S
Sean73
Guest
What is a good defense for some one who tries to draw a comparison between how much money Peter had and how much money the Pope and the Church has?
- Status
S
Scott_Waddell
Guest
Simple. The wealth of the Church is held in trust. It is not the pope’s personal stash. JPII died with no assets.
Scott
Scott
B
b_justb
Guest
Is the manager of the local bank rich because he is an overseer of the funds entrusted to him?
F
Fidei_Defensor
Guest
The only salary a pope gets to keep are the coins he is buried with.
A
alexaustralia
Guest
Any one knows how much money the Church donates to charity?
Just wandering
God bless
Alex
Just wandering
God bless
Alex
A
adnauseum
Guest
A neighborhood congregation of protestants surely collects tithes from its members, keeping enough in savings to get the church through unexpected emergencies.
Well, the Catholic Church is a world-wide Church, and so it stands to reason that it would hold significant assets to protect and preserve itself in times of crisis.
And not just on a material level. The Church is entrusted with the deposit of faith. The loss of the teaching office of the Church would devastate civilization.
Ask your friend to read the book How the Catholic Church Built Western Civilization by Thomas E. Woods, PhD. The book gives a good idea of how essential the Church is to survival.
Well, the Catholic Church is a world-wide Church, and so it stands to reason that it would hold significant assets to protect and preserve itself in times of crisis.
And not just on a material level. The Church is entrusted with the deposit of faith. The loss of the teaching office of the Church would devastate civilization.
Ask your friend to read the book How the Catholic Church Built Western Civilization by Thomas E. Woods, PhD. The book gives a good idea of how essential the Church is to survival.
S
steve_b
Guest
- How much money DID Peter have?
- How much money does the Pope have?
- As far as the Catholic Church’s wealth goes,
b. One could also say that splits and divides in a family causes a 50% drop to ones wealth on each split. One only has to think about how divorce effects ones wealth .
Consider Vatican hill for example, the site of the Vatican and the grounds around the Vatican. It’s been in the family for at least 1700 years. Nice appreciation on 1 property don’t ya think? The Catholic Church has alot of property like this around the world that has been in one and the same family.
Protestantism on the other hand, is made up of denominations that are each independent from the others, and they split and divide routinely. That effects the net worth of each individual denomination. The wealth gets split and divided endlessly among new denominations, reducing the wealth of each individual denomination. Collectively though, the wealth is still there, it’s just divided among more individual congregations. Protestants as a whole don’t pool their resources among Protestantism because they are not one with each other, and they have no central government…Catholics worldwide are one under the Pope therefore wealth from one Church, one family is used globally.
L
Liberian
Guest
Sean,
A lot of the Church’s supposed “wealth” consists of things that, while they are priceless, are pretty much unsaleable. To whom would the Church sell St. Peter’s Basilica or the Sistine Chapel?
- Liberian
S
Sean73
Guest
Thank you. These replies are of great help in defending this issue.
A
Akanke
Guest
I see many hospitals named after saints (in Nashville, we have St. Thomas Hospital). Does the Church provide for any of these hospitals?
V
viktor_aleksndr
Guest
I think if we will ask the pope how much wealth does the church have i think his answer will be
“we have the riches on heaven and earth but we do not own them. It is entrusted to us by the rightful owner, and that is GOD.”
“we have the riches on heaven and earth but we do not own them. It is entrusted to us by the rightful owner, and that is GOD.”
A
adnauseum
Guest
The donation of the lives of Edith Stein & Maximillian Kolbe who gave their lives for others in the Concentration Camps would seem to be worth something.
But I’m sort of old fashioned in my view of what charity is.
T
The_Augustinian
Guest
Speaking of which, if I remember correctly the Vatican and all its treasures are insured for only one euro.
- Status