Why the Resurrection and the Immortal Soul at the Same Time?

  • Thread starter Thread starter newenglandsun
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
N

newenglandsun

Guest
Hi, in my philosophy of religion class this week, we are talking about religion and death and the topic of the immortal soul in Christianity comes up and one question raised was if the soul is immortal then what is the point of Jesus’s resurrection?

I’m wondering this. Could someone help?
 
Hi, in my philosophy of religion class this week, we are talking about religion and death and the topic of the immortal soul in Christianity comes up and one question raised was if the soul is immortal then what is the point of Jesus’s resurrection?

I’m wondering this. Could someone help?
You are a human being, soul and body.

If there were no immortal soul (which contains your mind), the restored body would not be you, as it would have a blank brain in its new head.

Your soul is the life, but needs a body to hold and express the life. The soul makes you “you,” but it requires a human body to “be you.”

“You” can “be” only as a human BEING with a human BODY!

If our LORD had not risen from death bodily, He would not have had power over death and no hope would exist for death-bound human beings. HIS BODILY rising affirms that He has power to restore embodiedness to us after we have suffered death. Spiritual body; pneumatikon soma.

ICXC NIKA!
 
The purpose of the Resurrection was to have the ability to prepare our souls for Heaven. Prior to Christ’s sacrifice, the souls of the faithful departed did not have access to Heaven, they internally sat in a place for the repose of souls that was not Hell, but also not Heaven. Then, the Resurrection opened the gates of Heaven, thus allowing entry way for immortal souls to be in the full presence of God.

The very fact that our souls are immortal is the whole reason for the Resurrection. I can’t really fathom the argument that the soul’s immortality negates the effectiveness of the Resurrection, as the soul is redeemed by it.
 
Hi, in my philosophy of religion class this week, we are talking about religion and death and the topic of the immortal soul in Christianity comes up and one question raised was if the soul is immortal then what is the point of Jesus’s resurrection?

I’m wondering this. Could someone help?
Human soul is immortal. It is from God, and if the sin of disobediece had not been commited by first man and his wife, it had to end to God for all eternity. But because of this sin, human soul must live eternally even after a mere death (separation of body and soul) but either back to its Creator (expressed by notions like “heaven” “eternal peace” “perfection” “supreme good” etc), or prohibited from reuniting its Creator (expressed by notions like “hell” “eternal fire” etc).

However, to Christians, the possibility of overcoming a committed sin is in the faith that Christ died and resurrected. The point that you are asking is that, in order for the hereditary sin committed by Adam and Eve to be forgiven a sacrifice was to be offered. This is the way that Jesus Himself chose to be the price. This sacrifice was to immitate the Semitic (Jewish in particular) understanding of sacrifeces of which lambs and other cattle seemed appropriate. Jesus chose Himself as the Lamb of Sacrifice to pay the price for reconcilliation of man to his Creator. Therefore He had to die.

But his death could have meant nothing if He hadn’t rise. It could have become very hard to make it understandable this much while He was treated as a mere stuborn person, legally charged guilty and was sentenced to die. Just a mere scene!
But it was not that way. Yes, He died under natural law, which up to now says less about the real intention.

His Resurrection changed everything. What was thought to have been a mere scene is no longer so, but a long founded plan, foretold by prophets who lived more than 500 years before the very scene. It was not a mere death! The Lamb was slain already, but in order to make it clear that it was not a slain for nothing, He rose in glory and was witnessed by all whom He chose and were strengthened to make these things understood by other peoples. Faith in these Mysterious Scenes and leading a non-contradictory life leads to Justification. And as one is baptised, it meas he/she essentially believe in these scenes as true and sacrificial for reconcilliation. (In your time refer to the Catholic Creed).

This means that the Resurrection of Jesus was the peak of the reconcilliation process. This reconcilliation is that which gives a chance to the **immortal soul **to taste eternity back with its Creator which is referred to as Heaven. Therefore the effect of Jesus’ Resurrection is to bring about a possibility of eternal peace which was lost by sin.
 
The word “resurrection” comes from the Greek word anastasis, and it means “to stand up again.” It refers to the reanimation of the corporeal (physical) body with life, but it is not applicable to the immortal soul.

The soul is not corporeal, and thus the word “resurrection” cannot be applied to it. That which does not die and has no means of “standing up” cannot be “resurrected.”

On Judgment Day God will resurrect all humans in bodily form, “those who have done good deeds to the resurrection of life, but those who have done wicked deeds to the resurrection of condemnation.” (John 5:28, 29.) This reanimation of the corporeal body will be by means of returning one’s soul to a newly resurrected physical human form.

Many people mistakenly use the term “resurrection” to explain entry to heavenly life after one’s death. This is incorrect as it refers to the raising of the human body in a resurrection, like Christ’s for those who have been judged worthy of eternal life with God.
 
This would imply God changed his mind or changed in some way, in that he decided instead of having souls sitting in neutral place, not heaven or hell, he would be crucified and rise to save all of us. However it is said many times in the bible, God will never change and always be the same, to me it sounds like he did change his mind on where souls go after death, meaning he must have had a change of heart or mind…right???
 
This would imply God changed his mind or changed in some way, in that he decided instead of having souls sitting in neutral place, not heaven or hell, he would be crucified and rise to save all of us. However it is said many times in the bible, God will never change and always be the same, to me it sounds like he did change his mind on where souls go after death, meaning he must have had a change of heart or mind…right???
God is perfect and no change at all. What has been fulfilled in about 33 AD was the fulfillment of the promise God mentioned as He was condemning the Serpent (Satan) as per Gen. 3:15. It is his plan which was to be fulfilled as the fullness of time came.
 
This would imply God changed his mind or changed in some way, in that he decided instead of having souls sitting in neutral place, not heaven or hell, he would be crucified and rise to save all of us. However it is said many times in the bible, God will never change and always be the same, to me it sounds like he did change his mind on where souls go after death, meaning he must have had a change of heart or mind…right???
God does not exist in our realm governed by the laws of time and space. God is the author of time, and therefore his actions, while seen as affecting our history, have always been a part of God’s existence in eternity.

Everything God is and God does has been and always will be. Our mundane experience places it in the timeline of history on the Cross in 33 A.D., but it has been God’s eternal purpose before the foundation of the world and before the creation of time and space. God could foresee what would be required for the history of those with free will to play out according to his purpose because God transcends the boundaries of time.

Therefore God never changed his mind. God only chose to reveal his purpose so it would unfold one page at a time as history played out. What happens in history was already decided before time existed and could even say goodbye to its first second.
 
God does not exist in our realm governed by the laws of time and space. God is the author of time, and therefore his actions, while seen as affecting our history, have always been a part of God’s existence in eternity.

Everything God is and God does has been and always will be. Our mundane experience places it in the timeline of history on the Cross in 33 A.D., but it has been God’s eternal purpose before the foundation of the world and before the creation of time and space. God could foresee what would be required for the history of those with free will to play out according to his purpose because God transcends the boundaries of time.

Therefore God never changed his mind. God only chose to reveal his purpose so it would unfold one page at a time as history played out. What happens in history was already decided before time existed and could even say goodbye to its first second.
Thank you for explaining that, it makes perfect sense to me now. I had never thought about it like that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top