Why do a lot of American Catholics not like Muslims?

  • Thread starter Thread starter JCats1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’ve looked into the Muslim faith and I’ve met many Muslim people and they’re all peaceful and they all denounce extremist actions.
What do you mean by the term “extremist actions”? For example, I am wondering whether or not it is an extremist action for a government to ban the novel The Satanic Verses. How can I determine whether or not it is an extremist action?

I imagine that a government might be motivated to ban that novel to keep the peace, because availability of the novel could provoke – or be used as a pretext for – violence.

Now, I could imagine that somebody might characterize such a government as distrusting Muslims or disliking Muslims or failing to recognize the truth that the overwhelming majority of Muslims are peaceful, etc.

So, let us go back … what is an “extremist action”? If I owe you one cent and I travel a hundred miles to pay you what I owe, then I have done something. It would be a deliberate action, and not merely a dream, an attitude, or a thought. It is extreme in the sense that it indicates a strong commitment to deal with something that is very small. So, is that an example of an “extremist action”? The two words taken together could be interpreted as conveying that meaning. Would a Muslim denounce me for paying to you what I owe you?
 
Hello everyone. I am 17 years old. I have noticed on these forums and a lot of other places that American Catholics seem not to trust Muslim people and are very wary of them. Why is this happening? They seem to distance themselves from them and not trust them at all and seem to assume that all Muslim people are terrorists, which is completely false. I personally like integrating with cultures and I feel as if I don’t belong to one culture and I am open to learning about other religions/cultures. I’ve looked into the Muslim faith and I’ve met many Muslim people and they’re all peaceful and they all denounce extremist actions. I know people have told me that the Quran says some things that indicate an extremist attitude but we need to contextualize and look at the historical background of the creation of the Quran. Also, Muslims and Catholics believe in the same God of Abraham, so why emphasize the fact that we are so different? I’ve been noticing this anti-Islam sentiment coming mainly from American Catholics, wheras European and Canadian Catholics are more open to them. Why is this?
As a Catholic, I have a deep respect for Muslims. Unfortunately though, I think a lot of Americans tend to paint all Muslims with the broad stroke of the brush and kinda view all Muslims to be like ISIS and radicalized. Truth is, you’ll find radicalized believers in just about every world religion. Just because you find some radicalized Muslims that doesn’t mean that all Muslims are radicalized. However, some radicalized Muslims will be rather deceitful. I tend to give people the benefit of the doubt. I work with many wonderful Muslim people. I have great conversations with them from entertainment to religious conversations. We all get along great!

One time while on the bus I was talking an American tourist. This was shortly after 9-11 and we past by a Mosque and a Mosque High School in my home town. The look of judgment on their face was telling. They cringed deeply and basically said, “I can’t believe Canadians would allow a Mosque and a Mosque High School.” I bit my tongue but I should have said, “here in Canada, we believe not only in democracy but also freedom to express our religion/faith” I can’t remember exactly what I said but I wouldn’t be a bit surprised if they would decide never to return to this part of Canada. I think if we’re exposed to enough of the Muslim population we begin to see Muslims are like everyone else. There are good Muslims and bad Muslims, good Catholic’s bad Catholic’s etc etc and the media and news never really helps either. Whether they want to spread anti-muslim propaganda or anti-Catholic propaganda both are out there and both are equally presented through the media and so if American’s are quick to believe all news out there and hang on CNN as if CNN is like the bible or something I can understand why some American’s have a low view of Muslims. It’s about the same reason why some people will hate Catholic’s and the Catholic Church. There’s a lot of misinformation out there. However, it’s difficult to love a people when some of their people are killing our people. This is not just true about religion it’s also true about ethnicity. Some black people and native American people will have difficulty trusting white people because of the history of racism and segregation etc etc just like in our day when Americans will associate all Muslims with 9-11 and/or ISIS. Truth is though, ISIS radicalized Muslims are killing their own people as well.

So, we just need to see things in it’s proper perspective.
 
Hello everyone. I am 17 years old. I have noticed on these forums and a lot of other places that American Catholics seem not to trust Muslim people and are very wary of them. Why is this happening? They seem to distance themselves from them and not trust them at all and seem to assume that all Muslim people are terrorists, which is completely false. I personally like integrating with cultures and I feel as if I don’t belong to one culture and I am open to learning about other religions/cultures. I’ve looked into the Muslim faith and I’ve met many Muslim people and they’re all peaceful and they all denounce extremist actions. I know people have told me that the Quran says some things that indicate an extremist attitude but we need to contextualize and look at the historical background of the creation of the Quran. Also, Muslims and Catholics believe in the same God of Abraham, so why emphasize the fact that we are so different? I’ve been noticing this anti-Islam sentiment coming mainly from American Catholics, wheras European and Canadian Catholics are more open to them. Why is this?
I’m British so I can’t answer for Americans,but we do have British people with the same attitude., which unfortunately appears to be on the increase because of the terrorism, and the recent reporting in the media about the radicalisation of some British born young Muslims who have been leaving the country to join IS in Syria.

