Why is it that we absolve God from all the horrible things that are happening to us

  • Thread starter Thread starter Joybearer
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

Joybearer

Guest
Forgive me but I am going to say that this post will be done with a negative tone because being sick and tired of this life is an understatement. I wouldn’t speak of the experience of others but for 32 years of my life, I have been bullied and have things consistently being taken away from me. I have just used a huge chunk of profanities on God these past couple of days which I never had no matter how difficult it was. Now that’s done, I’m hoping there can be some sort of answers around here.

I have tried being optimistic and hopeful and was let down at every turn for decades, money, things and friends being taken away and even after I thought that nothing more could be taken, God will find new ways to take more and more. Whenever I ask anyone of the absence of God or the deliberate suffering He is causing in my life with no respite, there are always the same old answers. “Be grateful for what you have”, “God can see around the corner and will give you what you need.”, “Everything will be fine in the end”, and more recently, after talking to a Franciscan Sister in a series of counselling session, everything seems to be my fault and that God is absolved of everything that I cannot even point a finger at Him. She kept asking questions to whether I had put in enough effort and thought into the things that I do and what pissed me off the most was that I could honestly and confidently say that everything that I could do in my power, I did, and literally left the rest to God. I still had a little hope that there might be some faults that I may had overlooked. There are so much uncertainty in life and every single time it turns out badly no matter how much effort and thought I put in. And if I don’t it turns out negatively as well in case some new age quasi-protestant here starts saying that I should let God do all the work.

This is absolutely sickening. I have just returned from atheism not too long ago, but I cannot fathom and ever-loving dad showing such “meanness” or at the very least, nonchalance. I wouldn’t be backsliding into atheism again but I certainly will not be having any good things to say about God. And if an opportunity presents itself to benefit myself through sin, causing maximum offence to God, guess what I will do?

If you look at this post and see it as a child’s rant, your life has been too good and you should have a share of my suffering. See if you can make it redemptive. It’s easy to believe in an omnibenevolent god if your life is good and everything(most) is beautiful.

If I can confirm the non-existence of this deity, or one day am convinced as such, I will not hesitate to end it all right then and there. I did not ask to be born and have no interest in taking up this trash of a life where everything is practically fecal matter. I am not Job and I don’t care when You had created the mighty hippo or the ferocious croc. I didn’t even have the riches of Job in the beginning and I’m not even asking for immense riches, just a break.
 
What has happened in your life to cause so much pain?

Having people in your life that will respect you and give you support is always immensely important and necessary.
 
Last edited:
I read your post a few times so I could really hear your cry for help and the pain you are enduring. You do not need folks suggestions to “fix” your life right now. All I can offer is what transformed my life when I was in despair. I went to eucharistic adoration of the Blessed Sacrament every day I could and prayed the Rosary every day. These two things radically transformed my life. I know prayer may not seem like giving you much but I am fully convinced on the power of prayer. The best thing I can do for you is to pray for you. I am going to pray a Rosary for you right now. May God bless you and heal your wounds.
 
I’m sorry you’re going through these hardships :confused:.

Everything you described is the work of other humans. Not God.

At the same time, we have no way of knowing your “origin story”, the chain of causality, or where the responsibility lies for how things turned out.
 
If you look at this post and see it as a child’s rant, your life has been too good and you should have a share of my suffering.
Please, never presume to know what anyone else’s life is like. That is not logical. There are many people on CAF and in the world that have terrible lives. I, or anyone reading your post could have a terrible Life, and still think you are being childish.

I am sorry your life is difficult. But lashing out at God is not the answer. He is not a vending machine where you put in a prayer and he grants a wish. It sounds like your love for him is very conditional, and it sounds like you are very wrapped up in your pain. Perhaps you can find a way to reach out or help others and it will help you forget your trouble. Post some prayers in the prayer intention section for other people and you may find some peace in your own life.
 
Last edited:
We are created with free will. What happens in this world is mostly the result of evil. Jesus said his kingdom is not of this world.
 
God is not an American father. Or modern western father in any sense.

Hebrews:
{5:8} And although, certainly, he is the Son of God, he learned obedience by the things that he suffered.

Sirach:
{30:1} He who loves his son will frequently chastise him, so that he may be happy in the very end, and not grope for the doors of his neighbors.
{30:8} An untamed horse becomes stubborn, and a child left to himself becomes headstrong.
{30:9} Coddle a son, and he will make you afraid. Play with him, and he will make you sorrowful.
{30:10} You should not laugh with him; otherwise you may have grief, and in the end, your teeth will be clenched.
{30:12} Bow down his neck in his youth, and beat his sides while he is a child, lest perhaps he may become stubborn, and then he will not trust you, and so he will bring sorrow to your soul.

What cultural fatherhood are you talking about, when you say a loving father wouldn’t do xyz?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top