Trouble with RCIA

  • Thread starter Thread starter Homebody422
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
H

Homebody422

Guest
Hi all,

My husband and I both grew up going to various Protestant churches, but spent most of our 20s non-affiliated and not really even Christian at all. However, when we had our son last year, we started thinking about how we wanted him to be raised and the sorts of influences we wanted around him. We decided to give Catholicism a try for a variety of reasons, suffice it to say that we felt drawn to it. and did a great deal of research before we even went to our first Mass. We went to a couple of different parishes, found one we really liked, and signed up for the RCIA program. Now that it’s started, however, we’re having some problems.

Our biggest hurdle has been finding someone to watch our one-year-old during classes. I stay home with him all day and we’ve never really had anyone else watch him before. Our closest family is an hour away and we don’t know anyone else who can watch him (and I’m unwilling to just hire someone off Craiglist; we don’t really have the money to spare anyway). We found someone who can watch him at the church, but not come to our house. So we tried that a couple of times, but the problem is that the classes go so late (from 7:00 pm till about 9:30) that he gets really tired and fussy and starts crying. Since he’s just down the hall from where we’re having the class, everyone can hear him, so I have to run in and stop it. Last time he started up immediately, and I ended up missing the whole class because he was being clingy and wouldn’t let me leave.

Because of the problems with the baby, my husband’s just been going by himself, but I really don’t like it. My husband’s schedule right now is very burdensome on all of us in the first place, and this is just adding another 4 hours a week when he’s not home and I have to watch the baby by myself, while he’s off doing something we were supposed to be doing together. Both he and I have tried to talk to the RCIA coordinator about our predicament, but she’s not been able to help us.

It’s gotten to the point where I’m ready to just scrap the whole idea. I like going to Mass, and I love learning about the Catholic faith and I really feel like it’s right for me and my family, but I don’t like feeling like I have to jump through all of these hoops. I’m used to Protestant churches where you can be a member just by showing up. I understand why the Catholic church requires a few more steps than that, but it should not be so burdensome a thing. All the Catholic churches in my area have RCIA on weeknights-- is that they way they all are? And if so, why? Why not do it on Sundays, when people are presumably going to already be there? I can think of a lot of other reasons, besides my own, why weeknights might be problematic for people, especially in this economy where people have to take what work they can get. I’d think the Church would want to be as accomodating as possible to people who want to convert, but so far it doesn’t seem to be the case.

So to sum up: I really want to be a Catholic. I really want to be able to go through all of the steps together with my husband. But there doesn’t seem to be a practical way for it to happen. I feel extremely frustrated and a little resentful. I find that the longer it goes on like this, the more I feel like giving up entirely, and I don’t know what to do. Any advice, insight or prayers would be extremely appreciated.
 
I will pray for you.

8 months ago I reverted to Catholicism, and I also encountered many practical difficulties like this. It really felt like the world was trying to stop me from joining the Church. I would even ask myself if it was a sign of fate, but my heart dismissed this idea and kept me driving forward.

I can say that many of those hurdles have disappeared today. I really feel like I will soon be able to call myself genuinely and 100% Catholic.

I really hope that you find a way to overcome these difficulties. Being raised Catholic I never had to do the RCIA, but I am sure that it will end soon enough. Maybe this is just a high hurdle. In the mean time, I hope that someone on this forum can help you with these practical difficulties!

All the best,
Robert
 
Has your RCIA director told you that this (your missing class) is putting your confirmation in jeopardy?
 
Maybe you could talk with the priest and meet with him in private to cover what was discussed in class? Have the RCIA coordinator email you the notes? Or alternate classes with your husband so both of you get to experience the classes but neither of you is stuck with the baby all of the time? The coordinator and priest are supposed to work with you to make converting easier. Not everyone is available at the same times, but everyone who wants to should be able to join the Church at the Easter Vigil.

Weeknight RCIA classes are the norm where I live, too. I think they assume people are busy on weekends or something? But, oddly enough, the children’s classes are offered before Mass. 🤷
 
Maybe you could talk with the priest and meet with him in private to cover what was discussed in class? Have the RCIA coordinator email you the notes? Or alternate classes with your husband so both of you get to experience the classes but neither of you is stuck with the baby all of the time? The coordinator and priest are supposed to work with you to make converting easier. Not everyone is available at the same times, but everyone who wants to should be able to join the Church at the Easter Vigil.
x2.

