A Question to Converts

  • Thread starter Thread starter Nevermore22
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
My immedate family here knows that I have been attending for two years and would like to convert and be in full communion with the Catholic Church, however my husband point blank refuses to even think about getting his previous marriage annulled.

My parents know I can’t convert until my husband changes his mind so they are praying for him to come to their church and have me re-integrate with the Baptist faith.

Our sixteen year-old son has started to attend with me and is thinking of converting, so I know that things are happening even if it is slowly.
 

My parents know I can’t convert until my husband changes his mind so they are praying for him to come to their church and have me re-integrate with the Baptist faith.
You may have done this already, but a heart-to-heart talk with your husband (perhaps again) is in order.

I am sure he does not wish to be married to his previous wife and he does want to be married to you. If you believe as Catholics do that valid marriages are for life, then explain to him the problem of his previous, still valid marriage. If he feels this is nonsense, ask him to at least respect your views out of the love he has for you. Pointing out the relevant scripture may help.

In refusing to cooperate, he is forcing you into a situation against your will. Ask him to think about it. As a man of faith, how can he accept doing that?
 
I have very recently begun gently telling those around me my intentions, although I’ve started with casual acquantainces and I will work my way up to the closer relations.

So far my coworkers are all responding in the same manner.

First they ask why.
I tell them I’m being called to it.
And they respond with; Do what’s right for you.

The same won’t be true of my family when I tell them because they love me and they TRULY care about my final destination.

To use a secular description, I feel like someone who is ‘coming out of the closet’. It’s very delicate, scary work. I just don’t know who is going to attack me right out and who is going to respond with indifference.

So far only three people have shown joy at my decision but one is Catholic and the other two are non-Catholic Christians who are just happy to see me growing closer to God.

Annnd that’s my long story. 🤷
 
Everybody thought that I was mad apart from my mother and the parish! These people are just different and they don’t understand 🙂
 
Nickybr, be assured of ongoing prayers as you go through this challenging time. Know that others have been there before you. C.S. Lewis commented, "Parents don’t agonise that their children might become Methodist.’ or words to that effect. Trust the Holy Spirit to give you the right time & the right words for each loved one.
 
joe_cool, your story is awesome, thanks for posting it!

pandacordova, I will take to my heart to pray for you and your husband. I know what it is like to feel the need to convert, but cannot because someone is holding you back. God might be using this as a test for patience, you never know.
Everybody thought that I was mad apart from my mother and the parish!
In my circles, everyone thinks I am mad! I find it all funny though.

Thanks again to everyone who posted new stories. I have taken them all to heart and I thank you.

In Christ,
Never
 
I sort of eased my parents into it by starting off with an Emergent church, then a daily Anglican prayer service, and then Mass. The response to Anglicanism was “oh, that’s just too Catholic”. 😛

I hadn’t told them I was going to Mass at all, though I think they suspected. Then, when my fiance and I got engaged, he told them (in a forgetful, nervous moment that I still give him grief over), that we would be having a Catholic wedding–even though neither of us was even in RCIA at that point. That was bad, bad, bad. The engagement was an unpleasant surprise for them anyway, and adding a conversion to Catholicism was just too much.

I got weepy calls from my dad about Marian idolatry, and e-mails from my mom about pedophiles, and all that. I tried explaining things (they have a LOT of misconceptions), but it was always just too emotional. Luckily, it’s been two years, and they’ve stopped. We haven’t discussed it in a long time, other than to say that we’re praying for each other.

