Where does one draw the line on humorous lyrics and violent references?

[jjb5985]

Me and some friends like getting together to make humorous songs. We are recording some “gangster rap” songs but I came across a moral dilemma. The songs are purely jokes and parodies of the genre, but considering they are probably going to be played for a large number of people, I try to make sure the lyrics aren’t too vulgar or explicit. I’m not sure where to draw the line though with certain things. Usually slang terms for violent fighting like “bustin heads” “splittin wigs” “carrying 9’s (guns)” hitting someone or whatever other references to violence. These phrases can mean different things depending on who you talk to because they are slang, but they are usually references to violence acts. I said I wasn’t sure if that was ok because it might come across as promoting violence which if this were “real” music I wouldn’t want. They said it’s all in good fun and just a joke and no one is going to take it seriously. My question is if these kind of lyrics or anything else if done in a joking manner and isn’t too explicit and vulgar would be acceptable? I know “jokes” can certainly go too far and be sinful. At the same time, I don’t want to be overly scrupulous about something that is just a joke and isn’t meant to be taken seriously by anyone even though the som listeners may not know it is a joke. Can you give me an idea if this kind of stuff is ever acceptable as a joke or where a line is drawn? Thanks.

 

[Fr.Vincent_Serpa]

Dear JJ,

Know your audience. If children are likely to hear the songs, then you have to be more careful. It’s a judgment call and the judge is you. The fact that you are concerned sounds like there is reason for concern. You are to be commended for such sensitivity. Would that more entertainers today had it.
Know your audience, JJ. If it’s just for the guys, that’s one thing. But such things can be difficult to control once they have a life of their own.

Fr. Vincent Serpa, O.P.