Was the Papacy divinely established?

  • Thread starter Thread starter MilesVitae
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It would be an interesting read.
I don’t recall the point in question being a large part of the passage - just a passing mention, something like “for this reason the fathers bestowed privileges on you [the Church in Rome].” If only I could find it - at this point, my memory of it may be somewhat inaccurate anyway.
Canon 28 never had Ecumenical status, and was never accepted by the Church of Rome. Just because Rome eventually accepted Constantinople among the as second among the Patriarchates (an act of oikonomia, I really believe), that does not mean that Canon 28 was accepted. Canon 28 had a clause that was simply unacceptable to the Tradition of the Church - namely, that Constantinople was part of the Pentarchy for the sheer reason that it was the new capital of the Empire. Rome NEVER accepted that. It was not until after Constantinople began claiming apostolicity from St. Andrew as the basis for its place in the Pentarchy, it was not until the East had explicitly removed any mention of the capital status of Constantinople as the basis for its place in the pentarchy (which happened at the Synod of Trullo) that Rome could finally agree to give Constantinople a place in the order of Patriarchates.
I just read this in another thread - the infallibility roundtable, I think . 🙂 I actually didn’t mean to imply that Rome ever accepted Canon 28 - but I thought that even the East didn’t accept it for centuries, and eastern writers for a long time only spoke of 27 Canons of Chalcedon.
 
That is a logical and worthy consideration, one that I applied in my own study of Catholicism when I was not yet Catholic. But I believe you cannot get around the quotes that are part of the Acts of Ecumenical Councils (from Pope St. Leo, Pope St. Agatho, etc.). If you have studied the Ecumenical Councils, you will discover that the Greek Acts do not always perfectly coincide with the Latin Acts, particularly in places where the authority of Rome is at issue, even for correspondences from the Pope. But if you find that there is no difference, then such claims by the Roman See indeed had Ecumenical acceptance, as they were enshrined as part of the Acts of the Councils.

Blessings,
Marduk
Hmmm, interesting. I’ve never looked into (or been aware) of differences between the two. Do you have specific examples in mind?

Also, if there were differences between the two versions of the Acts, specifically regarding the claims of Rome, then the East did take issue, to some extent, with Rome?
I apologize - I’ve really never studied early Church history much before now, so there are a lot of matters about which I am ignorant.
 
…Certainly some of the fathers did seem to hold that the role of the bishop of Rome was of divine origin - for instance, Saint Jerome and some of the popes themselves. Could this not have been an erroneous development of thought on their part, however?
Good going with the research! You are on the right track. And what would you expect a pope to say???
 
Good going with the research! You are on the right track. And what would you expect a pope to say???
If he were truly the holder of Peter’s primacy, I would expect him to say something like what Leo, etc. do say.

If he were attempting to falsely use the petrine origins of his church as a way to claim more power for himself, I would expect him to say something like what Leo, etc. do say.

If he had come to a mistaken, but understandablem notion of his own authority and relation to that of Peter’s, I would expect him to say something like what Leo, etc. do say.
 
Is there any patristic basis for the Davidic Kingdom interpretation of Mt 16:18. Undeniably, keys are a symbol of power. But are the keys given to Peter really a reference to the steward of Isaiah 22:22? And, are they passed on, or did it refer only to a unique role among the Apostles (who all possessed the power of binding and loosing, and - if my memory serves me - all participated in the power of the keys)?
I had actually found two Father when I was studying the ECF/NPNF series that connects the keys of Isaiah 22:22 to the authority of the Church. Unfortunately, I don’t have my book series with me, and I do not have the time or the will to research CCEL.

Of course, I don’t expect you to take just my word for it, but I assure you it is there if you want to take the time to look for it.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
If he were truly the holder of Peter’s primacy, I would expect him to say something like what Leo, etc. do say.

If he were attempting to falsely use the petrine origins of his church as a way to claim more power for himself, I would expect him to say something like what Leo, etc. do say.

