When did Mary stop being "ever virgin?"

  • Thread starter Thread starter ultimate_ed
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
May I remind you that conversions go both ways? I belong to a church that is about 75% ex-Catholic. The pastor once asked for a show of hands of how many were ex-Catholic, and that was it. You may find yourself with us someday. Or I with you.
I would loooove to see the statistics on the percentage of well catechized Catholics with a very good understanding regarding the Dogmas who left the Church. I’m betting it’s a much smaller number. So a simple show of hands gives a false impression of what your pastor was attempting there.

However, I do notice that the ex protestants I see all over the Catholic forums on the net, already had quite a decent understanding about their protestant beliefs before they converted to Catholicism. Stick around awhile and observe. Read many of the ex-Catholic’s posts who will get even the basic doctrines confused. It will be too soon the next time I hear: “Then why do they say Jesus had brothers if Mary remained a Virgin?” from the mouth of yet another exCatholic.

It’s like losing the weak links to gain stronger ones for the Church.
 
I would loooove to see the statistics on the percentage of well catechized Catholics with a very good understanding regarding the Dogmas who left the Church. I’m betting it’s a much smaller number. So a simple show of hands gives a false impression of what your pastor was attempting there.

However, I do notice that the ex protestants I see all over the Catholic forums on the net, already had quite a decent understanding about their protestant beliefs before they converted to Catholicism. Stick around awhile and observe. Read many of the ex-Catholic’s posts who will get even the basic doctrines confused. It will be too soon the next time I hear: “Then why do they say Jesus had brothers if Mary remained a Virgin?” from the mouth of yet another exCatholic.

It’s like losing the weak links to gain stronger ones for the Church.
HI!

I love your tagline, by the way. How appropriate to this thread!

You don’t know what the pastor was trying to do. I don’t remember clearly, now, either, but he wasn’t being disparaging of Catholics. He tended to be very sympathetic towards Catholics and hung around a lot of monks. He has a Catholic spiritual director. No one got concerned about it as far as I know, and he mitigated some of my anti-Catholic tendencies. I am aware that much of my mental attitude and formation is what you would call anti-Catholic. I am nervous about saying something vile that will get me kicked off the Forum. As I started here on what was a whim, I haven’t quite figured out what I am doing here. I am far from theologically literate. If I converted (which I cannot see happening) I would not be one of the stronger links, that is for sure!

But that is a digression. The fact of the matter is that we don’t have the data to determine the quality of converts in either direction. I haven’t polled my ex-Catholic parishioners on whether they were properly catechized, etc., and I doubt that you have polled your converts on the depth of their theological knowledge of the reformation, etc. We simply don’t know. I think we can all agree that theological education across the church is poor and needs improvement. I mean the whole church - all Christians assembled anywhere.

-Tina:)
 
Randy,

Instead of battling the quote system, which I have yet to master I will respond with the following:
  1. I discussed convert quality in the previous post to this one.
  2. The (supposed) sinfulness of Mary would be at least one separate thread in itself. It probably has been, but I haven’t looked. To me that would be an awkward thread and somewhat tasteless. Sort of like doing one on Hey! Yo Mama’s Ugly!! I think Mary is at the least to be respected as one of the greatest saints the Church has ever had.
  3. Does not the Catholic Church exalt being single over being married, and somehow being married indicates at best a deficit in self control?
  4. You make an interesting point about Mary being honored as Mother as much as Virgin.
  5. I support the formulation of Mary as Mother of God as Christological. I do not support it in the sense that it conveys any sense that Mary herself is divine. I have seen Catholics maintain that it does. We have some around here who are really, really, really into the Lady of Guadelupe in a way that makes me uncomfortable.
-Tina:)
 
Randy,

Instead of battling the quote system, which I have yet to master I will respond with the following:
it took me a long time to figur out how to do this style of quoting…It is hard to explain but in reality it is simple to do…go the section at the bottom of the home page and find “the sandbox” i had a thread there in which i learned how to do this.
  1. I discussed convert quality in the previous post to this one.
  1. The (supposed) sinfulness of Mary would be at least one separate thread in itself. It probably has been, but I haven’t looked. To me that would be an awkward thread and somewhat tasteless. Sort of like doing one on Hey! Yo Mama’s Ugly!! I think Mary is at the least to be respected as one of the greatest saints the Church has ever had.
  1. Does not the Catholic Church exalt being single over being married, and somehow being married indicates at best a deficit in self control?
  1. You make an interesting point about Mary being honored as Mother as much as Virgin.
  1. I support the formulation of Mary as Mother of God as Christological. I do not support it in the sense that it conveys any sense that Mary herself is divine. I have seen Catholics maintain that it does. We have some around here who are really, really, really into the Lady of Guadelupe in a way that makes me uncomfortable.
Yes it would make many catholics uneasy that some should attribute any divinity to Mary…
 
  1. Does not the Catholic Church exalt being single over being married, and somehow being married indicates at best a deficit in self control?
No. Why would you have such an impression?
  1. I support the formulation of Mary as Mother of God as Christological. I do not support it in the sense that it conveys any sense that Mary herself is divine.
Neither would I, but it does not convey that sense, so there is no problem there.
I have seen Catholics maintain that it does.
Please direct these folks to this forum, and we’ll set them straight.
 
