P
promethius
Guest
It is true that simply being published does not constitute proof of authority, however it is not true by contravention that one must be peer reviewed in order to demonstrate authority.Indeed. But being a published work is not proof of any authority. I gathered that much, but the authors are religious from what I can gather? And would I be right in thinking the people possessed were also religious or from religious backgrounds/families?
In particular in the case of exorcism, we recognize that there is no authoritative text. However, in terms of Catholic Theology we also believe that 1) only a catholic priest may be appointed an exorcist and 2) only an exorcist appointed by the bishop can successfully carry out an exorcism (the full rite on those who are fully possessed, not just minor possessions, etc). Beyond that, Exorcists are largely their own authority and speak with regards to their own practices, although the Rite of Exorcism has recently been revised to be more restrictive against abuses.
One of the books I mentioned to you was written by Fr Gabriel Amorth, who was appointed by the Pope as the Exorcist for the Diocese of Rome. That constitutes authority on the subject. The Rite (the book, not the movie) was made in conjunction with Father Gary Thomas, whose story is told in the books, and Fr Thomas has endorsed the book as true to his experience as an exorcist (who, again, has authority by HIS appointment as such by HIS bishop)
As to authoritative sources on Exorcism, generally an exorcist is the authority on the subject, although some bishops are likewise educated. With an impremateur, a non-religious might be able to give something of an authoritative testimony as well though (such as the case with the The Rite by Matt Baglio).
As to the subjects of Exorcism, for the third time, no. Often times those who come to priests (or are brought to priests, more often) are not catholic or not even religious. Possession is not limited to those who are catholic.
Fair enough, but you should understand the difference between Catholic understanding of possession and exorcism and protestant versions of these beliefs. Catholics accept very few accounts of exorcism (I generally peruse texts on the subject of demonology for errors before I even consider spending money on them).I didnt make a baseless assertion. Once again you seem to be reading into what I wrote something I did not intend. I merely asked if you could reference a peer reviewed and authenticated article of possession of an atheist. My reference to internet stories just reflects the fact there are millions of demonic possession stories on the web, many of them, if not all, highly dubious and not much more than hearsay and gross distortion of actual facts and events. I wasnt making a link between that line and the books you referred to. You made that link all by yourself.
Like I said, discernment has always been about more than “strange behavior”, and quoting the protestant salem witch trials at me is rather pointless since I don’t believe that protestants have any authority in the subject of formal Rites of Exorcism and Giles Corey probably never encountered a Catholic Exorcist in his entire life. (and, if anything, the Salem Witch trials had more in common with the Inquisition than with the Rite of Exorcism and possession).And with very limited knowledge of the mind and its working I would venture much of that discernment was wrong. Giles Corey might have something to say about the discernment techniques used on him![]()
Discernment in the case of possession has NEVER involved torture practices either, because demons do not respond to physical pain. A technique of discernment might be sprinkling of plain water on someone while praying verbally. If they recoil in fear and pain thinking it is holy water, they are not possessed because plain water has no effect on demons. Another sign might be the sudden appearance of an unstudied foreign language in response to prayers or sacraments, recoiling from sacramentals, knowing future events or unknowable things.
So, I think if you’re definitely confused between the Rite of Exorcism and the Inquisition…
I don’t disagree with you here. The chance for errors and abuse has been greatly reduced lately.I think fortunately with the advent of modern psychiatry and our understanding of the workings of the minds and body and mental illness this discernment discernment has greatly improved.
Alright, then let’s start with how you would account for someone who is able to predict future events, speak languages they’ve never studied or been exposed to, recoils instinctively from holy water (even when they are unaware that it is holy water) and is able to make guesses about things they should not know? Are these “rational” behaviors that have their locus in the brain?Once again you seem happy to see something I neither said nor intended. At no point did I, or would I, dismiss anyones beliefs as ‘hocus pocus’’. My position is all abnormal human behavior can be explained rationally and has a locus somehwere in the brain. Others do no agree. Great. That’s a wonderful opportunty for a pleasant conversation and exchange of views.