Traditions not found in Bible

  • Thread starter Thread starter aball1035
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The mere statement that something from outside of scripture MUST be believed (e.g. the assumption) violates the precept of Deuteronomy 4:2. It is an additional commandment not found in scripture, that people must believe this extra-Biblical doctrine.
 
The mere statement that something from outside of scripture MUST be believed (e.g. the assumption) violates the precept of Deuteronomy 4:2. It is an additional commandment not found in scripture, that people must believe this extra-Biblical doctrine.
How do you know that the Epistle of James is a inspired text?
 
How do you know that the Epistle of James is a inspired text?
As I have said, the Canon of Scripture is that which is accepted by all people, in all places at all times. (Yes I know Luther questioned James, but as he did not ultimately reject it that is of no consequence).
 
If it is based on scripture, post a reference. Otherwise, its just one man’s opinion.
You said you were catholic, right? So you must know:

1 - “Heresy is the obstinate denial or obstinate doubt after the reception of baptism of some truth which is to be believed by divine and Catholic faith” (CIC, can. 751).

2 - “…] an apostate from the faith, a heretic, or a schismatic incurs a latae sententiae excommunication” (CIC, can. 1364).

Therefore, someone who, with full knowledge and deliberate consent, denies or obstinately doubts the bodily Assumption of the Blessed Virgin, which is divinely revealed dogma, commits grave sin of heresy and separates from God. Moreover, someone who externalizes his formal heresy (e.g. writing his heretical position over here) is automatically excommunicated, not in communion with the Church, excluded from the sacraments.
 
As I have said, the Canon of Scripture is that which is accepted by all people, in all places at all times. (Yes I know Luther questioned James, but as he did not ultimately reject it that is of no consequence).
Tobit, Judith, Maccabees, etc are not accepted by everyone, but aside from that, there is nothing in Scripture that would have told the early Christian Church what to add to the Bible. That doctrine came from outside of the Bible - from the sacred authority of the Church.
 
You said you were catholic, right? So you must know:

1 - “Heresy is the obstinate denial or obstinate doubt after the reception of baptism of some truth which is to be believed by divine and Catholic faith” (CIC, can. 751).

2 - “…] an apostate from the faith, a heretic, or a schismatic incurs a latae sententiae excommunication” (CIC, can. 1364).

Therefore, someone who, with full knowledge and deliberate consent, denies or obstinately doubts the bodily Assumption of the Blessed Virgin, which is divinely revealed dogma, commits grave sin of heresy and separates from God. Moreover, someone who externalizes his formal heresy (e.g. writing his heretical position over here) is automatically excommunicated, not in communion with the Church, excluded from the sacraments.
I have not actually denied the doctrine, merely questioned why it should be a doctrine and questioned its importance. I did not at any time say that it did not happen. It might have, it might not have. I do not regard it as an important issue and don’t really have a view one way or the other. My point is rather that we can not definitively know one way or another.
Tobit, Judith, Maccabees, etc are not accepted by everyone, but aside from that, there is nothing in Scripture that would have told the early Christian Church what to add to the Bible. That doctrine came from outside of the Bible - from the sacred authority of the Church.
No, those books are not accepted by everyone. It must be then that they are not scripture, in line with the view not only of protestants but also of the Jewish community from whence those books came.
 
No, those books are not accepted by everyone. It must be then that they are not scripture, in line with the view not only of protestants but also of the Jewish community from whence those books came.
The Council of Trent

Decree Concerning the Canonical Scriptures
But if any one receive not, as sacred and canonical, the said books (all deuterocanonical) entire with all their parts, as they have been used to be read in the Catholic Church, and as they are contained in the old Latin vulgate edition; and knowingly and deliberately contemn the traditions aforesaid; let him be anathema.

This is a defined doctrine of the Catholic church, and you seem to be saying that this doctrine is false and we are free to reject it.
 
I have not actually denied the doctrine, merely questioned why it should be a doctrine and questioned its importance. I did not at any time say that it did not happen. It might have, it might not have. I do not regard it as an important issue and don’t really have a view one way or the other. My point is rather that we can not definitively know one way or another.

No, those books are not accepted by everyone. It must be then that they are not scripture, in line with the view not only of protestants but also of the Jewish community from whence those books came.
You are saying it might not have happened. This means you are calling it into doubt, and this is heresy as well. You don’t need to deny it in order to be heretical. It is enough to obstinately doubt it.

