A Muslim I know suggested I read the Koran

  • Thread starter Thread starter Annie
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you want to learn about Muslims, talk to them and ask questions. Reading the Koran doesn’t really help, for these reasons.
  1. Maybe one out of a hundred Muslims has read the Koran. They just say they do. He probably hasn’t
  2. Islam is based on the Hadith literature, which is supposed to be interpretation of the Koran.
  3. Their faith is based on what their mufti tells them. (preaching) and on their culture. Which part of the Islamic world is he from? This makes a difference.
Two out of three ain’t bad. The interpretations are called tafsir. The ahadith are mostly random tales with no relation to the Qur’an.

The Qur’an itself is a relatively brief read, but because it’s a sayings collection, it’s hard to follow along, like the gospel of Thomas. It was assembled well after the fact from memory and scraps scratched onto cow shoulder blades and similar surfaces. It was a preliterate society without ready access to papyrus, or editors.

There was some effort to sort the collection by topic, but by the nature of the composition, one ayah spoken years later often precedes another it was never intended to complement.

The largest theological division is between the sayings from Mecca and the sayings from Medinah, when Muhammad was outside or inside the power structure. Where the sayings conflict, precedence goes to the later, Medinan ayah by their theory of abrogation.

There’s honestly no reason anyone should avoid the Qur’an, but I’ve found the ahadith are much more informative. Use a search tool. Iqra!

And yes, you need to learn a bit of Arabic, too. Not much, a couple dozen words will do for the most part.

But if you’re going to read them with a muslim, keep in mind that the Qur’an is considered the principle miracle of Islam, comparable to the resurrection for Christians. Treat the book like you’d treat the host if you want to avoid offense. That means wash your hands, and don’t be perusing it while eating a sandwich, (at least while they’re watching).

Keep in mind that individual muslims don’t use their sacred texts to make their own religious rulings. Those come from imams following formal study in one of a half dozen recognized schools of fiqh, some of which are in a great deal of religious tension.
 
Last edited:
It’s not so much that I want to avoid reading the Koran; I simply don’t have the time or mental energy. And if I did, I would probably have reading certain parts of the Bible higher up on my list…

Maybe I will just have to accept that I am not going to become an evangelist to Muslims overnight 🙂

Thank you for all the advice–if I were to read it, he might well have caught me eating at the same time as it would have been during lunch :o
 
Last edited:
the God portrayed isn’t very merciful and comes across as much more of a “bean counter”. The God in the Bible (the same God) is portrayed much more merciful even in the Old Testament
I had heard that, and also that they think things are good because Allah said so rather than the other way around as we do.

I hope to work that into conversation… 🙂
 
The main reason he would converse with you is for work purposes or to try to convert you. I doubt seriously that you will be able to have a logical discussion with him.

For instance, ask him if he believes women should have four male witnesses before their story of being raped will be believed by a court.
 
Well, we’ve often chatted about non-work stuff like family. General conversation. I don’t think he would have Waite for over a year to start trying to convert me, but I do think that people who like their religion want to share it, in addition to any suggestions or requirements to evangelize.
 
I like Catholicism and think ot has more to offer than Islam does? Is that not enough?

ETA: and reading the Bible is not what I think is best to start with. That’s not really what I “want him to do.”
 
Last edited:
For instance, ask him if he believes women should have four male witnesses before their story of being raped will be believed by a court.
I wouldn’t really want to come out that strongly against his religion. I would more like to show what goodness there is in mine.
 
Well, I do not have any inherent curiosity about Islam because I am Catholic. I also don’t want to learn to multiply in Roman numerals since I know how to do it with Arabic numerals, which is a lot better.

To evangelize, I think it is good to know something of what the other person believes, which is why I asked my question originally. But I don’t think I need to go further than that.
 
Well the Quran has a lot of the same stories as the Bible OT. I once read the story of Moses and Joseph in the Quran and what struck me is the mentioning of crucifixion as a method used in Egypt. There is zero historical evidence of such a thing. Needless to say the discussion with the Muslim friend went south pretty quickly and I have never accepted any invitation to read the Quran since.
 
Last edited:
There are some VERY GOOD Catholic answers websites that deal with how to answer Muslims. Google them first for how to respond then read the Koran. You can ask your friend to read Genesis,Exodus and the New Testament. They deny the Divinity of Jesus. Talk about how much you love God. The loving relationship we have with God is what they are lacking.
 
If a Muslim is evangelizing to you, odds are they are pretty devout. I’ve known a few devout Muslims very well and I can tell you that their efforts at evangelization are often a one-way street.
If you reply in kind, you run the risk of personally offending them (sounds strange by Western standards, I know), and they will often turn their efforts elsewhere.
Ultimately, this makes sense if conversion is the goal, assuming all souls being equal.
Your efforts are commendable, but your time may be better spent engaging fellow Christians.
 
I’ve known a few devout Muslims very well and I can tell you that their efforts at evangelization are often a one-way street.
Isn´t this true for all kinds of evangelization? Who ever wants to convert another person into his/her faith doesn´t want this vice-versa.
So, I don´t see why it´s taken negative as “one way street” when it comes from a muslim.
 
Last edited:
@alice24
I think Alice makes a good point, and it is something I have wondered about before. I feel a certain way about my Faith; don’t others feel the same way about theirs?

On the one hand, St Peter said to always be ready the explain the reasons for our faith, which to me does means I do not have to persuade people or “win” arguments, just show that I am reasonable. OTOH, Christ said to go out and teach all nations.

I follow a wobbly line when it comes to evangelizing 🙂
 
If you know your Faith well I don’t believe it would pose a problem for you.
The only think that happened when I read the Koran it’s that I was bored to death, you may want to spend your time with better books
 
To the OP, perhaps if he mentions you reading the Quran again you deflect a bit and ask him what his favorite verse is and then mention a favorite verse of yours from the Bible. Then just discuss those! Or ask him what the Quran says about family…or working with others in a business…something that is unlikely to be dramatically different between your faiths…kind of neutral ground type questions.

I see nothing wrong with saying I just don’t have time to give it a good reading right now but am interested in how our faiths are similar…or different. This would keep things at a slower and gentler sharing and give time for both of you to develop a genuine friendship. I’d avoid controversy completely. It’s not needed and you have to work together.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top