13 yo questioning animal vs. human abilities

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lots2Learn
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

Lots2Learn

Guest
My 13 year old voiced a concern about the differences between man and animal. She thinks that God has lessened our senses so that we are dependant on Him. She thinks it’s ‘kinda mean, really.’ I know I have seen this discussed somewhere, but I can’t find it on the forums.
 
The Eastern fathers teach that this is PRECISELY correct. But your teenager misses the point.

The “garments of skin” with which God clothed Adam and Eve were a change in their physical senses to keep them from instant access to demons.

This was not done for meanness, but was for their own protection.
 
To say nothing of skin holding all our organs in and protecting the inner workings of the body from physical damage. Gotta keep those demons out.

Humans have big brains, we can think and reason. Dogs for example have a strong sense of smell to hunt food, in the wild they’re completely dependent on it. We are not.
 
Reminds me of a quote from Mark Twain.

“I have been studying the traits and dispositions of the “lower animals” (so called) and contrasting them with the traits and dispositions of man. I find the results humiliating to me.”

It’s true we humans are physically inferior, with the exception perhaps of opposable thumbs, but we compensate for it with our mental capacity. I think of it more like comparing different people. My friend is a self-proclaimed flop and music and art, but makes up for it by being an absolute genius at math and science. There are many roles to be filled on this stage of life, and every creature and person is given different traits and qualities so as to fill them as He sees fit.
 
My 13 year old voiced a concern about the differences between man and animal. She thinks that God has lessened our senses so that we are dependant on Him. She thinks it’s ‘kinda mean, really.’ I know I have seen this discussed somewhere, but I can’t find it on the forums.
im sure a biologist can explain the evolutionary advantage to devoting the physical resources of the brain to a higher intelligence instead of more sensory processing, but i think its clear from the fact that said intelligence is a much more poweful tool for survival than strengthening any particular sense would be.

im more concerned with this phrase ‘kinda mean, really.’

that should be nipped in the bud, G-d doesnt do anything to be mean, we may not understand how something benefits us, but G-d is not mean. the problem of course is that when she gets older she will be exposed to atheists whose primary argument is the Problem of Evil, that a perfect G-d is responsible for the evil in the world, its practically taught in university any more. the refutation to the Problem of Evil, that its really a lack of information on our part is rather technical for a girl that age. so allowing the idea at all that G-d might be mean will be quite dangerous in just a few years.
 
im more concerned with this phrase ‘kinda mean, really.’

that should be nipped in the bud…
Nipped in the bud? Do you believe that the OP should demean his/her daughter’s ability to work things out for herself? Give her all the information, let her make up her own mind. 13 is not too young for someone to think these things through intelligently and form a rational conclusion.
the problem of course is that when she gets older she will be exposed to atheists whose primary argument is the Problem of Evil, that a perfect G-d is responsible for the evil in the world, its practically taught in university any more.
You have a very unrealistic view of atheists.
the refutation to the Problem of Evil, that its really a lack of information on our part is rather technical for a girl that age.
Not at all. You are underestimating this girl. Do you believe indoctrination is a good thing?
so allowing the idea at all that G-d might be mean will be quite dangerous in just a few years.
I would suggest that attempting to bend a thirteen-year-old to one’s will is significantly more so.

The lack of respect for one’s children is something that, judging by some of the posts I’ve seen on this forum, is rife amongst catholics (I suspect it’s not just catholics to be fair). I find that incredibly sad.
 
Nipped in the bud? Do you believe that the OP should demean his/her daughter’s ability to work things out for herself? Give her all the information, let her make up her own mind. 13 is not too young for someone to think these things through intelligently and form a rational conclusion.
i dont think its demeaning at all to tell the child the truth, in fact that is a parents responsibilities. i have raised 2 children in that age range, and i dont think that most children have the education necessary at that point to rationally examine the issue.

though through the use of the words, “demean”, i see you have no problem using the loaded langauge fallacy, typical.
You have a very unrealistic view of atheists.
i am personally familiar with a number of atheists, i was one as a young man myself also, and i continue to monitor the community of atheist in general, i think i have a pretty firm grasp of the realities of atheism. you may disagree.
Not at all. You are underestimating this girl.
maybe she is a savant, i dont know.
Do you believe indoctrination is a good thing?I would suggest that attempting to bend a thirteen-year-old to one’s will is significantly more so.
a child shouldnt be allowed to exercise their will in all matters, faith is one of them.

