Wedding gift for my father's third marriage?

  • Thread starter Thread starter The_Hidden_Life
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

The_Hidden_Life

Guest
Hello, I am looking for ideas on how to be respectful to my father (and his soon-to-be new wife) while not giving him the message that I think he is doing a wonderful thing.

The history: my parents were baptized Christians (non-Catholic) who divorced when I was a child. My mother has never remarried. My father remarried a year later and his second wife died two years ago, after twenty years of marriage. My father stated his itention from the time his second wife was terminally ill with breast cancer to marry again some day after some time had passed. So. He was contacted by a woman who knew him from church and they started going out about four or five months ago. They became engaged. He sold his house in preparation for the wedding but it sold sooner than expected and now he is moving in with his fiance six weeks before the wedding and no, they are not living chastely. This is a big disappointment to me and my brother and sister, who all are shocked at his behavior.

I have not met this woman. I am going to visit for a weekend during which I will attend the wedding reception a week after the wedding. The practical dilemma that occurred to me is: what do I give this couple as a wedding gift? But really, I am at a loss for how to deal with the whole situation.

When I try to talk to my father about how I feel about him behaving this way he gets hurt feelings (he’s a marriage and family therapist, just to inject some irony here) and I feel like perhaps I am wrong for arguing with my parent (honor thy father, and all that). From my sister and brother’s reports they are at a loss as to why my father would pick her to marry, other than that she has a lot of money and my father is always anxious about when will he ever get to retire. Sounds comical, but it does seem that every time I talk to him about her he is always mentioning that he will be able to afford to come visit us more often once he’s married, rather than gushing about how wonderful she is and how in love they are.

Help!
 
I’m sorry, but I just don’t find anything too unusual here. Your father divorced your mother when you were a child. This is tragic, but since he is not a Catholic, I don’t see any way he could get an annulment. They probably allow divorce in his church. Since his second wife died (and he never divorced her), he doesn’t strike me as the type of guy who just keeps dumping women so he can keep getting married again. Two years is plenty of time after the death of a spouse to meet someone new. It is sad that they are living together, so isn’t it better that they’re going to make it legal (at least in the eyes of the state). Could it be that you just don’t like this woman, or that you are worried about your inheritance? If I were you, I would be polite and go to the wedding. As for a gift, just check to see if she is registered somewhere.
 
I suggest giving him a Bible and the CD “Contraception Why Not” from onemoresoul.com (unless his wife is past childbearing age). Don’t forget a scapular and a miraculous medal.
If you don’t have a clue what to give him in terms of traditional wedding presents, give to a charity in their name.

my Mother my Confidence,
Corinne
 
40.png
Listener:
I’m sorry, but I just don’t find anything too unusual here. Your father divorced your mother when you were a child. This is tragic, but since he is not a Catholic, I don’t see any way he could get an annulment.

Could it be that you just don’t like this woman, or that you are worried about your inheritance? If I were you, I would be polite and go to the wedding. As for a gift, just check to see if she is registered somewhere.
You’re right that it’s not that unusual, but that it itself tragic. Question for you: Aren’t marriages of baptized Christians, even though not Catholic, presumed to be valid?

I can’t say I do or don’t like this woman. I haven’t met her yet. My siblings have and one certainly doesn’t like her and the other is indifferent.

Inheritance is not an issue for me. I am more concerned with the scandal this is causing in the family and especially how this affects my younger brother and sister, both unmarried and until recently living under his roof. They are 26 and 22 and not particularly strong or outspoken in their faith and to see their famously Christian father shacking up with this new woman is quite a shock to them. My father is the guy everyone looks up to as the “nice guy,” he teaches Bible studies, even preaches on occasion. He doesn’t belong to a denomination currently (and doesn’t believe they’re important), but in the past he was Disciples of Christ, now attending United Methodist.

Wedding registry: honestly, hadn’t thought of that yet. I’ll look it up and see if I can find anything. The wedding is out of state and I can’t go. I’m only attending the reception.
 
40.png
coralewisjr:
I suggest giving him a Bible and the CD “Contraception Why Not” from onemoresoul.com (unless his wife is past childbearing age). Don’t forget a scapular and a miraculous medal.
If you don’t have a clue what to give him in terms of traditional wedding presents, give to a charity in their name.

my Mother my Confidence,
Corinne
Corinne, would it be appropriate to give sacramentals to non-Catholics who might not take care of them properly? They would probably give them away at the first opportunity and as a convert, honestly, I don’t fully understand the role of these devotional items myself. I mean, I know what they are for, but I don’t personally own either a Miraculous Medal or a scapular as I haven’t yet really explored that. I’m still a novice in praying the Rosary! 🙂

They have plenty of Bibles in the house already and contraception is not an issue, they’re both past the age of fertility. When I came into the Catholic church I gave my father a couple books about the faith to explain what Catholics really believe, but he’s never read them.

A charitable contribution is a good idea. Any suggestions?
 
Your father’s wedding day isn’t the day to take this up, really it’s not. I would think you’ve told him, “Dad, I have no problem with you being happy, I don’t even know your fiance. It’s just that…well, I think you’re still married to Mom. This is a real problem for me.”

If you are on-board enough to go to the wedding, then be on-board enough to bring a gift. If they have registered, and have signed up for anything that is essentially just for your dad, consider that.

Otherwise, since he is a marriage therapist, a contribution to an organization that you and your dad both think supports deep and long-lasting marriages would be a nice gift that shouldn’t irk your conscience.

A sacramental shouldn’t be given if you think the receipient is likely to consider it an insult. A gift shouldn’t be given primarily to make you feel good. It should be a sign of your love and affection for the receipient, and one that you honestly think will be taken as such. If not, don’t give it. That is the more honest and above-board route. And don’t forget that under normal circumstances, gifts are not necessary for a third marriage, particularly if the couple is affluent.
 
BLB, thank you for this post. It really cuts through some of the emotions I have and helps me to see the situation more clearly. Thank you.
 
The Hidden Life:
Corinne, would it be appropriate to give sacramentals to non-Catholics who might not take care of them properly? They would probably give them away at the first opportunity and as a convert, honestly, I don’t fully understand the role of these devotional items myself. I mean, I know what they are for, but I don’t personally own either a Miraculous Medal or a scapular as I haven’t yet really explored that. I’m still a novice in praying the Rosary! 🙂

They have plenty of Bibles in the house already and contraception is not an issue, they’re both past the age of fertility. When I came into the Catholic church I gave my father a couple books about the faith to explain what Catholics really believe, but he’s never read them.

A charitable contribution is a good idea. Any suggestions?
I hope that you get a scapular soon. I didn’t understand it at first when Mom gave me one a few years ago but about a week ago I read a story on Spirit Daily spiritdaily.com about how miracles are associated with those who wear scapulars. Miraculous medals and the green scapular are known for aiding in conversions to the Church. If you don’t think that your dad will take care of them or wear the scapular, hide it somewhere in his house. I know that sounds weird but I’ve read really cool stories about how God uses them to bring people to Him.

Suggestions for charitable contributions: cora.dashjr.org/links/charity.html
Catholic Relief Services
a crisis pregnancy center
maybe something associated with stuff your dad is interested in…for example, if he likes to give to poor people or to the hungry, you could find a charity that does those things

my Mother my Confidence,
Corinne
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top