A few questions on salvation

  • Thread starter Thread starter wolfpup
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
W

wolfpup

Guest
I think I am right in saying that Catholicism teaches that Gods grace has to be co-operted with in order for us to be saved, and that we can freely reject God’s grace at any time and sin.

Calvins theology teaches that if we are truly saved then we cannot cut ourself off from God - we will never commit mortal sin or turn away from Christ. Salvation here is seen as a total change of heart where we would not want to sin after the salvation event.

I have a few questions:

If baptism provides us with the grace of justification and the Holy Spirit, why do we even want to sin afterwards? I understand that we have to co-operate, but it seems that even those who are recieving sacraments often have habitual sins that need to be overcome.
It also doesn’t seem to make sense that God would ask us to not sin if we still have a fallen human nature - and then condemn us to hell for not overcoming it.

Here are a few scripture quotes that I hope others may be able to explain in light of Catholic teaching. They seem to me to point towards the OSAS understanding, although I know that the teaching is unhistorical.

John 10: 28 - “I give them eternal life, and they shall never perish; no one can snatch them out of my hand. My Father, who has given them to me, is greater than all; no one can snatch them out of my Father’s hand."

Eph 4:30 -* “And do not bring sorrow to God’s Holy Spirit by the way you live. Remember, he is the one who has identified you as his own, guaranteeing that you will be saved on the day of redemption.”*

1 John 3:9: 9 No one who is born of God will continue to sin, because God’s seed remains in them; they cannot go on sinning, because they have been born of God. 10 This is how we know who the children of God are and who the children of the devil are"

Heb 10:6 *If we deliberately keep on sinning after we have received the knowledge of the truth, no sacrifice for sins is left, 27 but only a fearful expectation of judgment and of raging fire that will consume the enemies of God.
*
1 John 5.16-17: *“If you see your brother or sister committing what is not a mortal sin, you will ask, and God will give life to such a one - to those whose sin is not mortal. There is sin that is mortal; I do not say you should pray about that. All wrongdoing is sin, but there is sin that is not mortal” *
I know the above quote it used by Catholics to understand the difference between mortal and venial sin, but if we can be commit mortal sin (perish), and then come back to God, it seems to contradict the other verses above (john 10) that say that those in Christ will not perish.

Is there any biblical evidence of someone after repentance commiting mortal sin and perishing (after the holy spirit comes at pentecost) and and then coming back to God?

Hope you can help
 
I think I am right in saying that Catholicism teaches that Gods grace has to be co-operted with in order for us to be saved, and that we can freely reject God’s grace at any time and sin.

Calvins theology teaches that if we are truly saved then we cannot cut ourself off from God - we will never commit mortal sin or turn away from Christ. Salvation here is seen as a total change of heart where we would not want to sin after the salvation event.

I have a few questions:

If baptism provides us with the grace of justification and the Holy Spirit, why do we even want to sin afterwards? I understand that we have to co-operate, but it seems that even those who are recieving sacraments often have habitual sins that need to be overcome.
It also doesn’t seem to make sense that God would ask us to not sin if we still have a fallen human nature - and then condemn us to hell for not overcoming it.

Here are a few scripture quotes that I hope others may be able to explain in light of Catholic teaching. They seem to me to point towards the OSAS understanding, although I know that the teaching is unhistorical.

John 10: 28 - “I give them eternal life, and they shall never perish; no one can snatch them out of my hand. My Father, who has given them to me, is greater than all; no one can snatch them out of my Father’s hand."

Eph 4:30 -* “And do not bring sorrow to God’s Holy Spirit by the way you live. Remember, he is the one who has identified you as his own, guaranteeing that you will be saved on the day of redemption.”*

1 John 3:9: 9 No one who is born of God will continue to sin, because God’s seed remains in them; they cannot go on sinning, because they have been born of God. 10 This is how we know who the children of God are and who the children of the devil are"

Heb 10:6 If we deliberately keep on sinning after we have received the knowledge of the truth, no sacrifice for sins is left, 27 but only a fearful expectation of judgment and of raging fire that will consume the enemies of God.

1 John 5.16-17: *“If you see your brother or sister committing what is not a mortal sin, you will ask, and God will give life to such a one - to those whose sin is not mortal. There is sin that is mortal; I do not say you should pray about that. All wrongdoing is sin, but there is sin that is not mortal” *
I know the above quote it used by Catholics to understand the difference between mortal and venial sin, but if we can be commit mortal sin (perish), and then come back to God, it seems to contradict the other verses above (john 10) that say that those in Christ will not perish.

Is there any biblical evidence of someone after repentance commiting mortal sin and perishing (after the holy spirit comes at pentecost) and and then coming back to God?

Hope you can help
Catholics dont believe we must co-operate with God to be saved, thats a potestant twisting of the concept. We dont “want” to sin but we do unless we are ever viglant and frequently receive the sacraments. Sin is a freely chosen act on our part that has the effect of seperating us from God. Nothing apart from God can enter heaven and nothing impure can enter heaven. Sin make us unfit for heaven unless we are soehow able to reconcile ourselves with God.
 
