A cheap shot from an Athiest

  • Thread starter Thread starter mellowcheddar
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

mellowcheddar

Guest
Good morning all:

My brother and I have never had a great relationship. (We are both in our 30’s.) He has a nice family with 2 young kids. My husband and I would love to see them more often, but he always cancels at the last minute or “forgets” that we had plans. Well, yesterday we got in a fight about it. This fight has been coming for over a year.

Well, whenever we DO get in arguments, he tosses in a comment to the effect of “Well, you’re quite the Christian if you’re fighting with me.” This is a man who hasn’t set foot in a church for anything except weddings and funerals for over 15 years. He has told his kids (7 and 4) that religion is a joke and that anyone who goes to any kind of church is an idiot.

Meanwhile, I am a Lector and am training as a Server.

My problem is this: Is he right? I know we are supposed to forgive and forget, but this relationship has been abusive in the past and sometimes it still is. Surely Christ wouldn’t want us to set ourselves up for insults and abuse. Defending the Lord and his church are one thing- taking this kind of junk from my brother is a different story.

We have all sinned in the eyes of God, and none of us is perfect, and many of us are not “good Christians,” if for no other fact than since we are humans and sinners we are bound to falter and stumble.

Can anybody give me some (name removed by moderator)ut of any kind on my situation? This is really bugging me.
 
you don’t really say what you and your brother are fighting about. Are you fighting over the fact that he makes plans and then cancels on you or simply fails to show up? Because that has nothing to do with Christianity and everything to do with bad manners. He’s an adult and you are not responsible for his manners or the lack them.

The best thing you can do for your relationship is to stop fighting. Send him and his family invitations without the expectation of them showing up. If they come it will be a lovely surprise, if they don’t you won’t be disappointed and have a reason to argue with him.

Also I would apologize for the fighting. Once you apologize for fighting he has nothing to hold against you.
 
Why would you want to see “more of” someone who treats you like that? :confused:

As someone I know and love dearly always says - “blood is only redder than water”.

Let it go and let him take the initiative next time. If he wants to see you, he will take the effort - and hopefully be a bit nicer to you. But don’t stand around as his punching bag.

Just because he’s family does not mean you must have a relationship with him. Some people are just toxic, no matter what you do or say. This sounds like one of those situations.

~Liza
 
These both seem like good answers. We fight over d*** near EVERYTHING and we always have. He is 6 years older than me. He is the master of the cheap shot and loves to kick folks- not just me- when they’re down. But this is the only family I have nearby and despite the fact that he treats me like **** I want to be there for the kids.

A lot of times he’ll double-book over plans with me for plans with his wife’s family. I don’t blame his wife. He thinks he’s better than me and he always has. I have suffered from depression for 20 years and sometimes I wonder if he takes advantage of it to make himself feel better.

I’m more concerned, at this point, whether or not I AM a “good Christian”, or if he’s just throwing it in my face since he doesn’t have much else to work with. I care about representing Jesus and his followers a lot more than making this dork happy.
 
Apologize. Forgive him. Pray for him. And if you ever get into an argument with him again, try clinging to Christ’s peace as best you can. If you stay peaceful it could turn into a discussion rather than an argument.
 
There is nothing wrong with debating, and nothing wrong with speaking the truth. “Fighting” implies bad behavior - yelling (although there are times when raising your voice is not wrong), casting insults, being immature - those things are unbecoming of a Christian. But being Christian doesn’t mean that you can’t call out a person for doing something wrong, or for being hurtful. If you were, in fact, behaving badly, then it would be Christian of you to apologize. I am sorry for yelling at you/being mean etc…" It is also possible to say, “My approach was wrong, and I am sorry for that. I stand by the point of my argument though, and I stand by my right to call you on it.” If your brother truly thinks Christians are idiots, maybe it’s because he believes that Christians are supposed to be doormats - it sounds like he is indignant that you’re not being one (certainly would make it easier for him to win the fight that way, wouldn’t it?). I suppose he was counting on having freebie in the fight department. There is nothing wrong with challenging that, as long as it is done respectfully.

