Why teach people about sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter QuasiCatholic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This is my understanding of mortal sin… and possibly I am wrong.

Mortal sin is that which can kill our soul. God can allow us to go to Hell for all eternity based on dying with one mortal sin on our soul.
Not “can.” “Does.” Guaranteed.
When we commit a mortal sin, we need to receive the Sacrament of Confession to cleanse our souls and rejoin ourselves to God.
This is correct, yes. In the Sacrament of Reconciliation, when we make a good Confession, naming all the mortal sins we can remember, our dead souls are resurrected, and our mortal sins are forgiven.
Venial sins can be forgiven through the graces of Mass. We can also approach the Sacrament of Confession for our venial sins. This gives us much graces which in turns helps us stay in a State of Grace.
Again, correct.
My “non-theological thought” is that there will be people who died having committed mortal sin and not been to the Sacrament of Confession before death. I believe some of these people will be in Heaven after time in Purgatory.
This is impossible.
How will this happen… I don’t know. Does God allow everyone to make a perfect act of contrition before they die… including those who experience an accident with “instant death”? Does God allow the person to make a perfect act of contrition - just as the soul is leaving the body? I don’t know.
If so, then the person no longer has mortal sin on their soul. Right? Since Perfect Contrition at the moment of death supplies the place of the Sacrament of Reconciliation, and allows the person to be revived from the death of their soul, and forgiven of all their sins.
We can look at lists and see what sins fall under Mortal Sin. However, its not so black and white. Sin X appears under Mortal Sin, but then there are the other parts of defining mortal sin.
The heading should actually be “grave sin” since a person doing them unknowingly, or because of irresistible pressure, would not be guilty of mortal sin.
CCC 1857 For a sin to be mortal, three conditions must together be met: “Mortal sin is sin whose object is grave matter and which is also committed with full knowledge and deliberate consent.”
For the person who knew Sin X is mortal, and knew they were doing Sin X, and decided to do it even though it is a mortal sin… are they in mortal sin?
At that moment, yes. They need to go to Confession.
They plan to go to confession. They always strive to remain in a State of Grace. They know they will be at Mass on Sunday. They know they always want to receive Holy Communion and can not while in the State of Mortal Sin. They know they will seek the Sacrament of Confession before they go to Mass and Holy Communion.
And if they do so, then their sins will be wiped away.
Another person slacks on their Sunday Obligation. They know they are suppose to attend Mass, but they “feel God understands” I needed to buy groceries, etc. They marry outside the Church because “God understands and I’ll have it convalidated later”. It highly appears to be mortal sin… but since they “think” God understands… maybe they don’t have full knowledge. Are they in a State of Mortal Sin since they don’t have full knowledge as evidence by “God understands”? If they died today, would God allow them the full knowledge to now know they were in a state of mortal sin and allow them to express their Perfect Contrition?
I would say that this person is committing the sin of presumption (he assumes he knows better than God’s Church what God thinks) and that he is gambling with his immortal soul. He may or may not be “canonized” at his funeral for having the best of intentions, but in reality it is God who decides whether he had sufficient knowledge to realize he needed to do better than that.
We should all form our conscience as best as we can - learning what offends God - avoiding all sins - venial and mortal. We should frequent the graces of the Sacraments of Holy Communion and Confession. We should keep our souls free of Mortal Sin.
Absolutely. 👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top