One story I know is about Wild Man’s Island. (This May not be the correct version of the story, I can’t remember it that well-if you know the story, feel free to correct me)
It takes place in the Great Lakes region.
I believe it was about a fisherman who was rejected by the girl he loved, and who went out in his boat in a storm. Needless to say, he got shipwrecked on a tiny deserted island. He tried in vain to cry for help. The people on shore heard his faint and desperate cries, but the water was too rough for them to go out and look for him.
Although they found his battered up canoe on shore weeks later, they never found him. It then that the people on the mainland started to hear pitiful cries for help whenever it stormed. They would rush in their boats to the source of the noise-a deserted island-but found no one.
Because of these cries, the island became known as Wild Man’s Island. It is said that today, if you listen closely during a storm, you might hear the cry’s of the wildman’s ghost too.
Wild man’s island is a real place, and there could be some truth to the tale or how it got its name.
Also, my dad used to tell me a lot of creepy stories when I was little, especially about witches that kidnapped little girls and tried to turn them into witches.