A Friend Who Pulls Me Both Ways

  • Thread starter Thread starter harper
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
H

harper

Guest
I am a single, middle-aged woman. I have a friend, a boyfriend, I suppose, who strongly encourages me to live my faith, although he himself is not even Christian. He encourages me to go to Perpetual Adoration, respects all the physical boundaries of Catholic teaching, and when I’m having a hard day, reminds me of what the Bible, the Church, or the Saints would say about suffering. He builds me up and encourages me.

I truly believe I have become a better person, and grown in my faith, as a result of being with him. As one example, I have found deeper compassion and forgiveness for someone who has caused me a lot of grief, as a direct result of my time with him.

Yet…in some other respects, spending time with him is ‘leading me into temptation’ and I can see ways in which I have fallen down, too, as a result of being with him. For instance, he has lived a very worldly life. Sometimes, he says things that turn my thoughts to places I would have been better off not going.

Please give me some advice on deciding where the balance is with continuing to see someone who I believe overall has been good for me, and yet who pulls me the opposite direction in other ways.
 
Seems upon reading your post that there is sort of a vagueness about several things. Clarifying things might help. It may be time to bite the bullet and have those conversations that can sometimes be awkward but that are often the only way to find out where things stand.

First, have an honest soul-searching conversation with your own self and God. What vocation do you think God is calling you toward at this time in your life? Could it be marriage? Or should you remain in the single celibate state for the time being? Talk to a priest also about all of it if you can.

Then, if you think God might be calling you to marriage, is this a person you might marry? Would you and he be able to help each other get to Heaven? Is he open to the Catholic Faith for himself at all? If you married him, would your faith differences be a bridgeable gap, or would they become divisive over time?

In doing your own soul searching with regards to temptations is it maybe time to reaffirm your commitment to celibacy? If it’s getting too difficult with him around while you’re wrestling with the above questions, perhaps spend less time - or at least less alone time - together. Be together more in public than in private.

If it doesn’t seem right that you progress this relationship toward marriage, can you remain good buddies without sexual temptations? Maybe you just need to acknowlege that it’s tricky and have strategies in place. Be proactive.

After you get through all of the above, talk with him about what you’ve concluded.
 
Yes, 3Doctors, I posted this today. I joined years ago and found my way back. I thought I had posted at the time, but maybe I never did. Regardless, yes, this was posted today.

Thank you for your advice.

There is just about zero chance of marriage with this man at this point. Of course, God works in funny ways, and part of what keeps me seeing him is exactly your question about helping each other get to Heaven. I see myself becoming a better person and growing in my faith with him. Likewise, he is returning to prayer, thinking more deeply about his faith, and has stopped the very worldly lifestyle he was living, as a result of being with me. Yes, I believe we are both drawing closer to God and Heaven as a result of being together.

Celibacy isn’t the problem. He’s committed to not doing anything beyond the bounds of my faith or doing anything that would leave my conscience uncomfortable. The problem is simply where my own thoughts stray, knowing how he has lived and how his friends still do. Of course, I grew up with parents who kept porn magazines and some graphic books in plain sight of us kids, which had its impact 😦 so I’d be fighting this battle anyway.
 
Though you boyfriend has done good to you, he also leads you into temptation. Do you honestly think that you should marry someone who leads you into temptation? I hope that you get to meet a very holy Catholic man who does nothing but good to you and who will serve only to help you to become a saint. God bless you.
 
Thank you, 3Doctors. What a wonderful and encouraging site!

As I ponder the replies here, I’m (still!) pulled both ways. Of course I shouldn’t be with someone who leads me into temptation…and yet, are there people out there so perfect that they will never lead us into the smallest temptation? Maybe I’m a bit cynical about the world, but the fact that there’s a man out there who now basically refuses to do any more than hold my hand, who insists on behaving in a way acceptable to Catholic teaching amazes me. That it’s coming from a man with such a worldly background, who doesn’t even call himself Christian, amazes me even more. I see miracles happening in him, things so unbelievable I believe they could only be God working–and that, too, makes me hesitant to end this.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top