A child seeing "ghosts"

  • Thread starter Thread starter ryanferg
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
R

ryanferg

Guest
I posted something similar to “Ask an Apologist” but I have not heard back for a little while and I know they are very busy.

A close friend of the family has a daughter (about 10 years old now) who has been suffering for years with seeing ghosts and spirits. They torment her constantly…mostly at night but sometimes even during the day. At first her parents thought it was an overactive imagination and tried to explain it off…but they have come to the realization that something very real is tormenting her and feel helpless on what to do (they have a few experiences themselves but near to the degree of their daughter). She can’t even sleep in her room at night because she said they constantly approach her.

They have had her talk to a psychologist who has tried to help her cope with what is happening. He too does not feel that this is something she is fabricating.

I work with someone who belongs to an established paranormal investigation organization and I have asked if they can call him for advice. I warned him that they do not show his same enthusiasm for understanding this phenomenon and they would just be interested in try to get this to stop. My friends grew up Catholic but have since began to attend a non-denominational church…not for any reason in particular…but because they must not have realized the importance of the Catholic Church and how it is very different than Protestant churches.

I plan on talking to my pastor tomorrow for advice. I want to know what the Catholic Church teaches on how situations like this should be approached and what options they have for help from the Catholic Church if they do not currently belong to one.

Are there any paranormal investigators who work in close contact with the Catholic Church who can look into the situation and involve the Church if they determine their help is needed?
 
I know this is not the answer you’re looking for, but there are no such things as ghosts.

Of course it’s impossible to disprove the claims based solely on self-selected information from ghost-believers.

However there are a few interesting tidbits in the story:

“They [the parents] have a few experiences themselves.”

That one is telling. Probable indications: 1) the parents are suffering from mental illness and the child inherited the same illness, 2) the parents suffer from mental illness and the child is identifying with the parents as a psychological defense mechanism and/or 3) the child is suffering from a mental illness and the parents extreme stress is manifesting these delusions. There are many other possibilities, but those 3 stand out.

“They have had her talk to a psychologist who has tried to help her cope with what is happening. He too does not feel that this is something she is fabricating.”

If the report is accurate, then that is an awful psychologist. I’m not a fan of licensing, but if this behavior continues then this person is in danger of losing their license. Sounds like a psychiatrist I once knew who picked out medication and dosage by “aligning the chi.” In other words, we’re entering very, very dangerous territory here.

Advice #1: Find a reputable psychiatrist.
Advice #2: Speak to the pastor of the nearest Church.
 
I know this is not the answer you’re looking for, but there are no such things as ghosts.
I said “ghosts” in quotes because I don’t know what to call these experiences. In the “spirit” world you can angels (and fallen angels - demons)… I can’t imagine God sending angels to a child in this fashion so it concerns me that if these spirits are as real as she says they are they may possibly be demonic. This is a judgment I am qualified to make but since the Church has exorcists I have no doubt that these spirits are real and the Church takes battling these very seriously.

The existence of angels and demons is a dogma of the Faith…so I wouldn’t be too quick to judge that there could be some mental issues going on here. It is thinking like that that make people afraid to talk about these experiences. Are you suggesting that someone who is being tormented by demons is just suffering from disillusion mental problems? I would think that Saint Pio would have an opinion on that 🙂

Thank you for the reply…but you are correct…that is not the answer I was looking for and the reason why I originally posted this as a private message to the apologist forum.
 
40.png
VeritasLuxMea:
I know this is not the answer you’re looking for, but there are no such things as ghosts.
And you know this how?
 
I could see it as possibly coming form demonic sources. Angels and demons are definitely around and I doubt an angel would terrify a child.

I also don’t believe in ghosts because our soul leaves this earth instantly after death.
 
Well if the parents have already talked to a child psychiatrist and determined that the child isn’t suffering from some sort of mental impairment, then I would suggest you talk to your parish priest. If he can’t help you personally, he should know where to send you for additional help.
 
Poor baby. 😦 I’ll pray for her! I don’t know if it would help but you could teach her to say a pray to her guardian angel to protect her, and make sure she has holy water in her room. God bless.
 
I said “ghosts” in quotes because I don’t know what to call these experiences. In the “spirit” world you can angels (and fallen angels - demons)… I can’t imagine God sending angels to a child in this fashion so it concerns me that if these spirits are as real as she says they are they may possibly be demonic. This is a judgment I am qualified to make but since the Church has exorcists I have no doubt that these spirits are real and the Church takes battling these very seriously.