As pope Pius XII said:

“Hence if anyone, which God forbid, should dare willfully to deny or to call into doubt that which we have defined, let him know that he has fallen away completely from the divine and Catholic Faith” (MUNIFICENTISSIMUS DEUS, 45).
 
I have not actually denied the doctrine, merely questioned why it should be a doctrine and questioned its importance. I did not at any time say that it did not happen. It might have, it might not have. I do not regard it as an important issue and don’t really have a view one way or the other. My point is rather that we can not definitively know one way or another.
That’s not the case. When the Church defines a doctrine as a dogma it is certain that it happened. Again, using Scripture to prove the point, Christ told his Apostles, the Church he founded, that the Holy Spirit would guide his Church, which he established, into all truth. Just because individuals cannot understand why a dogma is true, does not mean we “cannot definitively know one way or another.” We can know because Christ himself promised that we can know. If we cannot know what the Church defines in matters of faith and morals, when Christ himself promised that we could, then we are lost, with each one of us feeling our way along, just hoping we get it right.
No, those books are not accepted by everyone. It must be then that they are not scripture, in line with the view not only of protestants but also of the Jewish community from whence those books came.
The Hebrew Scriptures were not defined until after the Church decided to make a canon of Scripture–to be read at all the Church’s liturgies–the principle reason the Church’s canon was established–not to use Scripture as a proof-text for doctrine. Doctrines are determined using the Scriptures as reference, but the Scriptures do not define doctrine. Otherwise, there’d have been no need for Church councils to decide doctrinal issues.

Doctrine begins and ends in the teachings of Christ as taught by the Church he founded. No one believed in Sola Scriptura (the idea you are promoting) until the reformation. That’s 1500 years of Christianity under the universal Church. Even the Orthodox don’t believe in or utilize a Sola Scriptura method for determining doctrine.

Someone has made you think that the Bible is supreme in determining doctrine. It’s not true. It wasn’t true until the reformation, when Protestant sects decided it would be useful in their break with the Catholic Church. No offense to Protestants, but they hardly have consensus as to what is important and what isn’t. You and I don’t make that decision. Christ’s Church makes that decision or there is no truth to be had.
 
In order to have a New Testament at all, something more than scripture alone was required.
In order to have any books other than Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, and Deuteronomy, something more than scripture alone was required.
 
The mere statement that something from outside of scripture MUST be believed (e.g. the assumption) violates the precept of Deuteronomy 4:2. It is an additional commandment not found in scripture, that people must believe this extra-Biblical doctrine.
How do you know that Matthew’s Gospel was written by Matthew? That Mark’s Gospel was written by Mark? …
 
It must be then that they are not scripture, in line with the view not only of protestants but also of the Jewish community from whence those books came.
The Sadducees accepted only the Pentateuch. By your definition, it must then be that the rest of the Old Testament is not scripture, because it was not universally accepted by the “Jewish community from whence those books came.”

Alternately, the fact that certain books are in some folks’ canons of Scripture but not others must imply that they are somehow “non-essential.” The problem with that is, Scripture does not tell us which of its teachings are essential and which are not. All Christians agree (or should!) that the Scriptures are the inspired Word of God… so, who’s going to volunteer for the job of deciding what parts of God’ Word are essential and what parts aren’t?
 
One argument in regard to the Old Testament Canon is that Jesus refered to one of the first incidents in the Old Testament and one of the last and thereby endorsed the entire canon.

That upon you may come all the righteous blood shed upon the earth, from the blood of righteous Abel unto the blood of Zacharias son of Barachias, whom ye slew between the temple and the altar. (Matthew 23:35)

It is a tradition that tells us the authorship of what we know as Matthew’s Gospel (per Irenaeus), but this tradition is not infallible, it is only assumed to be correct.

As for the Saducees, it seems uncertain that they only accepted the Torah (easier to spell than the other name for the five books of Moses) and not the remainder of the Old Testament

For instance:
The Sadducees had what has been called a conservative attitude toward Scripture–they restricted authority to the written law interpreted literally, and were not open to change. But the question that is raised concerns how much of the Scripture they accepted as God’s Word. We know from Josephus that they hated the traditions of the Pharisees, accepting only the written law. From this expression in Josephus, and the fact that Jesus limited Himself to the Pentateuch in debating the Sadducees, the Church Fathers concluded that the Sadducees only accepted the Law of Moses as Scripture. But this may be a misunderstanding on the part of the Fathers. When Josephus says that they rejected all but the written law, he probably meant that they did not permit legal or doctrinal deductions from the prophets. He most likely meant that they opposed unwritten traditions. According to the Talmud, in the debates the Sadducees were attacked from other books of the Bible and used them themselves in their arguments. This strongly suggests that they viewed them as Scripture as well.
 