Thankfully, they seem to have warmed up to my fiance, and I hope they’ll feel better about Catholicism someday too . . . in the meantime, our upcoming wedding is going to be a serious emotional mindfield. 😦
 
Technically I’m a revert, not a convert but I feel like a convert because I never really accepted many of the Church’s teachings (except that God exists) and left to join protestant evangelical churches almost as soon as I left home. I praise God for my family and especially my older sister who became very alive in her Catholic faith and really pushed my older brother (who had also become an evangelical) and I to visit her in Sydney (we lived in Melbourne) and attend a retreat run at her parish. (BTW she lived in a convent as a lay-person with other young women). It raised alot of questions and admittedly a lot of hate from me but I prayed and prayed that God would show me any truth they were saying so that at least I could get something out of the weekend. I just felt my heart open up so much and it was like breathing sweet air for the first time. I decided to look into the claims made by the church pretty seriously and it was a very painful and humbling experience but after only six months (I had expected to be working out what was true or not for the next ten years) I decided that Catholicism was the real deal. I never really openly told my parents - but then I’d never really told them that I left the Church either. I’m sure they twigged when I went from harrassing them about the mass (which I thought was the furthest thing from how the early Christians worshipped) to talking about being concerned about my second youngest brother receiving the Eucharist when not in a state of grace!

My brother and I came back to the Church within weeks of each other (it was so great having such a great support in him! But I am glad that we each made the decision to come home separately) and we share alot of the same group of evangelical Christian friends. I’m not sure the reaction he’s gotten but mostly I just get silence from my friends on the issue of my “reversion”. I strongly suspect that many had seen me as someone “saved” from the Catholic church and so now I must be a bit of a failure. I much prefer the few friends who argue heatedly about the Church because it means we can discuss it and it’s great that there are always answers to their objections! I do have a precious few friends who are genuinely interested in why I decided to become Catholic and there have been some fruitful discussions from that I think but the other one of these friends and I were talking (she’d always been really supportive about me searching for the truth of the matter) and she twigged for the first time that I actually accepted ALL of the Church’s teachings (I really don’t know how she missed that since we’ve spoken about it alot and I’ve been back for half a year now) and she blew right up and got so angry - I think she was so sure that my search would land me right back in the evangelical camp.

By far the hardest has been my non-Christian housemates who think I’m mad and deluded. They’ve both had connection to protestants all their lives and don’t think badly of Christian beliefs but believing in the Real Presence of Jesus in the Eucharist? I just get rolled eyes and derisive laughter. I pray for them all the time but I find it quite a suffocating environment to be in.

… sorry that was so long - I obviously needed to let it out!
 
Technically I’m a revert, not a convert but I feel like a convert because I never really accepted many of the Church’s teachings (except that God exists) and left to join protestant evangelical churches almost as soon as I left home. I praise God for my family and especially my older sister who became very alive in her Catholic faith and really pushed my older brother (who had also become an evangelical) and I to visit her in Sydney (we lived in Melbourne) and attend a retreat run at her parish. (BTW she lived in a convent as a lay-person with other young women). It raised alot of questions and admittedly a lot of hate from me but I prayed and prayed that God would show me any truth they were saying so that at least I could get something out of the weekend. I just felt my heart open up so much and it was like breathing sweet air for the first time. I decided to look into the claims made by the church pretty seriously and it was a very painful and humbling experience but after only six months (I had expected to be working out what was true or not for the next ten years) I decided that Catholicism was the real deal. I never really openly told my parents - but then I’d never really told them that I left the Church either. I’m sure they twigged when I went from harrassing them about the mass (which I thought was the furthest thing from how the early Christians worshipped) to talking about being concerned about my second youngest brother receiving the Eucharist when not in a state of grace!

My brother and I came back to the Church within weeks of each other (it was so great having such a great support in him! But I am glad that we each made the decision to come home separately) and we share alot of the same group of evangelical Christian friends. I’m not sure the reaction he’s gotten but mostly I just get silence from my friends on the issue of my “reversion”. I strongly suspect that many had seen me as someone “saved” from the Catholic church and so now I must be a bit of a failure. I much prefer the few friends who argue heatedly about the Church because it means we can discuss it and it’s great that there are always answers to their objections! I do have a precious few friends who are genuinely interested in why I decided to become Catholic and there have been some fruitful discussions from that I think but the other one of these friends and I were talking (she’d always been really supportive about me searching for the truth of the matter) and she twigged for the first time that I actually accepted ALL of the Church’s teachings (I really don’t know how she missed that since we’ve spoken about it alot and I’ve been back for half a year now) and she blew right up and got so angry - I think she was so sure that my search would land me right back in the evangelical camp.

