Wearing a Rosary

  • Thread starter Thread starter noclevername
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
N

noclevername

Guest
Is it offensive to Catholics to wear a Rosary as jewelry? I am not Catholic but I’m in a Catholic family. My sister who is an alcoholic is living in a half-way house (I have permanent custody of her daughter) and recently found God (Baptist based religion) and she wears a Rosary as a necklace. I thought about saying something to her about it and then wasn’t sure if I should or not. Should I say something?
 
I would say something to her, yes. Rather surprised a Baptist would want anything to do with a Catholic sacramental or prayer aid. Tell her Catholics pray to Mary using the beads and I’ll bet she’ll yank it off her neck immediately.

😃
 
If I knew someone was wearing a religious item for purely decorative purposes I’d consider speaking to them about it… but firm knowledge in this area is a difficult one.

She may wear it as some small reminder to herself of the Lord.

I would not call that wrong in any way. That’s the only purpose of all the medals that you see in the parish repositories. You wear them to remind you of a devotion to some saint or apparition of Our Lady, or the Sacred Heart etc.

Of course to ascribe to them any special power is superstition and against properly understood church teaching.
 
Your sister is an alcoholic, living in a half way house, with a Rosary around her neck???
Wow. Don’t you dare say a word!!
I can think of a number of people that I would love to see a Rosary around their neck! Keep praying for her.
 
Check out this thread:
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=80700
Accordingly, it isn’t offensive to Catholics if people wear rosaries as jewelry.
You might like to let your sister know what the purpose of the rosary is. She may already be aware of the purpose. In which case, she has her own reasons for wearing the rosary that should not offend anyone but anti-Catholics.
 
How sad that your sister is in such bad circumstances! In light of this perhaps it’s good that she’s wearing a rosary as she sure needs prayer, healing and protection. She may be wearing it for just that reason- it could be indicative of her faith and her recognition that she needs our Lord and His Blessed Mother in her life. She sounds like a bruised reed, poor thing.😦
 
Your sister is an alcoholic, living in a half way house, with a Rosary around her neck???
Wow. Don’t you dare say a word!!
I can think of a number of people that I would love to see a Rosary around their neck! Keep praying for her.
😊

You are right, and I was wrong. Perhaps someone gave her the rosary with a hope that she would eventually reach the Truth of the Catholic Church.

I retract the glib comment I made earlier. Your sister is in recovery and has come to know God. One day at a time. Let her be. And yes, pray.
 
😊

You are right, and I was wrong. Perhaps someone gave her the rosary with a hope that she would eventually reach the Truth of the Catholic Church.

I retract the glib comment I made earlier. Your sister is in recovery and has come to know God. One day at a time. Let her be. And yes, pray.
You are very kind.
I understand where you are coming from, the idea of a Baptist wearing a Rosary would make me smile too. If only she knew! Ignorance is bliss in this circumstance. 😉
 
Has these Rosary Beads been blessed? If so, they should be treated as such. I would never propose anyone say anything negative to her. It might be a nice move to tell her how proud of her you are. you could also ask her to join you in either saying the rosary or just a Hail Mary together. Tell her you will pray to Mary for her recovery (and do it). Has it ever occurred to you that maybe Mary or God had someone, or even herself, place those rosaries on her as a way of bringing her closer to recovery? Miracles and recovery happen everyday. Just remember to both, “Give and Forgive”…jimperu
 
For a while I saw a lot of this. They were worn as a fashion statement, or as a tongue-in-cheek poke at Catholics. Madonna wore them as a sign of disrespect to the Church, and they are frequently worn by gang members.

I’d be gentle with your sister. It’s not the end of the world, but technically a rosary is not a fashion accessory.

Best of luck to her in her recovery.
 
Is it offensive to Catholics to wear a Rosary as jewelry? I am not Catholic but I’m in a Catholic family. My sister who is an alcoholic is living in a half-way house (I have permanent custody of her daughter) and recently found God (Baptist based religion) and she wears a Rosary as a necklace. I thought about saying something to her about it and then wasn’t sure if I should or not. Should I say something?
I wonder how she got a hold of it. Sadly, wearing a rosary as a neckless can lead to much misunderstanding. Wearing a rosary as a neckless is done by gangs and actually is banned in a number of schools due to that. So instead of it being used a a prayer tool, it becomes a status symbol for rock stars and gangs. Your sister and her struggles maybe doesn’t understand or realize any of this. Maybe not knowing, she thought it was a neckless. A number of religious orders wear them but they are on their belts not around their necks. I think you could ask her where she got it from and what she thinks it means or understands, ask her if wearing it gives her some comfort. I wish both you and her some peace and healing.
 
