Understanding our transgender moment

  • Thread starter Thread starter JimG
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

JimG

Guest
“The simple reality is that you can’t change your sex. There is no way to “reassign” sex because sex isn’t “assigned” in the first place. The best biology, psychology, and philosophy all support an understanding of sex as a bodily reality, and of gender as a social manifestation of bodily sex. Biology isn’t bigotry.”

 
I’ve often wondered about people who believe they are a different gender from what their biology dictates. I’m a man, but let’s say I believe I’m really a woman. So I undergo the hormone therapy and maybe even surgeries, but new clothes and all the rest. But still, in my brain/mind, it seems I’d still have that dissonance. There isn’t a scale that slowly tips toward my desired gender, no matter how much I change my appearance or physical body. There’s no switch to flip that tells my mind “Ok, you’ve arrived, you’re a woman now.” I’m 28 and I’ve never had a singular moment, a dividing line in my life where on one side is adolescence and the other is adulthood. So it seems like, no matter what lengths one would go to to alter their physical appearance, the mind can’t be so easily fooled. You begin with some sort of disconnect between reality and what you believe reality ought to be, but that disconnect is never resolved. In fact it seems that changing the physical to match the hoped for reality would, in the long run, make things worse because one would eventually have to face the reality that, despite those physical changes, the mind hasn’t changed. I’ve read a few storied of people who had gender reassignment procedures/therapy who, years later, deeply regretted the decision. Some transition back, most say it ultimately made their lives worse, for various reasons. I feel terrible that people go through this, and it’s not something I can relate to. It’s similar to people who want to be euthanized; my Church and my reason tells me it’s wrong, but could you imagine being in so much anguish that death seems a better option? Heartbreaking.
 
I can’t imagine feeling trapped in my own body. I have some issues I’d love to not have, but nothing to compare to what I’ve heard people describe with gender dysmorphia. I think the GLBTQ community, as a whole, has been unduly demonized by Christians (that goes for our non-Catholic friends, too). If I have a problem with porn or alcohol or gambling the Church presents itself as a place for healing, understanding (not acceptance) and clear pastoral guidance. Christ’s arms are perpetually outstretched; it is impossible for Him to hold any of us at arms length. I don’t think it outrageous to say those who struggle with these issues are the lepers of our time.
 
I’ve often wondered about people who believe they are a different gender from what their biology dictates. I’m a man, but let’s say I believe I’m really a woman. So I undergo the hormone therapy and maybe even surgeries, but new clothes and all the rest. But still, in my brain/mind, it seems I’d still have that dissonance. There isn’t a scale that slowly tips toward my desired gender, no matter how much I change my appearance or physical body. There’s no switch to flip that tells my mind “Ok, you’ve arrived, you’re a woman now.” I’m 28 and I’ve never had a singular moment, a dividing line in my life where on one side is adolescence and the other is adulthood. So it seems like, no matter what lengths one would go to to alter their physical appearance, the mind can’t be so easily fooled. You begin with some sort of disconnect between reality and what you believe reality ought to be, but that disconnect is never resolved. In fact it seems that changing the physical to match the hoped for reality would, in the long run, make things worse because one would eventually have to face the reality that, despite those physical changes, the mind hasn’t changed. I’ve read a few storied of people who had gender reassignment procedures/therapy who, years later, deeply regretted the decision. Some transition back, most say it ultimately made their lives worse, for various reasons. I feel terrible that people go through this, and it’s not something I can relate to. It’s similar to people who want to be euthanized; my Church and my reason tells me it’s wrong, but could you imagine being in so much anguish that death seems a better option? Heartbreaking.
I understand what you are saying, but I think the whole reason transgender people go through reassignment surgery, etc. it so they can be more comfortable. Imagine, as a boy, if you were required to present yourself to the world as a girl. Think about how uncomfortable that would make you. I think transgender folks are just looking to be comfortable in their own skin. I am sure there are varying degrees of how they perceive themselves once they have surgery, etc. I am not sure that perception has much to do with their level of comfort. They are still the same person on the inside. They are just more comfortable with what is on the outside.
 
I don’t doubt that discomfort is major factor in making those decisions. Were I in the same position I can’t say I wouldn’t. That’s merely my speculation, nothing more. I only know how I would want to be treated in my time of need, and I’m also well aware that, often times, that aid can come with some stern advice and warnings. If I’m on the verge of losing my family due to gambling, I shouldn’t be surprised when a priest tells me I need to quit gambling.
 
I agree with your last statement whole heartedly. It’s not an easy line to tow. I’m glad the leper analogy doesn’t fit your experience. Perhaps it’s just the people I’ve been exposed to.
 
I admit to being confused between transgender, cross dressing, and transvestites.

I think males should use the men’s room, no matter what their attire.

In schools, I ponder that we should have a universal dress code rather than different expectations for male vs female. Loose clothing, no belly skin, etc. Some basic guidance that works for both genders and avoids sexualization.
 
What bothers me is that there seems to be an idea that a boy can know what it feels like to actually be a girl. The reality is that a boy can only know what it looks like to be a girl. This was brought home to me when a boy wanted to be able to dress for PE in the girls’ locker room and the girls did not want him to. If he really felt like a girl, he would have understood why the girls didn’t want a person who is biologically male in the locker room with them while they were dressing. He had a male outlook to the situation instead.
 
Cognitive dissonance is incredibly strong in these people. They deserve our compassion, but they do not deserve our approval for denying the truth of their biology and attempting to impose that denial on our society.
 
What Annie said x 1000, the lack of empathy some of these people have for girls and women is astounding.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top