though again with the word “indoctrination” is the fallacy of loaded language.
The lack of respect for one’s children is something that, judging by some of the posts I’ve seen on this forum, is rife amongst catholics (I suspect it’s not just catholics to be fair). I find that incredibly sad.
they need guidance until they are sufficiently educated and mature to make good judgments. until then they are much too vulnerable to untoward influences.
 
i dont think its demeaning at all to tell the child the truth, in fact that is a parents responsibilities.
Apart from the fact that there is no evidence that it is the truth. And if it is the truth, then shouldn’t you trust the child to be able to arrive at it independently? If it’s so obvious, what do you have to worry about?
i have raised 2 children in that age range, and i dont think that most children have the education necessary at that point to rationally examine the issue.
It’s not about education, it’s about intelligence, a questioning mind. If she’s asking those sorts of questions then she’s ready to find out for herself. YOU are trying to stop her from thinking for herself.
though through the use of the words, “demean”, i see you have no problem using the loaded langauge fallacy, typical.
I have no idea what you’re talking about. My phrasing was not loaded in the slightest. If you wish to stop this girl asking questions, ‘nip it in the bud’ in your own words, then you are demeaning her ability to ask the right questions.
i am personally familiar with a number of atheists, i was one as a young man myself also, and i continue to monitor the community of atheist in general, i think i have a pretty firm grasp of the realities of atheism. you may disagree.
Yes, I do. I don’t know any atheists, nor have I seen posts from any on this forum, that advocate a, “God must not exist if there’s evil in the world” position. There are far stronger atheistic positions. You are out of touch.
maybe she is a savant, i dont know.
You don’t think the OP might have mentioned it? But either way, using that as a defence now shows a belated realisation on your part that you have not done this girl justice, you have just judged and ruled.
a child shouldnt be allowed to exercise their will in all matters, faith is one of them.
Why not? What you seem to be advocating is ‘forced faith.’ Which is an oxymoron, and sounds like a recommendation for brain-washing.
though again with the word “indoctrination” is the fallacy of loaded language.
in⋅doc⋅tri⋅nate

/ɪnˈdɒkhttp://cache.lexico.com/dictionary/graphics/luna/thinsp.pngtrəˌneɪt/http://ask.reference.com/web?q=Use+indoctrination+in+a+Sentence&qsrc=2892&o=101993

–verb (used with object), -nat⋅ed, -nat⋅ing. 1. to instruct in a doctrine, principle, ideology, etc., esp. to imbue with a specific partisan or biased belief or point of view.

Indoctrination is exactly what you’re talking about. But even if my language was loaded (which it isn’t), that does not make it fallacious.
they need guidance until they are sufficiently educated and mature to make good judgments. until then they are much too vulnerable to untoward influences.
You are not recommending guidance, you are recommending thought policing. And you are doing it without the slightest consideration for the individual in question.
 
Apart from the fact that there is no evidence that it is the truth. And if it is the truth, then shouldn’t you trust the child to be able to arrive at it independently? If it’s so obvious, what do you have to worry about?It’s not about education, it’s about intelligence, a questioning mind. If she’s asking those sorts of questions then she’s ready to find out for herself. YOU are trying to stop her from thinking for herself.I have no idea what you’re talking about. My phrasing was not loaded in the slightest. If you wish to stop this girl asking questions, ‘nip it in the bud’ in your own words, then you are demeaning her ability to ask the right questions. Yes, I do. I don’t know any atheists, nor have I seen posts from any on this forum, that advocate a, “God must not exist if there’s evil in the world” position. There are far stronger atheistic positions. You are out of touch.You don’t think the OP might have mentioned it? But either way, using that as a defence now shows a belated realisation on your part that you have not done this girl justice, you have just judged and ruled.Why not? What you seem to be advocating is ‘forced faith.’ Which is an oxymoron, and sounds like a recommendation for brain-washing.

Indoctrination is exactly what you’re talking about. But even if my language was loaded (which it isn’t), that does not make it fallacious.You are not recommending guidance, you are recommending thought policing. And you are doing it without the slightest consideration for the individual in question.
I think you’re being a little unfair here. We don’t allow kids to go out and try heroin do we? There is a lot that we try to teach kids and “indoctrinate” them with to try and help them. Even in the case of religion, I think the intentions are good at least. Don’t be so hard on parents trying to help their children learn and grow.

