Was Pontius Pilate really a bad guy?

  • Thread starter Thread starter callmeChris
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Pilate, being sent by Tiberius as prefect to Judaea, introduced into Jerusalem by night and under cover the effigies of Caesar which are called standards. This proceeding, when day broke, aroused immense excitement among the Jews; those on the spot were in consternation, considering their laws to have been trampled under foot, as those laws permit no image to be erected in the city; while the indignation of the townspeople stirred the countryfolk, who flocked together in crowds.

Hastening after Pilate to Caesarea, the Jews implored him to remove the standards from Jerusalem and to uphold the laws of their ancestors. When Pilate refused, they fell prostrate around his palace and for five whole days and nights remained motionless in that position. On the ensuing day Pilate took his seat on his tribunal in the great stadium and summoning the multitude, with the apparent intention of answering them, gave the arranged signal to his armed soldiers to surround the Jews.

Finding themselves in a ring of troops, three deep, the Jews were struck dumb at this unexpected sight. Pilate, after threatening to cut them down, if they refused to admit Caesar’s images, signaled to the soldiers to draw their swords. Thereupon the Jews, as by concerted action, flung themselves in a body on the ground, extended their necks, and exclaimed that they were ready rather to die than to transgress the law. Overcome with astonishment at such intense religious zeal, Pilate gave orders for the immediate removal of the standards from Jerusalem.

On a later occasion he provoked a fresh uproar by expending upon the construction of an aqueduct the sacred treasure known as Corbonas; the water was brought from a distance of seventy kilometers. Indignant at this proceeding, the populace formed a ring round the tribunal of Pilate, then on a visit to Jerusalem, and besieged him with angry clamor.

He, foreseeing the tumult, had interspersed among the crowd a troop of his soldiers, armed but disguised in civilian dress, with orders not to use their swords, but to beat any rioters with cudgels. He now from his tribunal gave the agreed signal. Large numbers of the Jews perished, some from the blows which they received, others trodden to death by their companions in the ensuing flight. Cowed by the fate of the victims, the multitude was reduced to silence.
  • Josephus, Jewish War 2.169-177
 
Now Pilate, the prefect of Judaea, when he brought his army from Caesarea and removed it to winter quarters in Jerusalem, took a bold step in subversion of the Jewish practices, by introducing into the city the busts of the emperor that were attached to the military standards, for our law forbids the making of images. It was for this reason that the previous prefects, when they entered the city, used standards that had no such ornaments. Pilate was the first to bring the images into Jerusalem and set them up, doing it without the knowledge of the people, for he entered at night.

But when the people discovered it, they went in a throng to Caesarea and for many days entreated him to take away the images. He refused to yield, since to do so would be an outrage to the emperor; however, since they did not cease entreating him, on the sixth day he secretly armed and placed his troops in position, while he himself came to the speaker’s stand. This had been constructed in the stadium, which provided concealment for the army that lay in wait.

When the Jews again engaged in supplication, at a pre-arranged signal he surrounded them with his soldiers and threatened to punish them at once with death if they did not put an end to their tumult and return to their own places. But they, casting themselves prostrate and baring their throats, declared that they had gladly welcomed death rather than make bold to transgress the wise provisions of the laws. Pilate, astonished at the strength of their devotion to the laws, straightway removed the images from Jerusalem and brought them back to Caesarea.

He spent money from the sacred treasury in the construction of an aqueduct to bring water into Jerusalem, intercepting the source of the stream at a distance of thirty-five kilometers. The Jews did not acquiesce in the operations that this involved; and tens of thousands of men assembled and cried out against him, bidding him relinquish his promotion of such designs. Some too even hurled insults and abuse of the sort that a throng will commonly engage in.

He thereupon ordered a large number of soldiers to be dressed in Jewish garments, under which they carried clubs, and he sent them off this way and that, thus surrounding the Jews, whom he ordered to withdraw. When the Jews were in full torrent of abuse he gave his soldiers the prearranged signal. They, however, inflicted much harder blows than Pilate had ordered, punishing alike both those who were rioting and those who were not. But the Jews showed no faint-heartedness; and so, caught unarmed, as they were, by men delivering a prepared attack, many of them actually were slain on the spot, while some withdrew disabled by blows. Thus ended the uprising.
 
At this time there appeared Jesus, a wise man. …] For he was a doer of startling deeds, a teacher of the people who receive the truth with pleasure. And he gained a following both among many Jews and among many of Greek origin. …] And when Pilate, because of an accusation made by the leading men among us, condemned him to the cross, those who had loved him previously did not cease to do so. …] And up until this very day the tribe of Christians, named after him, has not died out.

