2 interesting questions about Christ

  • Thread starter Thread starter SimonArizona
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

SimonArizona

Guest
  1. Moses says “You shall see your life hanging before you.”-Deut 28:66 Is this a prophecy of Christ?
  2. As the Word and Wisdom of the Father, Christ is able to know with His Father’s intellect. How come He didn’t know the hour of His return but only the Father did?
 
  1. Moses says “You shall see your life hanging before you.”-Deut 28:66 Is this a prophecy of Christ?
Maybe!
  1. As the Word and Wisdom of the Father, Christ is able to know with His Father’s intellect. How come He didn’t know the hour of His return but only the Father did?
Because His knowledge was limited by His human nature. It is most important that His intellect and will were human. In order to save us, Jesus must be us. In order to show us how to live as human beings, He had to be a human being just like us, if He had possessed the beatific vision from conception and known everything there was to know, it would have mitigated the authenticity of His earthly life. Many Catholic scholars would argue, however, that Jesus did have, as He grew in wisdom, age and grace, the highest possible ‘mystical’ human knowledge of the Father. Check out CCC 472 and 473.F.
 
St. Athanasius says, paraphrasing, that the Word of God was still ordering the universe and at the same time wielding his mortal body in Jesus.
 
Because His knowledge was limited by His human nature. It is most important that His intellect and will were human. In order to save us, Jesus must be us. In order to show us how to live as human beings, He had to be a human being just like us, if He had possessed the beatific vision from conception and known everything there was to know, it would have mitigated the authenticity of His earthly life. Many Catholic scholars would argue, however, that Jesus did have, as He grew in wisdom, age and grace, the highest possible ‘mystical’ human knowledge of the Father. Check out CCC 472 and 473.F.
Just a quick correction, He did have the beatific vision. As the CCC section 473 and 474 alluded to (“immediate knowledge”) and as Pope Pius XII explained in more detail:
Mystici Corporis:
But the knowledge and love of our Divine Redeemer, of which we were the object from the first moment of His Incarnation, exceed all that the human intellect can hope to grasp. For hardly was He conceived in the womb of the Mother of God, when He began to enjoy the Beatific Vision, and in that vision all the members of His Mystical Body were continually and unceasingly present to Him, and He embraced them with His redeeming love. O marvelous condescension of divine love for us! O inestimable dispensation of boundless charity! In the crib, on the Cross, in the unending glory of the Father, Christ has all the members of the Church present before Him and united to Him in a much clearer and more loving manner than that of a mother who clasps her child to her breast, or than that with which a man knows and loves himself.
Here’s another good article on the knowledge of Christ:

newadvent.org/cathen/08675a.htm
 
  1. As the Word and Wisdom of the Father, Christ is able to know with His Father’s intellect.
Simon,

That is an interesting way to put it, but I find it somewhat an odd construction. Christ, as God, had the same intellect as the Father, who is God. Each Divine Person have the same intellect and will (insofar as “intellect” and “will” can be spoken of in God).

The corollary to the above is that Christ, as man, did not have the same intellect as God, since a human intellect is finite. (Although this, in itself, does not show that Christ, as man, did not know the day or hour).

VC
 
  1. Moses says “You shall see your life hanging before you.”-Deut 28:66 Is this a prophecy of Christ?
  2. As the Word and Wisdom of the Father, Christ is able to know with His Father’s intellect. How come He didn’t know the hour of His return but only the Father did?
There are a number of ways to answer number two. One way (answered below by Fighting Fat) is that Jesus as a human being gave up some attributes (or in some way they were voluntarily limited). For instance, Jesus, wept, experienced hunger, was tired, and marveled.

Another way is the issue of ontological versus economic subordination. That is while all persons of the Trinity are equal ontologically they have different roles. This is another way in which the commentators have handled this question. We see throughout scripture that all persons of the Trinity had different roles in creation, in the salvation plan and so on. The time and place of Christ’s return is set by the Father (see Acts 1:7 in addition to the reference to Matt 24:36).
 
Genesis315,

You beat me too it. 👍 I was going to offer that as well.

VC
 
Not satisfied. Sorry haha

The Word of God was wielding His instrument (body) at the same time He was still ordering the universe. Athanasius takes pains to explain that the Word was not confined to His human body. I can’t figure out the mystery how He didn’t know who touched Him or the hour of His return.
 
Not satisfied. Sorry haha

The Word of God was wielding His instrument (body) at the same time He was still ordering the universe. Athanasius takes pains to explain that the Word was not confined to His human body. I can’t figure out the mystery how He didn’t know who touched Him or the hour of His return.
Another way to address the issue is in terms of ontological versus economic subordination. That is while all persons of the Trinity are equal ontologically they have different roles. This is another way in which the commentators have handled this question. We see throughout scripture that all persons of the Trinity had different roles in creation, in the salvation plan and so on. The time and place of Christ’s return is set by the Father (see Acts 1:7 in addition to the reference to Matt 24:36).

Read Acts 1:7 and a good Systematic theology text regarding the issue.
 
I thought that the Acts passage is not about Jesus’ knowledge, but about pointing his apostles in the right direction? Jesus tells his Apostles bascially its none of their business to know! The Apostles were still clamouring for an earthly kingdom it seems (v.6).

In terms of Jesus’ human nature - it is surely endowed with those qualities possessed by man before the Fall? He possesses the true human nature. The hypostatic union restores human nature and brings it into its right relationship with God in the most intimate way imaginable.

This is a great thread by the way, thank you SimonArizona! 👍
 
  1. Moses says “You shall see your life hanging before you.”-Deut 28:66 Is this a prophecy of Christ?
No. Deuteronomy was not written with the incarnation of Jesus in view.
  1. As the Word and Wisdom of the Father, Christ is able to know with His Father’s intellect. How come He didn’t know the hour of His return but only the Father did?
Word and Wisdom are metaphors, not statements of fact.

Intellect is an attribution of anthropomorphism to God. God is without form, without human attributes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top