What was St. Paul's "thorn"?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jas84173
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

jas84173

Guest
I was given a thorn in my body because of the outstanding revelations I’ve received so that I wouldn’t be conceited. It’s a messenger from Satan sent to torment me so that I wouldn’t be conceited. I pleaded with the Lord three times for it to leave me alone. He said to me, “My grace is enough for you, because power is made perfect in weakness.” So I’ll gladly spend my time bragging about my weaknesses so that Christ’s power can rest on me.
2 Corinthians 12:7‭-‬9

Is this passage in scripture meant to suggest that everyone of us struggle with a sin? Or is it meant to mean something I am interpreting wrong? I think it speaks beautifully to people who do struggle with a bad habit that seems impossible to overcome at times, even though it is a sin.
 
I think others will be able to provide a more helpful (and serious) answer, but I have to admit I do like *this * theory 🙂
 
Ver. 7-10. A sting of my flesh,[1] an angel, or a messenger of Satan, to buffet me. The Latin word signifies any thing that pricks or stings, the Greek word a sharp stick or pale: he speaks by a metaphor, as also when he says to buffet me; that is, by causing great trouble or pain. Some understand by it a violent headache or pain, or distemper in the body. St. Augustine mentions this opinion, and does not reject it, in Psalm xcviii. tom. 4. p. 1069.; in Psalm cxxx. p. 1465. St. Jerome also speaks of it in chap. iv. ad Galatas, tom. 4. p. 274, Ed. Ben. But St. Chrysostom, by the sting, and the angel of Satan, understands that opposition which St. Paul met with from his enemies, and those of the gospel; as Satan signifies an adversary. Others understand troublesome temptations of the flesh, immodest thoughts, and representations, suggested by the devil, and permitted by Almighty God for his greater good. — Thrice I besought the Lord. That is, many times, to be freed from it, but received only this answer from God, that his grace was sufficient to preserve me from consenting to sin. And that power and strength in virtue should increase, and be perfected in weakness, and by temptations, when they are resisted. St. Augustine seems to favour this exposition, in Psalm lviii. Conc. 2. p. 573. St. Jerome, in his letters to Eustochium, to Demetrias, and to Rusticus, the monk. And it is the opinion of St. Gregory, lib. 23. moral. tom. 1. p. 747. and of many others. (Witham) — If there were any danger of pride from his revelations, the base and filthy suggestions of the enemy of souls must cause humiliations, and make him blush. But these are to be borne with submission to the will of God, for his power is more evident in supporting man under the greatest trials, than in freeing him from the attacks. — Power is made perfect. The strength and power of God more perfectly shines forth in our weakness and infirmity; as the more weak we are of ourselves, the more illustrious is his grace in supporting us, and giving us the victory under all trials and conflicts. (Challoner) — When I am weak. The more I suffer for Christ, the more I perceive the effects of his all-powerful grace, which sustains, enlightens, and strengthens me: the more also the glory and power of God appeareth in me. The pagans themselves were not ignorant that calamity was the soil in which virtue usually grows to perfection. Calamitas virtutis occasio est. (Seneca) — Optimos nos esse dum infirmi sumus. (Pliny vii. ep. 26.)
 
Is this passage in scripture meant to suggest that everyone of us struggle with a sin?
Imagine your encounter with the thorn on the bush. You go by it and unwittingly you are stabbed with the thorn. You dig it from under your skin but the pain remains.

Saul had a pain that remained (guilt) though the problem was removed. It makes me think of Stephen but only Paul and God knows…
 
We can guess from here to next Sunday, but the bottom line is that we just don’t know.
 
I have sometimes wondered about this myself.
The Biblical scholar, the Jesuit Fernand Prat, said “to keep him in a state of humility by reminding him constantly of his weakness, God implanted in his flesh a thorn or a goad.” (“The Theology of Saint Paul,” vol. 1, p. 158-9) Not that this doesn’t have the sort of further dimensions alluded to by the opening poster.
I have found that some exegetes have asked this question themselves, and then threw their hands up in the air, concluding that we really can’t know what this thorn was exactly. Of course one theory or another could be true, like the ones being provided here, but I agree with the uncertainty some have said exists about this question.
 
The passage is relevant because it tempers the Gospel passage where Christ says, “Anything you ask shall be given unto you.”

Yes, anything we ask will be given to us, but that is always with the caveat of our ultimate good, our sanctification, and the salvation of our soul. St Paul was given very sublime and ecstatic revelations, including mystically traveling the Heavens, and as he says, in order to prevent him from becoming too proud, he was given the thorn in his flesh so that he maintained a healthy distrust in his own power. It’s not important what the thorn was or he would have told us. The reader can insert any persistent thorn they might have in their own life into the passage and it would fit.

Masters of the spiritual life are in agreement that there is almost always some particular defect in a person that they aren’t able to fully get rid of, and this defect works a lot of good for them, and this even includes if a person happens to sin by it, since the examination of conscience and penance for the sin pleases God moreso than the sin offended him.
 
It could be a specific sin, or a temptation to a specific sin; it also could be the pain wich comes with rejection “He who rejects you, rejects Me”.

It is entirely possible that others knew of what Paul spoke, but neither Paul nor his contemporaries saw fit to leave us an explanation. Obviously, whatever it was consisted of something seriously bothering to Paul. And that, apparently, is all we need to know.
 
It was a demon to beat him. When he was successful the demon would physically beat him. Padre Pio had a similar problem. When through his influence someone did not commit sin the demon was allowed to attack him.
 
I was given a thorn in my body because of the outstanding revelations I’ve received so that I wouldn’t be conceited. It’s a messenger from Satan sent to torment me so that I wouldn’t be conceited. I pleaded with the Lord three times for it to leave me alone. He said to me, “My grace is enough for you, because power is made perfect in weakness.” So I’ll gladly spend my time bragging about my weaknesses so that Christ’s power can rest on me.
2 Corinthians 12:7‭-‬9

Is this passage in scripture meant to suggest that everyone of us struggle with a sin? Or is it meant to mean something I am interpreting wrong? I think it speaks beautifully to people who do struggle with a bad habit that seems impossible to overcome at times, even though it is a sin.
We are are called, then, to love God and to believe in Him in the difficulties of life, because we recognize that the stormy things give us strength and the help to go forward each day. I cite again the example of St. Paul, who speaks of the “thorn in the flesh” 2 Cor. 12:7. We do not know exactly what he was suffering; he speaks of a “messenger of Satan” who was persecuting him. We can infer that it involved a physical suffering due to the action of the devil and not from natural causes. “three times I besought the Lord about this, that it should leave me, “ he affirms, nearly desperate 2 Cor. 12:8. God, however, does not free him. “My grace is sufficient for you, “ He responds to him 2 Cor. 12:9, because virtue is manifested and deepened precisely through suffering, where virtue is tried and perfected. The apostle’s experience confirms that we learn to love God through suffering, perfecting ourselves in love. Suffering –I repeat—offered as reparation for the salvation of souls and the conversion of sinners becomes an instrument of true collaboration with God’s work for the redemption of all humanity.
An Exorcist Explains the Demonic by Fr. Amorth with Stefano Stimamiglio pages 14-15

Hope this helps
 
Saint Paul’s thorn was a horn. That is a joke. Get it?:extrahappy:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top