OTOH, if things have always been this way, and you don’t think that a rational discussion is likely to bring about change, then perhaps what the others are saying is the best thing you can do. Changing your expectations, and your initial behavior might be the best way for you to not have as much conflict with him.
 
I think you got it right in the title of your post. It was a cheap shot. It sounds to me like he didn’t want to hear whatever you were saying and knew that you would be sensitive about this particular comment. My advice is to let it go.

I’ve been in a similar situation before, where a family member cancels plans at the last minute. In that kind of situation, I don’t think that we should have to put up with more from our family just because they’re family. If it were one of your friends doing this, would you continue to invite them out as often as you are now? Personally, I think it’s very rude to repeatedly cancel plans at the last minute like that. If your brother continues to cancel plans, then just stop inviting him as often. Let him invite you over if he finds himself wanting to spend time with you.

Try not to hold it against him, just allow him his own space. Continue to pray for him.
 
Don’t sweat it too much. I suspect that the fight was over the fact that he’s been an inconsiderate jerk for a long while now and shows no signs of changing. Like you said, it was a cheap shot. Arguments are not necessarily sin, but I can think of some responses that are both appropriate and equally to the point.


  1. *]“How would you know Mr. No Religion?”
    *]“I tend to argue with siblings who inconsiderately can’t keep plans.”
    *]“Yeah, well, I’m still better looking than you.”
    *]“That’s okay, Mom always liked me better.”

    Okay, the last two are meant to lighten this thread up. 🤷
 
Ahhhhhhhhhh… Siblings! :rolleyes: Heh heh heh… Often a very complex relationship. Often siblings are just not the ones we can witness to. I too have issues such as you describe. For me- I just step back and ‘model virtue’ and pray for them. If God wants to use you specifically then he will. Pray and trust the master. He’ll work it out.

P.S. Get Mary in on it! That’ll teach him! 😉
 
Are you a good Christian you’re wondering. Well, we’re all a work in progress. None is good but God alone, as Jesus says.
You’d be surprised how similar your brother is to mine. I refrain from throwing cheap shots back at him. When he says something mean, I simply say “Don’t be mean”.

I would deal with the kid’s mom, ask her if she would like a break some Saturday afternoon when you’ll take the kids out to the park and for an ice cream, or what ever you might like to do with them. Bet she says Yes! and she’ll be calling you! You can spend some time getting to know the little ones, which seems to me that’s your goal and maybe this strategy will be more successful. By pass grouchy and you’ll both be happier. I agree with the above poster, Get Mary on him!
 
He is the master of the cheap shot and loves to kick folks- not just me- when they’re down. But this is the only family I have nearby and despite the fact that he treats me like **** I want to be there for the kids.

A lot of times he’ll double-book over plans with me for plans with his wife’s family. I don’t blame his wife. He thinks he’s better than me and he always has. I have suffered from depression for 20 years and sometimes I wonder if he takes advantage of it to make himself feel better.

I’m more concerned, at this point, whether or not I AM a “good Christian”, or if he’s just throwing it in my face since he doesn’t have much else to work with. I care about representing Jesus and his followers a lot more than making this dork happy.
Whether you are a good Christian has nothing to do with this. Your brother sounds like an abusive jerk. People like that use whatever they can as ammunition against others. The ‘good Christian’ line is just that: a way to manipulate you into doing what he wants you to do and to make you feel bad.He probably knows he is treating you badly and has nothing to throw in your face except your faith that he obviously knows nothing about. Please see his behaviour for what it is.
 
This was a classic logical fallacy called the “redirect”.

He doesn’t want to address the real issue of his bad behavior and so throws up a shadow argument to distract.

Stay focused and unemotional and you will persevere.

Oh and do always pray for him. Know he is being doubly convicted in his heart: for him and his children. Your presence dismantles his contrived worldview and so is painful.

Just remember he knows nothing about being a Christian; if he knew the truth, he would be one. It might not hurt to remind him of such if he brings it up again.
 
