1Tim 4:1-5 (Re: No meat, celibacy)

  • Thread starter Thread starter TommyWommy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

TommyWommy

Guest
How are Catholics to regard this Scripture in relation to the prohibition against meat on Lenten Fridays and priestly celibacy? This seems to be a common anti-Catholic charge against the Church.

Thank you.
 
How are Catholics to regard this Scripture in relation to the prohibition against meat on Lenten Fridays and priestly celibacy? This seems to be a common anti-Catholic charge against the Church.

Thank you.
First keep in mind that Timothy is talking about false teachers here.

I think the word "prohibition"is a harsh word. Yes, every thing God has created is good and no food is to be rejected.

Abstaining from meat on Lenten Fridays is a sacrifice and maybe even a penance something we do to honor Jesus. Not that we are calling something bad that God made good. I think it is a discipline and not a dogma.

To be a celibate priest is a special calling from God. A vocation.

We know that marriage isn’t forbidden.

I know that this might not satisfy you but this is just my opinion.
Jeanne
 
First keep in mind that Timothy is talking about false teachers here.

I think the word "prohibition"is a harsh word. Yes, every thing God has created is good and no food is to be rejected.

Abstaining from meat on Lenten Fridays is a sacrifice and maybe even a penance something we do to honor Jesus. Not that we are calling something bad that God made good. I think it is a discipline and not a dogma.

To be a celibate priest is a special calling from God. A vocation.

We know that marriage isn’t forbidden.

I know that this might not satisfy you but this is just my opinion.
Jeanne
I think you’re on the right track. What I sometimes have encountered is the accusation that if ANYone (for example, a young, single man entering the priesthood) was told, “You can’t get married,” that constitutes “forbidden to marry” and therefore “proves” that the Catholic Church is a “false teacher.”

Same basic idea with no meat on Friday.

Essentially, they read the Scripture and look for anything that seems to contradict a specific Catholic teaching in order to support anti-Catholicism. Whether or not it is dogma doesn’t seem to matter. If it is “taught” in any regard it is a “false teaching” and therefore “proof” that the Catholic Church is a “false teacher.”
 
Verses 1-3 say, in essence, “There will be some people who advocate abstaining from foods and forbid marriage (v. 3), and they will have fallen away from the faith and accepted the doctrines of demons (v. 1).” Then verse 4 starts with the word “for.” It explains why these people are evil: “Everything created by God is good, and nothing is to be rejected if it is received with gratitude.”

So, putting it all together, we learn that some people will be deceived into thinking that some parts of God’s creation (like marriage and certain foods) are intrinsically evil, when in fact they are not, for they are “sanctified by the means of the word of God and prayer” (v. 5). Denying the goodness of God’s creation is a sign that someone has fallen away.

The Church doesn’t do this. She simply recognizes that celibacy, fasting, and abstinence are paths to a greater spiritual good. Her earthly leaders, acting in their roles as shepherds, enforce these disciplines on the faithful for their own spiritual benefit.

So: St. Paul is warning against people who deny that marriage and food are good things; the Church teaches that they are good things, but that denying them can bring greater spiritual growth. And that’s why 1 Tim 4 doesn’t conflict with the Church’s disciplines.

Hope that helps.
 
I think you’re on the right track. What I sometimes have encountered is the accusation that if ANYone (for example, a young, single man entering the priesthood) was told, “You can’t get married,” that constitutes “forbidden to marry” and therefore “proves” that the Catholic Church is a “false teacher.”

Same basic idea with no meat on Friday.

Essentially, they read the Scripture and look for anything that seems to contradict a specific Catholic teaching in order to support anti-Catholicism. Whether or not it is dogma doesn’t seem to matter. If it is “taught” in any regard it is a “false teaching” and therefore “proof” that the Catholic Church is a “false teacher.”
That young man can get married, the Church is not forbidding marriage to him. However he cannot be a priest if he does. The requirement to be single to be a priest is no different than the requirements to join certain organizations like the miltary for one. Fasting is in the bible, they might try reading it sometime instead of wasting time with false accusations.
 
I answered this a while back like this:

The Catholic Church forbids marriage? Since when? Priests choose not to marry in accord with the superior call described by Christ (Mt 19:12), repeated by Paul (1 Cor 7:1, 1 Cor 7:38).

Secondly, what food did God create that is “to be received with thanksgiving by those who believe and know the truth.”

Hint: Eucharistia = “thanksgiving”.

The Eucharist is to be received only by those who believe (1 Cor 11:29).

Paul wrote both Corinthians and the letter to Timothy. Timothy would have understood the “deceitful spirits” as those who forbid the Eucharist.I should be clear that this is my interpretation. 🙂
 
In the context of pairing a rule of abstaining with a rule of celibacy, it would seem that Paul is probably talking about a total (and perpetual?) ban on meat here, as celibacy is a total (and perpetual?) ban on sex, rather than the two days a year that the Church forbids it to her members.
 
How are Catholics to regard this Scripture in relation to the prohibition against meat on Lenten Fridays and priestly celibacy? This seems to be a common anti-Catholic charge against the Church.

Thank you.
Acts 15: 22Then the apostles and elders, with the whole church, decided to choose some of their own men and send them to Antioch with Paul and Barnabas. They chose Judas (called Barsabbas) and Silas, two men who were leaders among the brothers. 23With them they sent the following letter: The apostles and elders, your brothers, To the Gentile believers in Antioch, Syria and Cilicia: Greetings. 24We have heard that some went out from us without our authorization and disturbed you, troubling your minds by what they said. 25So we all agreed to choose some men and send them to you with our dear friends Barnabas and Paul— 26men who have risked their lives for the name of our Lord Jesus Christ. 27Therefore we are sending Judas and Silas to confirm by word of mouth what we are writing. 28It seemed good to the Holy Spirit and to us not to burden you with anything beyond the following requirements: 29You are to abstain from food sacrificed to idols, from blood, from the meat of strangled animals and from sexual immorality. You will do well to avoid these things. Farewell.

Acts 16: 4As they traveled from town to town, they delivered the decisions reached by the apostles and elders in Jerusalem for the people to obey. 5So the churches were strengthened in the faith and grew daily in numbers.
Here is a disciplinary rule clearly laid out by the Church for all to obey (Jewish Christians obeyed them mostly by their custom, Gentiles obey them according to Church instruction), and these laws included both dietary and ‘sexual’ regulations.
The “sexual immorality” is a bad translation, because fornication was always forbidden, what it really means is certain sexual relations which Jews found particularly scandalous.

The common rule of interpretation is to read Scripture which is unclear in light of Scripture which is more clear, and thus 1 Tim 4:3 cannot mean the Church has no power to set down such regulations, it must mean something else. And reading the context of 1 Tim 4:1-5, it is clear these are false teachers and apostates and it appears a whole sale forbidding of marriage and certain foods. Verse 4 says “for everything God created is good” implying these teachers saw ‘earthly pleasures’ as evil. This is precisely what certain gnostic groups believed, that the material is evil and the spiritual is good.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top