A Question About A Nun

  • Thread starter Thread starter BlyssfulDreamer
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I was wondering whether she was a nun or whether she adopts that convention of using “brother” and “sister” for men and women like they do in some communities. I was thinking since I would assume that a nun attending a TLM would dress in a traditional habit (then again, maybe her community doesn’t, so…)
 
“Women don’t hold the door open for other women, only men do that.”

I’m a woman and usually hold the door for anyone, man or woman, near me. I can’t see letting the door shut on someone when it is so easy to spend the extra 2 seconds to be courteous. Most people say thank you. I also appreciate it when men and women hold the door for me if I am close. It seems like basic common sense. 🤷
 
Don’t go reporting the nun (sister?) to her superiors. The only thing you know so far is that she was grumpy and rude to you. In any case, if you have another run-in with her, AND if she is in some kind of teaching or authority position at the parish, or belongs to an order affiliated with the parish, THEN it would be appropriate to speak with her superior.

That’s my take anyway.
 
After Mass today at the TLM oratory, I was leaving the church and held the door open for a lady(she was in street clothes) behind me who was also leaving. She the chastised me for holding the door open for her, saying that “Women don’t hold the door open for other women, only men do that.” She also said “You exit the church through the right door, not the left.” (The church has double doors) I was about speechless by this time and said I was sorry, though I wasn’t sure for what. She asked if I was married and I answered i was and she said she was Sister So and So and she dropped her hat and as I was reaching to catch it, i accidentally brushed her sleeve and she stepped back almost aghast and said “You never touch a sister!” By this time I was almost in tears and I wished her a nice day and turned around and left.

During Communion (we had no altar servers today) and she was next to me at the Communion rail and when I passed the paten off to her she wouldn’t take ot, as she had a crucifix in her hands that was quite large…so the priest took it from me and put it in front of her.

I don’t know …this is all strange and I feel I have done something wrong to offend her…or am I being completely silly?

Thanks and please feel free to throw the books at me if need be so i won’t make the same mistake next time.
When we visit the sisters at the convent (they meet with us homeschoolers once a month or more) we hug (so we touch LOL). We hold doors for each other and the kids always fight over who gets to hold the door.😃 The sisters also remind us that we should smile more. The doors at the convent are all single so I can’t remark on that, but at the church across the street they are double and both sides are used by us all sisters, lay persons and kids.

I think I would pray alot for her and any others sisters from her convent.
 
Yeah, never mind all this pomo counsuling crud… she’s a mean old bag. You’re not wrong, come on you were doing her a favor. I’ve never heard of that silly idea where only men can hold the doors open. What, you’re supposed to slam the door in her face!?

LOL.
 
After Mass today at the TLM oratory, I was leaving the church and held the door open for a lady(she was in street clothes) behind me who was also leaving. She the chastised me for holding the door open for her, saying that “Women don’t hold the door open for other women, only men do that.” She also said “You exit the church through the right door, not the left.” (The church has double doors) I was about speechless by this time and said I was sorry, though I wasn’t sure for what. She asked if I was married and I answered i was and she said she was Sister So and So and she dropped her hat and as I was reaching to catch it, i accidentally brushed her sleeve and she stepped back almost aghast and said “You never touch a sister!” By this time I was almost in tears and I wished her a nice day and turned around and left.

During Communion (we had no altar servers today) and she was next to me at the Communion rail and when I passed the paten off to her she wouldn’t take ot, as she had a crucifix in her hands that was quite large…so the priest took it from me and put it in front of her.

I don’t know …this is all strange and I feel I have done something wrong to offend her…or am I being completely silly?

Thanks and please feel free to throw the books at me if need be so i won’t make the same mistake next time.
Whether she is or isn’t a Sister, it sounds like she sneaked out alone today - without her keeper. I’m not joking. Rudeness at the door of the Church is sort of extreme behavior.
 
Be nice to her every time you see her. It will drive her crazy.
😃 I second this!
She’s the one with the problem, not you, OP, you sound a very nice polite well brought up person!
Be as sweet as you can to her and pray for her.
 
=BlyssfulDreamer;3333206] She asked if I was married and I answered I was and she said she was Sister So and So
Of all the things to ask " are you married?" Not a hello or thank you? very odd
 
I think, more than anything, this was God’s way of telling you to pray for this Nun.

Nuns have bad days too.

JD
:yup: Have to agree with this.

Blyssful… you did nothing wrong. Holding the door for the person behind you is just a courtesy, going out any double door is not wrong (but after I thought about this, it kind of goes with the idea of you always stay to the right side so you would go in the door closest to your right and out the door closest to your right - a different door each way if there is a double door but there is no hard and fast rule let alone church rule about this), as for touching her I never heard that either and I am a cradle Catholic who has had her fair share of Sisters for friends and hugs are in order sometimes as well as hand holding when praying in a venue outside of Mass.

Brenda V.
 
I never stated, implied, alluded to, or even thought anything about pyschiatric counseling. I am not sure where that came from. I referred only to counseling, i.e., in any form–which is why I did not specify any particular type. I recoiled at the amazingly hasty and quite premature suggestion that some might be needed, on the basis of one person’s version of a single encounter.
For a street-dressed Sister to flip out before even leaving the church suggests a problem. If she was simply having a bad day, then she needs to seek out BlyssfulDreamer and apologize, nothing less. That was a horrid example to her, and anyone who may have witnessed it.
 
Thanks to one and all for your very helpful, heartfelt responses. This incident did take me by surprise and I have thought about it often today.

