Why do Jesuits dress in black?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Exiled_Child
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

Exiled_Child

Guest
I’m not sure if this is the right place to ask, but does anyone know why Jesuits dress in black? Was it originally just a variation on the traditional clothing of priests, or was there some sort of symbolic significance?
 
Peace and All Good!
I’m not sure if this is the right place to ask, but does anyone know why Jesuits dress in black? Was it originally just a variation on the traditional clothing of priests, or was there some sort of symbolic significance?
As far as I know, it’s because of the similarity with the traditional clerical attire, though there may also be a deeper reason I’m unaware of…
 
Not just similarity. St. Ignatius Loyola did not give them a habit. They were just told to dress “properly” and not too rich. So they wore the clerical garb of the day, which at that time was a cassock (black robe).

Today I don’t think many Jesuits wear a cassock anymore, or for that matter clericals (black shirt and pants, white collar), except when saying Mass. Priests of the FSSP and of the ICRSS, and others who use the traditional Roman liturgy, wear a cassock and Roman collar as their official habit.

I don’t have a reference, but I believe it was St. John Eudes who said that the black color of the cassock represents being dead to sin. Whether this significance was attached to it at the time of its adoption for clerics, or later, I cannot say. The cassock itself is believed to be a version of the tunic worn under the toga in ancient Rome.
 
Not just similarity. St. Ignatius Loyola did not give them a habit. They were just told to dress “properly” and not too rich. So they wore the clerical garb of the day, which at that time was a cassock (black robe).

Today I don’t think many Jesuits wear a cassock anymore, or for that matter clericals (black shirt and pants, white collar), except when saying Mass. Priests of the FSSP and of the ICRSS, and others who use the traditional Roman liturgy, wear a cassock and Roman collar as their official habit.

I don’t have a reference, but I believe it was St. John Eudes who said that the black color of the cassock represents being dead to sin. Whether this significance was attached to it at the time of its adoption for clerics, or later, I cannot say. The cassock itself is believed to be a version of the tunic worn under the toga in ancient Rome.
And in tropical countries, the traditional cassock color was white.
 
I’m not sure if this is the right place to ask, but does anyone know why Jesuits dress in black?
I think I’m right in saying that St Ignatius required his followers to wear the typical clerical dress of the country or workplace in which they ministered - hence you will see Jesuits wearing a wide variety of clothing depending on where they are and what they are doing, usually as established by the norms of the diocese or episcopal conference in which they are working.

I remember reading an article critical of the manner in which several German Jesuits working in the academic world were wearing a shirt and tie rather than a clerical collar or a habit; a response to the article pointed out that ‘civilian’ garb was normal in German academia, and that all priests working as academics dressed this way in Germany, including (as a photograph clearly showed) Joseph Ratzinger before he became prefect of the CDF.

Hence the tradition of the Jesuits is to make themselves indistinguishable from secular priests by wearing whatever the latter wear within their particular working environment. It would be interesting to know what St Ignatius’s rationale was for this, but it is the long-established practice of the Order as mandated by its founder (or so a Jesuit once told me!).

In Christ,
Withburga
 
Thanks a million for all these answers everyone! I’ve particularly enjoyed reading about St. John Eudes today. He’s someone I knew was interesting, but hand’t actually investigated much. Of course, light internet research only barely scratches the surface… I have a hunch that quote of his absolutely correct, Ad Orientem, and I’m going to search out some actual books on him. The paper variety, I mean!🙂

I recently re-watched The Mission, and then the other day I cracked open this old book I have on Fort Michilimackinac, by Lyle M. Stone, which talks about “the black robes,” and I got to thinking how much the Jesuits attire adds to their mystique and fascination. If I ever find a really solid explanation I’ll post it back in this thread, just in case anyone else ever searches CAF for information on this subject! Again, thanks everyone.
 
I think you have it backward. True St. Ignatius didn’t give them a habit and told them to dress simply. So the simplest thing to wear was black. It was the secular priest that copied the Jesuits not the other way around. IIRC
 
You may be right. The cassock certainly goes back to ancient times and was worn by the laity as well as clerics, but it seems the first legislation emanating from the Holy See requiring clergy to wear a cassock was that of Pope Sixtus V in 1589, well after the death of St. Ignatius.
 
The cassock is the regular garb of clergy until today. Although it’s fallen out of fashion, it’s making a little bit of a comeback.

The cassock was originally used to keep warm in drafty churches, which explains its French name soutane, which shares the same root as the word for animal skins.
The churches were large, damp, and cold. Even if a church were to have a hearth for a fire, the place was so large that the warmth would dissipate almost immediately. As a solution, priests began wearing long coats of animal furs in the church. As time progressed, the clergy became somewhat identifiable with long coats, and when it became fashionable to wear shorter doublets, the clergy retained longer garments.
Over time, the cassock began to take shape. It was wool became more popular than skins, and it became pleated, and buttoned at the front.
The white band clerical collar was originally a band of fabric wrapped around the neck to keep the wool from chaffing the skin there.
Until recently, there were different regional variations on the cassock. Some priests in northern Europe would wear long tab “preaching bands” with it (a la St. Jean Vianney). In some places a “V” shaped notch became common at the neck, while in other a square notch became common. The “roman cassock” usually means a black cassock, with a pleat at each side, and a box pleat at the back; with thirty-three buttons in the front. The “french-cut cassock” is similar, but has a narrower skirt, and buttons on the sleeves.
Eastern styles of cassocks are very diverse, and often come in colors other than black.
And in tropical countries, the traditional cassock color was white.
One brief correction on this — White isn’t the traditional color for a cassock in tropical countries, it just allowed for comfort and practicality’s sake (by papal indult). Many clerics in tropical countries will still wear a black cassock on formal occasions.
 
One brief correction on this — White isn’t the traditional color for a cassock in tropical countries, it just allowed for comfort and practicality’s sake (by papal indult). Many clerics in tropical countries will still wear a black cassock on formal occasions.
in my sui juris church, priests wear white usually. bishops too. when they are with a pope, they waer black.
 
Generally clerical clothing has been black.

Today Jesuits normally wear regular priest clothing, but also will wear simple clothing.
In some cases like in India Jesuits will wear traditional cassocks.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top