The word “Eucharist” isn’t in scripture either, but that certainly doesn’t mean that the Eucharist isn’t in scripture. Eucharist is absolutely biblical. It’s simply what we call the body and blood of Christ in the sacrifice of the Mass. “Do this in memory of me…”

The Trinity is what we call God the Father, Son, Holy Spirit. The word “Trinity” is not in scripture, BUT THE TRINITY IS IN SCRIPTURE. We applied that word later to describe the three persons of Almighty God who are found in scripture.

Here they are, all three persons of our Trinity together…
“After being baptized, Jesus came up immediately from the water; and behold, the heavens were opened, and he saw the Spirit of God descending as a dove and lighting on Him; and behold, a voice from heaven said, “This is my beloved Son, with whom I am well pleased.”
Matthew 3:16


Look, here they are in scripture again, those three persons we call the Trinity…
“Go therefore and make disciples of all the nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit . . .”
Matthew 28:19

These things are not Church tradition or dogma. These things are taken straight from scripture, the teachings of Christ.

Peace
I guess I didn’t make it clear when I posted (try to find that word in Scripture). The point was that the word “trinity” is not found in scripture. Simple.
 
You are totally wrong. The bodily Assumption of the Blessed Virgin is, as pope Pius XII said, “based on the Sacred Writings” (MD 41) as well. It is infallible teaching, and saying it “is therefore not something we can be certain about” is totally heretical. You must read Pius XII’s Munificentissimus Deus and the First Vatican Council’s dogmatic constitution Pastor Aeternus.

“…] by the authority of our Lord Jesus Christ, of the Blessed Apostles Peter and Paul, and by our own authority, we pronounce, declare, and define it to be a divinely revealed dogma: that the Immaculate Mother of God, the ever Virgin Mary, having completed the course of her earthly life, was assumed body and soul into heavenly glory. Hence if anyone, which God forbid, should dare willfully to deny or to call into doubt that which we have defined, let him know that he has fallen away completely from the divine and Catholic Faith” (MD 44 - 45).
So to extend this logic to its obvious conclusion, every tradition is found in Scripture when it is established and formally declared by the Church. That makes this thread a “dog chasing its tail.” Move on.

Shalom
 
As for the Saducees, it seems uncertain that they only accepted the Torah (easier to spell than the other name for the five books of Moses) and not the remainder of the Old Testament
When the Saduccees asked Jesus, in Matthew 22:23-28, “…Now then, at the resurrection, whose wife will she be of the seven, since all of them were married to her?” what was Jesus’ answer? Jesus replied, “You are in error because you do not know the Scriptures or the power of God. At the resurrection people will neither marry nor be given in marriage; they will be like the angels in heaven. But** about the resurrection of the dead—have you not read what God said to you, ‘I am the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob’? He is not the God of the dead but of the living.” **Why did He quote Exodus 3:6 when there are any number of other passages He could have quoted?

St. Jerome explicitly tells us that He used this passage because of the Saduccees’ rejection of the rest of the Bible: “In proof of the resurrection there were many plainer passages which He might have cited; among others that of Isaiah, ‘The dead shall be raised; they that are in the tombs shall rise again’ [Isa 26:29, Septuagint]: and in another place, ‘Many of them that sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake’ [Dan. 12:2].
It is enquired therefore why the Lord should have chosen this testimony which seems ambiguous, and not sufficiently belonging to the truth of the resurrection; and as if by this He had proved the point adds, ‘He is not the God of the dead, but of the living.’
We have said above that the Sadducees confessed neither Angel, nor spirit, nor resurrection of the body, and taught also the death of the soul. But they also received only the five books of Moses, rejecting the Prophets. It would have been foolish therefore to have brought forward testimonies whose authority they did not admit.”
 
From bible.org/book/about-bibleorg,
The Bible.org Team is comprised of gifted Evangelical Christians
Their Bible only contains 66 books (i.e. it’s missing 7). If I were to have to explain to them why Catholics pray for the souls in purgatory (i.e. in order to aid them in their journey to heaven) – and why it’s very reasonable to contend that an intermediate state between hell and heaven is presupposed (i.e. because it would be futile to pray for those in hell (prayer can no longer help them) and *unnecessary *to pray for those in heaven (they have everything they need) – I would for the same reason quote 2 Timothy 1:16-18 and not 2 Maccabees 12:46
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top