Good points I thought, worth pondering. Re the Carmelite habit, it has always really stuck in my mind that St. Teresa of Avila wrote “whose (Our Lady) habit I unworthily wear”.
I think there is room for all in The Church “in My Father’s House there are many mansions, I go to prepare a place for you”.
If nuns wish to wear secular clothing - that’s fine. If they wish to wear a religious habit, that’s fine to me too. If they wish to form a community of members that can choose what to wear, then that is ok with me too. If nuns wish to modernize, ok. If nuns wish to return to traditional religious life as it was pre VII and with our without Latin, or even a bit of this and a bit of that, that’s ok with me too. It is never about what one wears, but who one is when one wears what one wears. I do know that “if The Lord does not build the city, in vain does the watchman keep vigil, in vain is your going to sleep early, early to rise, when He blesses His beloved as she sleeps”…what is not of God just will simply fade away.
However, I think if Rome or one’s Bishop, any validly appointed authority, makes some sort of ruling, then that is law to me…and that is fine with me too. For myself, I would only ask “How high, please”? Now that can either be me washing my hands of my responsibility and accountability and putting the burden of decision elsewhere and all that goes with it and being very happy about it …or it can be a virtue with sound and mature spiritual motivation. Perhaps with me, sometimes this sometimes…the ideal to be always that!
Obedience can be a virtue or it could be an escape, and as a virtue it can fuse the common bond making for unity…obedience means authority somewhere and St. Paul said “all authority comes from God”. Be all that as it may, authority or leadership also has responsibilities having received its authority from God and needs to recognize it is “the servant of the servants” and called to serve. Authority or leadership needs to be able to listen…to have ears that can hear and on a few levels…and in a human sense, it needs to be able to hear what another voice may be actually saying, and often to do this, it needs to ask. The Holy Spirit is absolutely all embracingly inclusive…and not at all snobbish, nor bigotted, nor selective. I feel that the more I am all embracingly inclusive and not at all snobbish, biggoted nor selective (common sense dictates. St. Albert “common sense is the guide of all the virtues”), then I am in a better position, Grace present, to hear on a spiritual level The Holy Spirit and in whatever way He chooses to speak for His good reasons…the gentle breeze, or the mighty wind.
I think change must come, because it is impossible to grow without change. Be that as it may, change is not necessarily good/positive growth in the direction of God’s Will. When I look at a rosebud that is later the rose…the essence of the matter is that I have noted change and growth from one appearance to another…and all along the process the essence is that it has been changing.
The answer?..the journey continues… and on we go and hopefully will love, respect and care for each other and all - and with ears that can hear…and The Will of God most often is an unfolding matter in our path and will endure.
My personal hope is to see the world indeed flooded with as many religious habits as we nowadays see the Islamic veil. When I see a women in an Islamic veil it reminds me of the presence of the Islamic religion in our midst…it speaks without a word. I dont know, perhaps God has something else in mind “My Ways are not your ways”. All too often we make an objective of what we think is God’s Will and then work towards that.
I dunno, perhaps we seculars need some item of clothing or a type of clothing itself that speaks without saying a word that Catholic Christianity is now present…but then I think, we would sure have to be prepared to live up to that, for it would sure speak loudly.
Just my really little lay person take…Blessings all…Barb