I am sure Sister will be at the TLM tomorrow morning and if circumstances present themselves in the same way tomorrow, I don’t think I would do anything different…maybe a recurring smile from a familiar face might be what she needs and a prayer on her behalf also.

Thanks again everyone…🙂 and God Bless you.
 
After Mass today at the TLM oratory, I was leaving the church and held the door open for a lady(she was in street clothes) behind me who was also leaving. She the chastised me for holding the door open for her, saying that “Women don’t hold the door open for other women, only men do that.” She also said “You exit the church through the right door, not the left.” (The church has double doors) I was about speechless by this time and said I was sorry, though I wasn’t sure for what. She asked if I was married and I answered i was and she said she was Sister So and So and she dropped her hat and as I was reaching to catch it, i accidentally brushed her sleeve and she stepped back almost aghast and said “You never touch a sister!” By this time I was almost in tears and I wished her a nice day and turned around and left.

During Communion (we had no altar servers today) and she was next to me at the Communion rail and when I passed the paten off to her she wouldn’t take ot, as she had a crucifix in her hands that was quite large…so the priest took it from me and put it in front of her.

I don’t know …this is all strange and I feel I have done something wrong to offend her…or am I being completely silly?

Thanks and please feel free to throw the books at me if need be so i won’t make the same mistake next time.
Looks like someone has found it difficult to live a life of celibacy… :cool:
 
Looks like someone has found it difficult to live a life of celibacy… :cool:
…{guilty snicker…lol!}

…all of the nuns I have known have been very loving, firm and make you write 500 lines for talking in class, but the sweet way they punished you made you do the punishment gladly!😛

Sister: “no speaking in class please” (smiling)
Us kids: “snicker…talk talk talk…snicker”
Sister: (said while smiling)…I love you and God loves you dear ones, but now you will write 500 times “I will not talk while Sister is talking…I love all of you!”
Us kids::eek: …yes ma’am!:o
 
Hmmm…I seriously doubt this woman is a nun. I think she’s got some mental health issues. You might ask Father who she is, I’m sure he knows - I’m sure you aren’t the only person she’s done this to. I don’t think she needs counseling, but I don’t think she was just “having a bad day” either. Not allowing a woman to hold the door, not allowing anyone to touch her, only entering and exiting a church through the right door (not the left - in Latin, “sinister” - hmmmm) yeah, there’s some mental health issues going on here! That’s not just “being crotchety.” Pray for her, but don’t let her upset you. My guess is that she’s off her meds. 🙂
 
Hmmm…I seriously doubt this woman is a nun. I think she’s got some mental health issues. You might ask Father who she is, I’m sure he knows - I’m sure you aren’t the only person she’s done this to. I don’t think she needs counseling, but I don’t think she was just “having a bad day” either. Not allowing a woman to hold the door, not allowing anyone to touch her, only entering and exiting a church through the right door (not the left - in Latin, “sinister” - hmmmm) yeah, there’s some mental health issues going on here! That’s not just “being crotchety.” Pray for her, but don’t let her upset you. My guess is that she’s off her meds. 🙂
I was kind of thinking along the same lines. And to me, another thing that seemed odd in the OP’s description was carrying a large crucifix up to Communion. Of course I don’t know, because I don’t know the lady, but some of this behavior reminds me of some of the things some patients used to do when I was a student nurse doing my psych rotation. I’m not being unkind here, nor judgmental, just making an observation. Her behavior does not seem to be normal, Sister or not. She needs prayers.
 
I was kind of thinking along the same lines. And to me, another thing that seemed odd in the OP’s description was carrying a large crucifix up to Communion. Of course I don’t know, because I don’t know the lady, but some of this behavior reminds me of some of the things some patients used to do when I was a student nurse doing my psych rotation. I’m not being unkind here, nor judgmental, just making an observation. Her behavior does not seem to be normal, Sister or not. She needs prayers.
That psych rotation in nursing school, no matter how many years ago it was (many, in my case 🙂 ), serves us well! I hope the OP isn’t frightened of this woman - she is odd, but doesn’t sound dangerous - and prayers are certainly needed. It must be challenging to go through life a little out of step with the rest of the world.
 
In the U.S., you always exit or enter on the right.
The woman may have simply been a nutjob, and not a sister of anything.
 
In the U.S., you always exit or enter on the right.
Well, not necessarily when it comes to the doors, and we aren’t so particular about it here in the US that we point it out to people and demand they use the right side only to exit. Nor do we say “In church you use the right side to exit” as if that’s some sort of rule for church-goers. In fact, I don’t think it’s something you would say to anyone in any circumstance…I have never heard someone say that, for instance, in a movie theater, or restaurant, or any public place I can think of…I’ve never heard someone say it, period. Unless you’re obsessive-compulsive, I don’t know that anyone would care what side you enter/exit on. Generally speaking we veer to the right, just as we drive on the right side of the road, but no one gets irate if you exit through the left side of a doorway and tells you “You exit church through the right door, not the left” as the OP posted.
 
In the U.S., you always exit or enter on the right.
The woman may have simply been a nutjob, and not a sister of anything.
Valke, thanks for stating that fact - and it is a fact. Restarants wouldn’t exist very long without this rule in place for all who enter/exit the kitchen. (Crash, bang.) Also it’s common custom when on sidewalks, esp in big cities across the country - although it does seem to go by the boards for many teenagers who simply choose to control sidewalks, five or six across. Back to the main point, yes it was very wacky for the “nun” to make an issue of this when exiting a church after Mass. (Some nuns go wacky too!)

PS - The Heschel quote is beautiful. Thanks.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top