I have a question, if a child’s parent was born Protestant and is beginning RCIA but the one year old child is not baptized what options are there for baptizing the child? If the child were to die before baptism, but it was the parents intention to have the baby baptized as soon as possible does baptism of desire come in to play? What are the church’s teaching on this? Thank you
The parents should speak with the pastor of the parish. The canon requires that he (the pastor) have a “founded hope” that the child will be raised Catholic. That lies in the middle ground between certitude and complete uncertainty.
The canon is elastic enough to give a latitude to the one who has the
cura animarum for his parish while also giving a definite orientation that is not to be interpreted too broadly or too strictly. The discussions surrounding this concept with my students were always the most interesting, as they struggled to apply the canon in situations I would propose to them.
Presuming that the parents and baby are in the first world, the vast majority of one year old children live and the value of applying the question of mortality in this instance is dubious. (If the child has an actual disability or life threatening condition or there is truly an expectation that the child is facing something life-threatening, of course the pastor should be informed of this at once.) However, the disposition of the parents is much less dubious.
If they are simply considering becoming Catholic, that is one thing. If they are firm in their intention and demonstrate that they’re determinedly on a path to become Catholic, that can qualify as a founded hope that the infant would be raised Catholic. If the parents have already been received into full communion with the Church, we are markedly beyond the threshold of founded hope.
The decision rests by canon law with the pastor – and since he knows the parties concerned, he is best positioned to make an informed decision and application.