I share the same view as you, because I too have met many peaceful decent good living Muslims who are not only as much against terrorist groups as we are, but also see them as the enemy of Muslims, as well as non-Muslims.
 
I will treat any individual with the respect due him or her as made in the image of God. That is my duty as a Catholic.

I am a native of a Muslim country and have spent my early years there and I can tell you the fruits of Islam are not good.

I know it’s politically incorrect, but I repeat, the fruits of Islam are not good.
 
I will treat any individual with the respect due him or her as made in the image of God. That is my duty as a Catholic.

I am a native of a Muslim country and have spent my early years there and I can tell you the fruits of Islam are not good.

I know it’s politically incorrect, but I repeat, the fruits of Islam are not good.
I suppose much of that depends on which country it is, and their system of government.
 
Do you know what exactly Jihad means? It is mentioned Jihad as only war in that web.

Jihad means to struggle. Jihad has four parts mainly.
  1. To struggle against self evil desires. That is the most importand part of Jihad.
  2. To struggle against evils and to struggle spread faith by wisdom. That is the most significant part of Jihad.
  3. To struggle to spend self assets to support faith and religion. There are many ways of that.
  4. To struggle against evils and bloody with sword and to preserve Islamic country with sword(weapon).
.
So if there is a billion Muslims and a very, very small percent is radical why don’t you muslims stand up and confront these terrorists? According to #4 they are evil and must be dealt with. Why do our troops and troops from other countries have to fight and die for you and your beliefs?
 
So if there is a billion Muslims and a very, very small percent is radical why don’t you muslims stand up and confront these terrorists? According to #4 they are evil and must be dealt with. Why do our troops and troops from other countries have to fight and die for you and your beliefs?
Most Muslims are peaceful, they want the same good things for their Families all of us want…
…It’s the much smaller percentage of “Fundamental” ( Devout ) Muslims which is at issue.

There will never be an “uprising” of liberal or peaceful Muslims against the devout Muslims…
…It would be like expecting liberal Catholics to attack Fundamentalist or devout Catholics for protesting an abortion clinic.
…Or liberal Catholics attacking by force Devout Catholics who stand against gay marriage.

This simply wont happen…
…This is a problem only God can remedy.
…Or literally a genocide against the ideology which no one should want.
 
I’m from the Netherlands.
And I think we’ve got pretty much the same experience with Islamic immigrants than people from the UK.

Note: There’s a vast difference between muslims in the USA and in in Western Europe.

Intelligence
USA: The muslim immigrants came because they had special talents or were highly educated.
W-EU: The muslims came to do petty tasks, they preferred to pick the men with no formal education.

Diversity
USA: Vast amount of different cultures. The muslims come from different denominations, different countries. (Heck, there’s even a large percentage of African American muslims)
W-EU: Mostly from 1 or 2 countries. Same denominations. (Almost no native muslims)

Multicultural society:
USA: Has for a long time been kind of everything. Different kinds of christians, jew etc. Different kind of races. Different people with socio-economic status. It’s more of a Gesellschaft than Gemeinschaft. People don’t care what everyone else does. Everybody is American.
W-EU: Mostly caucasians, which already had a tiny amount of immigrants (colonies).
Now the new muslim immigrants make a MAJOR impact on the society. In my country for example not everyone is seen as Dutch. There is the Dutch language and the way a Dutchmen looks. You can become Dutch, but you won’t be seen as Dutch. About 1/10th of the population is non-Western immigrant right now, most of those are muslim. This takes a great toll on the society. The immigrants create their own society and many first generation immigrants live here their whole life without learning the domestic language. Instead they continue to speak their own languages, watch their native television, they have their own islamic schools, their own grocery stores, their own barber etc. They’re not intergrating. They stick together.
That’s why populism is getting pretty big in many countries as a political movement.
 
Unfortunately, you can find prejudice just about anywhere. Some people prefer to blame all Muslims for the actions of a minority, just as some will blame all priests for the actions of a minority.
^^This^^ I once had a discussion with my philosophy professor about this (who I believe was an agnostic or an atheist, though he never revealed directly his faith). He was telling me that he wasn’t too happy with the movie “God’s Not Dead” because of the way it portrays the philosophy professor as an angry atheist out to destroy Christianity. As a result, he began to see many religious students not looking at philosophy professors too kindly because they assumed they were all out to get them.

