20/20 Special on Childbirth

  • Thread starter Thread starter lizaanne
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

lizaanne

Guest
Is anyone else watching this? It was a wonderful and beautiful show ----- until about 40 minutes in. Then it became totally anti-Catholic, talking about how wonderful it was that Catholic Mexico (Mexfam) is so brilliant that they hand out contraception and how now it is taboo for families to have many children. The even had shots of Churches and specifically pointed out that this is (was) a Catholic country.

It’s nothing but a show about population control, contraception, and even abortion. They are praising the women who are going behind their husband’s backs to contracept.

SHAME on ABC. 😦

~Liza
 
Write to them. Tell them you were diappointed and expect better, less biased journalism from them in the future.
 
Or write to someone who’ll call them out on it. Personally I’m a fan of Bill O’Reilly for that kind of thing, but I know not everyone is.
 
I don’t really know what you wanted.
I wanted the program to continue in the vein it started. Showing how women from Western society were going to countries where women in poverty stricken parts of the world were dying in childbirth, and taking them drugs to help them survive delivery, and improve hospital conditions. You know, the REAL way to address a problem.

Yes - women in these societies die in childbirth. But pregnancy and childbirth are not the problem. The unhealthy conditions, lack of drugs and medical attention, lack of training - THOSE are the problems!!! You don’t fix this by just stopping women from having babies - you empower women and treat them as they should be treated, buy giving them them proper access to medical care and medication, and educate them on how to be healthy when they are pregnant, and how to care for their children.

This show did nothing but the opposite. They thought they were fixing the problem by stopping the women from getting pregnant, and totally lost site that the REAL issues that caused women to die in childbirth are still there, still not being addressed, and still harming women who do chose to have children.

So in the end ----- nothing really changed. But in the process, unborn children died. How disgusting.

~Liza
 
Honestly, I didn’t care for the entire program. I think it overall oversimplified the problems in countries with high morality rates. Mostly it seemed a general pat on the American back for the technology and wisdom we’re bringing them. At the very mention that our maternal death rate for mothers in the US is pathetic for first world nations, this was merely used a criticism of our health care coverage problems. Everything about the program was just about spreading the general American consensus that having children is simply naturally so dangerous that it needs to be treated as if you’re having your leg amputated. I think following up with promoting contraception and abortion just goes with that fearful line of thinking.

And its no wonder we’re afraid. Our prenatal care in the US is over the top. I was given this huge book of a million and one different tests. For crying out loud, mosts of those tests are just to tell you if you’re baby has a genetic abnormality that might change a woman’s mind about “continuing the pregnancy.” We ended up going the homebirth route and it simplified everything.
 
I saw it and also thought it was a puff piece on the subject of contraception. I’d appreciate (name removed by moderator)ut on how to address a letter to Diane Sawyer. Here’s my first draft:

Dear Ms. Sawyer,

I recently viewed your 20/20 special on pregnancy and childbirth in third world nations. I appreciate the insight and reality check you obviously worked so hard to provide American viewers and the call to action you sounded in asking people to help make conditions safer for pregnant women worldwide who suffer almost unbelievable lack of resources in their hour of most need.

But I noticed that the segment on contraception in Mexico displayed a level of bias and partial truth unbecoming of a journalist of your stature. There are several points I would like to make on this segment.

The first objection I have is the incomplete coverage you gave to the effects of contraception on culture. You did enough research to note that the adoption of artificial contraception in Mexico has brought the total fertility rate of that nation down from over 8 to 2.2 in mere decades and left off there. But I assert that a more complete investigation would show that that overall average of 2.2 hides an alarming fact within. I would ask you in future such investigative reporting dig deeper and see what the total fertility rates are among the couples who are educated, wealthy and have access to the contraceptive techniques you so laud. You will likely find that the total fertility rate for those couples is 1.6 or less; less than replacement rate. The long term fruit of contraception is easy to see in Europe where native populations are in drastic contraction due to sub-replacement fertility rates. In America, like Mexico, total fertility is obscured by the high fertility of recent immigrants and the religiousity of a large minority of Americans that tends to increase the number of children in those families. But like Europe, the total fertility of second generation and later Americans is below replacement rate and falling. As your report notes, a global population of 7 billion and climbing does sound alarming, but hidden in the details of the data lies the fact that earth has already passed the inflection point of population and the contraceptive trend everywhere it becomes established is to create a culture of depopulation. In fact, every single first world country that has culturally embraced contraception as a positive value now has (or very soon will have) a sub-replacement fertility rate (See the CIA World Factbook for data, and note that 2.06 is replacement rate). Why is such a critical fact regarding the subject matter ignored in your report?

Your report also contained the implication that poor women in third world countries face only two options in life: Endless pregnancies until menopause/death or the ‘miracle’ of modern contraception. This is not journalism, but a dishonest argument technique called the “false dilemma.” Long before the 1960’s invention of the pill, wealthy families in industrialized urban areas were already smaller than those in poor, rural areas. The reason was not contraception, but comprehension of the human reproductive system. The human fertility cycle produces symptoms of fertility that can be recognized with minimal training and technology. Ironically these techniques are actually more effective in impoverished countries where the populace generally does not use significant quantities of over the counter medications that can obscure fertility symptoms. Mother Theresa routinely taught women in third world settings how to recognize their fertile symptoms and how to use this information to delay further pregnancies when circumstances warranted it (Creighton University has done extensive research on the method). This approach requires no logistics, creates no cultural dependance on pharmaceutical companies and has a historic track record of allowing reductions in family sizes when warranted without the unwanted cultural side effect of sub replacement total fertility. Ignoring this family planning approach, especially when your report took the effort of point out Mexico as a ‘catholic’ country is a serious oversight.

(continued)
 
I can only imagine that you get a good number of letters from crackpot theorists. As a head start to pointing out the solid basis of my concerns I offer you this reference paper prepared by the United Nations: un.org/esa/population/publications/longrange2/WorldPop2300final.pdf
You may recall that the findings within predict continued long term population growth. But buried within it are assumptions that are not well reasoned, by the admission even of participants. Historic data has never shown a return to replacement level fertility once contraception has ben culturally embraced. And yet, one of the contributors here admits to simply assuming that this change will occur in the future. Given that it entirely contradicts history to date, isn’t that a strange assumption? Here’s the quote:

"The United Nations’ medium scenario envisages that Total Fertility in the world’s more developed regions will
*rise *from an average level of 1.56 births per woman during 2000-2005 to 1.85 births per woman during 2045-2050 – before eventually settling at 2.06 births per woman for the remaining 250 years of the projection. Key issues, however, are whether there *will *be such a recovery in

fertility and, still more, the extent to which recent European and East Asian fertility experience may actually presage the future behavior of an increasing fraction of people living elsewhere in the world." (essay on page 148 of the document)

I would assert that the effects of artificial contraception changes the relationship of the married couple and effectively divorces the intimacy of marital sex from decisions about children (originally this is the assertion of Pope Paul VI in his much - ignored encyclical Humanae Vitae). This loss will not be countered by tax incentives or government subsidies on child care, as glibly asserted by the UN scholars elsewhere in the study. This potentially devastating long term cultural effect of contraception has not been discussed in major news media reports to date. It would be a service to your viewers if you would at some point make up for the deficiencies in your latest 20/20 project with an investigation of what contraception really is and what overall effect it has had on civilization to date. So far you’ve only spoken to its fans and given no chance to its critics. Last I checked, that isn’t journalism, it is advertising.

Sincerely,

Manualman (real name in the letter, of course!)

OK CAF readers. How about some feedback?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top