By far the hardest has been my non-Christian housemates who think I’m mad and deluded. They’ve both had connection to protestants all their lives and don’t think badly of Christian beliefs but believing in the Real Presence of Jesus in the Eucharist? I just get rolled eyes and derisive laughter. I pray for them all the time but I find it quite a suffocating environment to be in.

… sorry that was so long - I obviously needed to let it out!
Welcome home Naomi!

Your journey has been exactly what was necessary for you. Your friends are each on their very own path and you have great influence there - regardless of their predispositions. We never know how things will work out. Some who may appear most open could turn-out to be unmotivated. Others who express the strongest opposition may completely change their positions. You stand in witness to your faith and that may not be enough for some right now, but it can plant a seed…
 
I was raised in a very spritually abusive church that did alot of damage to our family and as such I ran from christianity as far as a could for many years. If any christian program came on the tv I cried, it gave me horrible anxiety and i felt like I would never find god for many years. I decided a few years ago to go looking for healing and god and tried many chruches walked out of all of them in tears… had anxiety attacks mid sermon…I became pagan and stayed in that faith for many years but it always felt empty and lonely. well last year I made a decision to completly give myself to god even if I didn’t know where that was. then a lady from a doctors office I go to told me about this healing catholic church inthe middle of the mountians so i gathered up my sister and her catholic friend and headed off on a pilgrimage. it was the beginning of a great journey. after I got back I could not get it out of my head so i did research and cried some more read a spiritual healing book and then attended my friends daughters quinceneara which to great and utter surprise I had no problem sitting through mass. so I did more research and bought a prayer book and prayed and I think really prayed for the frist time in my life with a deep and profound connection to god. then I read the catechism. and then found this website and then got my courage together and went to see a priest and that took alot of praying because I was so afraid. then I started gpoing to mass and everytime I am there I can see god and feel him in my heart. So here I am at heart and in life now happy and catholic its been a long journey
 
Welcome home as well!
In my case, my husband knew it was something I had always needed to do, it just took me time. He had never attended any other church but he had never had sacraments. I know, he is weird lol. I had been baptist & my mother put us on the church bus every Sunday, but never came with us. When my husband, children & myself, all came to the Church at the same time, my mother was surprised. When she came to me for advice, again, on the same old thing, the Holy Spirit moved in me & I wrote something that touched her in such a way, that she became a Catholic the following Easter. Yes, shocked me too. I didnt find out that my father was raised Catholic until after I was. We are not in touch much, long story. After some conversation & strong moving of the Spirit, he returned to the sacraments for the 1st time in decades. More shocking to me than my mother.
The only person I have had issue with was my uncle, my mother’s brother. He was more of a father to me than my father. He is a very proud, out gay man & has rejected Christianity in all forms, because he says they reject him, who needs them. He found his place in a guru in India. He made a few comments here & there, especially after he saw my Jesus tattoo. As we have gone along, he has accepted that this is MY spiritual path & he is happy I have one. I think he was afraid that I was going to reject him, degrade him e & teach my children to. When he saw that I still love him & pray for him, he has accepted it alot more.
My sister went to the Baptist church with me & never felt the call the Catholicism that I did. She was never interested in investigating anything we were taught, she kind of makes her own ideas. Her husband comes from a rabidly fundamentalist family & wont entertain the thought of something else, tho he doesnt attend church at all! My sister is currently going to a non denom sometimes, with a guy who calls himself an Apostle. She doesnt really care whether it is true. He pulls stuff out of the Bible & says it & she says wow! She isnt interested in the intellectual part. She finds Catholics to be full of stupid rules based only on what she thinks they teach.

I have been lucky on the friend part. We are military & move a lot, so many of my friends are not in my life day to day. Almost all of my current friends I have met through church activities,
Well that was more than I started out writing lol. Dont know if any of it is helpful. Im glad to be home, glad my family is with me & praying for the ones who arent. Its all we cane do I guess. Take care!
 
