What does Freedom mean to you?

  • Thread starter Thread starter simpleas
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
How does the Son set us free. The way you have things worded, it almost sounds like predestination; something that is automatic once Christ decides to provide it. But I contend that the truth can only be known though contemplation. But how do we know when we have reached the truth?

LOVE! ❤️
When we accept the offer, we are redeemed. That means everything is paid for! It’s not predestination, it’s just accepting the offer of salvation. His yoke is easy and his burden is light. Just accept what he offers, keep the law, and do what you want.
 
I simply trust myself more on whether to follow a particular rule and to what extent. I’ve earned respect for lashing out at some people and earned as much when I didn’t.

People tell you to listen to the Voice of God and be silent or something but I can only wait so long for a magical voice to whisper in my ear. Why shouldn’t I trust myself instead? Because God knows better? Because I’m corrupted by sin? Frankly, I’ve only used that as an excuse to doubt the good in my life and watch everything I ever wanted slip under me.

Never again.
So, you find that earning respect meets your needs, you need respect from other people.

I am hearing that you have felt some satisfaction in altering the rules that you heard in order to achieve this respect. Perhaps your need for autonomy, in the form of self-reliance, is also a factor?

Feel free to correct my observations. Respect from others is very important to you, I think I am hearing that.
 
Feel free to correct my observations. Respect from others is very important to you, I think I am hearing that.
On the contrary, I gained respect from others because I learned to respect myself first and prioritized that same self. That’s what freedom means to me.

You can’t give what you don’t have.
Others can’t respect you if you don’t even do the same for yourself.

It ain’t that complicated. 😉
 
On the contrary, I gained respect from others because I learned to respect myself first and prioritized that same self. That’s what freedom means to me.

You can’t give what you don’t have.
Others can’t respect you if you don’t even do the same for yourself.

It ain’t that complicated. 😉
So, are you saying that people only respect people who respect themselves? I am trying to hear what is inside the “can’t”.

So, like, if the rule is “respect all others”, is freedom the ability to break this rule and lash out at some people? Or is the “lashing out” done as a matter of respect?

It is a little complicated, to me. I am trying to find the shape of things. I would say that it is our nature to respect only those who respect us, for example. This may fall under the “natural conscience”. But, perhaps, to fail to respect people who do not respect themselves, and not, instead, be moved to mercy, can be a slavery of sorts. For what would be the roadblock to such mercy?

Would you agree that it depends on the definitions and the context?
 
Would you agree that it depends on the definitions and the context?
That’s the gist of it. I don’t know about you but the only real deciding factor on whether to break a rule or not is if the rule continues to support that which I want (and not just trying to wring out a wishy-washy compromise).

Some call it selfishness but that’s how I am now (and am at least honest enough about it). You want a real paradox though? Consider the idea that giving yourself as a gift is only possible if actually had a self to give.
 
That’s the gist of it. I don’t know about you but the only real deciding factor on whether to break a rule or not is if the rule continues to support that which I want (and not just trying to wring out a wishy-washy compromise).
Someone whose teaching I value says, “our greatest human need (want) is to be helpful to those around us”.

Do you agree? Do you find that the well-being of the people around you becomes somewhat an extension of your own needs?
Some call it selfishness but that’s how I am now (and am at least honest enough about it). You want a real paradox though? Consider the idea that giving yourself as a gift is only possible if actually had a self to give.
IMO, all behavior is essentially selfish. To me, what happens is that the “self”, through development of empathy and love for others, comes to encompass all of those around us. So, even the feeding of a homeless person, because it makes one happy, is a selfish act to some degree. I will grant that when we “want” to the degree that it comes at someone elses’ expense, then this could be labeled as “selfish”, and is ordinarily a violation of the common conscience. However, the use of the word is too broad to be divided in such a way. If a person is getting something at someone else’s expense, he is behaving hurtfully out of ignorance or blindness. Calling it “selfish” does not help us undertand the problem, it only condemns the action. Do you agree?
 
Do you find that the well-being of the people around you becomes somewhat an extension of your own needs?
In a way, it does. However, I don’t like it when people try to use that extension against itself. “Yes, I care for you but asking me to bleed myself out for your sake is like demanding the goose to cut out all the gold in its belly.”

It’s why the concept of self-denial no longer makes sense to me. 🤷
Calling it “selfish” does not help us undertand the problem, it only condemns the action. Do you agree?
Actually yes. But then again, I think that only makes condemnation a waste of breath and doesn’t bring anyone closer to a real answer. 🤷
 
In a way, it does. However, I don’t like it when people try to use that extension against itself. “Yes, I care for you but asking me to bleed myself out for your sake is like demanding the goose to cut out all the gold in its belly.”

It’s why the concept of self-denial no longer makes sense to me. 🤷
It is a concept that is very hard to pin down. If a person gives all his money away out of empathy for others who are suffering, there is certainly some fulfillment in that. If he gives it all away out of guilt, there is also fulfillment, in the form of guilt relief, I suppose.

Self-denial for its own sake? Depends. An alcoholic, for instance, denying himself that next drink? Probably a good idea.
Actually yes. But then again, I think that only makes condemnation a waste of breath and doesn’t bring anyone closer to a real answer. 🤷
I don’t think anyone ever thinks to themselves, “I should condemn that”. It is more of a triggered response to me. Condemnation does influence people to behave, but it by no means brings about understanding, and shedding condemnation is part of the path to forgiveness.
 
