order, nor the individual. They are truly supposed to be elsewhere.
Code:
Short story: we all took psychological tests in 1969, and mine were very good. My IQ was quite high I found out. But I also stuttered which showed on my tests no pathological issue. But the vice-Mother General (the only one who disliked me…on the border of hate) stated that the combination of high IQ and stuttering would be a possible mental disease…???..causing me to make a choice…to take psyshological therapy with a priest, if I got rid of my stuttering I could stay and they would pay for it. If it did not heal within 6 months, I had to leave and pay for it. Great stress! She humiliated me a number of times…the whole of the community (200 of them) loved me. My great aunt was a member also. It did not work…(today it is a known fact that the cause of stuttering is not psychological on the whole…we speak from both sides of the brain…and are mostly intelligent…go figure…didn’t know that then)

The priest found nothing wrong with me pyschologically…after keeping a diary. They told me to leave, get psychiatric help and do a course. I went for mental help for 9 months…the psychiatrist was a catholic and was very upset with the nuns, meanwhile I took the course to become an x-ray technician. All this took 2 years. Nearing the end of all of this, I went back to ask to come back and I was told that I should marry a good looking doctor. :eek:I was lied to! :eek:I walked away quite sad and angry…:mad:I was young, I wished I had a priest as a director, but I didn’t…

The end…:o
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top