** autdrew**, I’m glad that through you, your uncle is getting the opportunity to see the love of Christ. What a blessing that the Lord helped your parents to enter a deeper spiritual life through you! Praise God!!! 😃

** Bekamom**, it’s been such a long journey for you! I’m so glad the Lord has given you the peace and healing you so needed. The Catholic Church is Jesus Christ, the Healer. I’m so glad you have met Him and found your love and life in Him. He loves you so much that He gave His life for you. I’m so glad for you!!!

** Moscati**, may the Lord, through our Holy Mother, bring peace to your wedding and your future family life both at home and with your parents. May you all find peace, understanding and perfect unity. May God bless your efforts to explain things to your parents and may you live at peace with them. Love comes first, unity second, and I’m so glad the Lord is leading you in all this!

Naomi, the Lord has definitely blessed you greatly. I’m so glad He gave you the humility of heart to be able to receive His truth and light.

I’m sincerely sorry about those housemates :(. God bless you for standing firm in the faith in spite of this abuse. Remember that Jesus endured exactly the same derision and disagreement when He first shared the doctrine of the Eucharist. That is the point when many of His disciples left Him (John 6:66). However, the truth of this doctrine shone out across centuries and millennia, and is believed now by more than a sixth of the world’s population. Most of the rest have not heard about it or don’t know any of the reasons for believing in it. God has revealed this truth to souls in an endless variety of ways.
 
40.png
NaomiL:
By far the hardest has been my non-Christian housemates who think I’m mad and deluded. They’ve both had connection to protestants all their lives and don’t think badly of Christian beliefs but believing in the Real Presence of Jesus in the Eucharist? I just get rolled eyes and derisive laughter. I pray for them all the time but I find it quite a suffocating environment to be in.

… sorry that was so long - I obviously needed to let it out!
No problem! Thank you for sharing!
I to face trouble with those around me dealing with the Real Presence. My mother refuses to accept that it is not a symbol, it is really Him! She thinks the priest does magic during the concencration.
40.png
Bekamom:
I was raised in a very spritually abusive church that did alot of damage to our family and as such I ran from christianity as far as a could for many years
I am sorry about your background and your past. But it is awesome that you have come home! Your story sounds like God has really been drawing you in and has great plans for you.
40.png
autdrew:
Well that was more than I started out writing lol. Dont know if any of it is helpful. Im glad to be home, glad my family is with me & praying for the ones who arent. Its all we cane do I guess. Take care!
Wow! Your story is awesome! I wish God would bring my family home as well! Thank you for your story, and hopefully you can be a good witness to your uncle and sister as well!

Thanks again to everyone that posted their stories. They have touched me, and I know that the Lord has used these to read to me. So thank you all, and God bless.

In Christ,
Never
 
Thanks, I truly feel as ifI have been brought home. there is a sense of spiritual peace that I didn’t have before. I feel truly blessed.
 
Thanks, I truly feel as ifI have been brought home. there is a sense of spiritual peace that I didn’t have before. I feel truly blessed.
Can’t tell you how glad I am to read this! God bless, and welcome home!

P.S.
Not sure about you, but personally I find if old anxioties start creaping in that truely good music can also help some. Personally I love Music From the Vatican - Alma Mater featureing Pope Benedict XVI

amazon.com/Alma-Mater-Featuring-Voice-Benedict/dp/B002WYLN4E/ref=sr_shvl_album_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1279284883&sr=301-1

Advocata Nostra is one of my all time favs =)
 
just out of curiousity

is anyone here from a non-christian background?
 
I myself have told my family and friends about my desire to convert. I am just curious on how other converts were treated by those around them. Hopefully it was in a kind, respectful manner.

Thanks!

