"Why say Hail Marys?"

  • Thread starter Thread starter EphelDuath
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
**If anybody has an issue with reciting the words “sinful and sorrowful” when praying the Memorare, then it shows that one really has a warped sense of sin and does not understand the sinful nature he or she has - and refuses to acknowledge it.

Also, Louis de Montfort, by saying that we ‘bind’ ourselves to Mary - if reading him correctly - means that she is our spiritual mother because we belong and are members of Christ’s mystical body on earth. De Montfort means nothing else by this except that all graces come through her through her Son to us.**
This is exactly how I read Louis de Montfort. As was mentioned in an earlier post, prayer is individual. I choose to focus on Christ’s healing grace. This is not a denial of personal responsibility or sinfulness. It is from True Devotion of Mary, that I found the words used during the Little Crown of the Blessed Virgin. “Rejoice, Oh Virgin Mary, Rejoice a thousand times.” Christ has truly risen and he calls us to rejoice in his presence. We find these words in the writings of St. Paul. We also find them in the Old Testament when Ezra told the people to rejoice. The people were sad after the covenant was read to them, and their sins revealed. “Put away your sackcloth for this day is holy unto the Lord.” We should rejoice that our sins have been forgiven. Christ who died for my sins is risen and we are a Resurection people.
I would use the words of Joan of Arc. “I thank God if I am in a state of grace. If I am not in a state of grace, I ask God that I be placed in a state of grace.” When I fail to follow Christ, I rely on the healing power of the Sacrament of Reconciliation to restore me to grace. The statement that I may have a “warped sense” of my own sinfulness is an uncalled for judgment of where I stand before God.
“This is the day the Lord has made. Let us rejoice and be glad in it.”
 
There is only one question I have. What is the point of prayer? If God is immutable, then you can’t possibly think your prayers change God nor His will. So why pray at all? One answer very eloquently given by C.S. Lewis is, “Prayer doesn’t change God. It changes me.”

With that said, then prayer becomes me exercising my Will in such a way that I can grow closer to God. It is an individual expression of faith that will change my disposition and attitude. Thus, if I choose to pray the Rosary and find benefit in it, who has the right or authority to judge that? Jesus’ point about the prattling is very simple: You don’t understand God or prayer if your rattling off a litany of wants and needs, for God is omniscient. If you look at the Rosary, it in no way misunderstands the nature of God. It contains within it the humble admission that we do not sufficiently understand what is truly good for us and thus what we should pray for. Hence, the intercession of Mary makes sense.

Again, it all comes down to what you think prayer can do. If Lewis is right (which I think he is), then prayers are private and personal and you have no objective basis for judging them one way or the other.
Well put. God is unchangable. Prayer is about personal growth in our relationship to God and each other. If I do not pray, how am I to discern God’s will for my life?
 
**Again, I haven’t read all the posts, so I wouldn’t know if anyone has pointed out that many non-Catholic Christians ask fellow Christians to pray for them when in need - commonly called a ‘prayer chain’ (while claiming that no intermediary is necessary to begin with)…

& although I don’t know the ancient Greek terminology for this practiced tradition of some of our Christian brethren, or exactly where this precise term is located in the Bible, I wonder why a mere creation would be approached to pray on one’s behalf, if the mother of Christ, blessed among women & not just picked at random, is apparently often passed by.**
 
A quote from St. Alphonsus Delaguarie’s treatise (The Glories of Mary - published by the Catholic Book Publishing Company of New York and officially stamped by the Vicar General, the Archdiocese of New York, 1745 - contains quotes about Mary fromthe 5th century up until that time).

“Every prayer of Mary’s is like an established law for our Lord.’

I guess she establishes the law by which God acts :confused:

Further, “Every prayer of Mary’s is like an established law for our Lord, obliging Him to be merciful to everyone for whom she intercedes.”

It seems that God has to do what Mary asks Him to do, that’s His obligation. She sets the law for God. Is this scriptural?
)
**The quote that St. Alphonsus Liguori writes is that every prayer that our spiritual mother prays for us is like an established law for our God. It doesn’t say it is an established ‘law’ for our God. And what is that ‘law’? It isn’t a ‘law’ per se, but that God is merciful to us and slow to anger. That is a unique quality of God Who is unlike false gods whose main response is punishment and retribution.

What is scriptural is Mary’s intercession - most prominently at the wedding feast of Cana where she encouraged her Son to begin His divine Ministry on earth. Also, in the Old Testament, the Davidic Kingdom has the queen mother interceding for her subjects to the King. **
 
With all do respect, I think you need to reread the posts. You seem to be asking me a type of “when did you stop beating your wife” question.
With all due respect to you: Please re-read my post.

If I’m not correct on what the problem is that you have with the Hail Mary, or the recitation of the Rosary, please state what that problem is.

This conversation has been a long one and the reason for much of it’s length is someone (you) stating that there is a reason NOT to say the Hail Mary or to recite the Rosary.

If what I think is your reason is incorrect, then state what the reason is, and maybe we can move on.

Merry Christmas:p
 
With all due respect to you: Please re-read my post.

If I’m not correct on what the problem is that you have with the Hail Mary, or the recitation of the Rosary, please state what that problem is.

This conversation has been a long one and the reason for much of it’s length is someone (you) stating that there is a reason NOT to say the Hail Mary or to recite the Rosary.

If what I think is your reason is incorrect, then state what the reason is, and maybe we can move on.