Going back to the subject of Islam, it is the same thing. NEVER judge the majority based on the minority. I think that many Catholics do this partly because they want to demonize those who hold incorrect beliefs on God. Demonizing, is never the solution, however, and it is unfair and isn’t very Christ like either. Interfaith religious dialogue in a peaceful manner is the way to go about understanding each other:thumbsup:
 
jesusalright4me;13075887]^^This^^ I once had a discussion with my philosophy professor about this (who I believe was an agnostic or an atheist, though he never revealed directly his faith). He was telling me that he wasn’t too happy with the movie “God’s Not Dead” because of the way it portrays the philosophy professor as an angry atheist out to destroy Christianity. As a result, he began to see many religious students not looking at philosophy professors too kindly because they assumed they were all out to get them.
Your philosophy professor should be the first to respect another’s opinion, especially when his profession deals within the grey areas of logic and reason. Diversity of views is a compliment to philosophical thinkers and should be respected in the arena of freedom.
Going back to the subject of Islam, it is the same thing. NEVER judge the majority based on the minority. I think that many Catholics do this partly because they want to demonize those who hold incorrect beliefs on God. Demonizing, is never the solution, however, and it is unfair and isn’t very Christ like either. Interfaith religious dialogue in a peaceful manner is the way to go about understanding each other:thumbsup
I disagree with the OP’s view and Catholics wanting to demonize those with “incorrect beliefs on God”. Our present is a reflection of the past in Catholic/Muslim relations which is a huge subject of discussion that deals with the prophetic conquest of Islam over all the world which is unending.

The Catholic faith armies who were outnumbered both in land and sea defeated the invading Muslim Turks from conquering the West and Europe in the late and early 14th and 15th centuries. This is the status quo we find ourselves in today.

Islam has made a new prophetic conquest to conquer Western Christendom; “by your liberal laws Islam will conquer you”. Muslims have been migrating and integrating Western free societies since their defeat, and is outnumbering Christians once again, due to our abortion and anti Christian laws ( for one example; gay marriage which does not produce natural offspring) and social standards of living that are foreign to Christianity’s standards of living.

Your “interfaith religious dialogue” is key to the discussion here. Presently and in recent history the Pope’s have been making the effort in interfaith religious dialogue, in fact Vatican II documents address this work in progress with all different religious faith’s.

Thus officially the Catholic Church is the one making the efforts towards peaceful dialogue with Muslims.

How does one have a dialogue with Muslims, when Islam has political sanctions against Christians living within Muslim borders and civil penalty laws against Christian bibles and the exposition of Christianity in the public.

A Muslim dialogue speaks from three fronts; 1) religious 2) political 3) militarily. A Catholic does not speak from these three fronts only from the religious point of view, which can make the dialogue difficult, when the Catholic is at a disadvantage.

It can be difficult to understand from which tongue the Muslim has engaged his/her dialogue on interfaith religious subjects because the religion of Islam mixes religion with politics and secular government laws, when it was said, “religion is the opium of the people”.

I believe “American Catholics not like Muslims” is a bad choice of words. Americans are hated and sought after by those identifying themselves as Muslims. I believe the correct word to be used by any American should be cautious towards unknown Muslims. For the simple fact that Islam practices a virtue of deception towards non-Muslims, thus terror can strike at any time by an unsuspecting Muslim. We have to remember we are still at war with those who identify themselves as true Muslims and faithful servants to their prophet and the Koran, while some peaceful loving Muslims are considered apostates to Islam by their same Muslim counterparts.

So to which Muslim does one have an interfaith dialogue? When the Pope sent an envoy to the middle east to conduct an interfaith dialogue with Muslims, the envoy was sent away by Islam’s religious leaders proclaiming publicly “by your liberal laws, Islam will conquer you”
 
^^This^^ I once had a discussion with my philosophy professor about this (who I believe was an agnostic or an atheist, though he never revealed directly his faith). He was telling me that he wasn’t too happy with the movie “God’s Not Dead” because of the way it portrays the philosophy professor as an angry atheist out to destroy Christianity. As a result, he began to see many religious students not looking at philosophy professors too kindly because they assumed they were all out to get them.

Going back to the subject of Islam, it is the same thing. NEVER judge the majority based on the minority. I think that many Catholics do this partly because they want to demonize those who hold incorrect beliefs on God. Demonizing, is never the solution, however, and it is unfair and isn’t very Christ like either. Interfaith religious dialogue in a peaceful manner is the way to go about understanding each other:thumbsup:
Islam, just like Christianity is a body of beliefs. It goes beyond what individuals do or don’t do. We are not to judge an individual’s spiritual state but we can look objectively at the tenets of a faith and decide for ourselves if we agree or disagree with it. Disagreeing with a faith is not hate.

I disagree with the tenets of Islam but that by itself does not make me a hater.
 
I suppose much of that depends on which country it is, and their system of government.
In Islam there is no separation of Church and State…
…The Church IS the State - the State IS the Church.
…Therefore any Islamic Country is an Islamic State.
 
There is a very easy way to find answers to some of the questions being debated here. I propose a survey of sorts. If you know a muslim person, young or old, ask that person a question. Ask them if they think sharia law should be instituted in the country thdy live in. (US, UK, etc., wherever you happen to be) . Then ask if they think that this country should be converted
to Islam.

And please report the responses.
 
I will treat any individual with the respect due him or her as made in the image of God. That is my duty as a Catholic.

I am a native of a Muslim country and have spent my early years there and I can tell you the fruits of Islam are not good.

I know it’s politically incorrect, but I repeat, the fruits of Islam are not good.
Exactly.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top