…]

The Samaritan nation too was not exempt from disturbance. For a man who made light of mendacity and in all his designs catered to the mob, rallied them, bidding them go in a body with him to Mount Gerizim, which in their belief is the most sacred of mountains. He assured them that on their arrival he would show them the sacred vessels which were buried there, where Moses had deposited them.

His hearers, viewing this tale as plausible, appeared in arms. They posted themselves in a certain village named Tirathana, and, as they planned to climb the mountain in a great multitude, they welcomed to their ranks the new arrivals who kept coming. But before they could ascend, Pilate blocked their projected route up the mountain with a detachment of cavalry and heavily armed infantry, who in an encounter with the first comers in the village slew some in a pitched battle and put the others to flight. Many prisoners were taken, of whom Pilate put to death the principal leaders and those who were most influential among the fugitives.

When the uprising had been quelled, the council of the Samaritans went to Vitellius, a man of consular rank who was governor of Syria, and charged Pilate with the slaughter of the victims. For, they said, it was not as rebels against the Romans but as refugees from the persecution of Pilate that they had met in Tirathana. Vitellius thereupon dispatched Marcellus, one of his friends, to take charge of the administration of Judaea, and ordered Pilate to return to Rome to give the emperor his account of the matters with which he was charged by the Samaritans. And so Pilate, after having spent ten years in Judaea, hurried to Rome in obedience to the orders of Vitellius, since he could not refuse. But before he reached Rome, Tiberius had already passed away.
  • Josephus, Antiquities 18.55-64, 85-89
That’s pretty much all there is about Pilate. You decide.
 
What are you suggesting? That there’s a conspiracy controlling the world’s leaders with a threat of assassination? Sorry but real life tends to be less exciting than that compared to the movies. 😉

Ever been in an uprising? Have you lost your family to one? I’m sure our history books can tell us a lot. Bloody affairs aren’t they? Tell me, do you really think it was just Pilate’s life that was at stake? The more power you have in terms of rule, the more delicate your decisions end up. The death of one followed by the rioting chaos of many? I think you’re underestimating the repercussions of allowing mobs become revolutions.

Clearly you are either downplaying the symbolism of Pilate’s hand washing or you don’t know what it really means. Washing off one’s hands the way he did is an expression that basically says it’s not on him anymore.

And honestly, without sufficient force of arms, it’s hard to say Pilate really had any much of a choice. :hmmm:

Who are you to give a test on a position you never had? :rolleyes:
Look, I really have trouble following your train of thought. I don’t understand what you are so upset about, but you certainly seem to think that I am suggesting that I am some kind of seer who believes she knows what she does not. I am posting thoughts I have had on a situation of which we do not know the details. We don’t know EXACTLY what Pilate was afraid of. We can only make educated guesses. We don’t know EXACTLY what Pilate was thinking or how formed his conscience was. We can only make assumptions.

Also, whether or not I have ever been in an uprising has absolutely nothing to do with anything. I daresay most who read the Passion have not been in an uprising. Should we all then ponder only those things in Scripture which we have personally been through?

Last, I haven’t given any test and have no clue what you’re talking about. Is the position I’ve never had Pilate’s exact position? You are correct, I have never been Pontius Pilate. Nor have I been Mary, Jesus, Joseph, Moses, Julius Caesar, Marie Antoinette, President Carter, Jennifer Lopez, etc…what does that have to do with anything?

I am sorry, friend, I simply don’t get your ire.
 
And honestly, without sufficient force of arms, it’s hard to say Pilate really had any much of a choice. :hmmm
And one more thing: Of course he had a choice. Did St. Peter have a choice? St. Maximilliam Kolbe? Pope St. Leo the Great? Pilate had a choice. And he made it against Jesus.
 
In the Ethiopian Orthodox Church Pilate and his wife are regarded as saints. His wife for her dream and subsequent attempts to stop the crucifixion and both for a later conversion to Christianity after the resurrection.
 
In the Ethiopian Orthodox Church Pilate and his wife are regarded as saints. His wife for her dream and subsequent attempts to stop the crucifixion and both for a later conversion to Christianity after the resurrection.
I hadn’t heard that. Let’s hope they’re right!
 
In the Ethiopian Orthodox Church Pilate and his wife are regarded as saints. His wife for her dream and subsequent attempts to stop the crucifixion and both for a later conversion to Christianity after the resurrection.
One thing we could notice about Christianity of the first two centuries is the gradual intensification of anti-Judaism. As the rift between Christianity and Judaism grew wider apart, so did the conflict between them become more and more pronounced. During this period the Pilate and Romans were increasingly absolved of any responsibility for Jesus’ death; instead, “the Jews” are now considered to be the only ones who were guilty. In its most extreme form, Pilate doesn’t even pass sentence on Jesus: it is the Jewish mob who torture and crucify Him.

