What makes an act intrinsically evil?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ron_Conte
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This is not the opinion of any posters in this thread. Your failure to understand this is most concerning.
I’m beginning to think that many of the posts from and to Ron are talking past each other now. Since Ron does not actually understand the position of those he argues with, I believe some of his responses are not arguing with us at all, but with a mere strawman. As such, some of the responses back simply don’t make sense to Ron’s understanding, and may seem incongruous to other readers too, since we’re probably arguing with arguments that are beside the point anyway.

At this point, I prefer Ron merely reply to the direct questions put to him earlier throughout this thread regarding:

a) what is the difference between the moral object (noting the singular) and any conceivable ends?

a) how can he explain his (seemingly) inconsistent analysis of hysterectomy for medical reasons vs hormonal treatment for medical reasons?
 
I’m beginning to think that many of the posts from and to Ron are talking past each other now. Since Ron does not actually understand the position of those he argues with, I believe some of his responses are not arguing with us at all, but with a mere strawman. As such, some of the responses back simply don’t make sense to Ron’s understanding, and may seem incongruous to other readers too, since we’re probably arguing with arguments that are beside the point anyway.
It seems to me that in responding to the interpretations and understandings we have put to Ron, he misrepresents them, often badly. He does not rebut what is said, but rather something which would clearly deserve to be rebutted had it been said!
At this point, I prefer Ron merely reply to the direct questions put to him earlier throughout this thread regarding:
a) what is the difference between the moral object (noting the singular) and any conceivable ends?
a) how can he explain his (seemingly) inconsistent analysis of hysterectomy for medical reasons vs hormonal treatment for medical reasons?
Post #49 also lists key issues that Ron did not respond to despite repeated requests. I am perplexed that he prefers to repeat statements (often on matters not in dispute) rather than to pursue the key issues to a logical end.
 
It seems to me that in responding to the interpretations and understandings we have put to Ron, he misrepresents them, often badly. He does not rebut what is said, but rather something which would clearly deserve to be rebutted had it been said!
I’m even more confused as to why Ron misunderstands what we have said, when he himself has said the following things, that seem to directly mirror many of the opinions expressed here, that he has chosen to reject…
The moral object is also called the proximate end
That seems straightforward enough, and yet he still won’t address the question - what is the difference between the moral object and any conceivable ends?

and
I agree with Rhonheimer that an act has no sinfulness without an act of the human will (intention). An act that is not knowingly and intentionally chosen is not an intrinsically evil human act, not even on a merely objective basis.
We have stressed the role of the will in this debate; here Ron seems to agree.

and
Since the moral object is the end of an act that is intentionally (deliberately, voluntarily) chosen, the will and its intention is involved in the font called moral object.
Here Ron is saying that intention is involved in the moral object. Yes, I agree. This makes sense, as I have been saying, if we consider that any moral object itself can be broken down to consider the intention with regard to the proximate end (not the remote end). *
  • This is addressed by Fr Rhonheimer when he says: “the finis operis is always a finis operantis.”
I’m not sure what it is that Ron actually disagrees with anymore? It seems perhaps Ron’s issues are more in applying this to concrete situations - eg hysterectomy vs hormonal treatments - rather than on the abstract/theoretical side.
 
