Why no physical component to Catholicism?

  • Thread starter Thread starter St_Francis
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I was watching a video about a non-Catholic Christian minister who went to a kung-fu monastery… anyway, he said he wondered why there was no physical component to Christianity like these monks have, and it reminded me that I have heard this question elsewhere, for instance, in reference to yoga.

Well, I sort of have a feeling that this sort of thing is unnecessary in Catholicism, and a sort of flippant idea that maybe we are too busy helping those in need, but neither of those is a good explanatory answer, so I thought I’d ask while it’s on my mind 🙂

I understand that yoga has these exercises with the goal of emptying one’s mind, which is not what we are supposed to be doing, so that’s a partial answer, but not a full answer to why we don’t do something else.
Bro, do you even Traditional Latin Mass?

Tons of physical signs there to teach us the Faith.
 
I was watching a video about a non-Catholic Christian minister who went to a kung-fu monastery… anyway, he said he wondered why there was no physical component to Christianity like these monks have, and it reminded me that I have heard this question elsewhere, for instance, in reference to yoga.

Well, I sort of have a feeling that this sort of thing is unnecessary in Catholicism, and a sort of flippant idea that maybe we are too busy helping those in need, but neither of those is a good explanatory answer, so I thought I’d ask while it’s on my mind 🙂

I understand that yoga has these exercises with the goal of emptying one’s mind, which is not what we are supposed to be doing, so that’s a partial answer, but not a full answer to why we don’t do something else.
Dear St. Francis,
Code:
 When St. Catherine of Siena  was about 15 years of age, her parents punished her because she wanted to led the life of a religious completely devoted to Christ. Her parents wanted her to get married but she only wanted to be Christ's.  She was made to clean the house and serve her parents and 23 siblings at meal time like one of their servants.  They also wanted to stop her from praying.  So young St. Catherine prayed and the Holy Spirit told her to imagine she was serving the Holy Family, Mary & Joseph & Christ  & the Apostles.  So the punishment became a means of prayer and sanctification.  

 Now if she used this menial labor meant to be a physical punishment,  I am certain that all of us can find a physical component of Christianity.  We just have to pray, wait patiently and in time the Holy Spirit will reveal how God wants to use us.
 
The goal of yoga isn’t merely emptying one’s mind, yoga as an exercise is really a modern/western development. At the heart of it, the goal of yoga is to achieve a state of permanent peace, transcending the spiritual state from the physical state. Its origins vary from teaching liberation of the soul from the body through intense meditation to teaching the concept of a personal god.
Some sequence of poses on yoga are prayers, worshiping or as an homage to the various deities, for instance the “Surya Namaskar” or more popularly known as sun salutation, is in fact a worship/prayer to Surya, the Indian sun deity.

As you can see, the physical component is necessary, even more than necessary, it’s key, it is the key to achieving their goal of a state of permanent peace/transcendence. Without that physical element - there is nothing left.

For us Christians, the main focus is God. The key to God is through Jesus Christ, abiding by God’s word, doing His will as taught to us by His Church. There’s just simply no need of a “physical component” as is needed in what they call spiritual practices like yoga.
On the other hand, as others have pointed out, all of the gestures we do at mass, those are all physical components indeed!
So, do they use the physical practices to generate the feelings of peace and trandscendance?

One person told me that when someone feels fear, there are breathing exercses which will reduce the feeling of fear or slow one’s heartbeat? That’s why I’m asking.
 
So, do they use the physical practices to generate the feelings of peace and trandscendance?

One person told me that when someone feels fear, there are breathing exercses which will reduce the feeling of fear or slow one’s heartbeat? That’s why I’m asking.
You are correct, and there are several types of breathing taught to Nurses and Doctors as well as Therapists to ease several things: fear, anxiety, hyperventilation, rapid heartbeat, difficulty breathing with COPD (does not include asthma – at least not as taught to Nurses), and nervousness. I had to learn all of them in Nursing School. There are even breathing techniques to ease less severe panic attacks, which are similar to the techniques used for fear.

However, fear is also a survival trait. If a big bear is running toward you, I don’t recommend a breathing technique, I recommend climbing a tree, really quick! In such cases, fear is to speed our heart, lungs and reflexes to optimize survival.
 
So, do they use the physical practices to **generate **the feelings of peace and trandscendance?