That said, I do think the parent should entertain such questions as best they can, and not put any negative aspects towards asking questions and thinking critically about the topic. Good parenting involves guidance and understanding, not manipulation or force. Well… at least not too much of the latter… sometimes… well, they deserve it. 😉
 
I think you’re being a little unfair here. We don’t allow kids to go out and try heroin do we? There is a lot that we try to teach kids and “indoctrinate” them with to try and help them. Even in the case of religion, I think the intentions are good at least. Don’t be so hard on parents trying to help their children learn and grow.
I don’t think the heroin comparison stacks up unless you’re extrapolating my comments to an illogical conclusion. I’m not advocating that we let children engage in life-threatening activites to ‘learn for themselves’ whether or not they’re going to die. I’m advocating that they are *allowed *to question dogma and accepted wisdom, and take their own steps to lead themselves to a conclusion that they feel confident and happy with. Nothing more.

I don’t think wsp is advocating letting the child ‘learn’ at all, other than to ‘learn’ a one-sided perspective with no access to alternative POVs. In my opinion this is the opposite of true learning.

If my language and phrasing was a little harsh, I apologise; this is something that I feel strongly about. Not enough people truly give their children room to grow, they just want smaller version of themselves.
 
I don’t think the heroin comparison stacks up unless you’re extrapolating my comments to an illogical conclusion. I’m not advocating that we let children engage in life-threatening activites to ‘learn for themselves’ whether or not they’re going to die. I’m advocating that they are *allowed *to question dogma and accepted wisdom, and take their own steps to lead themselves to a conclusion that they feel confident and happy with. Nothing more.

I don’t think wsp is advocating letting the child ‘learn’ at all, other than to ‘learn’ a one-sided perspective with no access to alternative POVs. In my opinion this is the opposite of true learning.

If my language and phrasing was a little harsh, I apologise; this is something that I feel strongly about. Not enough people truly give their children room to grow, they just want smaller version of themselves.
I did misunderstand you then, that post makes it much clearer, thanks 🙂
 
Apart from the fact that there is no evidence that it is the truth.
other than the witnesses, the statements they wrote that we call Scripture, and the fullfillment of all those prophecies, written over the course of a couple thousand years by men that didnt know each other. yeah, we just made it all up and tens of billions have fallen for it, BWAAA–ha-ha-ha (my best maniacally evil laugh)
And if it is the truth, then shouldn’t you trust the child to be able to arrive at it independently? If it’s so obvious, what do you have to worry about?
math is true too, but no one just arrives at it without instruction
It’s not about education, it’s about intelligence, a questioning mind. If she’s asking those sorts of questions then she’s ready to find out for herself. YOU are trying to stop her from thinking for herself.
intelligence means nothing without an education, and a questioning mind is as likely to fall off a cliff as to climb a mountain without the proper education to understand the information it receives.
I have no idea what you’re talking about. My phrasing was not loaded in the slightest. If you wish to stop this girl asking questions, ‘nip it in the bud’ in your own words, then you are demeaning her ability to ask the right questions.
if you read what i wrote, i wish to nip in the bud the idea that “G-d is mean”
Yes, I do. I don’t know any atheists, nor have I seen posts from any on this forum, that advocate a, “God must not exist if there’s evil in the world” position. There are far stronger atheistic positions. You are out of touch.
so youve never heard of the POE? you dont know any atheists, and im the one out of touch?
You don’t think the OP might have mentioned it? But either way, using that as a defence now shows a belated realisation on your part that you have not done this girl justice, you have just judged and ruled.
or it shows the assumption that she is the average 13 year old. of course your wild extrapolation from assumption might be true too.
Why not? What you seem to be advocating is ‘forced faith.’ Which is an oxymoron, and sounds like a recommendation for brain-washing.
more loaded langauge… you say brain-washing, i say instructing in the faith.
in⋅doc⋅tri⋅nate
/ɪnˈdɒkhttp://cache.lexico.com/dictionary/graphics/luna/thinsp.pngtrəˌneɪt/http://ask.reference.com/web?q=Use+indoctrination+in+a+Sentence&qsrc=2892&o=101993

–verb (used with object), -nat⋅ed, -nat⋅ing. 1. to instruct in a doctrine, principle, ideology, etc., esp. to imbue with a specific partisan or biased belief or point of view.
Indoctrination is exactly what you’re talking about. But even if my language was loaded (which it isn’t), that does not make it fallacious.You
its fallacious because the evaluative meaning of the word is commonly negative, its an attempt to sway an audience through the negative connotations of the word instead of the strength of argument. you could have chosen any synonym for teaching the faith, you chose the one that stirs the most negative images in the audiences mind. you are
are not recommending guidance, you are recommending thought policing. And you are doing it without the slightest consideration for the individual in question.
more loaded language. now its “thought-policing” and i am considering the greater good of the child involved, for us, Salvation is the greatest good.
 