The existence of angels and demons is a dogma of the Faith…so I wouldn’t be too quick to judge that there could be some mental issues going on here. It is thinking like that that make people afraid to talk about these experiences.
Huh? That would be like if someone said, “I’ve had a stomach ache for a whole month straight.” You wouldn’t tell that person to see a doctor? Same thing here. There’s no shame in mental illness (at least there ought not be.)
Are you suggesting that someone who is being tormented by demons is just suffering from disillusion mental problems?
“Mental problems” is not a phrase I would use.

That said, almost certain… with a few minor exceptions: someone is playing a prank on them, there is a very real stimulus that they are misinterpreting, etc.
Thank you for the reply…but you are correct…that is not the answer I was looking for and the reason why I originally posted this as a private message to the apologist forum.
Gotcha. As ghosts are not real, I would be doing a major disservice by ignoring the question. I hope you understand why I felt it was necessary to reply. 🙂
40.png
tafan:
And you know this how?
The stunning absence of evidence is, in this case, evidence of absence.

We have a situation in which:

-Countless numbers of people since the dawn of time have believed in a particular occurrence.

-Of those, a significant amount have dedicated their lives to pursuing the subject.

-Yet despite ALL of these facts, no evidence is forthcoming.

Why? Because ghosts do not exist.

That’s my final word on the subject, as I don’t want to hijack the thread. But I would be glad to listen to any alleged “evidence” in a different thread.
 
Because of course, you know everything. :rolleyes:
No, but I do know that the ghost-believers have had the burden of proof for thousands of years and have provided jack squat in the way of reliable evidence. Failure of such epic proportions is practically unprecedented in history.

As indicated, I have no wish to hijack the thread, so will discuss elsewhere if desired.
 
A beliefe in ghosts is a very related part of Catholicism. Even priests and monks have had experiences of seeing the departed. it’s possible that ghosts may often be souls in Purgatory, whom God allows us to see, either for their good or ours. Michael Vorris has an excellant talk on the subject.

That being said, a GHOST would not be tormenting anyone. They might scare you in the sense of OH MY GOSH ITS A GHOST but they can’t harm you. So, what she’s seeing, if they feel fear0inducing at a deep level, is not a real ghost. Wether it’s her imagination, or demons, I cdan’t say
 
I could see it as possibly coming form demonic sources. Angels and demons are definitely around and I doubt an angel would terrify a child.

I also don’t believe in ghosts because our soul leaves this earth instantly after death.
And goes WHERE? Heaven, Hell, and…wait for it…Purgatory.
The church does not demand you believe in ghosts, but you need to realize that where Catholicism is concerned, your logic is wrong.
 
Why? Because ghosts do not exist.
I will believe this when the Church teaches this.

What would you consider Moses when he appeared to Jesus in Matthew 17:3? We know he’s not an angel…we know he had died and was buried…yet he appeared before Jesus with Elijah (who is in a category of his own).

In Matthew 14:26 the disciples saw Jesus walking on water toward them and said “It is a ghost” (NAB). Did Jesus scold them and tell them there are no such things as ghosts? I find it interesting that even 2000 years ago people were seeing things that they could not explain.

In Luke 24:26-39 the disciples think they are seeing a ghost and Jesus says “Look at my hands and my feet, that it is I myself. Touch me and see, because a ghost does not have flesh and bones as you can see I have.” (NAB) Jesus yet again does not discount the existence of ghosts…in fact some may interpret that he is acknowledging the existence of ghost by describing characteristic that they “do not” have.
 
The parents are not helpless on what to do. It is their job, and especially that of the father, to fulfill their state in life, which includes providing for spiritual leadership and protection of his family.

The father dropped the ball by allowing his family to leave the Church. Had he remained Catholic, he would have the benefits of sacramental graces, the power of the mass, and many other tools that Christ provided to His Church.

These tools assist the family in all challenges.
 
I I plan on talking to my pastor tomorrow for advice. I want to know what the Catholic Church teaches on how situations like this should be approached and what options they have for help from the Catholic Church if they do not currently belong to one.

