When to go to Confession

  • Thread starter Thread starter expectthebest
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Ditch the word ‘rules’ altogether and you’d be closer.

After all, the Church didn’t make ‘rules’ that God is Trinity, that Jesus is both fully man and fully divine, or that certain books are inspired scripture. What it did was teach Divine knowledge and Divine truths about these things that were revealed to it by the Holy Spirit.

Now - have all these divine truths been taught since the beginning of the Church and never changed? They HAVE always been truth, no mistake about that - God HAS always been Trinity, Jesus WAS fully human and fully divine, and certain writings ARE inspired scripture. Whether they were always explicitly taught - well, we don’t have complete records from all who taught, so we don’t really know. Some of them certainly were.

The important thing is that they always WERE true, even during the first two or three centuries when there was debate about the Trinity, about whether Jesus really was both divine and human, or about which books should be included in scripture (which there still is today, of course).

These things didn’t BECOME true only when they were pronounced as dogma at the Councils of Chalcedon, Nicea, Hippo and Carthage.

So in relation to sin - the truth that the Church teaches today about sin has always been true, and certainly is implicit in one of John’s epistles, which distinguishes clearly been sins that are ‘unto death’ (mortal) and sin which is NOT ‘unto death’ (venial). Even if all of it hasn’t always been explicitly taught or formalised as dogma, it is true and to be believed. The nature of sin doesn’t change, although our understanding of it, and God’s revelation of it to us, can. Just as His revelation of Himself changed from OT monotheism (since Christ had not yet been incarnated) to Trinity in the NT.
The problem I am having is that all of this is quite abstact. What you are saying is that what is and what is not mortal sin and the whole teaching of perfect contriciton vs confession has evolved over time and that even the orginal Apostles didn’t necessarily see things the same way. Mortal sin and confession are so basic to Catholic teaching, even for a child. But this Truth evoved over time? I’m having a hard time with that. Often I wonder what the Apostles would say about the Church today if they were to all of a suddent appear on earth.
 
The truth does not evolve over time. Period.

Jesus gave Peter the Keys to the Kingdom of Heaven, and promised that the Holy Spirit would be with the Church to guide it always. All of that is easily found in Scripture. Jesus promised that the gates of Hell would not prevail against His Church.

If the Church sees a need to define and rebuke a heresy of the times, so be it. If the Church needs to “change the rules” to accomodate changing times, technology, whatever, so be it. The Church is the Bride of Christ, guided by the Holy Spirit. Rest assured that it will do what Christ commands. It operates with the full authority of Jesus.

It does NOT change the truth.
 
The truth does not evolve over time. Period.

Jesus gave Peter the Keys to the Kingdom of Heaven, and promised that the Holy Spirit would be with the Church to guide it always. All of that is easily found in Scripture. Jesus promised that the gates of Hell would not prevail against His Church.

If the Church sees a need to define and rebuke a heresy of the times, so be it. If the Church needs to “change the rules” to accomodate changing times, technology, whatever, so be it. The Church is the Bride of Christ, guided by the Holy Spirit. Rest assured that it will do what Christ commands. It operates with the full authority of Jesus.

It does NOT change the truth.
I understand what you are saying. However, it seems that the Truth of today was not necessarily understood as Truth by the Apostles. Absoulute Truth can’t evolve. But understanding of Truth certainly can and I think has in the history of the Church. What is difficult to understand is why the Apostles did not teach these most basic rules as they are taught today. Namely the theology of perfect contrition vs that of Sacremental Confession and the forgiveness of sins.
 
God has always revealed himself to us gradually. Look at the history of the Covenants that God made with the Israelites. Scott Hahn has a great book on that topic. All through the Bible, God’s plan for salvation has been gradually revealing himself over time.

While Jesus spent about 3 years in his public ministry, considering all he had to teach, it was really opening up a fire hose! Small wonder we’re still absorbing and contemplating 2000 years later - we’ll still be doing that 2000 years from now probably.

Then, as now, the Apostles were given what they needed by the Holy Spirit. They, in turn, provided that to the early Church. We’ve had 2000 years since then to study and learn (and be guided). So to me, it’s not surprising that we are learning more as time goes on - standing on the shoulders of giants, and all that. We have some Doctors of the Church who have done a fabulous job of furthering our theological understanding.

I see it as a further and deeper understanding of the same truths, in general. Although, I bet some of the ECF’s and Apostles might put our understanding to shame as well…
 
God has always revealed himself to us gradually. Look at the history of the Covenants that God made with the Israelites. Scott Hahn has a great book on that topic. All through the Bible, God’s plan for salvation has been gradually revealing himself over time.

While Jesus spent about 3 years in his public ministry, considering all he had to teach, it was really opening up a fire hose! Small wonder we’re still absorbing and contemplating 2000 years later - we’ll still be doing that 2000 years from now probably.

Then, as now, the Apostles were given what they needed by the Holy Spirit. They, in turn, provided that to the early Church. We’ve had 2000 years since then to study and learn (and be guided). So to me, it’s not surprising that we are learning more as time goes on - standing on the shoulders of giants, and all that. We have some Doctors of the Church who have done a fabulous job of furthering our theological understanding.

I see it as a further and deeper understanding of the same truths, in general. Although, I bet some of the ECF’s and Apostles might put our understanding to shame as well…
Yes, I think you are correct. But, for issues that go straight to the foundation of forgiveness of sins, it doesn’t seem logical that the Apostles would not have had this foundation before Jesus left the earth. I mean, this goes straight to who is and who is not saved. This had to be clear at the time. This is what makes me wonder if the Church has not strayed away in the attempt to build on the teaching of the Apostles, at least to some degree. It’s almost like the old adage about a college professor spending years studying and tyring to figure out the hiddin meaning behind an authors work. And then the author comes out and says that there is no hiddin meaning and it’s just a story simple as that. Could we just be looking into things a little too far?
 
No, I don’t think so. The Apostles didn’t really do a whole lot until Jesus ascended into Heaven and sent the Holy Spirit to guide them. He promised to do this, and gave them full authority for his Church. I really don’t think it could be more direct than that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top