If I may offer an analogy or two…
Salvation, that is, a combination of Justification and Sanctification, is like diet and excersize. First comes the commitment to improve and then comes the effort.

Repentance and baptism are the commitment…a commitment to God…and Grace is received. (Justification)
Living in Christ, working to improve - to be perfect (Mt 5:48) is where the rubber meets the road. Christ says that it isn’t those who Cry “Lord Lord” but those who obey the fathers commandments who will be saved.

The person who commits to a diet but then fails to follow through is often left worse off than before they started. Likewise the person who begins an excerize regimen with a goal of say running a 5k run, but fails to follow through will never acheive their goal.

So it is with those who are baptized but fail to follow through - Fail to seek, not only justification, but sanctification. They often find themselves worse off than before.

Peace
James
 
I have a few questions:

If baptism provides us with the grace of justification and the Holy Spirit, why do we even want to sin afterwards? I understand that we have to co-operate, but it seems that even those who are recieving sacraments often have habitual sins that need to be overcome.
It also doesn’t seem to make sense that God would ask us to not sin if we still have a fallen human nature - and then condemn us to hell for not overcoming it.
Wolfpup, When we are cleansed from all sin in Baptism we are justified and given the gift of sanctifying grace to overcome our human nature(concupiscence) and to grow in holiness.It does not happen over night, it is a life long process.

W e have been given the Sacraments to help us to persevere in overcoming our tendency toward concupiscence.
We have a merciful God and he knows his children well and he wants us with him forever more , he loves us, that is why He is always there with his actual grace pulling us back into his love when ever our human nature is tempted by the evil one:eek:who is forever lurking with his tools of distuction.
So we live our life in Christ through His Body the Church and we pray for the grace of perseverance
You must remember that the Father has given his children the freedom to always in temptation to chose him or not , we have free will.Peace, Carlan
 
If I may offer an analogy or two…
Salvation, that is, a combination of Justification and Sanctification, is like diet and excersize. First comes the commitment to improve and then comes the effort.
Repentance and baptism are the commitment…a commitment to God…and Grace is received. (Justification)
Living in Christ, working to improve - to be perfect (Mt 5:48) is where the rubber meets the road. Christ says that it isn’t those who Cry “Lord Lord” but those who obey the fathers commandments who will be saved.
The person who commits to a diet but then fails to follow through is often left worse off than before they started. Likewise the person who begins an excerize regimen with a goal of say running a 5k run, but fails to follow through will never acheive their goal.
So it is with those who are baptized but fail to follow through - Fail to seek, not only justification, but sanctification. They often find themselves worse off than before.
Thanks James. I don’t think there is much disagreement in the fact that we must persevere and do the will of God, as Jesus says. I think the difference comes when we ask why do those people who have been baptised fail to follow through? Scripture seems to say that this is how we will know those who have been “born again” - if they willingly sin. (1 john, Heb 10 below).
Wolfpup, When we are cleansed from all sin in Baptism we are justified and given the gift of sanctifying grace to overcome our human nature(concupiscence) and to grow in holiness.It does not happen over night, it is a life long process.
W e have been given the Sacraments to help us to persevere in overcoming our tendency toward concupiscence.
We have a merciful God and he knows his children well and he wants us with him forever more , he loves us, that is why He is always there with his actual grace pulling us back into his love when ever our human nature is tempted by the evil onewho is forever lurking with his tools of distuction.
So we live our life in Christ through His Body the Church and we pray for the grace of perseverance
You must remember that the Father has given his children the freedom to always in temptation to chose him or not , we have free will.Peace, Carlan
Carlan, I understand the “free will” part - but it seems from the Scripture below that those who do choose sin afterwards, it seems that nothing can be done. (1 john 5)
If it is about slowly overcoming our fallen nature, then why do they say things like this?

What I don’t see in scripture is those who have been placed in Christ and then been cut out then be able to come back again. (absolution of mortal sin after baptism). I don’t know, it just seems that from what I’ve read, the apostles expect us to lead a completly transformed life after baptism, such that one would not willingly sin., and if they did sin willingly “no sacrifice for sins is left, 27 but only a fearful expectation of judgment and of raging fire that will consume the enemies of God.” If we fail to perservere, then thats it. We have lost eternal life, or perhaps we never had it in the first place.

My thoughts on this are so muddled right now. I hope I am making even a little bit of sense.

Hope you can help.
 
Thanks James. I don’t think there is much disagreement in the fact that we must persevere and do the will of God, as Jesus says. I think the difference comes when we ask why do those people who have been baptised fail to follow through? Scripture seems to say that this is how we will know those who have been “born again” - if they willingly sin. (1 john, Heb 10 below).

Carlan, I understand the “free will” part - but it seems from the Scripture below that those who do choose sin afterwards, it seems that nothing can be done. (1 john 5)
If it is about slowly overcoming our fallen nature, then why do they say things like this?