Merry Christmas:p
Well, if I may, Ginger, like most Protestants, have ‘respect’ for Mary as the Mother of God, but that is as far as it goes.

They protest (“Protestants”) that devotion to Mary takes them away from Jesus.

This is pure nonesense, of course, Jesus gave us Mary at the Cross. She is not a distraction, and takes nothing from our worship of Jesus. It is just another thing to complain about.

Funny, Protestants never say they ‘worship’ Jesus either. They pray to the Father in his Name, but ‘worship’ Jesus? - I just don’t hear it from them. Maybe in His humanity, they don’t see his Divinity.

We say, we worship Him, we glorify Him, we adore Him. That being so, how does Mary distract us from Jesus Christ, our Lord and Redeemer. How come they never say that? - that they worship Him, they adore Him, they glorify Him.

Let’s hear it for Jesus!

Per Mariam ad Jesum - To Jesus through Mary.

peace
 
If your question is not rhetorical and you are asking what problem Protestants have witht hte rosary,

The answer is a ratio of about Ten Hail Mary’s to one Our Father.

I personally have a problem any time more attention and time is given to a created being over God.

As for meditating on the Gospels or any other Scriptures, I can do that while reading them and praying before, after and ocassionally in the middle of my reading.
Then go ahead, do what pleases YOU. We have billions of people in this world doing just what They want. But don’t forget, the Blessed Mother said at Fatima, in 1917 to PRAY the Rosary every day for the conversion of sinners. Now by golly if God sent Jesus’ Mother to tell us that, than who are we to argue with God. If you don’t think the events in Fatima ever really happened then get yourself a copy of the local newspaper. I think its called O’Secular, that was printed on that day, Oct. 13, 1917. Even if you can’t read it, the pictures are worth 1,000 words. I have seen a copy of it.
There is a big difference in PRAYING the Rosary and just rattling off words. How it actually got started is not the important thing, how we say it is and why we say it.
We just celebrated the 150 Ann. of Lourdes, France where the Blessed Mother appeared to Bernadette and told her to pray the Rosary. Do you believe in miracles?? Go there and see for yourself what its all about. Protestants don’t even know what they are missing. If they spent half as much time looking into these things sincerely, instead of bashing Catholics, they’d be a whole lot better off. And so would we !!!
 
Then go ahead, do what pleases YOU. We have billions of people in this world doing just what They want. But don’t forget, the Blessed Mother said at Fatima, in 1917 to PRAY the Rosary every day for the conversion of sinners. Now by golly if God sent Jesus’ Mother to tell us that, than who are we to argue with God. If you don’t think the events in Fatima ever really happened then get yourself a copy of the local newspaper. I think its called O’Secular, that was printed on that day, Oct. 13, 1917. Even if you can’t read it, the pictures are worth 1,000 words. I have seen a copy of it.
There is a big difference in PRAYING the Rosary and just rattling off words. How it actually got started is not the important thing, how we say it is and why we say it.
We just celebrated the 150 Ann. of Lourdes, France where the Blessed Mother appeared to Bernadette and told her to pray the Rosary. Do you believe in miracles?? Go there and see for yourself what its all about. Protestants don’t even know what they are missing. If they spent half as much time looking into these things sincerely, instead of bashing Catholics, they’d be a whole lot better off. And so would we !!!
Excellent response. Ginger ‘left the building’ about two months cause of all our all too “judgemental, self-righteous, and moral superior attitude”. That came after her 'Mary Magdalene" moment. But prayer thrumps carousing any time.

peace
 
Excellent response. Ginger ‘left the building’ about two months cause of all our all too “judgemental, self-righteous, and moral superior attitude”. That came after her 'Mary Magdalene" moment. But prayer thrumps carousing any time.

peace
Sorry I missed her but maybe she will be back, even if just out of curiosity. Lets keep her in our prayers.
 
What?:confused: I don’t think you’ve read through the posts. I’ve been defending prayer to Mary for 3 days. I’m not sure “Marian Worship” is the term you want to be using to describe those things (honor, veneration, prayer, praise). Our Protestant brothers and sisters have a hard enough time understanding why we pray to Mary let alone having to explain your defenition of “Marian Worship”. I can’t say I’ve ever heard that title given to the way we honor Mary, atleast not by another Catholic. I definitely would rather not call it Marian worship.😉

SD
All self respecting Catholics know the difference between their Worship of God, (The Blessed Trinity) and their devotion to Mary. Its the non-catholics that have a problem with it and thats because they have made up their mind what we believe and nothing we can say will make a difference to them. I have a collection of Blessed Mother vases and my son made some shelves over my windows in order to display them and I have a protestant friend that just can’t understand why I have sooooo many. I think shes almost afraid to come into my house. but she has a collection of antique stuff and I told her I would rather look at something that reminds me of Our Lord and HIS Mother than old junk. I was trying to be funny but I don’t think she liked it very well.
 
If your question is not rhetorical and you are asking what problem Protestants have with the rosary,

The answer is a ratio of about Ten Hail Mary’s to one Our Father.

I personally have a problem any time more attention and time is given to a created being over God.

As for meditating on the Gospels or any other Scriptures, I can do that while reading them and praying before, after and ocassionally in the middle of my reading.
Some protestants maybe do not understand the Rosary, but lots of them are starting to say it. You can say the Rosary anytime, anywhere. It doesn’t compete with the Gospels but compliments them. We do create problems for ourselves sometimes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top