Words of consecration in TLM - aloud or silent?

  • Thread starter Thread starter chevalier
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

chevalier

Guest
As per title. I’ve come across both practices and I’m wondering where the difference is from. I doubt it’s up to the priest per se, so is it different between missals or high/low mass or…?
 
chevalier said:
As per title. I’ve come across both practices and I’m wondering where the difference is from. I doubt it’s up to the priest per se, so is it different between missals or high/low mass or…?
Click to expand...
In all TLM Masses (high or low), they are to be said secretly - pronounced but audible to the priest only.
 
AJV said:
In all TLM Masses (high or low), they are to be said secretly - pronounced but audible to the priest only.
Click to expand...
Strange… so how come my grandmother remembers hearing the priest distinctly pronouncing “hoc est enim corpus Meum”, each word separately and after a pause, some time between WWII and the Council? Did it change during that time?
 
chevalier said:
Strange… so how come my grandmother remembers hearing the priest distinctly pronouncing “hoc est enim corpus Meum”, each word separately and after a pause, some time between WWII and the Council? Did it change during that time?
Click to expand...
The 1967 document Tres Abhinc Annos gave permission to say the Canon aloud. I’m not sure between WW II and the Council- maybe her parish was experimenting or something? the only time the Canon was said aloud was at ordination Masses.
 
Strange… so how come my grandmother remembers hearing the priest distinctly pronouncing “hoc est enim corpus Meum”, each word separately and after a pause, some time between WWII and the Council? Did it change during that time?
Click to expand...
It did not. Her recollection is not accurate. Happens all the time.
 
AJV said:
The 1967 document Tres Abhinc Annos gave permission to say the Canon aloud. I’m not sure between WW II and the Council- maybe her parish was experimenting or something? the only time the Canon was said aloud was at ordination Masses.
Click to expand...
That explains something I’ve been wondering about then - I thought ArchBishop Burke said the consecration audibly at the ordinations of the ICKSP here in St. Louis this summer.

DustinsDad
 
That explains something I’ve been wondering about then - I thought ArchBishop Burke said the consecration audibly at the ordinations of the ICKSP here in St. Louis this summer.
Click to expand...
Not sure I understand. The change came about in October, 1967. Abp. Burke celebrates for ICR according to the 1962 missal, which includes a silent canon. :confused:
 
Chatter163 said:
Not sure I understand. The change came about in October, 1967. Abp. Burke celebrates for ICR according to the 1962 missal, which includes a silent canon. :confused:
Click to expand...
Then I’m confused too. Maybe someone else was there that heard differently. I could be wrong.

DustinsDad
 
Chatter163 said:
Not sure I understand. The change came about in October, 1967. Abp. Burke celebrates for ICR according to the 1962 missal, which includes a silent canon. :confused:
Click to expand...
He was mentioning for the ordinations of priests, no? Wasn’t that is allowed under the rubrics of the Pontifical, even the 1962?
 
Chatter163 said:
Not sure I understand. The change came about in October, 1967. Abp. Burke celebrates for ICR according to the 1962 missal, which includes a silent canon. :confused:
Click to expand...
He was mentioning for the ordinations of priests, no? Wasn’t that is allowed under the rubrics of the 1961 Pontifical?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top