One person told me that when someone feels fear, there are breathing exercses which will reduce the feeling of fear or slow one’s heartbeat? That’s why I’m asking.
Sort of, but not quite - I think for the real yoga practitioner, it is through the physical practices he/she will **achieve **permanent peace. See how the wording is a bit different, achieve vs. generate. The philosophical/theological ideas behind yoga views peace and transcendence not as feelings but as a state of being, if that makes sense.

And what JudyNurse said :yup::yup:
 
Sort of, but not quite - I think for the real yoga practitioner, it is through the physical practices he/she will **achieve **permanent peace. See how the wording is a bit different, achieve vs. generate. The philosophical/theological ideas behind yoga views peace and transcendence not as feelings but as a state of being, if that makes sense.

And what JudyNurse said :yup::yup:
The breathing practices taught to Nurses have nothing to do with Yoga, but are based upon the physiological responses in the biological body’s responses to different ways of breathing. Try (NOT FOR REAL!!!) breathing really, really fast and you will hyperventilate. That is a physiological response to your rapid breathing and it’s affects on the heart, circulation and brain function. (Don’t try this as you can pass out and fall !!!) Calm, measured, deep breathing is a means of relaxation, and very effective for nervousness, anxiety and some forms of fear – particularly useful for patients afraid in the hospital – afraid of needles, afraid of an x-ray procedure, and even used pre-operatively to reduce fear and anxiety prior to surgery. It’s commonly encouraged by Nurses and by Medical Doctors as a technique for relaxation. I do it when I have problems sleeping due to personal worries and minor aches and pains, and I drift off and sleep like a baby. Never have done Yoga, and at 72 and with arthritis, I’m not about to start, either !! I just use tricks for relaxation to ease the aches and pains and to ease my mind to a place of relaxation for sleep, combined with reciting prayers and sleep soundly at night when I do.

But mostly the prayers, especially the Rosary put me in a place of peace, and at night, combined with the measured, slow deep breathing and prayer, I not only find peace, but a good night’s sleep as well!
 
The breathing practices taught to Nurses have nothing to do with Yoga, but are based upon the physiological responses in the biological body’s responses to different ways of breathing. Try (NOT FOR REAL!!!) breathing really, really fast and you will hyperventilate. That is a physiological response to your rapid breathing and it’s affects on the heart, circulation and brain function. (Don’t try this as you can pass out and fall !!!) Calm, measured, deep breathing is a means of relaxation, and very effective for nervousness, anxiety and some forms of fear – particularly useful for patients afraid in the hospital – afraid of needles, afraid of an x-ray procedure, and even used pre-operatively to reduce fear and anxiety prior to surgery. It’s commonly encouraged by Nurses and by Medical Doctors as a technique for relaxation. I do it when I have problems sleeping due to personal worries and minor aches and pains, and I drift off and sleep like a baby. Never have done Yoga, and at 72 and with arthritis, I’m not about to start, either !! I just use tricks for relaxation to ease the aches and pains and to ease my mind to a place of relaxation for sleep, combined with reciting prayers and sleep soundly at night when I do.

But mostly the prayers, especially the Rosary put me in a place of peace, and at night, combined with the measured, slow deep breathing and prayer, I not only find peace, but a good night’s sleep as well!
Oh yes! I didn’t mean to imply that it had to do with yoga. I’m sorry if it sounded like that.
The breathing techniques as St Francis was asking about are, just like you explained, based on physiology. It doesn’t have anything to do with yoga - but, interestingly (or maybe not so much) the exercise part of yoga has everything to do with physiology of the human body.
 
Oh yes! I didn’t mean to imply that it had to do with yoga. I’m sorry if it sounded like that.
The breathing techniques as St Francis was asking about are, just like you explained, based on physiology. It doesn’t have anything to do with yoga - but, interestingly (or maybe not so much) the exercise part of yoga has everything to do with physiology of the human body.
True — but the end goal is quite different!
 
+JMJ+
I was watching a video about a non-Catholic Christian minister who went to a kung-fu monastery… anyway, he said he wondered why there was no physical component to Christianity like these monks have, and it reminded me that I have heard this question elsewhere, for instance, in reference to yoga.
For a Christian minister to ask this shows his lack of understanding of his faith.

One of the central mysteries of Christianity is the Incarnation, of elevating the ordinary to the divine by having Divinity Himself descend into the ordinary, and we are all called to do the same. Therefore we do not need a physical component of Christianity because Christianity itself insinuates into the physical world through our own lives. Other posters here have noted the physicality of our Christian faith, but our Christian faith also goes into everything else that we do, like sportsmanship in sports, chivalry in our daily lives, etc.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top