I don’t think the heroin comparison stacks up unless you’re extrapolating my comments to an illogical conclusion. I’m not advocating that we let children engage in life-threatening activites to ‘learn for themselves’ whether or not they’re going to die. I’m advocating that they are *allowed *to question dogma and accepted wisdom, and take their own steps to lead themselves to a conclusion that they feel confident and happy with. Nothing more.

I don’t think wsp is advocating letting the child ‘learn’ at all, other than to ‘learn’ a one-sided perspective with no access to alternative POVs. In my opinion this is the opposite of true learning.

If my language and phrasing was a little harsh, I apologise; this is something that I feel strongly about. Not enough people truly give their children room to grow, they just want smaller version of themselves.
with all due respect to liquids civillity, as far as im concerned the greatest good is Salvation, it is our only purpose in life, so anything that interferes with that process is completely unwelcome.
 
with all due respect to liquids civillity, as far as im concerned the greatest good is Salvation, it is our only purpose in life, so anything that interferes with that process is completely unwelcome.
“I’m not convinced faith can move mountains, but I’ve seen what it can do to skyscrapers”
 
“I’m not convinced faith can move mountains, but I’ve seen what it can do to skyscrapers”
i hear the millions of dead russian, chinese, vietnamese, peasants of atheistic marxist regimes crying for justice from their graves.

funny how you focus on 19 nuts and conveniently forget the few million on your side.
 
i hear the millions of dead russian, chinese, vietnamese, peasants of atheistic marxist regimes crying for justice from their graves.

funny how you focus on 19 nuts and conveniently forget the few million on your side.
Don’t miss my point please. Life is more than just following orders, whether you’re atheist or Christian. If you want to please God and gain salvation, that’s great, but don’t deny your God-given ability to think, learn, question, and apply logic because some other mortals say you should listen to their interpretation of a 2000 year old book translated from dead languages and thus surely missing a good portion of the context to begin with.
 
Don’t miss my point please. Life is more than just following orders, whether you’re atheist or Christian. If you want to please God and gain salvation, that’s great, but don’t deny your God-given ability to think, learn, question, and apply logic because some other mortals say you should listen to their interpretation of a 2000 year old book translated from dead languages and thus surely missing a good portion of the context to begin with.
my ability to think and question and learn are why im a theist, i didnt really start out as one as anything more than guilt by association, but if i hadnt had that influence i would never have found G-d and i believe that we all, theist and atheist only talk about these things because we all desire to find Him.

it isnt a 2000 year old book so much as a 3500 year old series of witness statements that follow the predictions of a series of events, and their fullfillment over that course of time, the convergent prophecies make Christianity unique, and nearly mathematically irrefutable. for me the climb to theism is entirely a rational process.
 
my ability to think and question and learn are why im a theist, i didnt really start out as one as anything more than guilt by association, but if i hadnt had that influence i would never have found G-d and i believe that we all, theist and atheist only talk about these things because we all desire to find Him.

it isnt a 2000 year old book so much as a 3500 year old series of witness statements that follow the predictions of a series of events, and their fullfillment over that course of time, the convergent prophecies make Christianity unique, and nearly mathematically irrefutable. for me the climb to theism is entirely a rational process.
That’s fine for you, but I’ll bring up a common example - the old woman / young woman:

mathworld.wolfram.com/YoungGirl-OldWomanIllusion.html

You say that it’s a rational process, and for you it likely is, but two people can see the same thing completely different and neither has to be wrong.
 
That’s fine for you, but I’ll bring up a common example - the old woman / young woman:

mathworld.wolfram.com/YoungGirl-OldWomanIllusion.html

You say that it’s a rational process, and for you it likely is, but two people can see the same thing completely different and neither has to be wrong.
as a concept one can make the argument, but in real life, one is either the young or the old. in the same way either we are right or we are wrong. a woman cant be just a little preganant so to speak. im off to bed. goodnight.
 
as a concept one can make the argument, but in real life, one is either the young or the old. in the same way either we are right or we are wrong. a woman cant be just a little preganant so to speak. im off to bed. goodnight.
Hahaha… are you really arguing for absolutes? Sigh. Well, goodnight.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top