No. Why would you have such an impression?
Well, from lurking here for one thing. Discussions on 1 Cor 7 where Paul supposedly prefers being single over marriage, and this apparently was picked up by Ambrose and Jerome and Augustine, who were certainly influential. The superiority of a life of self-denial, particularly with respect to the sex act, over marriage is exalted. Is your pope married? The bishops? The church fathers, such as Aquinas and Augustine and Jerome and Chrysostom? What about your priests in the Latin Rite?

-Tina
 
Well, from lurking here for one thing. Discussions on 1 Cor 7 where Paul supposedly prefers being single over marriage, and this apparently was picked up by Ambrose and Jerome and Augustine, who were certainly influential. The superiority of a life of self-denial, particularly with respect to the sex act, over marriage is exalted. Is your pope married? The bishops? The church fathers, such as Aquinas and Augustine and Jerome and Chrysostom? What about your priests in the Latin Rite?

-Tina
The Church puts marriage beside Holy Orders(priesthood)…Marriage is considered a sacrement,that in it’s self shows that the church does not look down on marriage.
 
The Church puts marriage beside Holy Orders(priesthood)…Marriage is considered a sacrement,that in it’s self shows that the church does not look down on marriage.
Ok. My mama always said to keep my words sweet in case I have to eat them. 😊

-Tina 🙂
 
Well, from lurking here for one thing. Discussions on 1 Cor 7 where Paul supposedly prefers being single over marriage, and this apparently was picked up by Ambrose and Jerome and Augustine, who were certainly influential. The superiority of a life of self-denial, particularly with respect to the sex act, over marriage is exalted. Is your pope married? The bishops? The church fathers, such as Aquinas and Augustine and Jerome and Chrysostom? What about your priests in the Latin Rite?

-Tina
Let’s review what the scriptures tell us:

1 Corinthians 7:1
1Now for the matters you wrote about: It is good for a man not to marry.

1 Corinthians 7:7
7I wish that all men were as I am. But each man has his own gift from God; one has this gift, another has that.

Paul reveals his own celibacy and offers an earnest wish that more people would follow his example.

1 Corinthians 7:8-9
8Now to the unmarried and the widows I say: It is good for them to stay unmarried, as I am. 9But if they cannot control themselves, they should marry, for it is better to marry than to burn with passion.

Paul concedes that getting married is better than struggling with sexual temptation; for those that “cannot control themselves, they should marry.”

Is Paul completely opposed to marriage? Not at all. The book of Hebrews states:

Hebrews 13:4
Marriage
should be honored by all, and the marriage bed kept pure, for God will judge the adulterer and all the sexually immoral.

Why then does Paul recommend celibacy?

1 Corinthians 7:32-35
32I would like you to be free from concern. An unmarried man is concerned about the Lord’s affairs—how he can please the Lord. 33But a married man is concerned about the affairs of this world—how he can please his wife— 34and his interests are divided. An unmarried woman or virgin is concerned about the Lord’s affairs: Her aim is to be devoted to the Lord in both body and spirit. But a married woman is concerned about the affairs of this world—how she can please her husband. 35I am saying this for your own good, not to restrict you, but that you may live in a right way in undivided devotion to the Lord.

From this passage, we can see Paul’s primary reason for advocating celibacy: he wants everyone to live in undivided devotion to the Lord, and in all of these verses, the Bible makes it clear that Jesus calls some men to the priesthood and offers them the gift of a celibate life to be lived in undivided devotion to God. Paul understands that not everyone is offered this gift and that not all to whom it is offered can or will accept it.

There are Catholic priests who are married; typically, these are men who were priests in the Anglican, Orthodox or other faith traditions and have converted to the Catholic faith after they were married in those churches. Under special circumstances, they may be ordained to serve as Catholic priests. Men who are already Catholic when they begin to discern their call to the priesthood must remain celibate.

The Catholic Church forbids no man to marry. However, she does desire that those who will represent Christ, who will stand in persona Christi (in the place of Christ) when administering the sacraments as priests, be like their Lord as fully as possible. This means that like Jesus, they are celibate men prepared to sacrifice their own lives in the service of God and others.

The calling and the gift is offered by God; those who choose to accept it do so freely. Here is an article, “Celibacy is a Gift”, that explains this more fully: catholic.com/thisrock/2001/0102fea5.asp
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top