Soeur Luc had her vocation tested seriously before she ever left for the African mission. She was a very talented and intelligent nurse, and in obedience, was asked to fail an examination to give a less talented sister the opportunity to go to the missions. She didn’t do so, passing the examination with the highest mark in the class. The movie goes on to highlight her continued disobedience to the Rule (particularly the rule of grand silence,) but the death of her father at the hands of the Nazis in occupied Belgium brought things to a head, so to speak.
The links provided are interesting, but clearly, Sister Luke did NOT belong in the convent! Holy Rules are supposed to be a support of the path to sanctity, not an impediment. For her, they were in direct conflict with her basic personality, one of independent thought and action. The fact that she entered the convent anyways was more of a reflection of society when young women were viewed as somewhat marginalized if they were not married or consecrated religious. She should have remained single, in the world, doing what she did best–being a nurse–and bringing glory to His name that way.
From Cavanlass—I watched this movie after I had left the convent. It is the truest nun/convent story that I’ve ever seen.
I disagree that Sr Luc was disobedient, and that her spirit was too independent, no matter what the movie said it was proving. I see her as one who tried with all her heart to conform, for all those many years. What I see is that the superior who ordered her to fail the exam (after all the money the order put into Sr Luc’s education, and the time involoved)–She has demonstrated her own poor judgement and inability to govern those under her.
I also see the constant happenings where other nuns are given the positions they had so hoped for, while Sr Luc is constantly put into a depressing and bleak job instead of being sent back to Africa, where she blossomed under an understanding and loving superior.
I really don’t know what else to say, other than you’d have to have been there in order to see the situation from the inside, and THEN make your judgement. Some of these convents had rules to break the soul, and some of these superiors --hard as it may be to believe, were nothing but broken and nasty women in their own right, who used their position to belittle and sometimes destroy the young women who entered their orders. That is not holiness.