i dont think its demeaning at all to tell the child the truth, in fact that is a parents responsibilities.
Apart from the fact that there is no evidence that it is the truth. And if it is the truth, then shouldn’t you trust the child to be able to arrive at it independently? If it’s so obvious, what do you have to worry about?
i have raised 2 children in that age range, and i dont think that most children have the education necessary at that point to rationally examine the issue.
It’s not about education, it’s about intelligence, a questioning mind. If she’s asking those sorts of questions then she’s ready to find out for herself. YOU are trying to stop her from thinking for herself.
though through the use of the words, “demean”, i see you have no problem using the loaded langauge fallacy, typical.
I have no idea what you’re talking about. My phrasing was not loaded in the slightest. If you wish to stop this girl asking questions, ‘nip it in the bud’ in your own words, then you are demeaning her ability to ask the right questions.
i am personally familiar with a number of atheists, i was one as a young man myself also, and i continue to monitor the community of atheist in general, i think i have a pretty firm grasp of the realities of atheism. you may disagree.
Yes, I do. I don’t know any atheists, nor have I seen posts from any on this forum, that advocate a, “God must not exist if there’s evil in the world” position. There are far stronger atheistic positions. You are out of touch.
maybe she is a savant, i dont know.
You don’t think the OP might have mentioned it? But either way, using that as a defence now shows a belated realisation on your part that you have not done this girl justice, you have just judged and ruled.
a child shouldnt be allowed to exercise their will in all matters, faith is one of them.
Why not? What you seem to be advocating is ‘forced faith.’ Which is an oxymoron, and sounds like a recommendation for brain-washing.
though again with the word “indoctrination” is the fallacy of loaded language.
in⋅doc⋅tri⋅nate
/ɪnˈdɒkhttp://cache.lexico.com/dictionary/graphics/luna/thinsp.pngtrəˌneɪt/
http://ask.reference.com/web?q=Use+indoctrination+in+a+Sentence&qsrc=2892&o=101993
–verb (used with object), -nat⋅ed, -nat⋅ing. 1. to instruct in a doctrine, principle, ideology, etc., esp. to imbue with a specific partisan or biased belief or point of view.
Indoctrination is
exactly what you’re talking about. But even if my language was loaded (which it isn’t), that does not make it fallacious.
they need guidance until they are sufficiently educated and mature to make good judgments. until then they are much too vulnerable to untoward influences.
You are not recommending guidance, you are recommending thought policing. And you are doing it without the slightest consideration for the individual in question.