Why does not God regrow limbs?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Daniel_Marsh
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

Daniel_Marsh

Guest
These medical practitioners, having observed advanced gangrene in his leg, concluded that amputation was the only way to save the patient’s life. When they provided testimony before the judges, these doctors would describe the leg as «very phlegmonous and gangrenous,» to the point of appearing «black.» Around mid-October, Estanga and Millaruelo performed the operation, cutting the right leg «four fingers below the knee.» Although they had made the patient drowsy with alcoholic and drugged drinks, as was the practice at the time, Miguel suffered excruciating pain: «In his torment,» the witnesses would later say, «the young man called upon the Virgin of the Pillar, unceasingly and with great fervor.» A surgery student by the name of Juan Lorenzo García, was given responsibility for recovering the amputated leg and burying it in a dignified fashion in a part of the hospital cemetery reserved for this practice. At this time of faith, respect for the body destined for resurrection dictated that even anatomical remains be treated with piety. García would later testify that he had buried the piece of leg horizontally, «in a hole as deep as a span,» that is twenty-one centimeters (approximately 8 inches), according to the Aragonian measure.
…

At the beginning of 1640, Miguel returned to the place of his birth. He arrived in Calanda in March, mounted on a small donkey. His journey of about 120 kilometers had exhausted him, but his parents’ affectionate welcome restored his strength. Miguel was about to turn 23. Unable to help his family by his work, he went back to begging for alms. Many people testified that they had seen the young amputee in the villages surrounding Calanda, mounted on a little donkey, his cut off leg conspicuous, to call upon the inhabitants’ charity. On March 29, 1640, the region celebrated the 1600th anniversary of the Virgin Mary’s «coming in the mortal flesh» to the banks of the Ebro, according to the belief of the people of the area. This is the origin of the Spaniards’ ancient veneration of the Virgin of the Pillar. Around the same time, a book called The Augustinus by Bishop Cornelius Jansen was published in Louvain, Flanders, at that time part of the Spanish empire. The author’s notorious and eponymous doctrine, Jansenism, rejects Marian devotion, popular piety, pilgrimages, processions, and popular interest in miracles as unworthy of pure faith…

That Thursday, March 29th, Miguel did his utmost to help his family fill baskets of manure loaded on a little donkey. He filled nine baskets in a row, in spite of the trouble he had standing on his wooden leg. When evening came, he returned home, exhausted, his stump sorer than usual. That night, the Pellicer family was forced, by order of the government, to put up one of the Royal Cavalry’s soldiers who was marching toward the border to push back the French troops. Miguel had to give him his bed, and slept on a mattress on the ground in his parents’ room. He stretched out on it around ten o’clock. Having taken off his wooden leg, he stretched a cloak over himself that was too short to cover his whole body, because he had lent his blanket to the soldier. He then fell asleep…

Two feet and two legs

Between ten-thirty and eleven o’clock, Miguel’s mother entered the room with an oil lamp in her hand. She immediately smelled «a perfume, a sweet smell.» Intrigued, she raised her lamp — two feet were sticking out, «one over the other, crossed» from under the cloak covering her son, who was fast asleep. Stunned, she went to get her husband, who lifted the cloak. No doubt about it, there were indeed two feet, each at the end of a leg! They managed with some difficulty to wake up their son. Gradually becoming aware of what had happened, Miguel was amazed. The first words that came to his lips were to ask his father to «take his hand, and forgive him for the transgressions he had committed against him.» This spontaneous and immediate reaction of humility in this person who was the beneficiary of a miracle, is a very strong sign of the divine origin of this wonder. When asked, in a voice full of emotion, if he had «any idea how this had happened,» the young man replied that he knew nothing about it, but when he had been awakened from his sleep, «he had been in the middle of a dream that he was in the Holy Chapel of Our Lady of the Pillar and that he was rubbing his amputated leg with oil from the lamp, as he had the custom of doing.» He was immediately sure that Our Lady of the Pillar had brought back his cut-off leg and put it into place. The following Monday, his parents each in their turn affirmed before the notary that they «thought and regarded as truth that the Most Holy Virgin of the Pillar had asked her Son, our Redeemer, and had obtained this miracle from God, because of Miguel’s prayers, or because such were His mysterious ways.» These Christians clearly saw that the Virgin does not «do» miracles, but that, through her supplication, she obtains them from the Most Holy Trinity. As loved and venerated as she is, the Virgin is not like a pagan goddess, but rather an intermediary between us and her Son, in keeping with the maternal role her Son Himself bestowed on her when He told Saint John, Behold, your mother! (Jn 19:27).

clairval.com/lettres/en/2006/12/08/2061206.htm

When Heather shows the world her newly restored leg everybody around the world will know what the power of Jesus can really do. Amen.

mwillett.org/restore.htm
 
Daniel, what happens to these people’s faith if Heather’s leg is NOT restored?