I’m reminded of a woman who came to her priest for help once because her teenage son was going bad, rejected God, etc. He said he would talk to the young man, which he did. The young man said he didn’t believe in God, etc., and there was absolutely nothing the priest could do for him. So, the priest told him that he would pray to God that God would “kick his butt” in order for him to believe. The young man just looked incredulously at the priest and left.

Two weeks later, the mother called the priest, frantically, saying that her son had gotten in a horrible car accident, breaking all four limbs and fracturing his skull. He was in the hospital, in traction, etc., and would the priest go visit him? The priest smiled and said he certainly would. The priest said he walked into the young man’s hospital room, and there he was, all bandaged up, in traction, etc. He said his whole head was bandaged and all he could see was holes for his eyes, nose, and mouth. The priest said he walked up to the young man’s bed, looked at him, and just smiled. He didn’t say anything. Then, he left. The young man finally got the message and has been a good Catholic and model citizen ever since! God certainly can work in mysterious ways!

Maybe you need to pray for your brother that God gets his attention! Better to suffer a few injuries than lose his immortal soul, don’t you think? 🙂
 
Maybe you need to pray for your brother that God gets his attention! Better to suffer a few injuries than lose his immortal soul, don’t you think? 🙂
Cute little story, but we also need to know when it’s time to blow the dust off our sandals and walk away. God never told us to be punching bags for those who refuse the Truth.

~Liza
 
I have a brother who sounds similar. He cancels or changes things frequently screwing things up(also not religious and thinks organized religion/Catholicismis a joke) . We just kinda expect it and NEVER plan anything around him and his family(we’ve learned this over the years). That way we are never disappointed. We have never had an argument about it though. We just go on and enjoy ourselves(the rest of the family). My brother suffers with depression and I really think sometimes it is just hard for him to get out and that’s okay. I never think he does it intentially. This may not be the case with your brother. I would just politely say “oh that’s too bad, we’ll miss you” and go on and enjoy the party or what ever event it is. It’s not about him anyway!! Life’s to short to worry about the little things. You could occassionaly send him a card to let him know that you love him and point out some of the quailities you admire in him. The bottom line here is that you love him and his family and cutting off ties with him will probably not solve this. I’m not suggesting that you let him abuse you–but coming up with a few one liners to his “jokes” that are kind may work better. I liked: “that’s okay mom likes me better”!!!🙂
 
I’ve had relationships like that in the past – granted, not with family. They would always make plans and cancel when something better came along or would hem and haw about even making plans, hoping that something better would come about.

I think you just have to cut your losses – I don’t mean totally break ties with your family, but stop expecting something that he’s obviously not willing to give. I think Dr. Laura says, “Stop expecting an alligator to act like a puppy dog” – or something to that effect. You can send nice birthday/Christmas cards and gifts, you can shoot them a nice e-mail once a week. But by constantly opening yourself up to the abuse, you damage your relationship even more. Maybe one day he’ll come around, maybe he won’t.
 
…–but coming up with a few one liners to his “jokes” that are kind may work better. I liked: “that’s okay mom likes me better”!!!🙂
except that he could take that personally.
I don’t think love of parents is a good thing to joke about with an antagonistic sibling, and it does play around with the matter of charity.
If he has any issues of resentment eg, having been the older by six years, that might only make the relationship worse;
or if he takes you seriously, that you believe your mom loves you better, that may only cause him to believe more securely that you live in spiritual fairyland.

Lighthearted responses may help to defuse…and I hope you come up with some suitable ones…at least it might help you to feel better.
 
Thank you all so much for your replies. Unfortunatly, when I texted his wife last night, I got 6-screen-long text messages back, a few at a time, at work. I just stood in a back room with my jaw on the floor. And now SOMEHOW, my husband (who usually does the smart thing and stays out of it) is yelling about seeing his niece and nephew- I didn’t know HE cared that much. So when he comes home, the crud’s really hitting the fan.

To top it all off, though, it IS All Saint’s, which is an Obligatory Mass.

When God closes a door He opens a window, I guess… 🤷 “I gotta go to Church today, bye.”