Far from being circular, the discussion has progressed fairly linearly. I have put to you these questions in the course of examining your interpretation of the application of moral theology to the scenarios we’ve been discussing. The following questions put to you: are unanswered by you:
  1. Why do you single out drugs (or a particular subset of drugs) which treat a medical disorder and cause sterility, from operations which treat a medical disorder and cause sterility? What is the moral difference? Upon what do you build your case that they are morally different? Is it:
  • the severity of medical condition / consequences of no treatment?
  • is it whether the treatment “cures”, as opposed to “relieves” symptoms?
Moral differences:
a. all chemical contraceptives are also abortifacients. These abortions do not occur from the treatment, since the couple can refrain from sex while taking the pill. These abortions result from the deliberate choice to have sex while taking that particular medication.
b. a hysterectomy does not cause abortions.
c. in the third font (circumstances), the good of having marital relations is outweighed by the bad consequence that innocent prenatals are killed.
d. the hysterectomy is only moral to treat a serious disorder, not a minor disorder. The pill is being prescribed by physicians in some cases for less than a grave cause (e.g. regulating periods). Other treatments are available in many cases.
e. a hysterectomy results in permanent sterility. The pill is a contraceptive (temporary sterility). A temporary cessation of marital relations has much less moral weight than a permanent cessation. The loss of the procreative meaning has moral weight. Most commentators disregard this loss because they have a contraceptive mentality.
  1. How are (inevitable) consequences distinguished from the moral object? Take note of the last 2 paragraphs of Post #41.
Each font proceeds from the human will to three different types of ends: the end intended by the agent, the end inherent to the chosen act, the end results (consequences). Sometimes two or three of these ends are the same; other times they differ. The fact that an end is or is not intended, is or is not a consequence, in no way informs us as to whether or not it is the moral object.
  1. What dictates the obligation to refrain from sex (if a medical treatment has caused sterility) if moral behaviour is to be achieved? You appear to be saying it hangs on whether the sterility in the first place was avoidable. How is that to be judged? Is sterility avoidable so long as one’s life is not imperilled by avoiding the sterilisation?
See above “moral differences”.
  1. How can your answers to the above be supported by HV14 (Unlawful Birth Control Methods) and HV15 (Lawful Therapeutic Means)?
I’ve already replied to this point in other posts. HV15 refers to hysterectomies. If HV15 had referred to abortifacient contraception, it would have been prominent in theological discussions since that time. Instead, applying HV15 to abortifacient contraception is a recent innovation, a radical reinterpretation of Church teaching.

I am trying to wrap up my participation in this discussion because I am concerned that further discussion will do more harm than good. Several posters above have badly misunderstood the basic teachings of the Church on morality, and they are teaching their misunderstandings to others.

“The negative precepts of the natural law are universally valid. They oblige each and every individual, always and in every circumstance. It is a matter of prohibitions which forbid a given action semper et pro semper, without exception, because the choice of this kind of behavior is in no case compatible with the goodness of the will of the acting person, with his vocation to life with God and to communion with his neighbour. It is prohibited – to everyone and in every case – to violate these precepts. They oblige everyone, regardless of the cost, never to offend in anyone, beginning with oneself, the personal dignity common to all.” VS 52

Pope Saint John Paul II: “contraception is to be judged so profoundly unlawful as never to be, for any reason, justified.” (L’Osservatore Romano, October 10, 1983, pg.7).
 
Here is a reminder of what you said earlier:
underacloud: So you are saying it is immoral because of the abortifacient potential of the treatment, not because it is contraceptive. Ron, this is a change in what you have been previously arguing.
Thus, from your last post we can disergard points a. b. and c.; they are not relevant to the question put to you.

Point d. is a medical question.

Point e. seems to be all that you rely on then, to declare that there is an intrinsic moral difference between hysterectomy and hormonal treatments for sexually active married women. That difference being whether the bad effect (infertility) is temporary or permanent. I know of no moral principle to support this position. Nor any moral theologian who treats this question in this way.
e. a hysterectomy results in permanent sterility. The pill is a contraceptive (temporary sterility). A temporary cessation of marital relations has much less moral weight than a permanent cessation. The loss of the procreative meaning has moral weight. Most commentators disregard this loss because they have a contraceptive mentality.
Each font proceeds from the human will to three different types of ends: the end intended by the agent, the end inherent to the chosen act, the end results (consequences). Sometimes two or three of these ends are the same; other times they differ. The fact that an end is or is not intended, is or is not a consequence, in no way informs us as to whether or not it is the moral object.
You have still not answered the question. It is clear enough now that you have no answer.
I’ve already replied to this point in other posts. HV15 refers to hysterectomies. If HV15 had referred to abortifacient contraception, it would have been prominent in theological discussions since that time. Instead, applying HV15 to abortifacient contraception is a recent innovation, a radical reinterpretation of Church teaching.
Why did they not then specify hysterectomy? Why leave the language open (“therapeutic means necessary to cure bodily diseases”)? And can you please cite any moral theologians who interpret it this way?

