A protestant who is torn in half

  • Thread starter Thread starter Finding_Faith
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
:)= friendly
Given an anti-catholic background how do you ask a question about catholism without sounding anti-catholic? ie Anti-catholic “teaching” catholics worship Mary. How would you phrase a question in this regards without sounding anti-catholic.
🙂 It is hard for me to understand your question. Do you genuinely want to know? I guess I used to be anti-catholic because I was indoctrinated in that line of thought for the first 25 years of my life in church and in school. Now, I am moving way beyond that and moving toward being Catholic. I guess if you ask if Catholics worship Mary, you (as a non-catholic) do not really know if Catholics worship Mary, so you don’t know the question is anti-catholic. I guess it depends on how you phrase it, or the tone of your voice?? Example: I have heard that Catholics worship Mary. Is that true? What do you really believe??? :o ?
 
Reply to page 7, post #102
It is impossible to see the Roman Catholic denomination as anything but a “competitor” when they call unity the same thing as submission.
There is no unity possible when submission to the Pope is the only permitted outcome. True unity is when you can accept differences, and still be “one in Christ.”
Like a tent revival? Wednesday night Bible studies in living rooms?
Changing the subject shows you are defending a paradigm and hardening your heart to the truth of CCC817, 818, & 819 (+ footnotes). They are a condensation of the official document"That They May Be One". I invite you to read and understand the Church’s vision for unity and if you can’t set aside your prejudice and don’t even care to know then don’t waste your time. Your concept of submission to the Pope is insulting, by the way. You’re way off. But hey, it’s our fault for not explaining it to you clearly enough. Why? Because it’s off topic.

Reply to page 7, post #102
No one wants that right to define what only your church can define. it is pertinent though for those of us participating here for Protestants to compare & contrast, and state how what you say hits us. The first thing I notice about your reply is that you resort to “authority” over scripture.

Let me quote me for you from Post 107:
I’m sorry you have not comprehended my post. Nowhere have I said the Church has authority over Scriptures. That is a misunderstanding of the relationship the Chuch has with the Scriptures. She has always been the servant of the Scriptures…
Baptism is a public event. The privitization of Christianity has been undermining Christian unity since the Prot. Revolt and staunch sola scripturists refuse to aknowledge the facts, and continue to obstruct Jesus’ prayer “That they may be one…”

I think this board has an ignore feature somewhere. Perhaps you have me on ignore by accident.
 
🙂 It is hard for me to understand your question. Do you genuinely want to know? I guess I used to be anti-catholic because I was indoctrinated in that line of thought for the first 25 years of my life in church and in school. Now, I am moving way beyond that and moving toward being Catholic. I guess if you ask if Catholics worship Mary, you (as a non-catholic) do not really know if Catholics worship Mary, so you don’t know the question is anti-catholic. I guess it depends on how you phrase it, or the tone of your voice?? Example: I have heard that Catholics worship Mary. Is that true? What do you really believe??? :o ?
My favorite BIBLICAL video on Mary:
youtube.com/watch?v=0aU18v-tl8I
 
It is obvious that the SDA still clings to its foundational hatred of the Catholic Church. SDA libraries contain writings teaching that the Catholic Church is the “whore of Babylon” and that the pope is the antichrist. Truly fringe stuff. I have not been able to locate an SDA-related website that is completely free of this hatred and prejudice. And, as with the LDS and JWs, their purpose, at some level, is simply to lead Catholics away from the ‘whore’ and toward their privately interpreted opinion of “truth”.

The Catholic Church considers them true Christians, by dint of their valid baptism. In return they hurl epithets. Ask yourself: Is that Christian?
 
It is obvious that the SDA still clings to its foundational hatred of the Catholic Church. SDA libraries contain writings teaching that the Catholic Church is the “whore of Babylon” and that the pope is the antichrist. Truly fringe stuff. I have not been able to locate an SDA-related website that is completely free of this hatred and prejudice. And, as with the LDS and JWs, their purpose, at some level, is simply to lead Catholics away from the ‘whore’ and toward their privately interpreted opinion of “truth”.

The Catholic Church considers them true Christians, by dint of their valid baptism. In return they hurl epithets. Ask yourself: Is that Christian?
Talk about being off topic…Are you scared that the OP just might see something I have said here?

The Roman Catholic denomination will accept no unity but submission to their own leader’s views on Christian dogma. Absolutely nothing else will be seen or pronounced as “unity” unless this submission has happened. The OP needs to understand what they are getting into; and I think perhaps you are concerned that some of the teachings you espouse here just are not Biblical.

The Roman Catholic denomination does not “accept” my Protestant baptism; unless I first submit to Rome. At best; I am a “schismatic” in the eyes of your Church. If you really “accept” my baptism, why not the OP’s? Why do so many forum members urge him to abandon his family & close friends just to join your denomination; if indeed you really do “accept” baptism in other denominations?
 
