A question about praying to saints

  • Thread starter Thread starter kbwall
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
K

kbwall

Guest
I am a recent convert (confirmed Easter 2011), so praying to saints is a relatively new idea. Why do so many people choose saints with the same name as themselves? At the risk of sounding rude, that sounds like rather arbitrary criteria for choosing one.
 
Different saints are patrons of different things. For example, St. Anthony is the patron saint of lost things. You don’t exactly pray TO saints; you pray THROUGH them, asking them to pray for you.
 
Why do so many people choose saints with the same name as themselves?
Do you mean people choose to pray for a saint’s intercession who has the same name?

Among my friends and family, our parents named us after a particular saint, because they were honoring that saint’s holy life and asking for that saint’s special help throughout that child’s life.

So it’s not as if one day we decided to ask for a saint’s intercession, and arbitrarily decided to ask for the help of a saint with the same name. It’s more about continuing to rely on the help of a benefactor our parents selected at birth.

Or do you mean people selected a saint of the same name as a saint for confirmation? It could still be related to the above reason–often Catholic parents name their children with a particular saint in mind as a patron.

In many countries, people celebrate their Name Day in addition to their birthday. Their Name Day is the feast day of the saint associated with their given name.
 
You don’t exactly pray TO saints; you pray THROUGH them, asking them to pray for you.
Yes you actually pray TO saints. That is the communication method by which you contact those in Heaven. Prayer is not necessarily considered to be worship by Catholics, prayer is how we exchange thoughts and messages with God, the angels, and the saints.
 
Yes you actually pray TO saints. That is the communication method by which you contact those in Heaven. Prayer is not necessarily considered to be worship by Catholics, prayer is how we exchange thoughts and messages with God, the angels, and the saints.
Exactly, the definition of prayer/pray is “to ask of”, which does not imply worship to anyone or a deity. However, prayer can be used as a form of worship when it is to a deity.

And to the OP:
In regards to just picking Saints that people pray to, people will often pray to their patron Saint to intercede for them. Patron Saints for people can be of the same name, and most of the time they are. It also gives people a connection with the Saint that makes prayer more personal. Sometimes converts (and other confirmation candidates) who choose a patron Saint will pick one that has gone through a similar experience in their life as the person themselves. For instance, St. Anthony was mentioned above. Someone who often loses things might choose St. Anthony as their patron Saint to look after them and help them to remember where things have gone.

And in terms of just picking a Saint to pray to, patron Saints have something they are a patron of which relates to them somehow. There are lists online if you search for them.
 
I am a recent convert (confirmed Easter 2011), so praying to saints is a relatively new idea. Why do so many people choose saints with the same name as themselves? At the risk of sounding rude, that sounds like rather arbitrary criteria for choosing one.
That’s the concept of “Patron Saint.” You might name your son Joseph and Saint Joseph would be his Patron. Your son grows up knowing this and can, and should really, develop a special relationship with Saint Joseph. When you convert, you chose your own Patron Saint, so usually they don’t have the same name as you do.
 
Don’t forget God allows us to pray to Him without intercession,
 
Don’t forget God allows us to pray to Him without intercession,
Truly, that is so. Why do Catholics pray to the spirits of the deceased, when they have the power and right to pray to God or Jesus directly? Are the saints greater than God?
 
Truly, that is so. Why do Catholics pray to the spirits of the deceased, when they have the power and right to pray to God or Jesus directly? Are the saints greater than God?
Why would anyone have asked Saint Peter to heal them when he was here on earth, when they could pray directly to Jesus? Why would we stop asking Peter to heal us, just because he passed?

We do it because it works. It’s the system God set up for us. It’s the Communion of Saints, the exchange of spiritual goods. Just like we go to one another for help, we go to our friends in Heaven.
 
Truly, that is so. Why do Catholics pray to the spirits of the deceased, when they have the power and right to pray to God or Jesus directly? Are the saints greater than God?
Here’s one way it was answered by a friend of mine…we are all in the Body of Christ, here on Earth, in Purgatory and in Heaven. Why do you pray to others here on Earth, asking for their prayers?? That’s what Catholics do, only the people we’re asking to pray for us are already living the fullest, most magnificent Eternity, where we are all striving to be. Of course we pray directly to God, ALL THE TIME. But the prayers of the saints magnify our prayers.
 