Are there any paranormal investigators who work in close contact with the Catholic Church who can look into the situation and involve the Church if they determine their help is needed?
well that is the first thing the parents should have done is see their priest.
Yes the Church does have them, they are called exorcists. There should be one for each diocese, a priest specially trained and spiritually prepared for that ministry–which a “paranormal investigator” is not. If psychological and physical disorder is ruled out he will decide how to proceed.

btw if the psychologist they consutlted did or recommended nothing further in the way of treatment she does not sound very professional.
 
The father dropped the ball by allowing his family to leave the Church. Had he remained Catholic, he would have the benefits of sacramental graces, the power of the mass, and many other tools that Christ provided to His Church.
I totally agree with you…but until a few years ago I didn’t fully understand how the Catholic Church was different than all of these other churches out there. I never left the Church…but there was a point in my life where I didn’t understand the importance of the Church. My own children were a significant part of my journey “back” to the Church and I thank God for the Holy Spirit and that he put the right people in my life that allowed me to open my eyes to what I was missing.

It has also crossed my mind that this may be a reason why this is happening (leaving the Church). God speaks to people in many different ways and this may be occurring to lead them back to the Church that Jesus established.
 
btw if the psychologist they consutlted did or recommended nothing further in the way of treatment she does not sound very professional.
In defense of the psychologist I am receiving that information second-hand. I don’t know what was said between them. I just know that they didn’t feel this was being invented by her and that she was being sincere in her perception of what was happening. I’m sure the psychologist didn’t just leave it at that…but that is a personal matter between the family and the psychologist.
 
In defense of the psychologist I am receiving that information second-hand. I don’t know what was said between them. I just know that they didn’t feel this was being invented by her and that she was being sincere in her perception of what was happening. I’m sure the psychologist didn’t just leave it at that…but that is a personal matter between the family and the psychologist.
you are quite right, and ultimately the whole situation is private unless and until they invite your (name removed by moderator)ut and advice, so be ready to help as you can, but if they have already decided to seriously consider the possibility of supernatural or demonic influence it is absolutely of no use to consult any other “paranormal” expert than the Catholic Church, who has been given that authority over these events by Christ himself.
 
I posted something similar to “Ask an Apologist” but I have not heard back for a little while and I know they are very busy.

A close friend of the family has a daughter (about 10 years old now) who has been suffering for years with seeing ghosts and spirits. They torment her constantly…mostly at night but sometimes even during the day. At first her parents thought it was an overactive imagination and tried to explain it off…but they have come to the realization that something very real is tormenting her and feel helpless on what to do (they have a few experiences themselves but near to the degree of their daughter). She can’t even sleep in her room at night because she said they constantly approach her.

They have had her talk to a psychologist who has tried to help her cope with what is happening. He too does not feel that this is something she is fabricating.

I work with someone who belongs to an established paranormal investigation organization and I have asked if they can call him for advice. I warned him that they do not show his same enthusiasm for understanding this phenomenon and they would just be interested in try to get this to stop. My friends grew up Catholic but have since began to attend a non-denominational church…not for any reason in particular…but because they must not have realized the importance of the Catholic Church and how it is very different than Protestant churches.

I plan on talking to my pastor tomorrow for advice. I want to know what the Catholic Church teaches on how situations like this should be approached and what options they have for help from the Catholic Church if they do not currently belong to one.

Are there any paranormal investigators who work in close contact with the Catholic Church who can look into the situation and involve the Church if they determine their help is needed?
My oldest son had this same problem at about the same age. I chalk it up to us being New-Agers, and I had consented to have my son initiated into a certain New-Age group called Surat Shabd Yoga (the path of light and sound). That’s when the problem started. I feel terrible that I got him involved with this group, which we left a few years later.

My son saw ghosts everywhere. Sometimes they sat in trees, always looking at him. He was very frightened, and I got to where I could tell when he saw one because he would get a certain frightened look on his face. He also saw ghost animals, especially cats. I’m not kidding.

I phoned the leaders of the New-Age goup I had belonged to to beg for help with the problem, but they had no advice to offer as to how to deal with it. A few years later, he stopped seeing them, and only saw little blue round things floating around. I knew nothing about Catholicism at the time.

Ryanferg, would you happen to know if the child has been receiving ‘laying on of hands’ or anything similar to that at the church the family has attended? I’m not trying to put down Pentacostals, but this sort of thing can happen in this situation.

I would recommend to your friend to pray the Rosary, or at least the short form of the St. Michael prayer, if they are possibly open to doing this. I wish I had known about the Rosary or St. Michael prayer when my son was having problems.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top