What I don’t see in scripture is those who have been placed in Christ and then been cut out then be able to come back again. (absolution of mortal sin after baptism). I don’t know, it just seems that from what I’ve read, the apostles expect us to lead a completely transformed life after baptism, such that one would not willingly sin., and if they did sin willingly “no sacrifice for sins is left, 27 but only a fearful expectation of judgment and of raging fire that will consume the enemies of God.” If we fail to perservere, then thats it. We have lost eternal life, or perhaps we never had it in the first place.

My thoughts on this are so muddled right now. I hope I am making even a little bit of sense.

Hope you can help.
Something can be done, if a person falls into deadly sin and repents. In John20:23 ,Jesus gives his apostles the power to fogive sins and this power is handed on down to our Bishops and Priests.The counsel of Trent defined that the power to forgive sins here in Jn20:23 is the same power exercised in the Sacrament of Penance, one of the seven sacraments of the Church. This Sacrament restores us to God’s grace with the absolution given by Christ through his Priest who acts in his person, “In Persona Christi”.I hope this explanation helps, I am not an Apologist nor am I very good at debate,But I do love my Church and I do try to share and defend her as best I can. I hope you stay here with Catholic Answers, we have many great Apologists here keen to help you understand what the Church teaches, and I ask our Lord to help and guide you in your search, Peace, Carlan
 
I think I am right in saying that Catholicism teaches that Gods grace has to be co-operted with in order for us to be saved, and that we can freely reject God’s grace at any time and sin.
This is a reasonable generalization although Catholicism puts no bounds on God’s Sovereignty in saving anyone in any manner He sees fit.
Calvins theology teaches that if we are truly saved then we cannot cut ourself off from God - we will never commit mortal sin or turn away from Christ.
  • And this is based on what clear Scripture?
  • And the reasons for writing letters to the various NT churches warning them about the eternal consequences of certain behaviors(1Cor 6:9-19, Eph 5:5 and Gal 5:19 (see my signature) served what purpose exactly?
Salvation here is seen as a total change of heart where we would not want to sin after the salvation event.
  • Not “wanting to sin” is a great fantasy proven repeatedly by every single generation of Christians, starting with the Apostles.
If baptism provides us with the grace of justification and the Holy Spirit, why do we even want to sin afterwards?
Well, either our sin nature remains despite being justified (Catholic position) or God, in His Sovereignty wills us to sin and we cannot do anything about it.
I understand that we have to co-operate, but it seems that even those who are recieving sacraments often have habitual sins that need to be overcome.
Are you ready for some shocking news? This isn’t Heaven, it’s planet earth and people are still people.
It also doesn’t seem to make sense that God would ask us to not sin if we still have a fallen human nature - and then condemn us to hell for not overcoming it.
Unless, of course, he provided us with ample power to overcome the temptations of the world and knew full well that he had.
Here are a few scripture quotes that I hope others may be able to explain in light of Catholic teaching. They seem to me to point towards the OSAS understanding, although I know that the teaching is unhistorical.
Not only is it “unhistorical” meaning that there is no record of any Christian holding such a belief for the entire first 1600 years of Christianity, but it is completely at odd with much of the NT.

John 10: 28 - “I give them eternal life, and they shall never perish; no one can snatch them out of my hand. My Father, who has given them to me, is greater than all; no one can snatch them out of my Father’s hand."

1 John 5.16-17: *“If you see your brother or sister committing what is not a mortal sin, you will ask, and God will give life to such a one - to those whose sin is not mortal. There is sin that is mortal; I do not say you should pray about that. All wrongdoing is sin, but there is sin that is not mortal” *
I know the above quote it used by Catholics to understand the difference between mortal and venial sin, but if we can be commit mortal sin (perish), and then come back to God, it seems to contradict the other verses above (john 10) that say that those in Christ will not perish.
John 10:28 is a relatively vague verse when you come right down to it. Who exactly are the sheep that Christ speaks of? Is it the Apostles? Is it a special subset of the saved known as the elect? Is it those already in Heaven? Is it the OT prophets? It’s unclear. That one verse simply isn’t one you can rest a theology on - especially when there are mountains of verses which speak of the obvious need for Christians to “follow him”, to avoid sin, to forgive others, to “stay awake”, to “persevere”, to follow the “narrow path” over and over again.
Is there any biblical evidence of someone after repentance commiting mortal sin and perishing (after the holy spirit comes at pentecost) and and then coming back to God?
I’ll tell you what - would you like proof that its possible to be saved, to have received the Spirit only to later have “fallen from grace” rendering Christ to be of no benefit to them?
Read the letter to the Galatians. Want to hear it again for another church? Read the letter to the Ephesians. Want to read it a third time? Read the letter to the 1st Corinthians - Ch 6 especially.
What you do matters - God has placed this truth in your heart and you are aware of it. Don’t let some mere human idea replace the Truth.
 
don’t mind the muddled thinking…all will become clear with time, prayer and being open to God’s direction.