Whenever I’ve been involved with RCIA the priest and the coordinator have worked with the participants to resolve scheduling issues. That included making alternate arrangements and scheduling one-on-one sessions for people who were not able to attend with the regular group.
 
I was the only candidate in my parish, and my sponsor and I went to the presbytery for RCIA. Perhaps the priest could come you your house, seeing it is 2 of you involved?
 
Hi all,

My husband and I both grew up going to various Protestant churches, but spent most of our 20s non-affiliated and not really even Christian at all. However, when we had our son last year, we started thinking about how we wanted him to be raised and the sorts of influences we wanted around him. We decided to give Catholicism a try for a variety of reasons, suffice it to say that we felt drawn to it. and did a great deal of research before we even went to our first Mass. We went to a couple of different parishes, found one we really liked, and signed up for the RCIA program. Now that it’s started, however, we’re having some problems.

Our biggest hurdle has been finding someone to watch our one-year-old during classes. I stay home with him all day and we’ve never really had anyone else watch him before. Our closest family is an hour away and we don’t know anyone else who can watch him (and I’m unwilling to just hire someone off Craiglist; we don’t really have the money to spare anyway). We found someone who can watch him at the church, but not come to our house. So we tried that a couple of times, but the problem is that the classes go so late (from 7:00 pm till about 9:30) that he gets really tired and fussy and starts crying. Since he’s just down the hall from where we’re having the class, everyone can hear him, so I have to run in and stop it. Last time he started up immediately, and I ended up missing the whole class because he was being clingy and wouldn’t let me leave.

Because of the problems with the baby, my husband’s just been going by himself, but I really don’t like it. My husband’s schedule right now is very burdensome on all of us in the first place, and this is just adding another 4 hours a week when he’s not home and I have to watch the baby by myself, while he’s off doing something we were supposed to be doing together. Both he and I have tried to talk to the RCIA coordinator about our predicament, but she’s not been able to help us.

It’s gotten to the point where I’m ready to just scrap the whole idea. I like going to Mass, and I love learning about the Catholic faith and I really feel like it’s right for me and my family, but I don’t like feeling like I have to jump through all of these hoops. I’m used to Protestant churches where you can be a member just by showing up. I understand why the Catholic church requires a few more steps than that, but it should not be so burdensome a thing. All the Catholic churches in my area have RCIA on weeknights-- is that they way they all are? And if so, why? Why not do it on Sundays, when people are presumably going to already be there? I can think of a lot of other reasons, besides my own, why weeknights might be problematic for people, especially in this economy where people have to take what work they can get. I’d think the Church would want to be as accomodating as possible to people who want to convert, but so far it doesn’t seem to be the case.

So to sum up: I really want to be a Catholic. I really want to be able to go through all of the steps together with my husband. But there doesn’t seem to be a practical way for it to happen. I feel extremely frustrated and a little resentful. I find that the longer it goes on like this, the more I feel like giving up entirely, and I don’t know what to do. Any advice, insight or prayers would be extremely appreciated.
As others have said, there are probably solutions to your issues.

However, we are not running the RCIA in your church. Our opinions will not resolve your issues.

You and your husband need to bring up the issues with the pastor and the RCIA coordinator.
 
We hold our RCIA classes on Sunday after Mass. But you would probably have the same problem finding someone to watch your child on Sunday morning. If you can’t get someone in your parish to teach one of you (one on one), maybe one of you could take RCIA on a different night at a different parish, not an ideal situation but I would rather do do that than to give up on the process (and the Church)!
 
I am praying for you!

I know in our group we do our best to accommodate the little ones - we have sometimes had as many babies in our class as Inquirers. 🙂

I don’t find them disruptive at all, but that’s quite possibly because I am going deaf. 🤷
 
You could ask your RCIA teacher if there might be a confirmation student or teenager who could volunteer some service time to watch your child during the RCIA class, in another room. At our parish, confirmation students have to have a certain number of community service hours.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top