If he had come to a mistaken, but understandablem notion of his own authority and relation to that of Peter’s, I would expect him to say something like what Leo, etc. do say.
One thing that is fascinating about the human mind is that if it accepts a notion as “true,” it will make everything conform to the accepted proposition. It takes a willy awareness to outsmart the mind and its tricks. Such is the two edged sword of mind!
 
Hmmm, interesting. I’ve never looked into (or been aware) of differences between the two. Do you have specific examples in mind?
Again, I wish I had my hard copy of the ECF/NPNF series with me! I actually recently had a friend mail me the volume on the Seven Ecumenical Councils here to the Philippines (which I should receive by the end of January). But the Acts of of Chalcedon, IIRC, contains some of these differences.
Also, if there were differences between the two versions of the Acts, specifically regarding the claims of Rome, then the East did take issue, to some extent, with Rome?
Yes. There was never any question, denial, or objection to Rome’s claim of having the primacy. The issue was always with certain claims that could be misconstrued to mean that Rome had the unilateral authority to interfere in the affairs of local Churches on his own initiative. No Church accepted this. High Petrine and Low Petrine advocates share this same view against the Absolutist Petrine position. The High Petrine position accepts the appellate authority of Rome to intervene, and even the direct authority to uphold universal canons of the Church if local authorities are found to be unjustifiably contravening such universal canons, but not an absolute nor unilateral authority to intervene in the affairs of local Churches.
I apologize - I’ve really never studied early Church history much before now, so there are a lot of matters about which I am ignorant.
And I apologize for not having my hard copy of the ECF/NPNF series on hand so I can back up what I am stating more readily and put your mind at ease.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
One thing that is fascinating about the human mind is that if it accepts a notion as “true,” it will make everything conform to the accepted proposition. It takes a willy awareness to outsmart the mind and its tricks. Such is the two edged sword of mind!
I’m confused…what’s your point?
 
I had actually found two Father when I was studying the ECF/NPNF series that connects the keys of Isaiah 22:22 to the authority of the Church. Unfortunately, I don’t have my book series with me, and I do not have the time or the will to research CCEL.

Of course, I don’t expect you to take just my word for it, but I assure you it is there if you want to take the time to look for it.

Blessings,
Marduk
None the less, thank you much for your very helpful answers.
 
Again, I wish I had my hard copy of the ECF/NPNF series with me! I actually recently had a friend mail me the volume on the Seven Ecumenical Councils here to the Philippines (which I should receive by the end of January). But the Acts of of Chalcedon, IIRC, contains some of these differences.
More excuses! 😉

and…what does IIRC stand for?
Yes. There was never any question, denial, or objection to Rome’s claim of having the primacy. The issue was always with certain claims that could be misconstrued to mean that Rome had the unilateral authority to interfere in the affairs of local Churches on his own initiative. No Church accepted this. High Petrine and Low Petrine advocates share this same view against the Absolutist Petrine position. The High Petrine position accepts the appellate authority of Rome to intervene, and even the direct authority to uphold universal canons of the Church if local authorities are found to be unjustifiably contravening such universal canons, but not an absolute nor unilateral authority to intervene in the affairs of local Churches.
Ah, yes, the High Petrine view…more to study.
 
More excuses! 😉
😃
and…what does IIRC stand for?
If I Recall Correctly.
Ah, yes, the High Petrine view…more to study.
And the High Petrine view is indeed worth studying.🙂 You might not find it under that name, but you will find unanimous evidence for it among the Fathers (and you’ll find little to none for the Absolutist Petrine views of certain Catholics or Low Petrine views of certain Eastern Orthodox).

Blessings,
Marduk
 
😃

If I Recall Correctly.
Ah…haha.
And the High Petrine view is indeed worth studying.🙂 You might not find it under that name, but you will find unanimous evidence for it among the Fathers (and you’ll find little to none for the Absolutist Petrine views of certain Catholics or Low Petrine views of certain Eastern Orthodox).
Blessings,
Marduk
I’ve already looked into the relatio a bit, and plan on getting a copy of the book by Ignatius Press (if I’m not mistaken) which contains it.
 