People sin after baptism because they (we) are weak. Christ knew this and gave us the sacrament of reconciliation.

Some even lose their faith entirely after baptism, yet Christ never closes the door to reconciliation. Instead He seeks that which is lost…

Remember the parable of the sower…The seed fell on 4 types of ground. One type rejects the seed immediately and one type accepts teh seed and bears much fruit, but two of those types accepted the seed and sprouted and then died off.
Think about why.

Peace
James
 
Something can be done, if a person falls into deadly sin and repents. In John20:23 ,Jesus gives his apostles the power to fogive sins and this power is handed on down to our Bishops and Priests.The counsel of Trent defined that the power to forgive sins here in Jn20:23 is the same power exercised in the Sacrament of Penance, one of the seven sacraments of the Church. This Sacrament restores us to God’s grace with the absolution given by Christ through his Priest who acts in his person, “In Persona Christi”.
Ok, so I understand the Sacrement of Reconcilliation. I know that it was instituted by Christ and is evident from the earliest Christian writings. But, I am not sure how it squares up verses I quoted below.
1 John 3:9: 9 No one who is born of God will continue to sin, because God’s seed remains in them; they cannot go on sinning, because they have been born of God. 10 This is how we know who the children of God are and who the children of the devil are"
Heb 10:6 If we deliberately keep on sinning after we have received the knowledge of the truth, no sacrifice for sins is left, 27 but only a fearful expectation of judgment and of raging fire that will consume the enemies of God.
Why is there a “fearful expectation of judgement” and “no sacrifice for sins left” if we can come back via confession and penance?
Why do many continue to sin after baptism when it says that we will know those who have been born again because they will not sin willfully?

Please do not take these questions the wrong way. I know that the Church has the authority to understand and explain scripture - it could not be any other way. I really do want to come to the Catholic viewpoint, but these things seem to get in the way for me.

Philthy - thank you for your post. I know that Calvin must be wrong, but I have a hard time proving it to myself.
I’ll tell you what - would you like proof that its possible to be saved, to have received the Spirit only to later have “fallen from grace” rendering Christ to be of no benefit to them?
Read the letter to the Galatians. Want to hear it again for another church? Read the letter to the Ephesians. Want to read it a third time? Read the letter to the 1st Corinthians - Ch 6 especially.
What you do matters - God has placed this truth in your heart and you are aware of it. Don’t let some mere human idea replace the Truth.
Ok, I have read those passages and I understand that the saved can “fall from grace” and sin. This is not what I have a problem with. What I don’t understand, or can’t see in Scripture, is those who have been saved, fallen again, then be saved again (through sacrament of penance). I understand that what we do matters, otherwise there would be no need of paul to remind us of the need to steer clear from sin. But if it is as 1 John and Hebrews 10 suggest (to my darkened mind) we have one chance, and we blow it if we spurn the blood of christ by sinning after he has saved us.

If I have misunderstood anything please point it out.
 
Ok, so I understand the Sacrement of Reconcilliation. I know that it was instituted by Christ and is evident from the earliest Christian writings. But, I am not sure how it squares up verses I quoted below.
1 John 3:9: 9 No one who is born of God will continue to sin, because God’s seed remains in them; they cannot go on sinning, because they have been born of God. 10 This is how we know who the children of God are and who the children of the devil are"
I believe that the key phrase here is “Willfully”. Consider this - how the term “willfully” plays into the issue. Those who truly commit to God maight sin, but they do not do so “willfully”… In fact, if you look at the requirements for a sin to be mortal, you will find that it must be an act of Will taken in full knowledge…

The reference in Hebrews really speaks to the idea of trying to have your cake and eat it too…One cannot claim to have had a change of heart, to Love God and Accept Christ if one continues intheir old, sinful ways…
Please do not take these questions the wrong way. I know that the Church has the authority to understand and explain scripture - it could not be any other way. I really do want to come to the Catholic viewpoint, but these things seem to get in the way for me.
Coming to understand thise things takes time. Especially if you have been previously trained in another viewpoint.
Ok, I have read those passages and I understand that the saved can “fall from grace” and sin. This is not what I have a problem with. What I don’t understand, or can’t see in Scripture, is those who have been saved, fallen again, then be saved again (through sacrament of penance). I understand that what we do matters, otherwise there would be no need of paul to remind us of the need to steer clear from sin. But if it is as 1 John and Hebrews 10 suggest (to my darkened mind) we have one chance, and we blow it if we spurn the blood of christ by sinning after he has saved us.
If I have misunderstood anything please point it out.
OK, let me clear. You are asking if there is a verse or passage in the Bible where someone was saved, fell, and was saved again?

The first one that comes to my mind is Simon Peter. In Mt 16 He receives the locution from God as to Jesus Identity as Son of God, Later, He denies Christ Three times on Holy Thusday night, and later is restored by Christ by when Christ tells him three times to feed and tend His sheep.