Pilate’s role as the one who condemns Jesus generally diminishes in later Christian sources. The idea is that the more the state persecuted Christians, the more generous becomes the description of Pilate as a witness to Jesus’ innocence. This trend has a precedent, ironically enough, in Jewish apologetics: Philo appealed to Caligula and reminded him of the many privileges that previous emperors had granted to Jews, in response to measures the emperor was about to enforce that were offensive to Jewish sensibilities. The funny thing is, the positive portrayal of Pilate ends in the 4th century, coincidentally with the arrival of Constantine and the recognition of Christianity as a legal religion. The Edict of Milan made it so that Christians no longer needed an ally in the form of a Roman official. Constantine and his successors were living, breathing emperors whose stature overshadowed that of a long-dead governor.

But of the Judaeans none washed the hands, neither Herod nor any one of his judges. And since they would not wash Pilate rose up, and then Herod the king orders that the Lord be taken away, speaking to them, “What I ordered you to do to him, do.” Now there was Joseph the friend of Pilate and the Lord there, and knowing they were about to crucify him, he came to Pilate and requested the body of the Lord for burial, and Pilate, having sent to Herod, requested his body. And Herod said, “Brother Pilate, even if nobody had requested him, we would have buried him since also Sabbath is dawning, because it is written in the Law: ‘The sun must not set on one who has been murdered.’” And he [Herod] handed him over to the people before the first of Unleavened Bread, their feast.

Now having taken the Lord they [the people] were pushing him, running, and saying, “Let us drag the Son of God along, having authority over him.” And they clothed him with purple and set him upon a seat of judgment, saying, “Judge righteously, King of Israel!” And one of them, having brought a thorny wreath-crown, set it upon the head of the Lord, and others, standing, were spitting in his eyes, and the rest struck his cheeks. Others were jabbing him with a reed-staff, and some scourged him, saying, “With such honour let us honour the son of God.” And they brought two wrongdoers and crucified the Lord in the midst between them, but he was silent as if having no pain. And they, when they set the cross upright, inscribed that ‘THIS IS THE KING OF ISRAEL.’ And having placed his clothes before him, they divided them up and cast a lot upon them.
 
LostWanderer:

I apologize for my rash tone. I still don’t get you and think you don’t get me, but I hope in Heaven we can have a chuckle about it.

Happy Easter, brother.
 
Here’s a quote about Pilate from Pope Benedict XVI’s book Jesus of Nazareth, Holy Week: from the Entrance into Jerusalem to the Resurrection:
"While Flavius Josephus and especially Philo of Alexandria paint a rather negative picture of him, other sources portray him as decisive, pragmatic, and realistic…The image of Pilate in the Gospels presents the Roman Prefect quite realistically as a man who could be brutal when he judged this to be in the interests of public order. Yet he also knew that Rome owed its world dominance not least to its tolerance of foreign divinities and to the capacity of Roman law to build peace. This is how he comes across to us during Jesus’ trial.’

And from volume II of Daniel-Rops’ book Jesus and His Times:
“It would be unwise to accept without qualification all that the two Jews, Philo and Josephus, say about him, for these fanatical nationalists accuse him of every crime in the calendar…We know that the Procurator had a heavy hand: reference has already been made to his harsh reprisals in Galilee (Luke xiii, 1). But the man responsible for the order of a province where the population was notoriously hard to manage had small choice of method.”

Just cited these two sources for balance here.
 
I think he was just an average guy who had a tough job and he knew how to do it. He was ambitios, pragmatic and wanted to do well in his career. I think that most people who share these characteristics would do the same thing today. I never saw him as a particularly bad guy, but a great example of human nature. I always found him very real and modern. I could never relate to the reformed prostitute or the Jewish priests, or even the Apostles - they all seemed remote to me. But Pilate has something that I can relate to and understand. Scary, no? I hope God was merciful to him and that his wife who followed Jesus prayed for him very hard.
 
One point against Pilate, which hasn’t been given much attention on this thread: according to St. Matthew’s gospel, his wife warned him (based on a dream) not to have anything to do with Jesus. He evidently paid no attention to this.

That said, we really don’t have enough information about Pilate to judge him. He may have been a horrible man, or perhaps he was just doing what he believed his duty required.
 
His sin was cowardice. Though there is evidence that he converted eventually.
 
One point against Pilate, which hasn’t been given much attention on this thread: according to St. Matthew’s gospel, his wife warned him (based on a dream) not to have anything to do with Jesus. He evidently paid no attention to this.

That said, we really don’t have enough information about Pilate to judge him. He may have been a horrible man, or perhaps he was just doing what he believed his duty required.
Didn’t that warning actually reinforce Pilate in trying to get out of the case?
 
Didn’t that warning actually reinforce Pilate in trying to get out of the case?
Yes, I suppose it did. I guess it was unfair to say that he paid no attention. Of course, in the end it was not the determining factor in his decision.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top