Thank you for your reply.🙂

If I’m right, you would say you are loving yourself more than God when you are in sin?
I can not understand how that can work. 😊
I agree if in sin we can still love God, but I would never have thought I ever loved myself over and above God, I do love myself, I was taught that I should love myself, respect myself etc.
When I first heard the teaching that we needed to love ourselves, I was grateful because I knew people who thought they were useless and worthless. It seemed important to me that each person knew how really valuable she or he was in the sight of God. Another thought was that when I love myself, I would take care of myself, eat right, keep good thoughts, be patient with myself, get myself to the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass because if I really love myself, I would want me doing the things which would get me to heaven.

When people talked about loving ourselves more than we love God, it usually was in the sense that we preferred doing something rather than obeying God. Preferring a substitute good is another meaning. “It is my way or the highway.” is another meaning. Sad to say, I believe that there are a few people who actually hate God.
Confession has always been a hurdle for me, I respect that you find comfort in it, and I can’t say I haven’t felt the benefit of confession, but from a teenager I pretty much got it into my head that I didn’t really need to go to confess, regular anyway.
For me, the comfort of Confession is that it is there when I really need it. That is not the best way to look at it. I have been telling myself that I should go regularly. I tell others that they should go because the Sacrament gives us graces for the future, etc., etc., We do need God’s help getting rid of annoying venial sins. It is time I follow my own advice …
I bet if you ever get to meet Adam, you will not slap him up side the head…ha.
Don’t bet on that. I recently discovered that my “justifiable” anger at an incident was turning into thoughts of innocent revenge. One would think that I would be perfect at my age. :rolleyes: Life isn’t like that. The devil never gives up offering new and appropriate sins for any occasion.
Don’t you think that societies rules were imposed from a christian view? Maybe not so much now, now I think we are becoming more accepting of one another, I know many countries still need to learn this. And I know much of what the church taught was aimed at the saving of people, but there was many harsh ways this was conducted.
So some people view religion as suppressive, that it takes away freedom rather than gives it.
It depends on the rules. I know that mistakes have been made in the name of Christianity. I also know that there are people who want to be free from every rule, even good ones. I wish people would be more specific when they use the very broad term of religion as in religion being suppressive. The Sacrament of Confession/Reconciliation gives back to us freedom from a particular sin. In cases of Mortal Sin, Repentance and Reconciliation gives us the freedom to receive Jesus, Himself, in Holy Communion.
Personally I’ve never felt suppressed, but I can see why other people do.
Me, too.
I wonder if a slap upside the head would straighten out these people.
 
Sad to say, I believe that there are a few people who actually hate God.

I agree that there are people that hate Him. The question is why? and I’d much rather deal with someone that hates God with a passion than someone that is indifferent. I can’t stand indifference. I am angry with God for the awful lot I been dealt with. I am being honest Hot or cold I will take you but lukewarm I will spew you out of my mouth, as Christ said. I am a daring sort. I think it is okay to get angry and tell Him why you are angry. and whilst on the subject of freedom, you can be totally free if you are honest. If you feel God gave you lemons in life and you are tired of making lemonade Being honest and telling God is a freedom. Accepting that you are angry or hate God for a terrible situation, is much freer than holding it inside and pretending that all is well when it isn’t. Free up the soul and be totally honest with God.
I have a friend that has horrible feet and can’t walk or do what he used to. He is like “oh well it’s God’s will nothing I can do about it and I will end up in a wheelchair and that is the will of God.” Meanwhile he is full of anger and rage and it comes out constantly. He is NOT free He is being imprisoned in his body and his walk with Christ. John 14. 12-14 is quite simply put. Pray in that capacity and expect God to honor his promise. I heal his feet in the NAME OF JESUS THE CHRIST!!! I expect you to HONOR your promise!!! That is freedom. Yes I can totally understand someone hating God. I never hate Him. I hate some of the garbage he lets happen to people who seem not to deserve it. I also hate his tarrying and his taking forever to do anything. I never hate God . but i can certainly understand people hating him when he could have done something to better their lives and he didn’t. My opinion on hating God and freedom.
 
When I first heard the teaching that we needed to love ourselves, I was grateful because I knew people who thought they were useless and worthless. It seemed important to me that each person knew how really valuable she or he was in the sight of God. Another thought was that when I love myself, I would take care of myself, eat right, keep good thoughts, be patient with myself, get myself to the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass because if I really love myself, I would want me doing the things which would get me to heaven.

When people talked about loving ourselves more than we love God, it usually was in the sense that we preferred doing something rather than obeying God. Preferring a substitute good is another meaning. “It is my way or the highway.” is another meaning. Sad to say, I believe that there are a few people who actually hate God.

For me, the comfort of Confession is that it is there when I really need it. That is not the best way to look at it. I have been telling myself that I should go regularly. I tell others that they should go because the Sacrament gives us graces for the future, etc., etc., We do need God’s help getting rid of annoying venial sins. It is time I follow my own advice …

Don’t bet on that. I recently discovered that my “justifiable” anger at an incident was turning into thoughts of innocent revenge. One would think that I would be perfect at my age. :rolleyes: Life isn’t like that. The devil never gives up offering new and appropriate sins for any occasion.

It depends on the rules. I know that mistakes have been made in the name of Christianity. I also know that there are people who want to be free from every rule, even good ones. I wish people would be more specific when they use the very broad term of religion as in religion being suppressive. The Sacrament of Confession/Reconciliation gives back to us freedom from a particular sin. In cases of Mortal Sin, Repentance and Reconciliation gives us the freedom to receive Jesus, Himself, in Holy Communion.

Me, too.
I wonder if a slap upside the head would straighten out these people.
Me also, hearing that sort of empowered me to believe I was stronger than I realised, and worthy to be a human being.

I don’t think that it is wrong to only go to confession when you really need it, doesn’t this show you are capable and understand your own soul well enough to know when you need to be heard in confession?

Some how I’m glad I live on the other side of the world, especially if you are prone to slapping people upside the head…ouch! LOL
:slapfight:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top