I think the idea of having “one chance” is wrong. Christ made the one sacrifice by which we are saved, but we, in our joureny, face the same risk as well as the same possibility every day. The risk is that we will fall, maybe not to the point of losing salvation, but fail in following Christ and in Loving as we should Love, God and neighbor…This same risk, if left unchecked by confession and restoration CAN lead us further and further from the true path until eventually we DO lose our salvation.
Likewise every day we have the opportunity to reform our lives once a gain, to renew our committment, to move forward - away from sinful behaviors etc and place ourselves even more firmly in Christ and Christ in us.

Peace
James
 
=wolfpup;7578082]I think I am right in saying that Catholicism teaches that Gods grace has to be co-operted with in order for us to be saved, and that we can freely reject God’s grace at any time and sin.
We must say “yes” to God’s grace and in that sense we cooperate with God’s grace.
Calvins theology teaches that if we are truly saved then we cannot cut ourself off from God - we will never commit mortal sin or turn away from Christ. Salvation here is seen as a total change of heart where we would not want to sin after the salvation event.
Calvinists believe that they can commit a deadly sin but God will always bring them back if they are one of the Elect. The problem is no one infallibly knows if they are one of the Elect that is, one of those who will endure to the end.
I have a few questions: If baptism provides us with the grace of justification and the Holy Spirit, why do we even want to sin afterwards?
We have free will. The grace of justification does not remove the effects of original sin which is the desire to sin.
I understand that we have to co-operate, but it seems that even those who are recieving sacraments often have habitual sins that need to be overcome.
We have the free will to sin and a wounded nature that desires to sin. The sacraments are a means of grace and will help us in our pursuit of holiness but free will is always at play. The more grace we receive through the sacrments and through the good works of grace the more our will is conformed to the will of the Father.
It also doesn’t seem to make sense that God would ask us to not sin if we still have a fallen human nature - and then condemn us to hell for not overcoming it.
God sends everyone sufficient grace to be saved.
 
=wolfpup;7578082I think I am right in saying that Catholicism teaches that Gods grace has to be co-operted with in order for us to be saved, and that we can freely reject God’s grace at any time and sin.Calvins theology teaches that if we are truly saved then we cannot cut ourself off from God - we will never commit mortal sin or turn away from Christ. Salvation here is seen as a total change of heart where we would not want to sin after the salvation event.
Here are a few scripture quotes that I hope others may be able to explain in light of Catholic teaching. They seem to me to point towards the OSAS understanding, although I know that the teaching is unhistorical.
John 10: 28“I give them eternal life, and they shall never perish; no one can snatch them out of my hand. My Father, who has given them to me, is greater than all; no one can snatch them out of my Father’s hand."
This verse is NOT saying that sin cannot take one out of the Father’s hand. No one who remains in the state of grace will be condemned. As long as you are in the state of grace you will remain in the Father’s hand.
Eph 4:30 “And do not bring sorrow to God’s Holy Spirit by the way you live. Remember, he is the one who has identified you as his own, guaranteeing that you will be saved on the day of redemption.”
That’s an interesting translation. You might want to look at better translations. Paul is warning the Christians NOT to grieve the Holy Spirit that is, to avoid sin. The Ephesian Christians were “sealed” for the day of redemption through their baptism and confirmation. That doesn’t mean they were guaranteed salvation.
Paul warns these same Ephesians who were sealed for redemption:
Ephesians 5:5-6: Be sure of this, that no immoral or impure man, or one who is covetous (that is an idolater), has any inheritance in the kingdom of Christ and of God. Let no one deceive you with empty words, for it is because of these things that the wrath of God comes upon the sons of disobedience.
1 John 3:9: 9No one who is born of God will continue to sin, because God’s seed remains in them; they cannot go on sinning, because they have been born of God.
10 This is how we know who the children of God are and who the children of the devil are"

Another interesting translation. Verse 9 should read “ No one who is born of God commits sin for God’s nature abides in him".
Calvinists like your translation because they believe only “habitual” sin means that you may not be one of the elect. ONE deadly un-repented sin can send one to hell
Heb 10:6If we deliberately keep on sinning after we have received the knowledge of the truth, no sacrifice for sins is left, but only a fearful expectation of judgment and of raging fire that will consume the enemies of God.
Another interesting translation .It should read “If we sin deliberately after receiving the knowledge of the truth…” Notice that the author of Hebrews includes himself as one that could sin deliberately. Also notice it is “sin” singular and it is deliberate which makes it mortal.
1 John 5.16-17"If you see your brother or sister committing what is not a mortal sin, you will ask, and God will give life to such a one - to those whose sin is not mortal. There is sin that is mortal; I do not say you should pray about that. All wrongdoing is sin, but there is sin that is not mortal"
I know the above quote it used by Catholics to understand the difference between mortal and venial sin, but if we can be commit mortal sin (perish), and then come back to God, it seems to contradict the other verses above (john 10) that say that those in Christ will not perish.
You must “remain” in Christ to be saved. One can fall into deadly sin and by the grace of God come back to repentance and be grafted back into Christ.
John 15:4-6
Remain in me, and I in you. As the branch cannot bear fruit by itself, unless it remains in the vine, neither can you, unless you remain in me. I am the vine you are the branches. He who remains in me, and I in him, he it is that bears much fruit, for apart from me you can do nothing. If a man does not remain in me, he is cast forth as a branch and withers, and the branches are gathered together, thrown into the fire and burned
Is there any biblical evidence of someone after repentance commiting mortal sin and perishing (after the holy spirit comes at pentecost) and and then coming back to God?
Hope you can help
James 5:19:
My brothers, if one of you should wander from the truth and someone should bring him back, remember this: Whoever turns a sinner from the error of his way will save a soul from death and cover over a multitude of sins
 
