What's the Baltimore Catechism?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Elzee
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

Elzee

Guest
I barely remember the Baltimore Catechism …can someone explain to me what it was, and was it replaced by the CCC? Or was the Baltimore Catechism more of a textbook? What’s the relationship between the two?
Also - is the Baltimore Catechism out of date - can it still ‘officially’ be used?

Thank you!
 
The Baltimore Catechism was indirectly a product of the Council of Trent, the 16th-century version of Vatican II. To counter the Protestant Reformation, Trent published a manual of Catholic teaching called the Roman Catechism. Written in Latin (the word catechismus meant “oral teaching”) it was used by clergy to instruct the faithful.

In 1884 the bishops of the United States, gathered in Baltimore, decided to publish an English version for use by American schoolchildren.
truecatholic.org/baltcont.htm
The first Baltimore Catechism, published in 1891, contained 100 questions. A larger edition, No. 2, held 421 questions, and a still larger version, No. 3, had 1,274 questions plus prayers. No. 4, the whopper, included lengthy “explanations” for teachers.

After Vatican II the old catechism fell out of favor. Then a gathering of bishops in Rome proposed a new catechism. That became a reality in 1994, when Pope John Paul II introduced the Catechism of the Catholic Church. Like the catechism of Trent, it was designed as a reference book to be used when preparing teaching texts for adults and children. But it doesn’t fit in your pocket like the Baltimore Catechism.

The Baltimore Catechism has seen something of a resurgence among young homeschoolers and people underwhelmed by their parish’s CCD program. We have been using it for our children for the last few years and as a result, they’re knowledge of the basics of the faith is head and shoulders over their peers–and above many adult Catholics, for that matter.

We use the St. Joseph Edition which came out in 1962.
aquinasandmore.com/index.cfm/FuseAction/store.ItemDetails/SKU/253/Category/0/
While some adults may sniff at the somewhat dated photos, my kids have never complained. The information is solid and timeless and if you teach them while they’re young, they’ll never forget it. I’ve had elderly ladies in Bible studies I’ve led, remember word for word what they learned as girls 50 years ago.
 
RyanL:

I was just about to say that, you beat me to it. I had to go back and edit this post, lol. Thanks. God bless you.
 
One of the alleged complaints about the Baltimore Catechism was that the children were required to MEMORIZE the answers. [shock and horror]. The answers were simple enough that memorization was possible. But my recollection is that the answers were also quite comprehensive and covered just about every area of moral theology.

Some have said that the new Catholic Catechism is too … intimidating… exhaustive … and some people are actually returning to the Baltimore Catechism voluntarily.

Seems to me that some few years ago I bought a whole set of the Baltimore Catechisms, so they are (or were) still in print.
 
Al as Fidelis mentioned and it’s also my understanding the CCC was not meant to be used as a textbook but rather a reference work to be used in preparing lessons in the faith.
 
I remember that my mom taught us with the Baltimore Catechism when we were young and our CCD teachers quized out of it, we actually had to know our basic before recieving Holy Communion. My daughter will be saying her first holy communion this year and I will be teaching her out of it.
 
40.png
LouiseL_SFO:
Al as Fidelis mentioned and it’s also my understanding the CCC was not meant to be used as a textbook but rather a reference work to be used in preparing lessons in the faith.
Actually, it was to be the reference book used for preparing regional or national catechisms.

I think the CCC is rich in devotional reading, myself. I always come away from it glad I’m Catholic.
 
40.png
Fidelis:
The information is solid and timeless
The doctrinal information is solid and timeless. The information relating to discipline reflects a pre-Vatican II Church, and thus is out-of-date where those disciplines have changed.
 
So are there three volumes of the Baltmore Catechism? I’ve looked it up on Amazon, and there appear to be two volumes in one set, three in another. How does it work? Is one volume for kids and another for older kids?

Basically, I want to buy a complete set, but I don’t know what to be looking for.
 
Here is an online link to the 1891 Baltimore Catechism Nos. 1, 2, and 3.

Here is an example of something that has changed since the 1941 edition that Fidelis gave a link to:
299. Does the Church forbid Catholics to contract marriage with certain persons?
The Church does forbid Catholics to contract marriage with certain persons, and the following are examples: first, a marriage with a non-Catholic; this is a mixed marriage; second, a marriage with a second cousin, or any relative closer than a second cousin.
Under current canon law, the “second cousin” rule has been changed to “first cousin”.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top