-Never
When I told my mom that I wanted to be catholic I was so surprised how calm she was about it. She had expressed in the past about her dislike of particular practices of the church and still does but she was OK with me wanting to become catholic. However that was a while ago and I plan on talking to her again when I join RCIA class. I don’t plan on walking around telling everyone of my conversion but I do plan on never being ashamed of my faith. And never being afraid to express my faith like praying the Rosary or crossing myself. Things that are uniquely catholic. I also want people to know the love of Jesus so I hope this shines through me wherever I go. Why be fearful of that? When I get a little shy about it I think of the martyrs. And the verse from the bible, paraphrased, if you are ashamed of Jesus, Jesus will be ashamed of you when you face him after you die.
 
Just out of curiousity, is anyone here from a non-Christian background?
Me! My parents and little sister are all atheists. When I became a Christian a few years ago, my parents weren’t very understanding at all. There were a lot of heated arguments, and they would do whatever they could to stop me from going to church (like refusing to lend me the family car). But over time they’ve gotten used to it, and realised that it wasn’t just a phase I was going through. (Believe me, I had my fair share of phases!) They still show no interest in it whatsoever, but they aren’t angry about it like they used to be. Anyways, when I started researching Catholicism, I didn’t say anything to them (although they probably figured it out because I have a terrible habit of leaving books lying around all over the house!), but when I decided to convert to Catholicism, I knew I’d have to say something! I thought long and hard about how to bring up that topic, but they ended up (unintentionally) starting the conversation! See, last Sunday morning, they asked why I was leaving home 3 hours earlier than usual, and so I told them that I was going to mass rather than the church (Church of Christ) I had been going to for the past few years. They seemed a bit shocked and asked what was ‘wrong’ with the church I used to go to (because I would always speak very highly of it), to which I explained that I had done some research and no longer agreed with their teachings. We haven’t really spoken about it since, but I’m praying for more opportunities to talk to them about it, and *hopefully *they might even come along when I am confirmed next year!

As for telling people at church… I’m *trying *to work up the courage to do that this weekend. Part of me wants to just never show up there again so as to avoid those conversations, but I know that wouldn’t be the right thing to do. That church has been a huge part of my life, and I am so grateful for the support they offered during some particularly difficult times. However, I have a sneaking suspicion that many people there won’t react the way I’d like them to when I tell them that I am becoming a Catholic! I know there will be people there (the leadership team in particular) who will try and debate with me. Now, I’ve done enough research to believe that the Catholic Church really *is *the one true Church established by Christ, but I certainly don’t know enough to be able to refute *all *their arguments on the spot! Also, I’m worried that some people will accuse me of making that decision simply because my boyfriend is Catholic (a couple of people have already said that to me). Sigh Sure, he’s a huge part of why I decided to research Catholicism, but there’s just no way I would convert because of a guy (even one as amazing as he is!) As much as I love my boyfriend, I love God more, and there’s just no way that I would go against His will and be a part of something I didn’t believe in. I am converting becasue God has called me to do so.

Anyways, rambling finished! It was really encouraging to read other peoples stories in this thread. Thank you all for sharing!
 
Hailz,

Welcome home! Don’t worry about answering everyone’s questions on the spot. It’s always acceptable to say “well I don’t know that yet”… Good luck to you!
 
God bless you, Hailz 👍. It really is difficult, but you’re doing the right things.

Have you read the articles on catholic.com? The tracts in the Library section are good at covering normal issues that Protestants will bring up, like indulgences, the Papacy, Mary, the Eucharist and the like. There also are some articles about points you could bring up, which Protestants won’t generally have studied, and even if they have, will not have any good arguments on. For instance, you could talk about the canon of scripture or the baselessness of sola scriptura.

May the Holy Virgin bless you, both as you speak to your parents and as you speak to your Christian friends.

I know how tough it is. My sister, when she started moving toward Catholicism, was warned that she might be following demons. I was too, and the “spirit of the Anti-Christ,” as well. It’s hard. But Christ always comes before men, and God will be with you. He too was rejected in His hometown. The passage describing Jesus’ rejection in His hometown was one of a few helpful passages during my conversion process.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top