Why wouldn't a true Protestant become Catholic?

  • Thread starter Thread starter mtnmikeblue
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Ive been thinking. If a True protestant were really connected and communing with the One True God. If they were Truly in a relationship with Jesus Christ.Then wouldn’t it follow that they would convert to Catholicism when presented with the truth of the Catholic Church?
How could anybody who knows God reject the True Church of God (Catholic Church) when faced with its doctrines of truth?
I mean when really presented with the doctrines of truth, presented in love by someone they know, one who is reputable. And they still reject the Catholic Church? How can this be?
Wouldn’t it be like when Christ came to the Jews and they rejected Him and said “we have God as our Father.”
I am afraid the problem is a little more implicit than that. The main reason for the Reformation was based on a complete misunderstanding of the doctrine “justification by faith”. (Of course, it was sparked by the selling of indulgences; but its abuse does not negate its truth) Luther rightly stated that the root planted (salvation by faith and not works) is what lets us receive the grace God has generously given. But he wrongly assumed this was all we need. Salvation in a smaller sense and faith in a bigger sense. (Ephesians chapter 2; This is the Catholic’s sanctifying grace, I think) Catholics also wrongly assumed he was wrong. But the Catholic view had another meaning: salvation in a bigger sense and faith in a smaller one. We mean salvation as getting to heaven. Faith leads to hope leads to love (good works). You know faith by its fruit (good works). (James chapter 2 deals with this) They are both right but unfortunately Catholics nor Protestants have no idea of this misunderstanding. I think this would be a good catalyst (if there is such a thing) to unite with our “separated brethren” without any compromise of doctrine. Protestants have no doctrine against praying to Mary, the saints and angels. They just think it idolatry but do not look into its Truth. Baptism, Eucharist, Sacraments in general, sacramentals, etc… These can be worked out once the understaing is there because these are all in the Bible, explicitly (such as Baptism IS “FOR THE FORGIVENESS OF SINS”!) or implicitly (Institution of the Eucharist).

sorry about the all caps deal. That is the ONLY thing I do not understand why Protestants do not believe that. That is clearly stated. A reunion is simply but not easy.

About the Anabaptist thing. Yes, it was a bad thing what the PEOPLE of the Catholic Church did. They never should have done that. This method is never condoned by the Catholic Church, only by some idiots inside. It goes against its faith and morals. People were, are and always will be sinners here on Earth, from atheism to Christianity; from idiot to genius; from the laity to the pope. I am sorry for their losses and what we as Catholics did. “Forgive us our trespasses as we forgive those who trespass against us.” That was the whole point of the apology. We want forgiveness. As believers in the Jesus’ words, we are surely doomed to hell if we cannot forgive other’s sins because Father Almighty will not forgive us if we do not forgive. If we pray this prayer, we are also dooming ourselves if we do not follow it. Anyway, the fact that this happened does not negate its heretical tendencies. For one, they teach that the Old Testament is useless or irrelevant. It clearly is not useless nor irrelevant. Jesus came to fulfill the law, not abolish it, which is exactly what the Anabaptists tried to do. If one believes differently than an orthodox (unless this is the modern one; I forget which) Anabaptist in this, then we have more denominations. They also believe infant Baptism is an abomination which the Bible never says, implicitly or explicitly.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top