Truly, that is so. Why do Catholics pray to the spirits of the deceased, when they have the power and right to pray to God or Jesus directly? Are the saints greater than God?
See Fr Vincent Serpa’s post Why Pray to anyone but Jesus? forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=702083&highlight=Praying+to+saints

Yes, we know we can pray to God directly, and we do. But God also asks us to pray for each other. And we believe in the living community of saints, who are in heaven with Him, ready to help us uf God so wills it. Just as we would ask a friend to pray for us, so we may also ask a saint to pray for us.
 
See Fr Vincent Serpa’s post Why Pray to anyone but Jesus? forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=702083&highlight=Praying+to+saints

Yes, we know we can pray to God directly, and we do. But God also asks us to pray for each other. And we believe in the living community of saints, who are in heaven with Him, ready to help us uf God so wills it. Just as we would ask a friend to pray for us, so we may also ask a saint to pray for us.
You ask a friend to pray to God for you, but you don’t pray to that friend to help you.
 
See Fr Vincent Serpa’s post Why Pray to anyone but Jesus? forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=702083&highlight=Praying+to+saints

Yes, we know we can pray to God directly, and we do. But God also asks us to pray for each other. And we believe in the living community of saints, who are in heaven with Him, ready to help us uf God so wills it. Just as we would ask a friend to pray for us, so we may also ask a saint to pray for us.
You ask a friend to pray to God for you, but you don’t pray to that friend to help you.
 
You ask a friend to pray to God for you, but you don’t pray to that friend to help you.
As I mentioned in my earlier post, to pray does not imply worship. The definition of ‘to pray’ or ‘prayer’ is “to ask of”. So by asking a friend, a Saint, even Jesus to do something for you, it is called prayer. So if you ask your friend to help you move, you are praying to your friend to help you move. Praying to God can be a form of worship, however, and when used as such, should not be placed on anyone else. But when we pray to the Saints, or to each other, we are not worshiping them, we are asking of them.

The word ‘pray’ was used more in older English, but the definition is still the same. Shakespearean plays used the word ‘pray’ when characters would ask something of another. And even “everyone’s favorite Bible translation” (sarcasm), the KJV, uses the word ‘pray’ from one person to another. An example of this is from the Second Book of Kings:
2 Kings 4:26:
Run now, I pray thee, to meet her, and say unto her, Is it well with thee? is it well with thy husband? is it well with the child?..
In this case, it is in-fact a “man of God” who is ‘praying’ to his servant to meet with a woman who is approaching them.

So, it is not incorrect to use the word ‘pray’ when referring to when someone is asking something of the Saints, or even someone here on Earth.
 
As I mentioned in my earlier post, to pray does not imply worship. The definition of ‘to pray’ or ‘prayer’ is “to ask of”. So by asking a friend, a Saint, even Jesus to do something for you, it is called prayer. So if you ask your friend to help you move, you are praying to your friend to help you move. Praying to God can be a form of worship, however, and when used as such, should not be placed on anyone else. But when we pray to the Saints, or to each other, we are not worshiping them, we are asking of them.

The word ‘pray’ was used more in older English, but the definition is still the same. Shakespearean plays used the word ‘pray’ when characters would ask something of another. And even “everyone’s favorite Bible translation” (sarcasm), the KJV, uses the word ‘pray’ from one person to another. An example of this is from the Second Book of Kings:

In this case, it is in-fact a “man of God” who is ‘praying’ to his servant to meet with a woman who is approaching them.

So, it is not incorrect to use the word ‘pray’ when referring to when someone is asking something of the Saints, or even someone here on Earth.
I personally would not find it appropriate to be on my knees and pray to a friend as I would my savior Jesus Christ.
 
You ask a friend to pray to God for you, but you don’t pray to that friend to help you.
Yes, you do. “Pray” means “petition.” But it’s an older use and we don’t say,“Pray, tell!” anymore when someone offers a bit of gossip. Or “Pray, pass the sauce.” I believe “Prithee” means “pray thee.” So we pray for help. Only now, we use the word almost exclusively for those on the other side or supernatural or Divine persons.
 
I personally would not find it appropriate to be on my knees and pray to a friend as I would my savior Jesus Christ.
That’s a very Protestant thing to say…are you perhaps a convert to Catholicism? Is the belief in the communion of saints and the intercession of saints something that you are struggling with?