Quote from Wolfpup.
Ok, I have read those passages and I understand that the saved can “fall from grace” and sin. This is not what I have a problem with. What I don’t understand, or can’t see in Scripture, is those who have been saved, fallen again, then be saved again (through sacrament of penance). I understand that what we do matters, otherwise there would be no need of paul to remind us of the need to steer clear from sin. But if it is as 1 John and Hebrews 10 suggest (to my darkened mind) we have one chance, and we blow it if we spurn the blood of christ by sinning after he has saved us.
Yes you are right Jesus died on the cross for our sins only once.
When we accept that redemption He won for us we are saved. But that does not mean if we fall into deadly sin,and many of us do, even though you believe you never will or can after salvation, that work Christ did on the cross no longer counts for us and that somehow we were not saved in the first place and so repentance and forgiveness is pointless.
God is merciful , a God of love, so, if we do fall off the path into deadly sin He in his mercy has provided a way for us to return to him, and if we refuse to come to grips with it and not seek again God’s love and mercy, forgiveness in repentance and sorrow and we die in our sin, well yes , then we have turned away from Christ and that chance for salvation that he gave us and we will end up in hell. hope this helps. Peace, Carlan
 
Catholics dont believe we must co-operate with God to be saved, thats a potestant twisting of the concept. .
Maybe I am mis-understanding you… We do have to 'cooperate" with God to be saved in the sense that we must say “yes” to God’s grace. It is 100% God and 100% man. As long as we don’t reject His grace we will be saved.

1 Cor. 3:8-9: "The man who plants and the man who waters have one purpose, and each will be rewarded according to his own labor. For we are God’s co- workers.

1 Cor. 15:10: "But by the grace of God I am what I am, and his grace to me was not without effect. No, I worked harder than all of them—yet not I, but the grace of God that was with me.

2 Cor. 6:1"Working together with him, then, we also urge you not to receive the grace of God in vain
 
=wolfpup;7580722]Ok, so I understand the Sacrement of Reconcilliation. I know that it was instituted by Christ and is evident from the earliest Christian writings. But, I am not sure how it squares up verses I quoted below.
Why is there a “fearful expectation of judgement” and “no sacrifice for sins left” if we can come back via confession and penance?
We have the free will NOT to come back. When we sin deliberately we are rejecting the Holy Spirit. Paul said this to the Elect. "If we deny him , he will deny us; If we are faithless he remains faithful fro he cannot deny himself. " 2 Tim 2: 10-13
God always remains faithful and will forgive those who come to confessin and repentance.
Why do many continue to sin after baptism when it says that we will know those who have been born again because they will not sin willfully?
We have a wounded nature as a result of original sin. A person is “born again” through baptism. Peter tells his audience that “baptism now saves you " 1 peter 3:21 yet he tells this same audience: 'Be sober, be watchful. Your adversary the devil prowls around like a roaring lion, seeking someone to devour. Resit him, firm in your faith.” 1 Peter 5:8
 
That’s an interesting translation. You might want to look at better translations. Paul is warning the Christians NOT to grieve the Holy Spirit that is, to avoid sin. The Ephesian Christians were “sealed” for the day of redemption through their baptism and confirmation. That doesn’t mean they were guaranteed salvation.
Paul warns these same Ephesians who were sealed for redemption…
Hi Third Day! :tiphat:

You make some excellent points here. I just want to comment - especially in the context of this thread where the OP is struggling with the notion of OSAS - that you should avoid making statements like the one bolded. Catholics and OSAS adherents differ in their understanding of the word “salvation”. The Ephesians Paul is speaking to were, in fact, saved in the sense that when they repented, believed, and were baptized they became children of God. They were saved, and that much is “guaranteed”. What is NOT guaranteed is that they would remain in that state and (at the completion of their earthly lives) inherit the Kingdom of God (KoG). That is the language more typically used (vs saved, salvation, etc) to distinguish between what happens when one enters into God’s family during their earthly pilgrimage (saved) and what happens at the conclusion of that pilgrimage following judgment (inherit the KoG). When we narrow our focus to the message of the NT with respect to inheriting the KoG we find that it is much easier to reconcile not only Paul with James, but Paul with himself! For how else is one to understand Eph 2:8-9 with Eph 5:5-6? It becomes quite obvious that the quote from chapter 2 relates to how we ENTER INTO A RELATIONSHIP WITH GOD (ie become “saved”) whereas chapter 5 is dealing with how we REMAIN IN THAT RELATIONSHIP so that when we face judgment we will inherit the KoG. 1Cor 6:9-10, Eph 5:5-6 and Gal 5:19-20 could not be more explicit in this regard: those “saved” Christians who persist in various mortal sins have “fallen from grace” and have “no inheritance in the KoG or of Christ”.