BTW, that is a beautiful story of Miguel.
 
They claim her leg was restored.

But, I often encounter bitter people who have left their church because God did not act like the magic genie they demand him to be. Others will go on a guilt trip for not having enough faith.
Basically, they will either go deeper into this bondage of theology or they will throw out everything as a bad trip.
 
Everything depends on our faith. If we believe God will heal us, it will happen. There are many people healed of blindness or deafness because it’s much easier to believe it will than that their limbs would regrow. God bless.
 
Daniel,

I want to thank you for posting this article today. The topic is very timely, as My nephew (my sister’s son) who is in the Army was attacked last month by an IED while on patrol in Baghdad. He lost both his legs. Our family is faithful, and we were just discussing that it is entirely possible that God would heal him completely. This article is a reminder of God’s awesome power and Mercy.

“Jesus, I Trust in You!”
 
I think the biggest problem with miracles is that people want to demand specific miracles. I.e., my leg has been amputated, why has God not restored it. God, like any good parent, does not always give us what we want, but he will always give us what we need (though this too needs to be thought of in the context of our immortal life, not our life on this Earth).

Will God heal those who have had amputations? Yes, but he may or may not restore the limb. I have a friend who lost both of her legs due to injuries she sustained as an infant in a fire; if anyone had a right to be bitter about her lot in life, it was her. That being said, she always did her best to not let her situation keep her down and kept faith in God. The result is that she is married and has a beautiful daughter. While her legs are still gone, I think it is safe to say she has been healed. I would say that is the true miracle.

When God performs the flashier miracles, I think we need to remember that it is not generally simply for the person who received the miracle but rather so that others may be increased in faith.

One of the most difficult prayers we can ever say is the one that Jesus uttered in the Garden; “Not by my will but by yours.”

–
Bill
 
God does regrow limbs. Most notably on starfish and other lower order animals. Somehow the biology prevents such regeneration in more complex organisms. But God designed it that way and who are we to question Her?
This comes dangerously close to tempting the Lord God.

Matthew
 
Why does not God regrow limbs?

Because He knows what is most beneficial for our salvation, and the salvation of others around us. Anything that can teach us humility, patience, compassion etc and turn our hearts of stone into hearts of flesh is much better for us in the long (eternal) run than it might be to have healthy pairs of limbs all our lives.

John
 
God does regrow limbs. Most notably on starfish and other lower order animals. Somehow the biology prevents such regeneration in more complex organisms. But God designed it that way and who are we to question Her?
This comes dangerously close to tempting the Lord God.

Matthew
Did I read this right?
 
What, now you’re protesting the existence of the Holy Spirit, Lady Wisdom?
Does not the Scripture tell us that She was there in the beginning, guiding the work of creation?
Somehow I suspect that your attitude may be tending toward heresy.

Matthew
 
What, now you’re protesting the existence of the Holy Spirit, Lady Wisdom?
Does not the Scripture tell us that She was there in the beginning, guiding the work of creation?
Somehow I suspect that your attitude may be tending toward heresy.

Matthew
I simply wasn’t aware that the Holy Spirit was a She?

BTW, heresy is teaching a falsehood. Ignorance is not heresy, if so, I’d be one of the biggest heretics around.
 
What, now you’re protesting the existence of the Holy Spirit, Lady Wisdom?
Does not the Scripture tell us that She was there in the beginning, guiding the work of creation?
Somehow I suspect that your attitude may be tending toward heresy.

Matthew
Methinks that you are a little too quick to throw around the “H” word.

In the Catechism, the Holy Spirit is addressed as “He”.
683 "No one can say ‘Jesus is Lord’ except by the Holy Spirit."1 "God has sent the Spirit of his Son into our hearts, crying, ‘Abba! Father!’"2 This knowledge of faith is possible only in the Holy Spirit: to be in touch with Christ, we must first have been touched by the Holy Spirit. He comes to meet us and kindles faith in us. By virtue of our Baptism, the first sacrament of the faith, the Holy Spirit in the Church communicates to us, intimately and personally, the life that originates in the Father and is offered to us in the Son.
684 Through his grace, the Holy Spirit is the first to awaken faith in us and to communicate to us the new life, which is to "know the Father and the one whom he has sent, Jesus Christ."4 But the Spirit is the last of the persons of the Holy Trinity to be revealed. St. Gregory of Nazianzus, the Theologian, explains this progression in terms of the pedagogy of divine “condescension”:
There may be other occasions where the Holy Spirit is addressed as “She” but, since I am unaware of them, I wanted to ask you for clarification.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top