Unsure of prayers?

  • Thread starter Thread starter DiscerningTheTruth
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

DiscerningTheTruth

Guest
When my grandfather passed away, some of his last words before going into a coma were a reaffirmation of his lifelong atheism and what was essentially a blasphemous cursing of God. Is it pointless, or even wrong, to pray for the repose of his soul as there seems to be little chance he is in Purgatory?
 
We never know what God in his Mercy will do, so we don’t know who goes to heaven or not, and shouldn’t assume anything. Pray for him anyway. And I am sorry for your loss.
 
We will never know for sure on this earth if he encountered God’s Mercy or God’s Justice after his death. Personally I would still pray for him and have some Masses offered for him. If he is in Purgatory he will benefit greatly from prayers, if he is lost for eternity your prayers may still be of benefit for other souls.
 
Last edited:
Jonah prayed to the LORD from the belly of the fish before he died, where no other human ear could hear his repentance and pleadings. And three days later he was spit out onto the beach and the (Angel of the) LORD spoke, “Arise!”

After all this, Jonah told his episode of dying and being raised from the dead. In the resurrection many will tell how the LORD heard their cry as they died.
 
Only God, Himself, can judge us after we die. It is devastating for your family to think that your grandfather had no chance of heaven, so stop thinking that way as soon as you can trust God enough to do so, for at least two reasons. The first reason, of course, is that only God can judge us when we die.

The second reason is that to assume the worst scenario for your grandfather is detrimental to your health. You must carefully guard over this precious body, mind, and soul that God gave to you—His gift to you, and yours to cherish. Don’t make yourself sick over a situation that is not yours to judge. Just place all of your trust in Jesus, and, yes, do pray for your grandfather’s soul.

We have only a fraction of the understanding of the depth and scope of what God can do and will do. It’s entirely possible that in what we perceive as a coma, or unconsciousness, however brief or lengthy, was a time during which your grandfather reached a new level of understanding, and did decide that he wanted to be with God. We’re not privy to those last communications between God and man, so we must proceed as we would for any other poor soul who has died and “pray them to heaven.”

We know that time is different for God, with no restrictions as to what he can accomplish. With God, nothing is impossible and all things are possible. It’s God’s world and His rules. Since He’s the umpire, we must trust Him to take care of all His children, even His wayward children, as He sees fit. For our part, we can pray for their souls each day, just as we hope that someday someone will pray for us after we die.

It might comfort you to study Catholic teaching about temporal atonement for sins, purgatory, and indulgences. Best wishes to you and your family.

Continue to pray for him according to your beliefs, but let God do all the judging
 
Just entrust him to God and pray for him regularly.
Yes, you can and should have Mass said for him.

You have no idea what went on while he was in that coma. He might have had a “come to Jesus moment” as they say.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top