Talk about being off topic…Are you scared that the OP just might see something I have said here?
The only thing the OP will see are your constant strawman arguments.
The Roman Catholic denomination will accept no unity but submission to their own leader’s views on Christian dogma.
That’s like saying the SDA protestant denomination only submits to a text written by men excluding any involvment by the Holy Spirit.
The Roman Catholic denomination does not “accept” my Protestant baptism; unless I first submit to Rome.
More straw. The Church accepts ALL Baptisms in the Trinitarian formula. Even yours if it was done that way.
At best; I am a “schismatic” in the eyes of your Church.
You’re definitely not a schismatic. You’re a splinter protestant sect that is even many times labeled a cult by these same protestant brethren.
If you really “accept” my baptism, why not the OP’s? Why do so many forum members urge him to abandon his family & close friends just to join your denomination; if indeed you really do “accept” baptism in other denominations?
We urge him to follow his conscience and seek the truth. A truth within the Church that he may be called to. Baptism doesn’t mean you’re also free to remain in your errors.
 
🙂 It is hard for me to understand your question. Do you genuinely want to know? I guess I used to be anti-catholic because I was indoctrinated in that line of thought for the first 25 years of my life in church and in school. Now, I am moving way beyond that and moving toward being Catholic. I guess if you ask if Catholics worship Mary, you (as a non-catholic) do not really know if Catholics worship Mary, so you don’t know the question is anti-catholic. I guess it depends on how you phrase it, or the tone of your voice?? Example: I have heard that Catholics worship Mary. Is that true? What do you really believe??? :o ?
The question itself is not a-C, just something that so many of them come at Catholics with. You’re right…tone etc are important, but alas, the intarweb fora lacks that capacity.

There is an excellent tract from Our Sunday Visitor called Top Ten Questions Catholics are Asked and it covers this and 9 other issues that we are often asked. If you want a copy, just PM me your address and I’ll mail it to you. I keep a supply on hand. 🙂

As to Mary worship…we do not. here are links to very good articles from catholic Answers online Library.
True. Always happens when those who genuinely hate the Catholic Church drop in.
Easy PO18G. we should never stoop to the other guy’s standards bro. Remember 1st Peter 3: 8-17. 👍
 
Easy PO18G. we should never stoop to the other guy’s standards bro. Remember 1st Peter 3: 8-17. 👍
I could have used “prefer less” instead of “hate”, but that would not have conveyed the level of animus that is directed at the Catholic Church by a certain non-Catholic community. My comment was in response to certain SDA-based anti-Catholic comments. Being all-too familiar with the SDA and their virulent anti-Cathlicism, I believe I used the correct term as applies to their traditional and current teaching toward our faith. I should have pointed that bit out, for the sake of clarity. Such comments serve only to confuse those who are genuinely seeking the truth.

Bottom line: Point well taken. Mea culpa! :o
 
I have no idea what happen here,but there is a lot of arguments going on here.but for those who like to know i was not able to make it to my first mass this past week,but i am determine to go this week.please pray for me so i can get the answers i seek.thank you
 
I have no idea what happen here,but there is a lot of arguments going on here.but for those who like to know i was not able to make it to my first mass this past week,but i am determine to go this week.please pray for me so i can get the answers i seek.thank you
Sorry about all of the detours! It is a sad fact of my human nature that I am easily sidetracked. I offer my regrets here. As well, when some people realize that you may be seeking a different communion, they feel an odd sense of loss, and the inevitable arguments begin. Seeking the truth is a life-long endeavor. I suggest taking your time, reading up on Catholicism, and praying over it.

May Christ’s peace be with you.
 
I could have used “prefer less” instead of “hate”, but that would not have conveyed the level of animus that is directed at the Catholic Church by a certain non-Catholic community. My comment was in response to certain SDA-based anti-Catholic comments. Being all-too familiar with the SDA and their virulent anti-Cathlicism, I believe I used the correct term as applies to their traditional and current teaching toward our faith. I should have pointed that bit out, for the sake of clarity. Such comments serve only to confuse those who are genuinely seeking the truth.

Bottom line: Point well taken. Mea culpa! :o
👍😃
 
I have no idea what happen here,but there is a lot of arguments going on here.but for those who like to know i was not able to make it to my first mass this past week,but i am determine to go this week.please pray for me so i can get the answers i seek.thank you
What happened here is what happens in family courts across the globe. Someday the children’s voices will count for more than the blind arrogance of their parents.

Prot101 is banned. Same response, same results. The definition of insanity is…? I pray with you.
 
This thread is getting off topic.
Perhaps 'Torn in half" could find out if the Protesters/Protestants Martin Luther and Calvin disputed the perpetual virginity of Mary. I don’t believe Mary’s virginity was argued by them.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top