I just couldn’t believe the rage coming from my sister-in-law. She’s a very “meek” person, and my brother treats her lousy too. I never knew she had it in her. She is all insulted for her husband and her kids.
“When do you ever call the kids on their birthdays?!” she texted me.
I don’t remember what my reply was- I was at work and didn’t wanna get all ticked off and angry on the line. But later when I talked to my Mom, she said,
“When have they ever invited you to any of their birthday parties?”
“Never, Mom.”
“There you go.”

(And speaking of “Mom”, I did throw out a “Hail Mary” for patience before I went to my Accounting class. She helped me chill out. My one friend and I just call her ‘Mama.’ 😃 )

This whole argument is spiraling into a much larger mess than I imagined, and since it’s the second half of the semester, THIS ought to be fun.

Ugh, Saint Lawrence, help me out here.
 
Thank you all so much for your replies. Unfortunatly, when I texted his wife last night, I got 6-screen-long text messages back, a few at a time, at work. I just stood in a back room with my jaw on the floor. And now SOMEHOW, my husband (who usually does the smart thing and stays out of it) is yelling about seeing his niece and nephew- I didn’t know HE cared that much. So when he comes home, the crud’s really hitting the fan.

To top it all off, though, it IS All Saint’s, which is an Obligatory Mass.

When God closes a door He opens a window, I guess… 🤷 “I gotta go to Church today, bye.”

I just couldn’t believe the rage coming from my sister-in-law. She’s a very “meek” person, and my brother treats her lousy too. I never knew she had it in her. She is all insulted for her husband and her kids.
“When do you ever call the kids on their birthdays?!” she texted me.
I don’t remember what my reply was- I was at work and didn’t wanna get all ticked off and angry on the line. But later when I talked to my Mom, she said,
“When have they ever invited you to any of their birthday parties?”
“Never, Mom.”
“There you go.”

(And speaking of “Mom”, I did throw out a “Hail Mary” for patience before I went to my Accounting class. She helped me chill out. My one friend and I just call her ‘Mama.’ 😃 )

This whole argument is spiraling into a much larger mess than I imagined, and since it’s the second half of the semester, THIS ought to be fun.

Ugh, Saint Lawrence, help me out here.
Hmm, boy. You know, being a student, you have an advantage over the rest of us. You probably have a free counselling center at your college. You might want to take advantage of those fees you pay, call the student counselling center, and get yourself someone with some training to talk with you one-on-one. You can be sure that whoever you talk to will have had some experience with family issues that impinge on a person’s studies!!

In the meantime, try to dodge the bullets and stay out of the arena until you get some help sorting out what your situation is and some good advice about how to proceed. You are more likely than not to make things worse while everyone is on the warpath. It’s a Tuesday. They can wait.

A Hail Mary before that session won’t hurt, either!
 
One of my uncles was a lot like your brother. He caused all sorts of strife in the family, treated one of his sisters like dirt, was rude to his parents, was very anti-Catholic/catholic bashing, was always late for things, if he bothered to show up at all, and tried to play off his siblings against each other. So, my family made teh decision to basically cut him out of their lives.

Anyway, he learnt the hard way, and eventually started to make polite and humble moves to come back into the fold. It took about 10 years for him to have the forgiveness of our family, but that sister he treated badly, she and him still have issues, and they both sometimes bring my mum into it - she’s the eldest in that family. There’s still some friction, but its managable, and his second wife is quite a calming influence on him.

My two cents, for what its worth, is to just cut ties with him. Ignore him. Completely. HOwever, before you do that, write him a letter, email or just tell him, that you’re no longer going to have anything to do with him because of his behaviour, and if he wants to be involved in your life then he’ll have to conduct himself accordingly.

Its an unfortunate thing to have to happen, but it might just sort him out. Its also sad if he has kids, my uncle had kids, and the rest of us cousins, and my siblings, we dont’ get on well with those kids from his first marriage, I can’t help wonder if it was his behaviour, his ranting against us, or how my family handled it.

I hope things work out well, and I’ll pray. It can be salvaged, but it might take some time.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top