Marduk,

Did you catch the post about the passage from John Chrysostom commenting on Matthew 24?

Was that the passage you were referring to, and (if so) what are your thoughts on my response to it?
 
I even recall a passage from the early church which speaks of the Fathers bestowing privileges on the church at Rome (I haven’t found it again, yet).
Possibly Ignatius of Antioch? He was made bishop ~69 a.d. and died a martyr in Rome ~107 a.d. He is a disciple of St John the apostle, and thought to be the 1st in writing to call the Church the Catholic Church (letter to the Smyrneans) and he calls only the Church of Rome the Church that presides in love. (letter to the Romans). As an aside, compare the introductions of each of his letters to each Church to get a feel for his thought process in writing to each Church. Keep in mind, Antioch was Peter’s previous see, but as you know Peter didn’t stay there he went to Rome.

Ignatius of Antioch [SAINT]
MV:
Certainly some of the fathers did seem to hold that the role of the bishop of Rome was of divine origin - for instance, Saint Jerome and some of the popes themselves. Could this not have been an erroneous development of thought on their part, however?
Did Jesus not make a special effort in the Gospels to bestow on Peter the leadership role among all the apostles and the Church?

for example

Luke 22: Upper Room (last supper)

24 a dispute arose among them as to which of them was considered to be greatest. 26 the greatest among you should be like the youngest, and the one who rules(hegeomai) like the one who serves. 27 For who is greater, the one who is at the table or the one who serves? Is it not the one who is at the table? But I am among you as one who serves. 28 You are those who have stood by me in my trials. 29 And I confer on you a kingdom, just as my Father conferred one on me, 30 so that you may eat and drink at my table in my kingdom and sit on thrones, judging the twelve tribes of Israel. 31 “Simon, Simon, Satan has asked to sift you (plural) as wheat. 32 But I have prayed for you(singular), Simon, that your faith may not fail. And when you have turned back, strengthen (sterizo) your brothers.”

They weren’t disputing about Jesus being the greatest, but who’s greatest among the apostles. Jesus ends their argument with the following

ἡγέομαι hēgeomai(Jesus is refering to Simon)

definition
  1. to lead
    a) to go before
    b) to be a leader
  2. to rule, command
  3. to have authority over
  4. a prince, of regal power, governor, viceroy, chief, leading as respects influence, controlling in counsel, overseers or leaders of the churches
  5. used of any kind of leader, chief, commander
  6. the leader in speech, chief, spokesman
    στηρίζω stērizō(Simon is to)
definition
  1. to make stable, place firmly, set fast, fix
  2. to strengthen, make firm
  3. to render constant, confirm, one’s mind
Sounds like the papacy Divinely instituted, don’t you think?. There’s other examples as well
 
Yes

“On you Peter I build my Church”

The next Bishop of Rome received the same Authority granted to Peter in succession. With Peter. The Church teaches it, it makes sense, its a tradition that has lasted 2000 years.

How could something last so long if it wasn’t established by God?
 
To Steve B,

I have no objection to the fact that Peter was the first of the Apostles (Mt 16, Lk 22, etc.). I also have no objection to the fact that Rome held a primacy over the other churches (as Saint Ignatius and others witness to), and that this primacy was due to its petrine origins.

What I am concerned with is whether or not the the primacy of Rome was a divinely intended continuation of Peter’s primacy. There were other churches that held special places of honor (such as Antioch and Alexandria), but this honor was not divinely established. The place of Rome could be the same (albiet higher).

Ian Ward,

You are making your assertions on the assumption that Catholicism is true. I am investigating it without that assumption, looking for the evidence for this claim - I am looking to see if the Catholic claims for the papacy are indeed a 2,000 year old tradition.
 
To Steve B,

I have no objection to the fact that Peter was the first of the Apostles (Mt 16, Lk 22, etc.). I also have no objection to the fact that Rome held a primacy over the other churches (as Saint Ignatius and others witness to), and that this primacy was due to its petrine origins.