At the time HV was written, less was known regarding abortifacient properties of certain hormonal medications. That is the reason discussions of it are more recent.

Can you cite one moral theologian who treats hormonal contraception in the manner you do? Or who interpret HV the way you do? I have cited several who treat it the other way. You have not cited a single one.
 
Moral differences [between surgical procedures causing sterility and medication-based treatement]:
a. all chemical contraceptives are also abortifacients. These abortions do not occur from the treatment, since the couple can refrain from sex while taking the pill. These abortions result from the deliberate choice to have sex while taking that particular medication.
b. a hysterectomy does not cause abortions.
c. in the third font (circumstances), the good of having marital relations is outweighed by the bad consequence that innocent prenatals are killed.
d. the hysterectomy is only moral to treat a serious disorder, not a minor disorder. The pill is being prescribed by physicians in some cases for less than a grave cause (e.g. regulating periods). Other treatments are available in many cases.
e. a hysterectomy results in permanent sterility. The pill is a contraceptive (temporary sterility). A temporary cessation of marital relations has much less moral weight than a permanent cessation. The loss of the procreative meaning has moral weight. Most commentators disregard this loss because they have a contraceptive mentality.
Points (a), (b), (c) are off the topic. Chemo drugs can cause sterility (temporary or permanent) but not abortions.

Point (d) - I agree that medication should be taken prudently and have made that point previously. A person delighting in the opportunity to take “the pill” for a mild case of acne in light of the extra opportunities for sex it presents in all likelihood does wrong. And I repeat - the discussion is not about “the Pill”.

Points (d) and (e): Your comments here are most significant. In formulating these response, you have eschewed your previous strident assertion that the intrinsic evil of contraception was in evidence with medication, but not surgery. By weighing consequences, you are suggesting that we have a case of an unintended side-effect mixed with a good moral object, and hence the good of the medical treatment needs to be weighed against the bad of causing sterility/sterile sex. I have no objection to this view (as difficult as this “weighing” might be in some situations). This is miles away from your prior position.
Each font proceeds from the human will to three different types of ends: the end intended by the agent, the end inherent to the chosen act, the end results (consequences). Sometimes two or three of these ends are the same; other times they differ. The fact that an end is or is not intended, is or is not a consequence, in no way informs us as to whether or not it is the moral object.
This does not at all address the question - how one distinguishes a consequence (even those inevitably resulting from the act) from its moral object.
HV15 refers to hysterectomies.
That’s you assertion with nil evidence. A hysterectomy is very specific, where as the term used in the Encyclical “Lawful Therapeutic Means” is broad, particularly when the contrasting activity to which the Pope refers is “Unlawful Birth Control Methods”. It is inconceivable that only hysterectomy can be permissible - and no other “therapeutic means”.
 
“The negative precepts of the natural law are universally valid. They oblige each and every individual, always and in every circumstance. It is a matter of prohibitions which forbid a given action semper et pro semper, without exception, because the choice of this kind of behavior is in no case compatible with the goodness of the will of the acting person, with his vocation to life with God and to communion with his neighbour. It is prohibited – to everyone and in every case – to violate these precepts. They oblige everyone, regardless of the cost, never to offend in anyone, beginning with oneself, the personal dignity common to all.” VS 52

Pope Saint John Paul II: “contraception is to be judged so profoundly unlawful as never to be, for any reason, justified.” (L’Osservatore Romano, October 10, 1983, pg.7).
I 100% agree with the Pope. But how odd that you tack this onto the end of your post - a post in which you eschewed the argument of intrinsic evil!

It seems to me that we have arrived at this conclusion: of all the things contraception is, it is NOT ‘having sex after a prudently chosen hysterectomy for a medical purpose,’ nor is it ‘having sex after a prudent choice to take a medication for medical purpose’.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top