Sometimes we give honor to those recognized as being above us in some way with our bodies–high ranking officers are saluted, or people may curtsey to royalty.

We as Catholics, when we are kneeling in a position of prayer, are giving honor first and foremost to God. If we ask for a saint’s intercession during a period of prayer, we won’t interrupt the prayer to God by changing body positions, as if we are somehow dishonoring God. We recognize that the saint has achieved great holiness, so as to be in union with God…and therefore the saint in a way is honored too, but that’s not the focus of the prayer.

If you read the lives of the saints, their recordings of their prayer lives are in general focused completely on intimate prayer with Christ. I can’t think of any lives/journals of the saints I’ve read that record lengthy prayer to someone in heaven…that was not the focus of their prayer lives; rather, union with Christ was.

We recognize that those in heaven are in total and complete union with God. So when we are asking for a saint’s intercession, we understand that that saint would only pray and help us if it is in accordance with God’s will. It’s not as if we’re asking the saint to do something “behind God’s back”–that wouldn’t be possible anyway, because the saint in heaven is completely and totally one with God.
 
The context originated if a intercession was required. There is several different opinions on that. Nevertheless. Simply no is the answer. In the military as your example we treat high rank officials different that foot soldiers. Same with prayer and worship. It’s critical as stated in first commandment.
That’s a very Protestant thing to say…are you perhaps a convert to Catholicism? Is the belief in the communion of saints and the intercession of ********saints something that you are struggling with?

Sometimes we give honor to those recognized as being above us in some way with our bodies–high ranking officers are saluted, or people may curtsey to royalty.

We as Catholics, when we are kneeling in a position of prayer, are giving honor first and foremost to God. If we ask for a saint’s intercession during a period of prayer, we won’t interrupt the prayer to God by changing body positions, as if we are somehow dishonoring God. We recognize that the saint has achieved great holiness, so as to be in union with God…and therefore the saint in a way is honored too, but that’s not the focus of the prayer.

If you read the lives of the saints, their recordings of their prayer lives are in general focused completely on intimate prayer with Christ. I can’t think of any lives/journals of the saints I’ve read that record lengthy prayer to someone in heaven…that was not the focus of their prayer lives; rather, union with Christ was.

We recognize that those in heaven are in total and complete union with God. So when we are asking for a saint’s intercession, we understand that that saint would only pray and help us if it is in accordance with God’s will. It’s not as if we’re asking the saint to do something “behind God’s back”–that wouldn’t be possible anyway, because the saint in heaven is completely and totally one with God.
 
That’s a very Protestant thing to say…are you perhaps a convert to Catholicism? Is the belief in the communion of saints and the intercession of saints something that you are struggling with?

Sometimes we give honor to those recognized as being above us in some way with our bodies–high ranking officers are saluted, or people may curtsey to royalty.

We as Catholics, when we are kneeling in a position of prayer, are giving honor first and foremost to God. If we ask for a saint’s intercession during a period of prayer, we won’t interrupt the prayer to God by changing body positions, as if we are somehow dishonoring God. We recognize that the saint has achieved great holiness, so as to be in union with God…and therefore the saint in a way is honored too, but that’s not the focus of the prayer.

If you read the lives of the saints, their recordings of their prayer lives are in general focused completely on intimate prayer with Christ. I can’t think of any lives/journals of the saints I’ve read that record lengthy prayer to someone in heaven…that was not the focus of their prayer lives; rather, union with Christ was.

We recognize that those in heaven are in total and complete union with God. So when we are asking for a saint’s intercession, we understand that that saint would only pray and help us if it is in accordance with God’s will. It’s not as if we’re asking the saint to do something “behind God’s back”–that wouldn’t be possible anyway, because the saint in heaven is completely and totally one with God.
Then I ask you this, in turn - is prayer or petition to the Saints and Mary required for salvation, in Catholic thought? Has Benedict mandated it?
 
Then I ask you this, in turn - is prayer or petition to the Saints and Mary required for salvation, in Catholic thought? Has Benedict mandated it?
“Has Benedict mandated it?”
Catholic teaching regarding the communion of the saints has been part of the Catholic Church’s teaching for a long time. See the description about it in the Catechism here: vatican.va/archive/ENG0015/__P2B.HTM

There are many aids and helps to salvation. The communion of the saints is one of them.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top