What I am concerned with is whether or not the the primacy of Rome was a divinely intended continuation of Peter’s primacy. There were other churches that held special places of honor (such as Antioch and Alexandria), but this honor was not divinely established. The place of Rome could be the same (albiet higher).
Clearly the Protestant materials you’re exposing yourself to, are disturbing your peace. I think you’ll find no one here will try to create something that hasn’t already had it’s provable roots in place for the last 2000 years. I’m curious, how much work have you done on this project so far? Here’s a couple of things for your consideration.
  • Look through the NT scriptures. Find ALL the cities mentioned in scripture and who received letters from an apostle. All those letters of Paul were written primarily to Churches. Ask yourself, how is Christianity doing there today? How about the ancient sees that you mention?
  • Cardinal James Gibbons observed in his book The Faith of Our Fathers] that "*Peter occupied for a time the city of Antioch as his first See. But, in the mysterious providence of God, he abandoned Antioch and repaired to Rome; and now, little remains of the ancient Antioch of Peter’s day except colossal ruins. Had the Popes remained in Antioch, Syria would now very probably be, instead of Europe, the centre of Christianity and civilization. The immortal Dome of St. Peter’s would, doubtless, overshadow the banks of the Orontes instead of the Tiber; and Antioch, not Rome, would be the focus of art, science, and sacred literature, and would be called today “The Eternal City.” *That’s certainly a very interesting point don’t you think?
  • That dovetails with what I said about Peter in an earlier post…true? forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=8718589&postcount=54
MV:
Ian Ward,

You are making your assertions on the assumption that Catholicism is true. I am investigating it without that assumption, looking for the evidence for this claim - I am looking to see if the Catholic claims for the papacy are indeed a 2,000 year old tradition.
Miles,
you’re in the right place to get the information and evidence you seek. 🙂
 
I’m confused…what’s your point?
You offer three alternatives and claim that the same answer will suffice. As indeed it will, in the sense that given the predilection of any particular individual, their inclination to believe a premise will marshal all other data, true or not, same as another’s argument or not, to validate their particular take on things. It helps if there is a group doing this and supporting each other surrounding a particular premise of any kind.

Better?
 
Clearly the Protestant materials you’re exposing yourself to, are disturbing your peace. I think you’ll find no one here will try to create something that hasn’t already had it’s provable roots in place for the last 2000 years. I’m curious, how much work have you done on this project so far? Here’s a couple of things for your consideration.
Actually, I have read very little Protestant material on the subject (and most positive arguments I have seen against the papacy don’t bother me too much). For that matter, I haven’t read much Orthodox material on the subject. So far, I have been primarily engaged in looking for patristic evidence for the papacy, as well as understanding the reasons for it. Since I believe there is support for the Catholic position, I am beginning to try to find patristic objections to the papacy.
  • Look through the NT scriptures. Find ALL the cities mentioned in scripture and who received letters from an apostle. All those letters of Paul were written primarily to Churches. Ask yourself, how is Christianity doing there today? How about the ancient sees that you mention?
  • Cardinal James Gibbons observed in his book The Faith of Our Fathers] that "*Peter occupied for a time the city of Antioch as his first See. But, in the mysterious providence of God, he abandoned Antioch and repaired to Rome; and now, little remains of the ancient Antioch of Peter’s day except colossal ruins. Had the Popes remained in Antioch, Syria would now very probably be, instead of Europe, the centre of Christianity and civilization. The immortal Dome of St. Peter’s would, doubtless, overshadow the banks of the Orontes instead of the Tiber; and Antioch, not Rome, would be the focus of art, science, and sacred literature, and would be called today “The Eternal City.” *That’s certainly a very interesting point don’t you think?
Peter was the first among the Apostles, and so the cities he occupied received honor in the Church - Rome in particular. As the papacy developed (whether legitimately or otherwise), Rome became all the more important in the Church, etc. I don’t see it as particularly strong evidence…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top