Blessings!
 
Wow, there is a lot of posts already! I will hopefully be able to reply tomorrow. Interesting note on the translations Third Day.

While searching the web, (I should probably stop doing that) I found this:

warrantedfaith.org/theology/calvinism/485-calvinism-declared-by-the-church-fathers

I know, probably a lot of quotes taken out of context and so on. The quotes on Irresistable Grace and Perserverance of the Saints and the most interesting.
I know it is a lot to ask, but perhaps there is someone who is well versed in the Church Fathers that could debunk this?

Anyway, I will be get back to you all later.
 
I think I am right in saying that Catholicism teaches that Gods grace has to be co-operted with in order for us to be saved, and that we can freely reject God’s grace at any time and sin.

Calvins theology teaches that if we are truly saved then we cannot cut ourself off from God - we will never commit mortal sin or turn away from Christ. Salvation here is seen as a total change of heart where we would not want to sin after the salvation event.

I have a few questions:

If baptism provides us with the grace of justification and the Holy Spirit, why do we even want to sin afterwards? I understand that we have to co-operate, but it seems that even those who are recieving sacraments often have habitual sins that need to be overcome.
It also doesn’t seem to make sense that God would ask us to not sin if we still have a fallen human nature - and then condemn us to hell for not overcoming it.

Here are a few scripture quotes that I hope others may be able to explain in light of Catholic teaching. They seem to me to point towards the OSAS understanding, although I know that the teaching is unhistorical.

John 10: 28 - “I give them eternal life, and they shall never perish; no one can snatch them out of my hand. My Father, who has given them to me, is greater than all; no one can snatch them out of my Father’s hand."

Eph 4:30 -* “And do not bring sorrow to God’s Holy Spirit by the way you live. Remember, he is the one who has identified you as his own, guaranteeing that you will be saved on the day of redemption.”*

1 John 3:9: 9 No one who is born of God will continue to sin, because God’s seed remains in them; they cannot go on sinning, because they have been born of God. 10 This is how we know who the children of God are and who the children of the devil are"

Heb 10:6 If we deliberately keep on sinning after we have received the knowledge of the truth, no sacrifice for sins is left, 27 but only a fearful expectation of judgment and of raging fire that will consume the enemies of God.

1 John 5.16-17: *“If you see your brother or sister committing what is not a mortal sin, you will ask, and God will give life to such a one - to those whose sin is not mortal. There is sin that is mortal; I do not say you should pray about that. All wrongdoing is sin, but there is sin that is not mortal” *
I know the above quote it used by Catholics to understand the difference between mortal and venial sin, but if we can be commit mortal sin (perish), and then come back to God, it seems to contradict the other verses above (john 10) that say that those in Christ will not perish.

Is there any biblical evidence of someone after repentance commiting mortal sin and perishing (after the holy spirit comes at pentecost) and and then coming back to God?

Hope you can help
Romans 10:13 tells us how to be saved. It does not tell us we remain saved.

This begs the question: is being saved irreducible or can you lose your salvation?

Knowing the consequence of sin is that it separates us from God, Jesus tells His disciples [Christians] to pray for forgiveness of their sins [Luke 11:2].

So, even though Jesus’ disciples were saved by Romans 10:13, they must continue to seek forgiveness of their sins.

If being saved is irreducible, then it follows that Luke 11:2 would be not be necessary and you could sin with impunity.

So, would God save you to sin? Clearly, no.

Therefore, salvation is not irreducible and can be lost.
 
Wow, there is a lot of posts already! I will hopefully be able to reply tomorrow. Interesting note on the translations Third Day.

While searching the web, (I should probably stop doing that) I found this:

warrantedfaith.org/theology/calvinism/485-calvinism-declared-by-the-church-fathers

I know, probably a lot of quotes taken out of context and so on. The quotes on Irresistable Grace and Perserverance of the Saints and the most interesting.
I know it is a lot to ask, but perhaps there is someone who is well versed in the Church Fathers that could debunk this?

Anyway, I will be get back to you all later.
Wolfpup,I took a look at the link on Calvinsm that you provided. They claim that the Chruch Fathers believed in all five points of Calvinism TULIP. Of course they didn’t provide any footnotes on where these quotes are found. If you read them carefully NONE of the prove their claims.
I did a word search on the one the provided for Justin Martyr. Here is what their website posted:

LIMITED ATONEMENT
Justin Martyr (A.D. 150): “He endured the sufferings for those men whose souls are [actually] purified from all iniquity…As Jacob served Laban for the cattle that were spotted, and of carious forms, so Christ served even to the cross for men of every kind, of many and various shapes, procuring them by His blood and the mystery of the cross.”