Your sister is an alcoholic, living in a half way house, with a Rosary around her neck???
Wow. Don’t you dare say a word!!
I can think of a number of people that I would love to see a Rosary around their neck! Keep praying for her.
Thanks for this. The more I think about it, the more I agree with your statement. She’s lost her child, the courts will never give her back so she needs something.
 
Thanks for this. The more I think about it, the more I agree with your statement. She’s lost her child, the courts will never give her back so she needs something.
Can your sister have any contact with her daughter at all? If not, she must have done something pretty egregious. And if she’s in recovery, she will have faced her actions and come to some sort of recognition of the harm she’s done. Very difficult work to do, for alcoholics and for the rest of us!
 
Thanks for this. The more I think about it, the more I agree with your statement. She’s lost her child, the courts will never give her back so she needs something.
I was thinking more along the lines of being in a spiritual battle, and someone has put ‘armor’ on her.

“…draw your strength from the Lord and his mighty power. Put on the armor of God so that you may be able to stand firm against the tactics of the devil. Our battle is not against human forces but against the principalities and powers, the rulers of this world of darkness, the evil spirits in regions above. You must put on the armor of God if you are to resist on the evil day.” Ephesians 6: 10-13

She has definitely been in a battle and losing. The Rosary is a formidable weapon, and whoever has given it to her is praying for her and for her victory. May you see it!
 
May the rosary draw her closer to her higher power. I know it did for this prodigal in recovery.

dave
 
There is nothing wrong with wearing a rosary around the neck in and of itself. There may be subjective motives that are questionable, but unless someone has some special gift of infallibly reading others’ motives, I wouldn’t assume they were questionable motives.
 
My Rosary stays in my pocket. It is not an item of jewelry but an item that helps me get closer to God through the intersession of Our Blessed Mother Mary
 
There are actually rosaries that are made to be worn as a necklace.

If you want to wear one, but can’t find one that will fit over your head, seek out one designed to be worn. 👍
 
Can your sister have any contact with her daughter at all? If not, she must have done something pretty egregious. And if she’s in recovery, she will have faced her actions and come to some sort of recognition of the harm she’s done. Very difficult work to do, for alcoholics and for the rest of us!
My sister is can see her daughter on a very limited basis and only under my direct supervision. And yes, she’s an alcoholic but there is a lot more than just her alcoholism that got her child removed. I have been worried about my niece for her entire life and rightfully so. THe authorities have placed her with me and I now have permanent custody.

My sister is facing her actions. And she is remorseful and understands what she did wrong. But at the same time, she’s living in this “ministry” (I call it a half-way house but they call it a ministry). It’s a non-denominational ministry but they seem like very devout Baptists. (I have learned about many different religions and protistant denominations). They are teaching my sister that she can be “cured” of her alcoholism by reading and studying the Bible. My sister is not getting any counseling, she’s not going to AA, etc. I asked my sister what will happen when (if) she is ever on her own and something very stressful happens if she has any coping mechanisms so she won’t turn to alcohol. She said her coping mechanisms are her faith and the Bible. I applaud her devotion but it makes me very nervous. My sister was an atheist before she had to go to rehab. She found God in rehab but she has been sober barely over a year. So her Christianity is very very new. I am worried that it won’t last and as much as I hate to say this, I worry that it’s not enough to keep her from taking a drink. She needs a sponsor like those in AA but she has nothing like this.

Also, she is not working nor is she going to school or doing anything to better herself. She is allowed to do both where she lives - actually she is encouraged to do so. And there is a small chance that if she petitions the courts, she might get unsupervised visitation or overnight visits with her daughter but she would hvae to work for it and she’s not doing that. That would mean that she has to have a job, a place to live, a place for her daughter to sleep, reliable transportation, sobriety for a period of time, etc. But she’s not wokring for that. She seems content at the half-way house. She told me she’s going to petition for overnights at this half-way house but there is no way I would allow that. I would fight it with everythign I had because there are men at this place. My niece was severly sexually abused by her biological father so there is no way I would ever let my niece stay in a place where there are men she doesn’t know. (My niece revealed this to us after I had custody and her father is now in jail awaiting trial. And part of the reason mom can’t have her back is because my niece told mom about the abuse and mom didn’t do anything and kept letting dad see her). Actually, I would fight overnight no matter where they were. I can explain why but that’s a whole other post.

So I guess what the problem really is is that I am very angry with my sister. I will never understand why she isn’t working her arse off to better herself. She knows what she has to do to see her daughter more but she isn’t doing it!!! She can call every night if she wants to but she only calls once every week or so. UGgggggg!! I am a mother and I hate being at work all day away from my kids. I will never understand her. She loves her daughter but doesn’t seem to want to do what she can to see her more.

Sorry, this turned into more than just a Rosary question. I guess I’m just mad at her for so many reasons and her wearing the Rosary just really really bothers me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top