What is interesting about this one is that the quotes are from two different chapters of Justin’s Dialogue with Trypho, The first that I highlighted in blue is from chapter 41 and the second quote in red from chapter 134

They tie them together to make it appear that Justin is teaching Linited Atonement. Here is the first one in context

CHAPTER 41 THE OBLATION OF FINE FLOUR WAS A FIGURE OF THE EUCHARIST
Justin: And the offering of fine flour, sirs, which was prescribed to be presented on behalf of those purified from leprosy, was a type of the bread of the Eucharist, the celebration of which our Lord Jesus Christ prescribed, in remembrance of the suffering which He endured on behalf of those who are purified in soul from all iniquity, in order that we may at the same time thank God for having created the world, with all things therein, for the sake of man, and for delivering us from the evil in which we were, and for utterly overthrowing principalities and powers by Him who suffered according to His will. Hence God speaks by the mouth of Malachi, one of the twelve [prophets], as I said before, about the sacrifices at that time presented by you: ‘I have no pleasure in you, saith the Lord; and I will not accept your sacrifices at your hands: for, from the rising of the sun unto the going down of the same, My name has been glorified among the Gentiles, and in every place incense is offered to My name, and a pure offering: for My name is great among the Gentiles, saith the Lord: but ye profane it.’ He then speaks of those Gentiles, namely us, who in every place offer sacrifices to Him, i.e., the bread of the Eucharist, and also the cup of the Eucharist, affirming both that we glorify His name, and that you profane

CHAPTER 134 THE MARRIAGES OF JACOB ARE A FIGURE OF THE CHURCH
Now Leah is your people and synagogue; but Rachel is our Church. And for these, and for the servants in both, Christ even now serves. For while Noah gave to the two sons the seed of the third as servants, now on the other hand Christ has come to restore both the free sons and the servants amongst them, conferring the same honour on all of them who keep His commandments; even as the children of the free women and the children of the bond women born to Jacob were all sons, and equal in dignity. And it was foretold what each should be according to rank and according to fore-knowledge. Jacob served Laban for speckled and many-spotted sheep; and Christ served, even to the slavery of the cross, for the various and many-formed races of mankind, acquiring them by the blood and mystery of the cross

In the first Justin is speaking about the Eucharist and shows how the Book of Malachi is a prophesy of the sacrifice of the Mass and the Eucharist.

The second doesn’t show limited atonement at all. Their quote says “Christ served, even to the slavery of the cross, for the various and many-formed races of mankind, **acquiring them by the blood **and mystery of the cross.”
I don’t know where limited atonement is in that verse.Scripture says that Christ died for the sins of the whole world. Justin isn’t saying anything different.
 
I have now read the posts from yesterday, and a lot of it makes real sense.
James 5:19:
My brothers, if one of you should wander from the truth and someone should bring him back, remember this: Whoever turns a sinner from the error of his way will save a soul from death and cover over a multitude of sins
That is exactly what I am looking for, thank you. Clearly that person has been cut off from salvation (since there are so many mentions that sinning after baptism = losing salvation) and has been brought back.

I guess it boils down to whether the earliest Christians had formal confession or not. Did they have to confess to a priest? I know there are references in EFCs for confession but was it the same as in later times - a priest acting In Persona Christi. I am not sure that the apostolic fathers make reference to this.

Also some EFCs also seem to think no forgiveness after baptism.

“Christ shall not die again in behalf of those who now commit sin, for death shall no more have dominion over Him; but the Son shall come in the glory of the Father, requiring from His stewards and dispensers the money which He had entrusted to them, with usury; and from those to whom He had given most shall He demand most. We ought not, therefore, as that presbyter remarks, to be puffed up, nor be severe upon those of old time, but ought ourselves to fear, lest perchance, after [we have come to] the knowledge of Christ, if we do things displeasing to God, we obtain no further forgiveness of sins, but be shut out from His kingdom. And therefore it was that Paul said, ‘For if [God] spared not the natural branches, [take heed] lest He also spare not thee, who, when thou wert a wild olive tree, wert grafted into the fatness of the olive tree, and wert made a partaker of its fatness.’” Irenaeus, Against Heresies, 4:27:2 (A.D. 180)." (scripturecatholic.com)

I just don’t understand, taking in all that Scripture and the Church Fathers have to say on the issue many people still have problems with repetitive, habitual sinning after they have been baptised. They suggest that baptism makes a person new, changes behavior, and that sinning afterwards is the exception not the rule. Surely, we are supposed to become holier each day and yet so many Catholic saints as they go on realise how sinful they are. Many Popes and Saints have confession daily. It just seems to someone who has not ever experienced baptism or confession that it seems to change nothing in a person. We are still all sinful creatures despite the sacraments. I don’t mean to cause offense by saying all this, but I really want to believe in Christ and his Church but this is a major stumbling block for me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top